What do you think?
Rate this book
Eleanor's Secret
London, 1942
When art school graduate, Eleanor Roy, is recruited by the War Artists Advisory Committee, she comes one step closer to realising her dream of becoming one of the few female war artists. But breaking into the art establishment proves difficult until Eleanor meets painter, Jack Valante, only to be separated by his sudden posting overseas.
Melbourne, 2010
Although reluctant to leave her family at home, Kathryn can't refuse her grandmother Eleanor's request to travel to London to help her return a precious painting to its artist. But when the search uncovers a long-held family secret, Kathryn has to make a choice to return home or risk her family's future, as Eleanor shows her that safeguarding the future is sometimes worth more than protecting the past.
Eleanor's Secret is at once a surprising mystery and compelling love story.
When art school graduate, Eleanor Roy, is recruited by the War Artists Advisory Committee, she comes one step closer to realising her dream of becoming one of the few female war artists. But breaking into the art establishment proves difficult until Eleanor meets painter, Jack Valante, only to be separated by his sudden posting overseas.
Melbourne, 2010
Although reluctant to leave her family at home, Kathryn can't refuse her grandmother Eleanor's request to travel to London to help her return a precious painting to its artist. But when the search uncovers a long-held family secret, Kathryn has to make a choice to return home or risk her family's future, as Eleanor shows her that safeguarding the future is sometimes worth more than protecting the past.
Eleanor's Secret is at once a surprising mystery and compelling love story.
440 pages, Kindle Edition
First published April 24, 2018
23 people are currently reading
439 people want to read
About the author
Caroline Beecham
6 books81 followersCaroline is the author of four historical fiction novels; Maggie's Kitchen, Eleanor's Secret, Finding Eadie (published as When We Meet Again in North America) and Esther's Children, and also a novelisation, Rainbow. She has 20 years experience as a writer and producer in film and television and has worked on a documentary about Princess Diana lookalikes, a series about journeys to the ends of the earth, as well as a feature film about finding the end of the rainbow. While she has done none of these things herself, she has discovered that she loves to write and to share lesser-known histories; and in particular those of pioneering women whose lives she reimagines through fiction. Caroline studied the craft of novel writing at the Faber Academy in 2012 and has a MA in Film & Television and a MA in Creative Writing. She currently lives in Sydney, Australia with her husband and two teenage sons.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 51 reviews
April 24, 2018
It was London, 1942 and Eleanor Roy had joined the War Artist Advisory Committee, or WAAC as it was known. She was tasked with signing artists to sketch, draw and paint the war so everyone at home saw the images depicting what their loved ones were going through. Eleanor herself was an artist; had recently graduated – and dreamed of becoming a war artist herself. But the struggle was that the establishment would only take male artists – it was hard for Eleanor to make her way.
When Eleanor met artist Jack Valante, she was drawn to his compassion and empathy for his subjects. As Jack and Eleanor became close; friends then more – she was shattered when Jack was posted overseas. Would she ever see him again? She kept his paintings close…
Kathryn was in her home in Melbourne, Australia with her husband and son Oliver, when she received a call from her grandmother, Eleanor to join her in London – she needed help in a quest that only Kathryn could assist with. It was 2010 and many years had passed since Eleanor’s war years, but the search Kathryn embarked on brought her closer to her grandmother than ever before. But the secrets Kathryn uncovered had her wondering if she really knew Eleanor at all. What would the discovery of secrets deeply buried achieve?
Eleanor’s Secret is another fascinating and riveting historical fiction novel by Aussie author Caroline Beecham. I loved Maggie's Kitchen and this one didn’t disappoint. The setting moves back and forth as we learn more about Eleanor’s past, while Kathryn searches for answers during that unattainable time. I thoroughly enjoyed Eleanor’s character, both young and old, and Kathryn seemed to have the same gritty determination that her grandmother had. Filled with love, hope, deception (there was one person I was prepared to hit!) and secrets, Eleanor’s Secret is one I have no hesitation in recommending highly.
With thanks to Allen & Unwin for my ARC to read and review.
When Eleanor met artist Jack Valante, she was drawn to his compassion and empathy for his subjects. As Jack and Eleanor became close; friends then more – she was shattered when Jack was posted overseas. Would she ever see him again? She kept his paintings close…
Kathryn was in her home in Melbourne, Australia with her husband and son Oliver, when she received a call from her grandmother, Eleanor to join her in London – she needed help in a quest that only Kathryn could assist with. It was 2010 and many years had passed since Eleanor’s war years, but the search Kathryn embarked on brought her closer to her grandmother than ever before. But the secrets Kathryn uncovered had her wondering if she really knew Eleanor at all. What would the discovery of secrets deeply buried achieve?
Eleanor’s Secret is another fascinating and riveting historical fiction novel by Aussie author Caroline Beecham. I loved Maggie's Kitchen and this one didn’t disappoint. The setting moves back and forth as we learn more about Eleanor’s past, while Kathryn searches for answers during that unattainable time. I thoroughly enjoyed Eleanor’s character, both young and old, and Kathryn seemed to have the same gritty determination that her grandmother had. Filled with love, hope, deception (there was one person I was prepared to hit!) and secrets, Eleanor’s Secret is one I have no hesitation in recommending highly.
With thanks to Allen & Unwin for my ARC to read and review.
April 12, 2018
In London 1942 Eleanor Roy, recruited by The War Artist Advisory Committee (WAAC), meets artist Jack Valante. There is an instant attraction that lead to something more as time goes on. But then Jack is posted overseas and despite their love for each other, he disappears from her life. There are secrets Eleanor doesn’t know about Jack. Moving on in time in Melbourne 2010, Kathryn receives an urgent request from her grandmother, Eleanor. This concerns a precious painting and also digging in to the past to find out what happened to Jack all those year before. Even though it means leaving her husband Chris, when things are already tenuous between them, with sole care of their autistic son Oli, Kathryn feels she has no choice but to honour her grandmother’s request and fly to London to help her.
From the beginning the story moves between the two time frames until they converge exposing a family secret. This story grabbed me from the first page. As it went along, since I wasn’t even born during these war times, I learnt a lot I never knew about the way artists were used during the Second World War. The information is woven seamlessly into the story and the facts are essential to the plot. I loved reading about the ingenuity of artists when materials were in short supply and the way they adapted ordinary household items. I even learned something I never knew before about the Australian anthem.
The fact that it took me a few days to read the book was never because I was not interested but rather just that, sadly, life events intruded and had to take precedence over reading time. Whenever I did get a chance I was back there with Eleanor, and Kathryn. This is an engrossing story. Eleanor, Jack, and Kathryn are all strong likeable characters and I liked the way Oli picks up on something the adults have missed. This is a story of intrigue, love, family, choices and the consequences of those choices. Setting is also well conveyed.
My first read by this author was a thoroughly enjoyable experience. I would recommend this book to all who like a well told story with strong believable characters, historical background and sense of place. This is one not to miss. Thanks to for Allen&Unwin for my ARC to read and review.
From the beginning the story moves between the two time frames until they converge exposing a family secret. This story grabbed me from the first page. As it went along, since I wasn’t even born during these war times, I learnt a lot I never knew about the way artists were used during the Second World War. The information is woven seamlessly into the story and the facts are essential to the plot. I loved reading about the ingenuity of artists when materials were in short supply and the way they adapted ordinary household items. I even learned something I never knew before about the Australian anthem.
