When I came to read The Proximity of Stars by Benedict Stuart, I noticed that it had 12 reviews already, all of which were 5 stars. This was certainly a positive indication that the book is a good read.
The primary character is Brian Sunderland, a young man of philosophical bent who is constantly looking for answers to some of life’s great questions. His musings naturally affect his personality, and his character is build of solid and permanent values.
His life takes an unexpected turn when he goes on holiday to a small island with his friend, Gary. Two girls surprisingly turn up out of nowhere, but they are spies and very soon the military arrive in a helicopter ... and thus begins a life of trouble, conspiracies and, indeed, adventure for Brian, even into outer space. However, and I for one was relieved about this, we are not introduced to all sorts of weird aliens. Instead the focus of the book tends to be on the struggle between good and evil, and the complex inter-relationships between the characters, especially when the principal antagonist turns out to be a relative of Brian’s.
From the point of view of creative story and plotting, the book deserves the many plaudits it has received. However, there were a number of issues that bothered me, not with story or character, but with aspects of writing. One reviewer judges the writing to be ‘quirky’. I’m afraid that for me that translates into rushed and immature. In his haste to get on with his story, the author takes many lazy shortcuts, allowing some quite clunky and naive writing to stand. At the very least, this should have been dealt with during the rewrites.
I had a problem, too, with the dialogue. Apart from over-use of the word ‘ain’t’, which really grated on me each time it popped up, I found the dialogue very unwieldy and unnatural at times. And throwing huge chunks of back story into dialogue is messy indeed.
I get the impression the author hasn’t read a great deal of fiction. If he’s going to write fiction, he should read fiction. Many small formatting issues, faulty structure, and trying to pile too much information into short paragraphs, would be issues that would become obvious to him as, unfortunately, they become obvious to the discerning reader.
These issues, however, have little to with story and, indeed, they probably have more to do with me than with Stuart, People who enjoy story and are generally impervious to writing styles and techniques, will enjoy this book for what it is, a rollicking Space Odyssey with a somewhat unsophisticated undercurrent of questioning about our world and its values. Aficionados of science-fiction will love it.