This book was a well-written quick read. Theo’s story of recovery was nice to hear and very inspiring! I hope never to be in such a health crisis, but if so, I aspire to work as hard as he did and recover so fully! Despite the nice things about the story and the writing, I found many elements of this book immensely frustrating.
The author and his son clearly come from a background of extreme privilege and never acknowledge the essential role that being financially well-off plays in how the story turns out. Without the ability to spend at least hundreds of thousands of dollars on things that are just casually mentioned in the book, including: having amazing health insurance and/or paying out of pocket for long stays in the hospital and rehab, tons of extra sessions with various therapists, taking a plane instead of an ambulance when transferring to rehab, access to some of the best doctors and facilities in the world, at least a few last-minute flights, his parents taking time off work and literally moving across the country, furnishing an entire new rental apartment, renovating his apartment (which I guess he/they own in addition to their main home?) to be more handicapped-accessible — Theo’s recovery would have been much harder, if not impossible. That’s not to totally take away from the hard work that Theo did in his recovery or the dedication of the medical professionals involved, but it is clear that the family's financial situation was a major factor in the outcome of this story. The fact that it was not even really mentioned in the book was pretty upsetting to me, as a person who sometimes struggles to make ends meet, and, were I to be in a similar situation, would be bankrupted by it and would most likely spend the rest of my life paying off bills. This isn’t even counting other examples of privilege that were casually mentioned in passing, such as how they fly first class, own at least one horse, lived in Paris, etc. Interestingly, Theo’s mother, according to the book, comes from a less advantaged background - I would have been interested to hear her perspective on the role that the family’s finances played in their son’s recovery.
I found the father (the author) totally unsympathetic as a narrator. He paints his son as some kind of god-like being who can do no wrong. Both parents clearly dote on Theo to the extent that I’m not sure I would want to meet someone raised by parents so obsessed with their child’s perfection. The author makes everyone else’s life’s meaning all about Theo, including the doctors, nurses, therapists, Theo’s friends, etc., removing their personal agency. He also literally compared Theo’s struggles in recovery to both 9/11 and Hurricane Katrina, which I find quite offensive.
As someone who has struggled with depression in the past, I thought that that portion of the book minimized people's struggles with suicidal ideation and was only superficially sympathetic (basically, “he was improving so much and so many people love him, how could he possibly feel depressed?!?” - a common and frustrating response when others learn that one is depressed). By the way, Theo’s suicidal thoughts magically went away after a hug from his mom during a visit home.
It also seemed like the author was making the whole journey about him, though, to be fair, it’s probably very hard to write a book about someone else’s life without making it all about yourself. I would much rather have heard this whole book told from Theo’s perspective instead of his father’s overly-rosy view. A side note on this topic: It made me very uncomfortable when the book (again, narrated and written by his father) talked about Theo masturbating!
TLDR: an easy read full of unrecognized privilege