Cowboy's Redemption is the most recent novel in The Montana Cahills series, a series I've been following and one which I've given mixed reviews, and this review is going to follow that pattern, because these novels, while enjoyable reads for the most part, have some issues, which is why I could only give Cowboy's Redemption a 2-star rating. Let me start out by staying that the plot was interesting enough to keep me reading it in one sitting, but as soon as I read the last page, my thoughts immediately went to what I perceived as problems and inconsistencies.
The first issue relates to the cover and the title, which seemed to have absolutely nothing to do with this novel. The cover photo shows a handsome cowboy astride a horse, it's a good photo, but at no point in this novel is there a cowboy, let alone one on horseback. The hero, Major Colt McCloud, is in the military, where he is a helicopter pilot, a job he loves. He's inherited the Montana ranch from his recently deceased father, a ranch that's been owned by his family since his great great grandfather's day, but he hates ranching, and is on leave and in the process of trying to sell it, lock, stock and barrel. For a working ranch he seems to be the only one there, no other cowboys, no ranch foreman, no cook, no one caring for the animals--nada. Then we get to the title, which, try as I might, I could not figure out. Colt loves his career in the military, and while he was in Afghanistan, the young woman to whom he was engaged, cheated on him with his best friend and ended their engagement, making him a victim., so I couldn't help but wonder exactly why he needed redeeming when he'd done nothing wrong.
We next meet Lola, as she's escaping from the clutches of a quasi-religious cult to which her now deceased parents belonged, The Society of Lasting Serenity, run by cult leader, Jonas Emanuel. She manages to make it to the highway and ends up knocking on Colt's door in the middle of the night. She's the last person he expected to see, especially since during their one night stand a year ago, the night that Colt's fiance broke their engagement. He and Lola never even exchanged last names. He's soon to discover that their one-night stand resulted in the birth of their baby daughter, Grace, now 3-months old and held captive at the cult's compound, after being born and immediately removed from Lola's care. It seems that Jonas wants Lola as his wife, although he's 20 years older than she, and someone she hates and blames for the death of her parents. She finally manages to convince Colt that she's telling the truth after he has her examined by a local doctor, and the fact that she's recently given birth is confirmed.
They enlist the aid of Sheriff Flint Cahill, and return to the cult's compound with him, where they are totally snowed by Jonas, who insists that Lola had a stillborn male child, that she's off her meds, schizophrenic, and delusional, which is why she's concocted this ridiculous story, and after a brief tour of the compound, including a visit to a small mound of dirt in the compound's cemetery, they leave, something else that made no sense. Why on earth would law enforcement take the cult leader at his word, after hearing from a distraught mother that her child has been kidnapped, and that she's been held prisoner of the cult since the day it was born. Again, the lack of further investigation by law enforcement made absolutely no sense.
Eventually, Lola and Colt return to the compound late one night and manage to steal back baby Grace, but they do so without backup, without law enforcement, without weapons, and instead of taking the baby and getting as far away from the cult as they can, they go right back to Colt's ranch, and assume that now that they have baby Grace back, all is well, something else that made no sense. Why didn't they even consider that as a possibility? Why didn't they notify law enforcement that they needed protection? It was clear that the cult leader wanted Lola and wanted Lola badly enough that he wasn't about to give her up, so it's no surprise when he once again has them abducted.
The novel continues on in this fashion to an HEA ending, but the plot and its many inconsistencies kept piling up and stretched my willing suspension of disbelief to the breaking point. I've read many of Ms. Daniel's novels over the years, and I know that she's a far better writer than is exhibited in this novel, which also lacked any sort of relationship building, character development, or a believable plot. It also felt as if the author was racing to finish this novel by a deadline, and simply didn't have the luxury of time to smooth out all its rough edges.
I voluntarily read an advance reader copy of this novel. The opinions expressed are my own.