What do you think?
Rate this book


A handsome stranger moves to the small Pennsylvania town of Central Valley, and his name is Chris Brennan. He’s applying for a job as a teacher and varsity baseball coach at the local high school, and he looks perfect, on paper. But his name is an alias, his resume is false, and everything about him is a lie. And he has a secret plan - for which he needs a pawn on the baseball team.
Susan Sematov loves her younger son Raz, the quirky and free-spirited pitcher of the team. But Raz’s adored father died only a few months ago, and the family is grief-stricken. Secretly, Raz is looking to fill the Daddy-shaped hole in his heart.
Heather Larkin is a struggling single mother who’s dedicated to her only son Justin, the quiet rookie on the team. But Justin’s shy and reserved nature renders him vulnerable to attention, including that of a new father-figure.
Mindy Kostis is the wife of a busy surgeon and the queen bee of the baseball boosters, where her super-popular son Evan is the star catcher. But she doesn’t realize that Evan’s sense of entitlement is becoming a full-blown case of affluenza, and after he gets his new BMW, it’s impossible to know where he’s going – or whom he’s spending time with.
The lives of these families revolve around the baseball team – and Chris Brennan. What does he really want? How far will he go to get it? Who among them will survive the lethal jeopardy threatening them, from the shadows?
Enthralling and suspenseful, One Perfect Lie is an emotional thriller and a suburban crime story that will keep readers riveted to the shocking end, with killer twists and characters you won’t soon forget.
Audiobook
First published April 11, 2017
Would have been such a good book if not for the preposterous ending!
So let's get the ending out of the way first before I have a stroke about it. Honestly, other than being a bit predictable (which I'll get to later), I was really enjoying this book, but then it was like the author thought she had to write some big Hollywood blockbuster of a climax. All she ended up doing was writing something that so completely stretched the bounds of reality that I suddenly realized I had left "reality-based" fiction and stepped completely into "fantasy-based" fiction. It's frustrating because the author, Lisa Scottoline, obviously has some talent and could have come up with something much more realistic.
Okay, now the good: The characters. This is not the type of book that I normally read. But someone recommended it and so I thought what the heck. Almost immediately, I got involved in the characters. How the main character, Chris Brennan, started manipulating the people around him. It was really fascinating. Seeing how the problems in people's lives were used and twisted to his advantage. I really started to care about the families, especially the boys on the baseball team. Lisa did such an excellent job of drawing me into all their lives and making me care. Would have been such a great book if not for that damn ending...
The plot was good. There is a surprise about a third of the way in that I did not see coming. Good for you Lisa. But after that, it was relatively predictable. That said I was still very much enjoying it. It was holding my interest. I wanted to find out what happened to the characters. But then there as that damn ending...
What could have been a four or five-star book, relegated to the three-stars just because of an absurd ending. Such a disappointment.