The fact that it took me a few days to read the book was never because I was not interested but rather just that, sadly, life events intruded and had to take precedence over reading time. Whenever I did get a chance I was back there with Eleanor, and Kathryn. This is an engrossing story. Eleanor, Jack, and Kathryn are all strong likeable characters and I liked the way Oli picks up on something the adults have missed. This is a story of intrigue, love, family, choices and the consequences of those choices. Setting is also well conveyed.
My first read by this author was a thoroughly enjoyable experience. I would recommend this book to all who like a well told story with strong believable characters, historical background and sense of place. This is one not to miss. Thanks to for Allen&Unwin for my ARC to read and review.
May 24, 2018
3.5★s
“War art was the public face of the warring nation; their visible response to the conflicts and a reflection of their national grief.”
Eleanor’s Secret is the second novel by British-born Australian author, Caroline Beecham. It’s 1942 and, as well as her volunteer work, Eleanor Roy is holding down two paying jobs and keeping an eye on her fragile younger sister, a trainee nurse. She’s lucky to have work in the field she loves: art. On behalf of the Ministry of Food, she organises artwork for the British Restaurants, to boost the morale of those on the home front; and she works for the War Artists Advisory Committee, commissions from which are referred to by some artists as the Government’s “magic carpet”.
What Eleanor would prefer to be doing, though, is working as a war artist herself, recording what really happens in battle. But she’s a woman and, at this stage, not even allowed to drive herself and the art works around. But her MoF work does introduce her to Jack Valante, a talented but mysterious artist with Latin good looks, a man she can’t get out of her head.
Jack is immediately enchanted by Eleanor, but is already committed to work for his country, work about which he cannot even tell his ailing mother or hard-working sister. His work as a war artist will be his cover for certain covert activities but, until his first tour of duty, he is frustrated that he can’t help Eleanor achieve her dream.
In 2010, Kathryn leaves behind her husband and young son in Melbourne to travel to London. Her grandmother wants her to bring back to her the Jack Valante painting hanging on Kathryn’s wall. Kathryn learns that Eleanor, a long-retired art teacher, has had a purchase enquiry, and is hopeful that the buyer, Jack’s nephew, will put her in contact with Jack. As Kathryn makes enquiries and uncovers traces of the elusive artist, she begins to wonder if her grandmother has shared with her all the facts.
Beecham gives the reader an interesting tale of historical fiction which includes a wealth of information (perhaps too much?) about war artists and their work. The first half of this novel is somewhat slow-moving. It is not until Kathryn gains access to Jack’s journals that the narrative gains pace and interest. However, the finish feels a little rushed. The mystery is intriguing even if, in places, the plot is a little sketchy, and some parts of the resolution feel a bit contrived. Ignoring this, it is a wonderful love story. Fans of historical fiction and art are likely to enjoy this one.
With thanks to Allen & Unwin for this uncorrected proof copy to read and review.
“War art was the public face of the warring nation; their visible response to the conflicts and a reflection of their national grief.”
Eleanor’s Secret is the second novel by British-born Australian author, Caroline Beecham. It’s 1942 and, as well as her volunteer work, Eleanor Roy is holding down two paying jobs and keeping an eye on her fragile younger sister, a trainee nurse. She’s lucky to have work in the field she loves: art. On behalf of the Ministry of Food, she organises artwork for the British Restaurants, to boost the morale of those on the home front; and she works for the War Artists Advisory Committee, commissions from which are referred to by some artists as the Government’s “magic carpet”.
What Eleanor would prefer to be doing, though, is working as a war artist herself, recording what really happens in battle. But she’s a woman and, at this stage, not even allowed to drive herself and the art works around. But her MoF work does introduce her to Jack Valante, a talented but mysterious artist with Latin good looks, a man she can’t get out of her head.
Jack is immediately enchanted by Eleanor, but is already committed to work for his country, work about which he cannot even tell his ailing mother or hard-working sister. His work as a war artist will be his cover for certain covert activities but, until his first tour of duty, he is frustrated that he can’t help Eleanor achieve her dream.
In 2010, Kathryn leaves behind her husband and young son in Melbourne to travel to London. Her grandmother wants her to bring back to her the Jack Valante painting hanging on Kathryn’s wall. Kathryn learns that Eleanor, a long-retired art teacher, has had a purchase enquiry, and is hopeful that the buyer, Jack’s nephew, will put her in contact with Jack. As Kathryn makes enquiries and uncovers traces of the elusive artist, she begins to wonder if her grandmother has shared with her all the facts.
Beecham gives the reader an interesting tale of historical fiction which includes a wealth of information (perhaps too much?) about war artists and their work. The first half of this novel is somewhat slow-moving. It is not until Kathryn gains access to Jack’s journals that the narrative gains pace and interest. However, the finish feels a little rushed. The mystery is intriguing even if, in places, the plot is a little sketchy, and some parts of the resolution feel a bit contrived. Ignoring this, it is a wonderful love story. Fans of historical fiction and art are likely to enjoy this one.
With thanks to Allen & Unwin for this uncorrected proof copy to read and review.
June 9, 2018
*https://mrsbbookreviews.wordpress.com
4.5 stars
Eleanor’s Secret, the second novel from author Caroline Beecham promises to be ‘an engrossing wartime mystery of past deceptions, family secrets and long-lasting love…’. I go this and so much more from this first rate dual time frame narrative novel.
Eleanor’s Secret transports the reader to London in the year 1942, a time of war, uncertainty and great upheaval. Eleanor Roy is the central protagonist of this mystery, come love story. Eleanor is an art school graduate who takes on a position at the War Artists Advisory Committee. We quickly learn Eleanor has ambitions to become one of the few female war artists active at this time. Her efforts to break into the field prove extremely difficult. Then, a painter by the name of Jack Valante enters Eleanor’s life and he tries to help her cause. The budding relationship between the two is intercepted by Jack’s posting overseas in the war effort. Beecham then transports the reader to a contemporary storyline, based in 2010. Eleanor Roy’s granddaughter Kathryn has been asked to visit her grandmother to assist in returning a valuable painting to the artist who painted it. We learn it is a tough exercise for Kathryn, leaving her home on the other side of the world, in Melbourne, Australia. Kathryn has an autistic son, a failing relationship and a business to run back home. However, the pull to help her grandmother at her time of need and solve an old family mystery encourages Kathryn’s resolve to make things right.
Eleanor’s Secret falls into a genre or category that I simply adore, dual time zone narratives based on family secrets from the past, which a figure in the present day must solve. I always enjoy stories based on old family relics and how these represent the key to unlocking a deep secret. Eleanor’s Secret bedazzled me from the start to the finish. While some readers before me have commented on the slow pace of the novel, this was the opposite for me. I lapped up this novel in three greedy helpings and I do not feel an ounce of guilt in indulging in this richly told tale!
I was first introduced to the work of Caroline Beecham, the author of Eleanor’s Secret, when I read her 2016 release and debut novel, Maggie’s Kitchen, another fine example of a historical fiction novel. Beecham revisits wartime London again, showing us how well versed she is in bringing important historical events and key figures to life. I can only imagine just how much research Beecham undertook in the making of this novel. Her dedication to her craft shines through this novel. Eleanor’s Secret is dripping in pitch perfect period detail, to the finest degree. Beecham covers everything from the food, fashions, cultural pursuits, morals and social attitudes of the time, the sense of destruction to London’s architecture, to the dialogue, which is authentic.
As a keen reader of all things historical and World War II based, I was left in awe as yet again, I was introduced to an aspect or area of history ignored until the production of this book. Eleanor’s Secret works to draw out attention to the forgotten artists of the war, who brought us so many striking images, capturing heartbreaking war experiences. Beecham goes that one step further and uncovers the important history of female war artists. There were very few of these talented figures in the war, but Beecham gives these trailblazers the recognition they deserve through Eleanor’s story.
