When I began reading this, I thought, “Oh no, I’ve already read this one.” In fact, one of the opening scenes was the same as from The Earl of Pembroke, told from different POVs. This time it was Jonathan and Audrey rather than James and Gillian. In a way, it made me feel like I want to read The Earl of Pembroke again, just so I can compare perspectives.
I loved the characters in this book, most familiar to me from previous books in the series, but I particularly loved Audrey and Jonathan. Audrey is an inspiring heroine -- strong, independent, hopeful, determined, courageous, curious, unwilling to be constrained by societal conventions, and she feels deeply. Jonathan, for misguided reasons, hides his feelings from her - but he is her perfect foil. As a result, she thinks he doesn’t care while he thinks she doesn’t. Meanwhile, everyone around them is well aware of the feelings they harbor for one another.
This had some genuinely amusing moments as well as quite a few touching and tense ones. And some thoughtful insights, like this one from Jonathan early on: “Do you ever feel like you’re an outsider looking in on this world? Like your face is pressed to the glass? All you hear is muffled, and what you see is a bit blurred. And most maddening of all, you can’t get any closer?” And this description of heartache was visceral in its accuracy: “Every dream he had hung his hopes upon in the last year quivered like dew on blades of grass, ready to drop to the earth and sink into oblivion. The emptiness in his chest nearly choked him. He closed his eyes for a minute, forcing himself to breathe deeply.”
And this was one of those amusing conversations that had me laughing:
“She wants to be a spy, yet she’d been telling everyone about it? Not an excellent way to start her career.” Godric’s biting sarcasm wasn’t lost on his wife. “She’s only nineteen,” Emily reminded him.
I loved the fact that Audrey wanted to be a spy, but couldn’t keep her mouth shut about it! The reason I include Emily’s comment about her being 19 is because I remember when I was nineteen, a long time ago, and despite her immaturity in some ways, she is still way more mature than I or any of my friends were. At nineteen, I wasn’t thinking about how I could help my country, and marriage was the furthest thing from my mind. So, maybe she was too exuberant and that clouded her judgment, but she had some serious goals and was exceptionally brave, and I have to admire her for that.
My only complaint about this book is that now I’m anxious to read the next one. It’s not a cliffhanger, but based on all that transpired in this one, I’m impatient to learn more about Charles Humphrey, Tom Linley and Hugo Waverly. Audrey and Jonathan are memorable characters and I recommend this book. I can’t wait for the next one.
Bonus: There is a complete bonus novel, Bewitching the Earl, at the end of this book and I loved it! Also, I received an ARC of this book as I am a huge fan of Lauren Smith.