What do you think?
Rate this book


380 pages, Kindle Edition
Published May 7, 2018

Fostering Faust, the first book in Randi Darren’s Fostering Faust series, is a dark blend of LitRPG and harem fantasy that seeks to push boundaries but stumbles in execution. While it boasts an interesting premise rooted in manipulation and personal gain, its shallow characters, troubling themes, and inconsistent narrative structure make it a difficult book to recommend, especially when compared to its contemporaries in the genre.

Premise and Potential

At the core of Fostering Faust is a Faustian bargain: the protagonist, Alex, is granted the power to control and manipulate others by making deals, exploiting their weaknesses, and fostering his influence. On paper, this sounds like a unique twist on the typical LitRPG protagonist's journey. Instead of merely gaining power through grinding or leveling up, Alex gains it through psychological and social manipulation. This twist could have provided an intriguing character study of moral ambiguity, but Darren's execution falls short.

Character Development: Shallow and Disturbing

Alex, like many protagonists in the harem genre, is a power fantasy self-insert. However, unlike the best works in the genre that temper their protagonist's growth with real-world consequences or emotional development, Alex remains largely unchallenged throughout the book. He doesn’t wrestle with his choices in any meaningful way, and his rapid rise to dominance feels less like an exploration of power and more like wish-fulfillment.
More concerning, however, is how the novel treats its female characters. They are often reduced to objects, manipulated by Alex with little to no agency. Their consent is regularly coerced or obtained through dubious means, which makes their relationships with Alex feel exploitative rather than genuine. Darren’s depiction of these dynamics is not framed as a critique of power, but rather as something to be indulged in, which leaves a sour taste, especially when compared to more nuanced works in the genre.
Worldbuilding: Thin and Uninspired
The world of Fostering Faust lacks the depth and complexity that’s found in other popular LitRPG or harem fantasy novels. There is little attention paid to developing the setting or the rules that govern Alex’s power. While the Faustian deal is interesting in concept, it is underutilized. The mechanics of the world seem to exist only to justify Alex’s manipulation, rather than being an integral part of the narrative.
In contrast, more successful LitRPG novels like Will Wight’s Cradle series or Dakota Krout’s Divine Dungeon series pay close attention to worldbuilding, ensuring that their systems feel logical and grounded. The protagonists in those series also interact with the world in a way that feels earned, rather than simply handed to them. In Fostering Faust, the world is more of a backdrop to Alex’s manipulations than a fully-realized setting.
Comparison to Contemporaries: Lacking Depth and Substance
When compared to other LitRPG and harem fantasy works, Fostering Faust feels especially thin. Where novels like Aleron Kong’s The Land or Travis Bagwell’s Awaken Online succeed is in providing a balance between action, strategy, and character development. Even in the more explicit or harem-centric works, there’s often an attempt to create well-rounded characters and explore their relationships with some level of depth.
Fostering Faust doesn’t manage this balance. It feels more focused on shock value and titillation than on crafting a meaningful narrative. The relationships are shallow, the power dynamics uncomfortable, and the plot unfocused. It feels as though Darren is trying to imitate elements of his contemporaries, but without understanding why those elements work in the first place. As a result, the novel lacks both the strategic depth of more serious LitRPG stories and the emotional engagement of more character-driven harem fantasies.
Writing Style and Structure: Inconsistent and Overindulgent

One of the most significant issues with Fostering Faust is its inconsistent tone and structure. The writing often veers between long-winded exposition, unnecessary sexual content, and half-hearted attempts at humor. The novel frequently indulges in scenes that add little to the overall plot, dragging down the pacing and leaving the reader feeling disengaged.

Moreover, the manipulation that’s meant to drive the plot is executed in a way that feels unearned. Rather than being a clever or morally complex character, Alex is simply handed the ability to dominate others with little effort. This lack of tension or challenge makes for a dull narrative. Where novels like Daniel Schinhofen’s Apocalypse Gates series manage to keep the reader invested with character growth and meaningful conflicts, Fostering Faust seems content to coast on its edgy premise without digging deeper.


Fostering Faust may appeal to a niche audience that is specifically looking for dark, harem-centric LitRPG fiction, but it is far from a standout entry in the genre. The novel’s reliance on manipulative power dynamics, weak character development, and lackluster worldbuilding hold it back from reaching the heights of its contemporaries. The concept of a Faustian deal is promising, but Darren’s execution is too shallow and indulgent to make the most of it.

When compared to more balanced and thoughtfully crafted works like The Land or Awaken Online, Fostering Faust simply doesn’t measure up. While it may have some appeal for readers who are looking for a power fantasy with dark undertones, most will find it lacking in substance and depth.

Overall, I would rate Fostering Faust 2 out of 5 stars. It has potential, but it’s lost in an overindulgent and ethically dubious narrative that fails to deliver on its premise.