It can be tricky to balance a contemporary based narrative with such a rich historical story thread. I think Beecham does an absolutely amazing job of balancing the two narratives equally. I came to value Kathryn’s 2010 journey just as much as the historical fiction thread, it is a vital instrument in sewing together the story as a whole. I really connected to Kathryn’s character and appreciated her back story, her vulnerability, as well as her determination to get to the bottom of her grandmother’s past. I developed an affection for Eleanor, both in the past and present day, which helped me to genuinely care about her story.
Romance has a smaller part to play in Eleanor’s Secret, but I feel it was handled in such a great way by Beecham. It is deeply romantic, capturing the rushed feelings during wartime and the worry that the one you love one may never come back from their posting. I felt every moment of Jack and Eleanor’s romance, it was a classic and heart rendering love story. Beecham is skilled in the art of the gradual reveal; we receive little breadcrumbs along the way to help us grasp Jack and Eleanor’s relationship demise, which is also cleverly connected to the central mystery of the painting in the present day. These elements all worked to draw me into this finely executed novel.
Back when I reviewed Caroline Beecham’s first novel, Maggie’s Kitchen in 2016, I stated this novel was, ‘an original wartime story, with a hint of romance that I absolutely recommend’. I agree this is quite the case for Eleanor’s Secret, Beecham’s second effort. I am going to go that one step further and issue this deserving historical fiction narrative with a full five star rating. If you do select Eleanor’s Secret to read, do not let the ‘Afterword’ section pass you by, or Caroline’s website, which adds another essential layer to this wonderful tale.
*I wish to thank Allen & Unwin for providing me with a free copy of this book for review purposes.
Eleanor’s Secret is book #59 of the Australian Women Writers Challenge
4.5 stars
Eleanor’s Secret, the second novel from author Caroline Beecham promises to be ‘an engrossing wartime mystery of past deceptions, family secrets and long-lasting love…’. I go this and so much more from this first rate dual time frame narrative novel.
Eleanor’s Secret transports the reader to London in the year 1942, a time of war, uncertainty and great upheaval. Eleanor Roy is the central protagonist of this mystery, come love story. Eleanor is an art school graduate who takes on a position at the War Artists Advisory Committee. We quickly learn Eleanor has ambitions to become one of the few female war artists active at this time. Her efforts to break into the field prove extremely difficult. Then, a painter by the name of Jack Valante enters Eleanor’s life and he tries to help her cause. The budding relationship between the two is intercepted by Jack’s posting overseas in the war effort. Beecham then transports the reader to a contemporary storyline, based in 2010. Eleanor Roy’s granddaughter Kathryn has been asked to visit her grandmother to assist in returning a valuable painting to the artist who painted it. We learn it is a tough exercise for Kathryn, leaving her home on the other side of the world, in Melbourne, Australia. Kathryn has an autistic son, a failing relationship and a business to run back home. However, the pull to help her grandmother at her time of need and solve an old family mystery encourages Kathryn’s resolve to make things right.
Eleanor’s Secret falls into a genre or category that I simply adore, dual time zone narratives based on family secrets from the past, which a figure in the present day must solve. I always enjoy stories based on old family relics and how these represent the key to unlocking a deep secret. Eleanor’s Secret bedazzled me from the start to the finish. While some readers before me have commented on the slow pace of the novel, this was the opposite for me. I lapped up this novel in three greedy helpings and I do not feel an ounce of guilt in indulging in this richly told tale!
I was first introduced to the work of Caroline Beecham, the author of Eleanor’s Secret, when I read her 2016 release and debut novel, Maggie’s Kitchen, another fine example of a historical fiction novel. Beecham revisits wartime London again, showing us how well versed she is in bringing important historical events and key figures to life. I can only imagine just how much research Beecham undertook in the making of this novel. Her dedication to her craft shines through this novel. Eleanor’s Secret is dripping in pitch perfect period detail, to the finest degree. Beecham covers everything from the food, fashions, cultural pursuits, morals and social attitudes of the time, the sense of destruction to London’s architecture, to the dialogue, which is authentic.
As a keen reader of all things historical and World War II based, I was left in awe as yet again, I was introduced to an aspect or area of history ignored until the production of this book. Eleanor’s Secret works to draw out attention to the forgotten artists of the war, who brought us so many striking images, capturing heartbreaking war experiences. Beecham goes that one step further and uncovers the important history of female war artists. There were very few of these talented figures in the war, but Beecham gives these trailblazers the recognition they deserve through Eleanor’s story.
It can be tricky to balance a contemporary based narrative with such a rich historical story thread. I think Beecham does an absolutely amazing job of balancing the two narratives equally. I came to value Kathryn’s 2010 journey just as much as the historical fiction thread, it is a vital instrument in sewing together the story as a whole. I really connected to Kathryn’s character and appreciated her back story, her vulnerability, as well as her determination to get to the bottom of her grandmother’s past. I developed an affection for Eleanor, both in the past and present day, which helped me to genuinely care about her story.
Romance has a smaller part to play in Eleanor’s Secret, but I feel it was handled in such a great way by Beecham. It is deeply romantic, capturing the rushed feelings during wartime and the worry that the one you love one may never come back from their posting. I felt every moment of Jack and Eleanor’s romance, it was a classic and heart rendering love story. Beecham is skilled in the art of the gradual reveal; we receive little breadcrumbs along the way to help us grasp Jack and Eleanor’s relationship demise, which is also cleverly connected to the central mystery of the painting in the present day. These elements all worked to draw me into this finely executed novel.
Back when I reviewed Caroline Beecham’s first novel, Maggie’s Kitchen in 2016, I stated this novel was, ‘an original wartime story, with a hint of romance that I absolutely recommend’. I agree this is quite the case for Eleanor’s Secret, Beecham’s second effort. I am going to go that one step further and issue this deserving historical fiction narrative with a full five star rating. If you do select Eleanor’s Secret to read, do not let the ‘Afterword’ section pass you by, or Caroline’s website, which adds another essential layer to this wonderful tale.
*I wish to thank Allen & Unwin for providing me with a free copy of this book for review purposes.
Eleanor’s Secret is book #59 of the Australian Women Writers Challenge
March 26, 2019
*www.onewomansbbr.wordpress.com
*www.facebook.com/onewomansbbr
Eleanor's Secret by Caroline Beecham. (2018).
London, 1942. Eleanor is an art school graduate recruited by the War Artists Advisory Committee and dreams of becoming one of few female war artists. Eleanor then meets Jack, only to be quickly separated by his sudden posting overseas.
Melbourne, 2010. Kathryn is leaving her family at home at her grandmother Eleanor's request for help to return a precious painting to its artist. But that search uncovers a family secret and Kathryn has to decide to go home or risk her own family's future.
I found this overall to be a pleasant book but nothing too exciting for me. I just didn't really feel connected to any of the characters in the book; I felt that at times the way they spoke didn't sound quite right to me for some reason. I did find the concept of the war artist committee interesting but also thought that there was a bit too much information about the nitty gritty stuff around this as well. I will say that I have been feeling a bit over books set in World War eras, particularly World War 2, so I do think that might have come into play with my reactions to this book and I may have felt a lot differently if I wasn't feeling so over done with war era fiction stories at the moment.
Reviewers that I both respect and have similar reading tastes to have praised this novel very highly so I'm sure a lot of readers would enjoy this book if you like historical fiction.
