I was torn in giving this a 4.5 or 5, but considering my enjoyment in reading this, I gave this a 5 in the end.
This retelling of Peter Pan is unlike any other that I have read. Of course, considering that this is my first retelling of the story, it's no wonder I'd think that.
Most importantly, though, this story isn't about Peter, but Wendy.
Wendy went on a trip to New Zealand with her best friend, Jennifer and while there, she experienced a strange phenomenon that transports her into a world she has never known before, lost in a complete foreign land. One of the things I love about this story is that Wendy lived in a modern world, one that has never heard of the actual Peter Pan story. So it's refreshing to see this kind of take in to this story. The Neverland world and the modern one has many things in common in terms of the things in its existence, yet again it's not the same.
There's also Peter. He's lived his whole life being alone and stranded on an island, navigating the seas and feeling content with that, until he met Wendy. These two characters also shared some things in common, yet they were also so much different. I absolutely love the chemistry between Wendy and Peter, the friendly banters they had with each other, and while their personalities are different, they relied on each other throughout the journey. Although Peter tend to opt an optimistic outlook on things, he's also mischievous but earnest. And Wendy's character is refreshing to read because while she's a worrier, and are reckless with her words when she's in a bind, she's also brave and strong and that was apparent when she helped fend them both from the pirates in some occasion, apart from Peter who was both reliable and always the knight beside her.
There's just one thing that I thought was a bit odd, which while I didn't think this occurred too much nor did it prevent me from enjoying the story OR left me feeling annoyed, was Peter's way of speaking. While he does sound archaic just like the world in Neverland, sometimes he sounded like a boy from Wendy's world rather when they were communicating. That did make me think about the consistency, however, it wasn't too pressing that I thought it was a problem for me to enjoy the book.
I had wondered how the ending was going to be like halfway through my read, will I get the satisfaction of Wendy making the smart and right decision that will suit what she loved and always wanted, or will she drop everything without closure just to get a chance at love? I'm glad to say that I was content with how it ended, and while they didn't make haste of their plan, it was a relief knowing that Wendy had planned things out and is someone who's responsible and loyal to her family, even when she had found love in the end.
All in all, though, I really love how Molly K. Mulligan wrote this story, how everything including the plot, settings, names of parts of the ship and the descriptions of every scene that I can imagine really well was laid out clearly in this story. While reading this, there was also a sense of magical wonder and feelings of ethereal-ness in this book and that definitely influenced how I feel in enjoying it. It was easy to get attached to Wendy and Peter and I loved how the story ended.
I'm really glad that I finally took the time to read this book :D