I'm struggling to write a review for this read. While "Raven, Fire and Ice" is the type of book I love to consume, I came away with a lukewarm response. Part of this may be explained by the fact that I was only able to read about a chapter a day versus reading the book over a day or two. The other part has to do with pacing and characters.
Basically, if you're into superhero like stories and/or journey style adventures, you'll probably enjoy this.
Despite my lukewarm impression, there are elements of the story I loved. I was excited to jump in the airship along with Lucinda and the other characters. We have three strong women that lead the narrative, fighting baddies and going on adventures. Lucinda Ravensburgh is a lead witch whose point of view we see most of the story through and she's a fun, spitfire of a character. Magda is the by the book military officer leading the mission and Ascara is her more rogue-like second in command. We get a lot of witty banter from Lucinda and I liked the interactions between the ladies.
Overall, the book holds a good amount of action, the world was original, and there's no lack of imagination from Nita Round.
That said, there's a lot that needed to be established in this debut book to the series and I think that impacted part of my enjoyment because it created a meandering effect. The story quickly kicks off with a missing persons mystery but that gets side-railed as we journey to a new land and encounter various obstacles and monsters along the way. I almost forgot what the mission was ultimately for.
The middle of the book is meant for us to discover what types of powers the lead characters possess, particularly for Lucinda to learn her true abilities and who she is, grow the relationships between the three women, and let us in on the rules of how this world works. It kept my interest but at the expense of pacing. The last quarter of the book, we return to the missing persons case which I found less riveting due to predictability and the characters suddenly seeming more generic.
I think more than anything, my key issue was that, though I liked the three women and their dynamic, there was also a superficial feel to them. Lucinda we get a pretty good idea of but Magda and especially Ascara are more of a mystery. I couldn't get very deep into their psyches or vulnerabilities or where they came from. I really crave this kind of thing. I have an inkling we'll uncover more as the series unfolds.
Do know the story introduces a potential f/f/f V-shaped poly relationship between these three ladies and there's a sort of instalove between at least two of them (that's explained by their powers). However, there's no sex in this book and the relationship statuses remain undefined. We get a good amount of flirting and cuddles though.
The book ends on a "more to come" style cliffhanger but the first book wraps itself up and feels complete.
Being a fan of these types of reads you may be asking how it compares to Anna Burke's "Compass" or Elizabeth Watasin's "Dark Victorian" because they share a lot of qualities. I'd say it was on par with my enjoyment of "Compass" while not achieving the levels of "Dark Victorian".
I think this is a good start to a fresh and original series and look forward to the adventures with Lucinda, Magda, and Ascara.
3.6 rounding up to 4 stars.