*www.facebook.com/onewomansbbr
Eleanor's Secret by Caroline Beecham. (2018).
London, 1942. Eleanor is an art school graduate recruited by the War Artists Advisory Committee and dreams of becoming one of few female war artists. Eleanor then meets Jack, only to be quickly separated by his sudden posting overseas.
Melbourne, 2010. Kathryn is leaving her family at home at her grandmother Eleanor's request for help to return a precious painting to its artist. But that search uncovers a family secret and Kathryn has to decide to go home or risk her own family's future.
I found this overall to be a pleasant book but nothing too exciting for me. I just didn't really feel connected to any of the characters in the book; I felt that at times the way they spoke didn't sound quite right to me for some reason. I did find the concept of the war artist committee interesting but also thought that there was a bit too much information about the nitty gritty stuff around this as well. I will say that I have been feeling a bit over books set in World War eras, particularly World War 2, so I do think that might have come into play with my reactions to this book and I may have felt a lot differently if I wasn't feeling so over done with war era fiction stories at the moment.
Reviewers that I both respect and have similar reading tastes to have praised this novel very highly so I'm sure a lot of readers would enjoy this book if you like historical fiction.
August 22, 2018
Finally manage to find a war book that wasn't a complete drainer!
This actually kept me pretty entertained. It was blessedly light on all the horrors-of-war details and focused more on the art and artists, which I found quite interesting. It's a new angle, thus quite refreshing.
The split views between the 1940s and 2010 also allow for variation and make things a bit more interesting, particularly as the mystery surrounding Jack's disappearance grows deeper and more intriguing. I was very curious about what happened to him, and was praying for a happy ending!
On that note, I feel like the conclusion fizzled a bit. There was the potential for big dramatic impact but it was a lost opportunity. I don't think I felt quite the desired effect.
It was an entertaining story pleasantly divided between Eleanor's past and Kathryn's present. It tackles a unique angle which makes this instantly more entertaining than so many other war books out there, and the characters were likable enough to inspire a little empathy.
Highly recommend for those who love war-era historical fiction.
This actually kept me pretty entertained. It was blessedly light on all the horrors-of-war details and focused more on the art and artists, which I found quite interesting. It's a new angle, thus quite refreshing.
The split views between the 1940s and 2010 also allow for variation and make things a bit more interesting, particularly as the mystery surrounding Jack's disappearance grows deeper and more intriguing. I was very curious about what happened to him, and was praying for a happy ending!
On that note, I feel like the conclusion fizzled a bit. There was the potential for big dramatic impact but it was a lost opportunity. I don't think I felt quite the desired effect.
It was an entertaining story pleasantly divided between Eleanor's past and Kathryn's present. It tackles a unique angle which makes this instantly more entertaining than so many other war books out there, and the characters were likable enough to inspire a little empathy.
Highly recommend for those who love war-era historical fiction.
March 9, 2018
Caroline Beecham is a fantastic author. She takes a subject and creates such a beautiful picture in the minds eye that you just can't help but become completely engrossed within the story.
This story set in the war follows Eleanor and her work with the War Artist Advisory Committee. And it follows Jack, one of the war artists....... And Eleanor's love.
This book gave me goosebumps on more than 1 occasion.
This story set in the war follows Eleanor and her work with the War Artist Advisory Committee. And it follows Jack, one of the war artists....... And Eleanor's love.
This book gave me goosebumps on more than 1 occasion.
May 27, 2018
From the Australian author of Maggie's Kitchen, Caroline Beecham, comes her second novel, Eleanor's Secret. Eleanor's Secret is a historical fiction novel told in the third person with a dual timeline. Set in London 1942 and Melbourne in 2010, it is the story of a two young women revealed in five parts.
In 1942, the reader follows in the footsteps of Eleanor Ray. A young woman who works for the War Artists Advisory Committee (WAAC), her true calling is to be a war artist. Knowing little about war artists during the second world war, I gained some basic but interesting insight into a career during that era. During that time a woman's place was still seen to be the homemaker despite them taking on many roles previously dominated by men. I truly felt for Eleanor as she tried to gain acceptance for her work. When she finally does it is with some unconventional yet understandable methods and with Jack Valante's help.
Jack is the love interest if of Eleanor and I had some high expectations of his role within the story. Initially, Jack too is a war artist but it's gradually revealed that this is a cover up for a more important mission. Most of the time the reader is in the dark just like Eleanor about this mission and I found this to be quite frustrating. I was hoping for intricate details and to learn more about this inner sanctum. Much more research would have added greater depth to Jack's journey during the war.
In 2010, Kathryn leaves Melbourne at the request of her grandmother Eleanor and heads to London to return a painting to it's owner. Like her grandmother, Kathryn has her own issues to deal with in modern times. Married with a child, Kathryn must decide with the clarity of distance if her marriage is worth saving. While I was invested in Kathryn's part, the story dragged in her timeline as not a lot seemed to happen as she endeavors to find the artist. Family secrets are revealed but it was nothing shocking or surprising. Instead it is logical and neatly tied together.
With themes of family secrets, war, love, men and women's roles in society this is an enjoyable way to pass the time.
Thank you to Beauty and Lace for a copy to review.
Part of the #AWWC#
In 1942, the reader follows in the footsteps of Eleanor Ray. A young woman who works for the War Artists Advisory Committee (WAAC), her true calling is to be a war artist. Knowing little about war artists during the second world war, I gained some basic but interesting insight into a career during that era. During that time a woman's place was still seen to be the homemaker despite them taking on many roles previously dominated by men. I truly felt for Eleanor as she tried to gain acceptance for her work. When she finally does it is with some unconventional yet understandable methods and with Jack Valante's help.
Jack is the love interest if of Eleanor and I had some high expectations of his role within the story. Initially, Jack too is a war artist but it's gradually revealed that this is a cover up for a more important mission. Most of the time the reader is in the dark just like Eleanor about this mission and I found this to be quite frustrating. I was hoping for intricate details and to learn more about this inner sanctum. Much more research would have added greater depth to Jack's journey during the war.
In 2010, Kathryn leaves Melbourne at the request of her grandmother Eleanor and heads to London to return a painting to it's owner. Like her grandmother, Kathryn has her own issues to deal with in modern times. Married with a child, Kathryn must decide with the clarity of distance if her marriage is worth saving. While I was invested in Kathryn's part, the story dragged in her timeline as not a lot seemed to happen as she endeavors to find the artist. Family secrets are revealed but it was nothing shocking or surprising. Instead it is logical and neatly tied together.
With themes of family secrets, war, love, men and women's roles in society this is an enjoyable way to pass the time.
Thank you to Beauty and Lace for a copy to review.
Part of the #AWWC#
August 17, 2019
(Will Dyson was Australia's first war artist who travelled without pay to France where in 1916 he saw some of the bloodiest fighting in history. Ben Quilty, is Australia's modern day acclaimed war artist and at this present time has an exhibition on view at the Gallery of Modern Art (GOMA) Brisbane until October.)
In 1942 Eleanor is working for the Ministry of Food and has been sent to have a contract signed by artist Jack Valante where she finds him drawing war orphans in an old estate building. Eleanor who had been an arts student recognises his work and a conversation ensues in connection with a mutual acquaintance and student advocate. Jack refuses to sign the contract for Eleanor, leaving her in a dilemma.
