*** MINOR SPOILERS ***
This book is a standalone and it is the first book I have read by the author.
The book tells the story of four middle aged sisters who get together when one of them dies. The three surviving sisters are asked posthumously via a letter to fulfill a request by the deceased sister, Meredith. During the book, each sister makes a life change for the better.
Jillian is the oldest and when she was a teenager, she was forced to give up a baby for adoption. She did it because she knew she could not provide a good home for her child, but she feels like it breaks something inside of her. Her parents pushed her to do the adoption and she ended up in the difficult atmosphere of a home for unwed mothers. After the baby was born, Jillian rarely returns home. Jillian has been married three times and has had a glamorous life in Paris as a model. She now is broke and divorced. Meredith’s request is for Jillian to go find her daughter. Jillian has many feelings about doing so: fear, shame, longing. Her journey involves going through those feelings and undertaking this journey. She is able to move forward with her life after doing so. During the search, she meets Rajiv. He does not reveal much about his past and I thought that it put them on an uneven footing.
Birdie (Beatrice) is a successful doctor, married, and has a teenaged daughter, Hannah. On the surface, she feels like her life looks perfect, but she feels alienated from her husband and child. She looks older than she is and has gained weight. She likes to be in control and, when her sister dies, she tries to take charge but her sisters do not let her and some decisions have to be made together. When the quest comes up to find Jillian’s daughter, she wants to be part of it as a way of connecting with her sisters because Meredith’s death makes her realize how important they are to her as well as that she needs to have a break from her life. During the search, she comes to terms with why she has a very strong need to be in control and is able to put some of those feelings to rest. She begins to try to reconcile with her husband and child. She also has to come to terms with two difficult shocks. I thought that the author minimized these shocks for her and for her husband. I thought her husband came across as very caring despite the distance between them.
Rose has taken care of Meredith for years. They lived in the family home which crumbled around their ears. She supported herself by working from home through her computer and has not left the house very often. With Meredith’s death, she is unmoored. She also has an email relationship with a trucker named DannyBoy. You are not sure if he is a good person or a con man, but his kind letters have led Rose to believe they are friends. Rose is the biggest proponent of fulfilling Meredith’s request. As the story moves on, Rose feels more free and, when she sees Jillian reaching out to try to find her child, she decides to be brave and to move on with the dreams that were set aside when she began taking care of Meredith. Also, when Birdie faces one of her challenges, I loved how Rose handled it.
Meredith is the youngest sister and has died. You find out early in the story that she has some kind of disability. Later in the story, you find it that she got brain damage from an accident in the swimming pool. It has a profound impact on the family as they all feel incredible guilt for what happened which they have never gotten over and it has affected their behavior and life attitude ever since. Their mother starts drinking which led them all to feel less loved. Meredith has always been concerned about Jillian’s baby who was given up and writes the letter to ask her sisters to find her. During their search, they each come to terms with Meredith’s death.
Birdie’s daughter, Hannah, goes on the journey with them and is made a part of the “four seasons”, becoming Meredith’s successor. Hannah’s role in the book is minimized but she and Birdie, her mother, learn to interact in a new and better way. Hannah is very supportive of her aunts. There is a scene towards the end of the book where I am surprised that she is not there (it is not explained).
Most of the story is about the sisters and their individual and joint journeys. They learn how much the mean to each other again. They also face what happened around Meredith’s injury and Jillian’s pregnancy, both of which had a huge impact on everyone in the family.
There are side stories about their relationship with men. Jillian meets Rajiv. Birdie and her husband, Dennis, have to decide how to move forward, together or apart. Rose has to make a decision about DannyBoy. Each of them are brought up in the context of each of the women learning something from the relationship, not about the relationships themselves. I thought each of these stories were wrapped up a bit quickly and that more could have been added. This is true, but it was not the point of the book. The book was about the sisters. Birdie’s husband had a previous relationship with Jillian that I did not think needed to be included in the book.
The title refers to the family’s last name, Season, and I thought it was an artificial name. It could have been tied a bit to the winter of Meredith’s death, the spring of the search, and the summer of the fulfillment which comes from it. There is a seasonal reference at the end of the book describing how every life does have a winter but then you move forward again. This concept could have been better done if it had been included. Or it could have just been eliminated and their family name could have been Smith.
I read this story more than 20 years after it was written. There are references to technology that are old and true to the time, but more importantly, it reflects a different society. When Jillian gives up her child, the way society looked at unwed mothers was very different. I thought the author captured that well.
Finally, another reviewer criticized this book because she did not like reading about the point of view of a birth mother. She had adopted a child and felt like Jillian and her sisters did not give enough consideration to whether or not the child wanted to be found. I think it conveyed an insecurity that I am sure adoptive parents have and a desire to protect their adopted child. I do think it is an important point. According to the Search Institute, 72% of adolescents want to know about their birth parents and 94% want to know which parent they look like. In this book, the child is an adult. People may want to know for medical reasons, curiosity, and other motivations. It all comes down to whether each wants to do so and, in most circumstances, my humble opinion is that it would be ok either side to know that the other was interested in them. They can then determine if they want to proceed. This is an issue for someone to consider before reading the book.
When I bought this book, I bought another by the same author and I do plan to read it. I liked the story of the sisters taking the time together and helping each other to a new beginning.