Rich yet succinct take on the history, styles, techniques, and ideas that make China’s chief art form.
The writing style is excellent, which means that the book is read easily, and you get to retain a lot of the information. And, what helps are the plentiful illustrations and examples.
One of the main messages here is that the Chinese elevate their writing system beyond simply a means of communication. Through a focus on strokes, rhythm, and structure, we get to appreciate the abstract beauty of the line. This resonates with me because although I do not speak Chinese (and will probably never learn it), I can spend a lot of time contemplating just how a character looks in terms of patterns and the movements of the elements in it. Now I am reassured that there is nothing strange about that. A character does not have to express any particular thoughts to be beautiful. In this way, it is somewhat surprising that the author did not draw a parallel between calligraphy and instrumental music, though he did so with dancing.
And, I particularly enjoyed the part about the distinctions between the different kinds of beauty. Also, the idea that the empty spaces of characters are essential to their appeal was eye-opening.
What also caught my interest is the notion of taking a symbol beyond the real. This is where we try to capture essential depiction of a thing without imitation. Relatedly, I liked the idea that the great works are not necessarily about perfect symmetry as they are about the elusive asymmetrical balance.
Finally, this book gives a lot of practical advice should the reader be inclined to start the practice. Among them are valuable insights such as: keep your brush tight, practice by copying and do not get discouraged because mastering the art form is not an easy task.
The only somewhat questionable part was the idea that writing style reflects personality and that we can deduce character traits from it. Now, I am not saying that who we are does not influence how we write. Of course it does. But that is different from claiming that tall people will end up making tall characters or that persons of optimistic disposition will be able to endow their writing with that universally identifiable quality.
Given that there does not seem to be much material on Chinese calligraphy in English, this is a must-read for anyone interested in the subject. But also, in its own right, this book is great due to its comprehensiveness, choice of topics, style, and conviction with which it is written. As a final note, I wonder how Mr Yee feels about the whole idea of simplifying characters as it was done in the People’s Republic. I guess we will never know.
‘A beautiful form should be beautifully executed’.