2010 Kathryn, Eleanor's granddaughter has arrived in London with a painting of Eleanor's tucked in her luggage, The Crimson Sun. Her grandmother has requested that she bring it back to the UK. This request comes at a difficult time for Kathryn, marriage strains with husband Christopher and her maternal pull to her small son. Still, because of Eleanor's ageing years Kathryn agrees to make the trip.
The book follows the two eras successfully with the young Eleanor grappling with the constraints of the times for women, wishing that she could follow the same path of male war artists. Her involvement with Jack develops further until his deployment overseas where she loses track of him until 2010 when events surrounding her past life and this painting end up solving the mystery of Jack's disappearance and revealing the whole story to Kathryn.
In 1942 Eleanor is working for the Ministry of Food and has been sent to have a contract signed by artist Jack Valante where she finds him drawing war orphans in an old estate building. Eleanor who had been an arts student recognises his work and a conversation ensues in connection with a mutual acquaintance and student advocate. Jack refuses to sign the contract for Eleanor, leaving her in a dilemma.
2010 Kathryn, Eleanor's granddaughter has arrived in London with a painting of Eleanor's tucked in her luggage, The Crimson Sun. Her grandmother has requested that she bring it back to the UK. This request comes at a difficult time for Kathryn, marriage strains with husband Christopher and her maternal pull to her small son. Still, because of Eleanor's ageing years Kathryn agrees to make the trip.
The book follows the two eras successfully with the young Eleanor grappling with the constraints of the times for women, wishing that she could follow the same path of male war artists. Her involvement with Jack develops further until his deployment overseas where she loses track of him until 2010 when events surrounding her past life and this painting end up solving the mystery of Jack's disappearance and revealing the whole story to Kathryn.
September 2, 2018
I really enjoyed Eleanor's Secret by Caroline Beecham, (author of Maggie's Kitchen) which I read just a couple of years ago and also loved.
Eleanor's Secret is a new and slightly different story focusing on War Artists.
This story is full of mystery and intrigue ~ an artistic flair and a touch of romance.
It's absorbing, easy to read, very interesting ~ full of history and research into War Artists of the 1940's.
Thank you to Amanda at Mrs B's Book Reviews and also the publishers, Allen and Unwin for a copy of this book.
I would recommend this book.
* This book really appealed to me as I'm interested in Art and History
Eleanor's Secret is a new and slightly different story focusing on War Artists.
This story is full of mystery and intrigue ~ an artistic flair and a touch of romance.
It's absorbing, easy to read, very interesting ~ full of history and research into War Artists of the 1940's.
Thank you to Amanda at Mrs B's Book Reviews and also the publishers, Allen and Unwin for a copy of this book.
I would recommend this book.
* This book really appealed to me as I'm interested in Art and History
July 3, 2018
Eleanor’s Secret by Caroline Beecham is part mystery, part love story, and proved just right for a couple nights’ winter reading. Beecham’s dual timeline story, set partly in wartime Britain and partly in 2010 London, was carefully knitted together, leading readers on a enjoyable and warm journey of discovery. I found the wartime artists’ aspect particularly fascinating, and indeed, this timeline grabbed me more overall both with its historical fact and the emotional investment.
May 22, 2018
It was an interesting insight into the Second World War. Thought two painters eyes. I like the historical value of the book, but I felt that it was a bit long winded. I would give it three a half stars. Thank you Beauty and Lace book club.
June 8, 2018
Review to come...
August 15, 2018
Thanks to Allen & Unwin for sending me a copy of this in exchange for an honest review!
Initial Thoughts Upon Finishing
This was certainly an interesting read. It didn't turn out to be what I expected from it and it was very slow-going at the start. I still enjoyed it, however, and thought it was really beautifully written! But the whole story is definitely more of a family saga than the nitty gritty historical fiction I was hoping for.
Eleanor's Secret
So! This book is historical fiction set around World War II in Britain. It follows the characters of Eleanor, both past and present - so the chapters are split between the now and then. The story begins with her recruiting in her granddaughter from Australia (a mostly irrelevant aspect to the story) in the hopes that she can help her find a man she used to know.
In the past, Eleanor was involved with the war artists. This is a topic I've not come across before and it was really interesting. These were the artists tasked with recording the war through their artwork - half for the sake of recording history and half for making sure the world didn't lose a generation of artists thanks to their general lack of priority in the career ladder during a war.
It's a story predominantly about family with a small, if predictable, plot twist. There's a nice splash of history that comes with it's setting but if you're looking for something similar to The Nightingale or All the Light We Cannot See - or perhaps even The Book Thief - it's not quite like that. This reads very much so more like chick lit (and in the odd chance you've read it, more like a book called Poppy Day).
What I Liked
I loved learning about the war artists and the historical setting and aspects of the book were gorgeous. It was a refreshingly new angle to an otherwise standard war story and I love it when you learn something new. I also really enjoyed having a motivated and spritely main character who was a woman looking to stand tall in a man's world.
The general story itself is enjoyable. However, many of my points on this aspect fall into the next part of my review . . .
Where I Was Let Down
This is a slow read. I got seriously bogged down in it. It's ultimate problem is the lack of any action happening. It's a lost-love story that stretches itself very thin by the end of it. Whilst it is heart warming and nice to see not only Eleanor in her old age come to terms with the past, but also her granddaughter sorting out her crumbling marriage, this is not what I thought I signed up for when I started this book.
The ending itself swung so determinedly from art, history and the excitement of the war years, to landing itself firmly into the chick-lit category that I could help but feel a little underwhelmed. But perhaps if one picked up this book knowing it was more of a family orientated story than nitty gritty historical fiction, the disappointment wouldn't be there at all.
Summary
Would I recommend this? To the right people. I'm not raving about this book but I certainly don't hate it. I really did like Eleanor's character and I really enjoyed the historical tid bits I got to see. Art doesn't make it all that often into WWII stories. So a happy, middle-ground three stars from me it is!
Happy reading!
Initial Thoughts Upon Finishing
This was certainly an interesting read. It didn't turn out to be what I expected from it and it was very slow-going at the start. I still enjoyed it, however, and thought it was really beautifully written! But the whole story is definitely more of a family saga than the nitty gritty historical fiction I was hoping for.
Eleanor's Secret
So! This book is historical fiction set around World War II in Britain. It follows the characters of Eleanor, both past and present - so the chapters are split between the now and then. The story begins with her recruiting in her granddaughter from Australia (a mostly irrelevant aspect to the story) in the hopes that she can help her find a man she used to know.
In the past, Eleanor was involved with the war artists. This is a topic I've not come across before and it was really interesting. These were the artists tasked with recording the war through their artwork - half for the sake of recording history and half for making sure the world didn't lose a generation of artists thanks to their general lack of priority in the career ladder during a war.
It's a story predominantly about family with a small, if predictable, plot twist. There's a nice splash of history that comes with it's setting but if you're looking for something similar to The Nightingale or All the Light We Cannot See - or perhaps even The Book Thief - it's not quite like that. This reads very much so more like chick lit (and in the odd chance you've read it, more like a book called Poppy Day).
What I Liked
I loved learning about the war artists and the historical setting and aspects of the book were gorgeous. It was a refreshingly new angle to an otherwise standard war story and I love it when you learn something new. I also really enjoyed having a motivated and spritely main character who was a woman looking to stand tall in a man's world.
The general story itself is enjoyable. However, many of my points on this aspect fall into the next part of my review . . .
Where I Was Let Down
This is a slow read. I got seriously bogged down in it. It's ultimate problem is the lack of any action happening. It's a lost-love story that stretches itself very thin by the end of it. Whilst it is heart warming and nice to see not only Eleanor in her old age come to terms with the past, but also her granddaughter sorting out her crumbling marriage, this is not what I thought I signed up for when I started this book.
