Women in Criminal Justice: True Cases by and About Canadian Woman and the Law is the fourth book in Durvile’s True Cases series. The book is unique in that stories are authored by eminent Canadian women judges and lawyers and deal with terrorism, drugs, sexual assault, and mental disorders, as well as motherhood, child protection, LGBTQ+, immigration, Indigenous, and other urgent issues of our times. Writers and their stories represent Canada from coast to coast to coast.
Hon. Susan Lang on flawed forensic evidence; Hon. Nancy Morrison on a horrendous case of sexual abuse; Hon. Lise Maisonneuve on the emerging role of women in criminal law; Hon. Danielle Côté on the pressures of Judging; Hon. Iona Jaffe on the Toronto 18 terrorism case; Senator Kim Pate on the plight of an Indigenous woman in prison; Jennifer Briscoe on the Fly-in Squad in Canada’s far North; Catherine Dunn on Indigenous victims of violence: Kaysi Fagan on a woman caught in the world of drug trafficking; Deborah Hatch on the ubiquitousness of wrongful convictions; Karen Hudson on people in the gallery of criminal justice; Barbara Jackman on immigration and human rights; Lucie Joncas on interacting with a population at risk; Susan Kyle on being a Crown and a mother; Jill Presser on the fight for LGBTQ+ justice; Rosellen Sullivan on a 13-year-old’s loss of innocence; and Jennifer Trehearne on interaction of courts and mental disorders.
Author royalties go to to establish Indigenous youth writers workshops in NWT.
Lorene Shyba, MFA, PhD, is an author and the publisher and creative director of Durvile & UpRoute Books. While publishing is her primary work, her own writing explores the ways technology, storytelling, and human curiosity shape our lives. Her recent book, The Curious Mirror: An Inquiry into AI and Ourselves, invites readers to look past the hype around artificial intelligence and consider what it reveals about us. Lorene has worked in publishing for more than three decades as a writer, editor, designer, and audiobook producer. She holds a PhD in interactive media from the University of Calgary and has taught creative arts, communications, and computer science. She lives and works in the foothills of the Rockies, with technology close at hand and nature, people, and dogs closer still.
I received an advanced copy in exchange for a review.**
This volume is the third book I've read in the true cases series. I'm thrilled they decided to focus an entire volume on the female expierences in our justice system. I enjoyed reading the various perspectives of judges, crowns and criminial defence lawyers. These legal professionals discussed our legal systems failings and recommendations on how to improve.
I appreciated our Lady Justice was on the cover. I never realized she was not blind like the typical lady justice image we all have. I loved the inclusion of the Women's and General Studies (WGSt) logo from the University of Saskatchewan throughout the book.
Some essay highlights for me were the following:
1. flawed forensic evidence - I heard about the mother risk hair analysis review, but I was not aware of just how many families were impacted by these lab results and the lasting impact these lab results had on the families.
2. the courage of Vicki - this story was incredibly heart breaking and unfortunately too common. I can't imagine how hard it can be for a judge to hear these stories and know the victim suffered her whole life.
3 how to shift a culture - I appreciate that this essay explained female experiences as judges and how maternity leave programs were not established right away
4. weeding out the good - I enjoyed Pearls story and how she was touched that Ms. Fagan was willing to tell her story. Lawyers can really make a difference in their clients lives and client stories can really impact how a lawyer practices.
5. shaky foundation of evidence and 6. pictures from a lawyer's expedition - I appreciate these essays regarding legal aid. I wish everyone could access legal services and not be forced to self represent.
7. suicial clients - I've lost a family member to suicide so I really appreciated this essay. I can't imagine how hard it was for Ms. Joncas to process her client's death. I hope suicide prevention is something legal professionals can be taught more about in the future and be a part of the suicide prevention solution.
I look forward to reading more volumes in the future and I appreciate the Canadian focus. I would love to see this series be added to the required reading for law schools and paralegal programs. These essays include various prespectives, advocacy advice and recommendations for improvement.
This book was hard to put down. As a law student or gave me better insight into our criminal justice system. I loved the multiple perspectives and issues addressed in this book. Would highly recommend.
For days I’ve looked for the right words to describe why I think this is a 5 star read. I would have talked about the depth and scope of the the book, but you can find that in the publishers description. But it is the depth and scope that impresses me still. I had no idea how much I would learn about our legal system, its strengths and its shortcomings, how it overlaps our social network, and the role our lawyers play.
I won’t pretend that only female lawyers are capable of such passion and purpose, but these writers happen to be women and their stories have a distinctly feminine perspective. It’s refreshing and it’s wonderfully hopeful because these lawyers are doing the work we all want and need them to do. It’s just that many of us are not aware of what that is until we read something like this book.
I am deeply impressed with the work it took to produce it: finding the contributors who have such diverse stories to tell and finding them from every part of this country. I’ll be looking for the other books in this series
I had to read this for a class I didn't particularly care for, but I don't think that has to do with my low review.
I thought that this book attempted to do too much, and therefore lost focus. While the overall theme was women in the criminal justice system, each chapter jumped around: Indigenous issues, mental health issues, LGBTQ+ issues, sexual abuse issues, etc. I felt like three or four longer essays would have been better than a long list of short ones, which hardly give the reader a real sense of the individual authors.