This review applies to both Eden’s Children and Eden’s Guardians (Kindle 1st Editions)
Why did I give these books 4 stars instead of 3? Because despite their flaws I was completely captivated by them. I read the first two books of this trilogy in two days straight and look forward to the third.
Sandy Johnson’s debut novel and its sequel tell a passionate tale of forbidden love that explores some challenging topics, including incest and rape, with an original twist. When long lost twins, Evelyn and Aiden, are reunited after about fourteen years their lives are thrown into total upheaval at a time when they are trying to come to terms with their newfound sexual desires. But they have so much more to learn about themselves and their family’s true nature. It is their journeys of self-discovery along with the mounting tensions between the characters that kept me hooked all the way through.
The biggest problem with these books is their unpolished nature. There are lots of grammatical errors throughout both and the paragraphing of dialogue could use some work too. If you struggle to get past pages of errors, I would not suggest reading the current editions of these novels. That said, I would recommend them to any romance readers who are willing to overlook such faults.
The main characters were credible angsty teenagers, although some of the secondary characters could benefit from further development. I would love to know what they like and dislike as well as what drives them. There were times when I found myself relating to both Evelyn and Aiden in different ways and I was reminded of my own struggles at that age. It would be difficult for me to choose a favourite of the twins (I loved them both), but of the secondary characters, Jake stands out as the most likeable thanks to his impish personality and kind heart.
I was moved by these books. I laughed and cried at several points and felt incredibly angry when the main characters were mistreated. And the sexual tension- by God! I’m not going lie- I was turned on by the twin’s intimate interactions.
In short, I rated these books for their potential. The creative concepts, troubling themes, and intense conflict (both inner and outer), along with the strong emotional response I felt as I read about the characters striving towards their goals have all set a strong foundation for a great story. It would be worth investing in some or more professional editing so that this trilogy can meet its full potential.