The ending itself swung so determinedly from art, history and the excitement of the war years, to landing itself firmly into the chick-lit category that I could help but feel a little underwhelmed. But perhaps if one picked up this book knowing it was more of a family orientated story than nitty gritty historical fiction, the disappointment wouldn't be there at all.
Summary
Would I recommend this? To the right people. I'm not raving about this book but I certainly don't hate it. I really did like Eleanor's character and I really enjoyed the historical tid bits I got to see. Art doesn't make it all that often into WWII stories. So a happy, middle-ground three stars from me it is!
Happy reading!
January 13, 2019
https://mjmallon.com/2019/01/13/book-...
Thank you to the author for a copy – opinions are my own.
This novel attracted me with its artistic slant and Eleanor’s desire to become a female war artist. I’ve never read anything about war artists before so this definitely piqued my interest. I particularly loved the scenes which focused on the war orphans and Eleanor struggling at first to bring them out of their shells, but succeeding by encouraging them to focus on things that mattered to them – taking them out of the carnage of war and into a happier place.
There are two main female characters: Eleanor and her granddaughter, Kathryn both of whom are engaging and well-developed. I found the shifts in time from WWII to modern day Britain a little jarring to begin with but I soon got the hang of it!
It is a well-written love story and a mystery too – What happened to Jack? Why did he disappear? I particularly enjoyed Jack’s diaries. These helped me gain a deeper understanding of Jack’s character and his frustration at the futility of war. There were rare moments of beauty. These particular entries shone through allowing for a momentary respite from Jack’s witnessing and recording daily bloodshed.
Overall, a well-researched story with some fantastic descriptive detail which really drew you into the story and made you feel totally invested in the characters and setting. I’d recommend this novel for readers of historical romance and those with an interest in art and art history.
I’d rate this 4.5 stars as the ending was so powerfully moving that it made me cry! I love it when that happens. Such a fantastic ending… ❤
Thank you to the author for a copy – opinions are my own.
This novel attracted me with its artistic slant and Eleanor’s desire to become a female war artist. I’ve never read anything about war artists before so this definitely piqued my interest. I particularly loved the scenes which focused on the war orphans and Eleanor struggling at first to bring them out of their shells, but succeeding by encouraging them to focus on things that mattered to them – taking them out of the carnage of war and into a happier place.
There are two main female characters: Eleanor and her granddaughter, Kathryn both of whom are engaging and well-developed. I found the shifts in time from WWII to modern day Britain a little jarring to begin with but I soon got the hang of it!
It is a well-written love story and a mystery too – What happened to Jack? Why did he disappear? I particularly enjoyed Jack’s diaries. These helped me gain a deeper understanding of Jack’s character and his frustration at the futility of war. There were rare moments of beauty. These particular entries shone through allowing for a momentary respite from Jack’s witnessing and recording daily bloodshed.
Overall, a well-researched story with some fantastic descriptive detail which really drew you into the story and made you feel totally invested in the characters and setting. I’d recommend this novel for readers of historical romance and those with an interest in art and art history.
I’d rate this 4.5 stars as the ending was so powerfully moving that it made me cry! I love it when that happens. Such a fantastic ending… ❤
June 27, 2018
In Eleanor’s Secret, Caroline Beecham skillfully interweaves two timeframes—World War II and the present. Eleanor’s job with the War Artist Advisory Committee entails selecting artists to portray the war for posterity and propaganda, while as a woman, her own artistic talent is overlooked. The mysterious artist Jack Valante initially resists signing an artist's contract, but cannot withstand Eleanor’s appeal. Their romance blossoms until he is sent to the front. Years later, Eleanor asks her granddaughter, Kathryn, to locate Jack.
Beecham’s rigorous research is evident in the wartime scenes. The setting and the character’s attitudes paint a convincing picture of the era. The author’s love of art is apparent in her evocative descriptions of relevant pieces. Her extracts from Jack’s diary evoke the grim reality of war.
In the current day scenes, Beecham captures Kathryn’s chaotic life complete with marriage problems and a son on the autism spectrum. When Kathryn flies from Australia to England to help her grandmother, she is explores the issues of national identity—is she happy in Australia, or should she answer the call of her homeland?
This is the second of Beecham’s books. The first, Maggie’s Kitchen, also set in wartime England, examines the struggle to provide meals during this time of hardship. In both, Beecham portrays strong women contributing to the war effort in innovative and constructive ways. I highly recommend them.
Beecham’s rigorous research is evident in the wartime scenes. The setting and the character’s attitudes paint a convincing picture of the era. The author’s love of art is apparent in her evocative descriptions of relevant pieces. Her extracts from Jack’s diary evoke the grim reality of war.
In the current day scenes, Beecham captures Kathryn’s chaotic life complete with marriage problems and a son on the autism spectrum. When Kathryn flies from Australia to England to help her grandmother, she is explores the issues of national identity—is she happy in Australia, or should she answer the call of her homeland?
This is the second of Beecham’s books. The first, Maggie’s Kitchen, also set in wartime England, examines the struggle to provide meals during this time of hardship. In both, Beecham portrays strong women contributing to the war effort in innovative and constructive ways. I highly recommend them.
July 30, 2018
ELEANOR'S SECRET by Caroline Beecham is a historical novel with a difference and opened up a whole new world to me as a reader when it came to art in World War II.
Eleanor is working for the War Artist Advisory Committee while also keeping an eye on her family as much as she can. While she feels lucky with regards to her job, her dream is to be a war artist herself and bring the reality of what is happening on the ground to those at home but as she is a woman this isn't a possibility. When her work brings her into contact with Jack Valante, an artist, Eleanor's life soon becomes brighter and full of promise but when he is posted abroad, things change for Eleanor and will affect her and those she loves for years to come ...
A dual timeline story, ELEANOR'S SECRET by Caroline Beecham has something for everyone but it was the part of the story set during the war that really captured by heart and imagination.
Discovering about art and its importance really gave this story a different perspective and Caroline Beecham's descriptions and engaging characters easily swept me along its pages.
Definitely, a novel that will charm historical fiction and World War II fiction fans everywhere.
*I voluntarily reviewed this book from the author
Eleanor is working for the War Artist Advisory Committee while also keeping an eye on her family as much as she can. While she feels lucky with regards to her job, her dream is to be a war artist herself and bring the reality of what is happening on the ground to those at home but as she is a woman this isn't a possibility. When her work brings her into contact with Jack Valante, an artist, Eleanor's life soon becomes brighter and full of promise but when he is posted abroad, things change for Eleanor and will affect her and those she loves for years to come ...
A dual timeline story, ELEANOR'S SECRET by Caroline Beecham has something for everyone but it was the part of the story set during the war that really captured by heart and imagination.
Discovering about art and its importance really gave this story a different perspective and Caroline Beecham's descriptions and engaging characters easily swept me along its pages.
Definitely, a novel that will charm historical fiction and World War II fiction fans everywhere.
*I voluntarily reviewed this book from the author
April 29, 2018
I was kindly sent this book by Allen and Unwin when I won Maggie’s Kitchen as part of the Goodreads giveaways.
An interesting take on World War II; once again Caroline Beecham weaves a tale of life in Britain through a government agency. Eleanor, a budding artist as well as an employee of the War Artist Advisory Committee encounters Jack; an established artist. The tale evolves around their joint love of art and friendship when the world is changing at a rapid pace.
