To talk about Barça's trophy-laden seasons from 2008, Graham Hunter, a journalist who has reported on Spanish football for more than a decade, writes a bit about what happened before the spellbinding years. He attempts to dive deep into Pep Guardiola's tenure at Barça's helm, articulate how dominant Barcelona was and how the manager got them to play that way. Hunter segues past with the (then) present and talks about the 80s and 90s; he invokes Johan Cruyff, Louis Van Gaal, Guardiola-the-player, Ronaldinho; he also weaves an informative portrait around the intricate politics behind the Catalan club. While doing so, he dedicates meaty chapters to important players during that 2008 to 2012 period: Lionel Messi, Xavi, Gerard Piqué, Carles Puyol (they have a chapter together), Víctor Valdés, Andrés Iniesta as also short passages on other influential players like Pedro, Sergio Busquets, Dani Alves and Eric Abidal.
I learnt a lot about Cruyff's influence on Barça's system and also on Barça's stature in the global football sphere. I learnt a lot about the man who influenced the club to believe in its youngsters, its canteras. That it was him who decided that every age group in Barcelona's youth system would play the same formation as the first team, speaks volumes of the effect his managerial stint at the club had, has on the club's fortunes even in present times. I have always had a huge respect for the legendary Cruyff and this book helped build that respect further.
I always been in awe of football clubs that have a solid youth system- Barcelona, Bayern Munich and Arsenal, to name a few. My firm belief is that in order for a team to play consistently well at the top level, it must have a solid foundation; it must have immense belief in its young guns.
Barça was the world's best, most successful club between the years 2008 and 2012, winning 14 trophies along the way, beating the top sides from the other European league in consistent and convincing fashion. The team played with at a breakneck speed, always on the move, always playing one-touch or two-touch (sometimes even half-touch) passes. The side was impossible to defend against on so many occasions and produced many a divine performance during that time. The 'tiki-taka' style introduced by Guardiola continues to influence many teams and many managers.
Hunter also talks a lot about José Mourinho and his rather abrasive managerial style at Barcelona's arch rivals, Real Madrid. Hunter also talks about Madrid's famed Galácticos project. He writes in brief about how in 2000, the new club president Florentino Pérez fashions Madrid's policy of buying the world's best players to assemble the best possible attacking team began. He also writes about how the project has in essence been a farce and that Madrid have repeatedly failed to deliver the goods on the highest of stages, despite having seemingly the crème de la crème on payroll.
This book was published in 2012 and emphasies often on Barcelona's 'Més que un club' ideal (translation: 'More than a club'). Over the years though, Barcelona has risen to be as commercial as Madrid and in the recent past, have even been more commercial than Madrid. After Sandro Rosell became the club president, the club has increasingly become more a brand than a football club. I read, only yesterday, an important piece by Jonathan Liew, called 'The "Madrification" of Barcelona: How Barca went from 'Més que un club' to just another global superbrand'. He paints a rather vivid picture and raises questions that, a few years back, would have been unheard of in the vicinity of the Catalan club- "Does Barcelona make money to exist? Or does it now exist to make money?"
Overall, this has been a long, informative but ultimately disappointing read. I admit that Hunter had a lot to cover. In the 450 or so pages of text, I am sure he feels even to this day that he could have said more. I am sure he feels that he could have penned down more pages. But his eagerness to write about a lot of things but his emotions as a fan that simply cannot avoid poring over the pages, make the book a rather incomplete mesh of unfulfilled pieces. I expected a lot from this book, because of my belief in Hunter's wit and his way with words and also because of my personal awe of and respect for the Barça side of Guardiola's. Too many portions seemed hurried. I found a few passages to be repetitive- they served no emphatic purpose and ended up being unnecessary flab to already burgeoning text.
I spent a lot of time reading this book. I took multiple detours, finding articles on the internet to supplement Hunter's reportage. As I read through the final few pages, I could not help but feel a sense of bitterness- a forlorn sense of being, imagining what this book could have been.
This book was about a tantalizing, mesmerising subject. Written by an excellent writer, it promised so much. It is regrettable that it failed to deliver.
PS: The chapter on Busquets was too short to pay event a token testament to his influence in the side. It's alarmingly short. Barely three pages. This, in a book about Barca, written by a journalist who is a self-confessed Barca fan and whose narrative oozes every bit of his fanboy awe. I expected more about Busquets.
Busquets remains understated, even in books. I am adding this quip about Busquets at the end of this review, to further supplement the irony.