Beecham uses Eleanor’s granddaughter in a present day setting as a detective, to unravel secrets she has kept to herself over her lifetime. This is the author’s second piece of work and was quite a lovely and enjoyable read. The only downside was it just ended. I had become invested in the two main protagonists and wanted to know more about them. I look forward to reading more of Caroline Beecham’s works in the future.
An interesting take on World War II; once again Caroline Beecham weaves a tale of life in Britain through a government agency. Eleanor, a budding artist as well as an employee of the War Artist Advisory Committee encounters Jack; an established artist. The tale evolves around their joint love of art and friendship when the world is changing at a rapid pace.
Beecham uses Eleanor’s granddaughter in a present day setting as a detective, to unravel secrets she has kept to herself over her lifetime. This is the author’s second piece of work and was quite a lovely and enjoyable read. The only downside was it just ended. I had become invested in the two main protagonists and wanted to know more about them. I look forward to reading more of Caroline Beecham’s works in the future.
July 19, 2018
Eleanor’s Secret was a great book that told a beautiful story capturing the tale from a Grandmother starting from 1942 to 2010 with her Granddaughter going to find what happened to her grandmothers sweetheart. It beautifully flowed from 1942 to 2010 with clues being found along the way. Not wanting to give too much away – It was an excellent read and definitely a book I would re-read again.
Thank you so much Beauty and Lace Bookclub and Allen & Unwin for letting me read this beautiful story.
Thank you so much Beauty and Lace Bookclub and Allen & Unwin for letting me read this beautiful story.
May 5, 2018
A dual timeline story ranging: 1942 and 2010, that was fabulous reading. Some twists in the story and many likeable characters that twisted the heartstrings.
Review copy received from Allen & Unwin Australia
Review copy received from Allen & Unwin Australia
March 30, 2018
A charming tale of love lost, of chances taken and lives changed. Well written and in the end a history lesson for those of us born after World War Two.
May 20, 2018
Wonderful combination of interesting part of history with lots of secrets, and terrific characters with elements of suspense and mystery - I don't normally read this genre but am so glad I did
October 7, 2018
Review originally published here: https://joyfulantidotes.com/2018/08/1...
What really stood out for me in this book was the focus on war artists, a profession I had never heard of up until this point. Basically, during the period of WWII, the sale of artwork of all kinds became incredibly scarce and, as a result, the livelihoods of artists more or less disappeared. Enter The War Artists’ Advisory Committee whose role was to recruit artists (400 in total) to record the war but also safeguard them from the frontline (whether they officially admitted this or not). As you can very well imagine, just a very small percentage of these artists were women.
Eleanor’s Secret recalls this part of the war on two fronts: from the side of Eleanor who dreamed of being a war artist and Jack, who found himself taking on the role. Eleanor and Jack are both wonderful characters and through them, we learn of an important piece of history not everybody is familiar with. Beecham worked to ensure her depiction was as accurate as possible by viewing WWII art, reading artists diaries, visiting important settings and, most importantly, interviewed artists. As a result of the author’s hard work, I enjoy not only a wonderful book but became aware of a part of history that interested me a lot. And you all know how I love to receive factual information through fictional books!
I believe that the above text showcases the brilliance of Eleanor’s Secret far more than my humble opinion but if you are interested in what I think, read on. There was an unexpected flow to this story that I truly enjoyed. I had imagined it to progress in one way but the turn it took was better than I could have imagined. Therefore, the more I read the more sucked in I got until one night I was awake at 2 am because I just had to know the conclusion.
I mentioned earlier that the main characters were great but there was something special which stood out in Eleanor for me. Eleanor is an ordinary hero and, in my opinion, there are not enough of them in this world. fictional or not. Her desire to help the war effort in whatever way she could was admirable and the strength she showcases throughout the book is something I wish I had more of. Eleanor is a prime example of how someone needs not have had cured a disease or be famous in order to be a role model.
One small negative is that in some parts I didn’t feel the story was as developed as it should have been. There were a few small gaps but whether or not they were a result of my greed and wanting more, decide for yourself when you read Eleanor’s Secret. One thing I can say though is what was missing in development was made up for ten-fold in emotion.
Overall, just in case you weren’t able to tell already, I wholly recommend this book. I will certainly be keeping an eye out from other works by Caroline Beecham from this point on!
I was sent a copy of this book in return for an honest review.
What really stood out for me in this book was the focus on war artists, a profession I had never heard of up until this point. Basically, during the period of WWII, the sale of artwork of all kinds became incredibly scarce and, as a result, the livelihoods of artists more or less disappeared. Enter The War Artists’ Advisory Committee whose role was to recruit artists (400 in total) to record the war but also safeguard them from the frontline (whether they officially admitted this or not). As you can very well imagine, just a very small percentage of these artists were women.
Eleanor’s Secret recalls this part of the war on two fronts: from the side of Eleanor who dreamed of being a war artist and Jack, who found himself taking on the role. Eleanor and Jack are both wonderful characters and through them, we learn of an important piece of history not everybody is familiar with. Beecham worked to ensure her depiction was as accurate as possible by viewing WWII art, reading artists diaries, visiting important settings and, most importantly, interviewed artists. As a result of the author’s hard work, I enjoy not only a wonderful book but became aware of a part of history that interested me a lot. And you all know how I love to receive factual information through fictional books!
I believe that the above text showcases the brilliance of Eleanor’s Secret far more than my humble opinion but if you are interested in what I think, read on. There was an unexpected flow to this story that I truly enjoyed. I had imagined it to progress in one way but the turn it took was better than I could have imagined. Therefore, the more I read the more sucked in I got until one night I was awake at 2 am because I just had to know the conclusion.
I mentioned earlier that the main characters were great but there was something special which stood out in Eleanor for me. Eleanor is an ordinary hero and, in my opinion, there are not enough of them in this world. fictional or not. Her desire to help the war effort in whatever way she could was admirable and the strength she showcases throughout the book is something I wish I had more of. Eleanor is a prime example of how someone needs not have had cured a disease or be famous in order to be a role model.
One small negative is that in some parts I didn’t feel the story was as developed as it should have been. There were a few small gaps but whether or not they were a result of my greed and wanting more, decide for yourself when you read Eleanor’s Secret. One thing I can say though is what was missing in development was made up for ten-fold in emotion.
Overall, just in case you weren’t able to tell already, I wholly recommend this book. I will certainly be keeping an eye out from other works by Caroline Beecham from this point on!
I was sent a copy of this book in return for an honest review.
June 5, 2018
If you love being transported back in time and discovering different worlds, then you will fall in love with Eleanor’s Secret. The story line switches between the 1940s and 2016, with the main characters of Eleanor and her granddaughter, Kathryn, the two protagonists. They are both strong and richly drawn and I found both their stories equally compelling. I particularly loved the depth and intricacy of the two storylines which both offer up lots of drama, romance, pace and a mystery that kept me guessing right up to the end.
As someone who appreciates art I found the premise of the story and the real war artists on which It’s based, really fascinating. Like Maggie’s Kitchen, Caroline managed to build a picture of this little-known area of the Second World War without telling the reader anything, just creating the world of the story through inventive settings and appealing characters. In this case it was the work of the war artists and some of the descriptions were really beautiful, the scene on page 199 being one of my favourites.
I found the relationships in the 2016 storyline sensitively drawn and really enjoyed the contribution that Kathryn’s son, Oliver, made to help his mother. I enjoyed Caroline’s first novel, Maggie’s Kitchen, very much and can see how her writing has evolved and gladly give it a five star review.
As someone who appreciates art I found the premise of the story and the real war artists on which It’s based, really fascinating. Like Maggie’s Kitchen, Caroline managed to build a picture of this little-known area of the Second World War without telling the reader anything, just creating the world of the story through inventive settings and appealing characters. In this case it was the work of the war artists and some of the descriptions were really beautiful, the scene on page 199 being one of my favourites.
I found the relationships in the 2016 storyline sensitively drawn and really enjoyed the contribution that Kathryn’s son, Oliver, made to help his mother. I enjoyed Caroline’s first novel, Maggie’s Kitchen, very much and can see how her writing has evolved and gladly give it a five star review.
April 22, 2018
Eleanor’s Secret was a very easy, pleasant, intriguing and charming read about mystery, love lost and family. There were many elements within the story that I enjoyed.
Firstly, I really liked the characters, especially Eleanor. They were believable, well-rounded and likeable, and each held a purpose within the story-line. Secondly, I loved the author’s descriptions of things, from the settings to the paintings, which created beautiful detailed images in my mind. Furthermore, like this author’s previous story Maggie’s Kitchen, this novel was also extremely well researched, and this contributed to me being completely captivated within the narrative. I found that once again I learnt something new about the time. This being the intense struggle for supplies, the limitations, determination and resourcefulness that the artists had and finally positions that artists were given in WWII. These were aspects that I had not ever reflected upon, so it really encouraged me to seek out more information about this. Overall, this was a delightful read that I strongly recommend, and I look forward to this author’s next novel.
Firstly, I really liked the characters, especially Eleanor. They were believable, well-rounded and likeable, and each held a purpose within the story-line. Secondly, I loved the author’s descriptions of things, from the settings to the paintings, which created beautiful detailed images in my mind. Furthermore, like this author’s previous story Maggie’s Kitchen, this novel was also extremely well researched, and this contributed to me being completely captivated within the narrative. I found that once again I learnt something new about the time. This being the intense struggle for supplies, the limitations, determination and resourcefulness that the artists had and finally positions that artists were given in WWII. These were aspects that I had not ever reflected upon, so it really encouraged me to seek out more information about this. Overall, this was a delightful read that I strongly recommend, and I look forward to this author’s next novel.
June 19, 2018
Beecham's novel was one that I found deeply engrossing. Though towards the start of the novel I was primarily drawn towards Eleanor's journey, the further into the novel I got, the more invested in both Eleanor and Kathryn's stories, particularly as Kathryn uncovered more and more about Jack Valante. The romance between Eleanor and Jack was one that didn't seem forced in any way, instead being incredibly believable, the way in which the two characters bounced off each other working beautifully. They were a pairing that I could genuinely get behind, which I often find difficult to do in novels that revolve around secrets as I become too distracted by questioning every action of the characters. Eleanor, Jack and Kathryn were all flawed characters who were depicted in a stunningly realistic fashion. My only wish for the novel was that Cecily's character could have been explored in a bit more detail as I found myself intrigued by what was revealed, yet a little shortchanged when she featured very little throughout.
June 22, 2018
Eleanor’s Secret by Caroline Beecham follows the life of Eleanor during the war in London in 1942 and later in her life in 2010, through her granddaughter, Kathryn.
In 1942 Eleanor is an art school graduate and is recruited by the War Artists Advisory Committee to help artists capture the war in any medium possible. Eleanor’s greatest dream is to become a war artist herself but this proves difficult for her and thus follows her story. Eleanor meets painter Jack Valente through trying to get him to sign up and provide art for the Ministry of Foods British Restaurants and the magnetism between them is palpable.
In 2010, Eleanor asks her granddaughter Kathryn to leave her family home in Melbourne and help her return a painting she has in her possession to the artist. During her search for the artist Kathryn uncovers a long held family secret.
Eleanor’s Secret is a mystery combined with a love story and very easy to read even spanning over the two timeframes. Thank you to Beauty and Lace and Allen & Unwin for allowing me to read this magnificent book.
In 1942 Eleanor is an art school graduate and is recruited by the War Artists Advisory Committee to help artists capture the war in any medium possible. Eleanor’s greatest dream is to become a war artist herself but this proves difficult for her and thus follows her story. Eleanor meets painter Jack Valente through trying to get him to sign up and provide art for the Ministry of Foods British Restaurants and the magnetism between them is palpable.
In 2010, Eleanor asks her granddaughter Kathryn to leave her family home in Melbourne and help her return a painting she has in her possession to the artist. During her search for the artist Kathryn uncovers a long held family secret.
Eleanor’s Secret is a mystery combined with a love story and very easy to read even spanning over the two timeframes. Thank you to Beauty and Lace and Allen & Unwin for allowing me to read this magnificent book.
May 31, 2018
I really enjoyed Maggie’s Kitchen so was looking forward to another Caroline Beecham book.
Eleanor’s Secret is a really well written and well researched book that covers two timelines.
It is 1942 in war-torn London where we are first introduced to Eleanor who joins the War Artist Advisory Committee during WWII .
In 2010 Eleanor is requesting her grand-daughter Kathryn’s help to solve the mystery of the disappearance of a war artist Jack Valante who Eleanor had a special relationship with.
There is intrigue, mystery, history and a love story. The descriptive passages of living through the turmoil and hardship of the war give the reader a real sense of how difficult and uncertain life would have been.
Keeping with the Maggie’s Kitchen theme I was intrigued and interested by the work of the war artists and the art which was displayed in the restaurants.
I enjoyed the story and felt I was on an adventure to find the secrets Eleanor kept.
Eleanor’s Secret is a really well written and well researched book that covers two timelines.
It is 1942 in war-torn London where we are first introduced to Eleanor who joins the War Artist Advisory Committee during WWII .
In 2010 Eleanor is requesting her grand-daughter Kathryn’s help to solve the mystery of the disappearance of a war artist Jack Valante who Eleanor had a special relationship with.
There is intrigue, mystery, history and a love story. The descriptive passages of living through the turmoil and hardship of the war give the reader a real sense of how difficult and uncertain life would have been.
Keeping with the Maggie’s Kitchen theme I was intrigued and interested by the work of the war artists and the art which was displayed in the restaurants.
I enjoyed the story and felt I was on an adventure to find the secrets Eleanor kept.
June 14, 2019
An interesting premise and an engaging story to begin with, but from the reveal of Eleanor's Secret becomes rather pedestrian. Granted it was a big deal at the time, but it doesn't really track in modern day. As I kept reading, I kept thinking "This is it, there isn't anything else?" This looks set to become an even bigger trope in historical fiction. I love reading women's stories and enjoy historical fiction, but it has got to be more complex than this. It reads well, and the dialogue seems true to the time. I enjoyed the characters, even if they were a little weakly- drawn. 3 stars.
May 31, 2018
Eleanor’s Secret is a thoroughly absorbing and enjoyable story. Its dual timelines are equally compelling. I was fully drawn into the mystery and didn’t work out the secret until I was close to finishing the book.
I found the history which inspires the book to be really fascinating and Caroline has done a great job with her thorough research turning up many interesting facts about Second World War Artists and life in that time.
A beautifully told love story and an intriguing mystery.
Caroline’s power of description is second to none. Her characters are strong and memorable.
I have no hesitation in giving this good read five stars.
I found the history which inspires the book to be really fascinating and Caroline has done a great job with her thorough research turning up many interesting facts about Second World War Artists and life in that time.
A beautifully told love story and an intriguing mystery.
Caroline’s power of description is second to none. Her characters are strong and memorable.
I have no hesitation in giving this good read five stars.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 51 reviews