What do you think?
Rate this book
The Tasmanian Tales #2
The Lost Valley
Tasmania, 1929: Ten-year-old-twins, Tom and Harry Abbott, are orphaned by a tragedy that shocks Hobart society. They find sanctuary with their reclusive grandmother, growing up in the remote and rugged Binburra ranges – a place where kind-hearted Tom discovers a love of the wild, Harry nurses a growing resentment towards his brother and where the mountains hold secrets that will transform both their lives.
The chaos of World War II divides the brothers, and their passion for two very different women fuels a deadly rivalry. Can Tom and Harry survive to heal their rift? And what will happen when Binburra finally reveals its astonishing secrets?
From Tasmania’s highlands to the Battle of Britain, and all the way to the golden age of Hollywood, 'The Lost Valley' is a lush family saga about two brothers whose fates are entwined with the land and the women they love.
The chaos of World War II divides the brothers, and their passion for two very different women fuels a deadly rivalry. Can Tom and Harry survive to heal their rift? And what will happen when Binburra finally reveals its astonishing secrets?
From Tasmania’s highlands to the Battle of Britain, and all the way to the golden age of Hollywood, 'The Lost Valley' is a lush family saga about two brothers whose fates are entwined with the land and the women they love.
361 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 27, 2018
776 people are currently reading
496 people want to read
About the author
Jennifer Scoullar
24 books136 followersJennifer Scoullar Bio
Jennifer has always harboured a deep appreciation and respect for the natural world. Her house is on a hill-top, overlooking valleys of messmate and mountain ash. A pair of old eagles live there too. Black-shouldered wallabies graze by the creek. Eastern Spinebills hover among the callistemon. Jennifer lives with her family on a beautiful property in the mountains, that was left to her by her father. Horses have always been her passion. She grew up on the books of Elyne Mitchell, and all her life she’s ridden and bred horses, in particular Australian Stock Horses. She has nine published novels. Brumby’s Run (Penguin 2012), Currawong Creek (Penguin 2013), Billabong Bend (Penguin 2014), Turtle Reef (Penguin 2015), Journey's End (Penguin 2016), Fortune's Son (Penguin 2017), The Lost Valley (Pilyara Press 2018), The Memory Tree (Pilyara Press 2019) and Wasp Season (Pilyara Press 2020)
Jennifer has always harboured a deep appreciation and respect for the natural world. Her house is on a hill-top, overlooking valleys of messmate and mountain ash. A pair of old eagles live there too. Black-shouldered wallabies graze by the creek. Eastern Spinebills hover among the callistemon. Jennifer lives with her family on a beautiful property in the mountains, that was left to her by her father. Horses have always been her passion. She grew up on the books of Elyne Mitchell, and all her life she’s ridden and bred horses, in particular Australian Stock Horses. She has nine published novels. Brumby’s Run (Penguin 2012), Currawong Creek (Penguin 2013), Billabong Bend (Penguin 2014), Turtle Reef (Penguin 2015), Journey's End (Penguin 2016), Fortune's Son (Penguin 2017), The Lost Valley (Pilyara Press 2018), The Memory Tree (Pilyara Press 2019) and Wasp Season (Pilyara Press 2020)
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 83 reviews
October 10, 2018
*https://theburgeoningbookshelf.blogsp...
The Lost Valley is a sequel to Jennifer Scoullar’s Fortune’s Son. You can read my review of Fortune’s Son here
The Lost Valley opens in 1929 at the height of the Wall Street crash. Ten year old twins Tom and Harry Abbott are orphaned by a tragedy and are taken in by their estranged grandmother Isabelle Buchanon. The twins handle their parents’ death and the move to their grandmother’s country home, Binburra, in different ways. Tom, a quiet soul, connects with nature and finds comfort in his grandmother’s attention. Harry acts out his anger making life difficult and tumultuous for everyone. The once close brothers are now separated by a growing rift of resentment.
The Lost Valley is a sweeping tale spanning 25 years encompassing the great depression with crippling economies and rising unemployment leaving families destitute and highlighting the lengths people had to go to simply to keep a roof over their head and food on the table; many women turning to prostitution.
Scoullar adds historical events to place the story solidly in its time period.
From the Australian bush to war torn London and the horrors of war with a focus on the terrible toll on the families of men disfigured during war with many wives preferring to distance themselves from these men rather than live with the heartache.
Jennifer Scoullar has created an atmospheric story of unforgettable splendour, sibling rivalry at its worst and the effects of the war on all men and women.
As in Fortune’s Son conservation and endangered species are at the heart of the story.
The Lost Valley can be read alone however to get the full benefit from this story I would recommend reading Fortune’s Son first and fall in love with the characters and the Tasmanian wilderness.
*I received a copy of the book from the author and chose to review it.
The Lost Valley is a sequel to Jennifer Scoullar’s Fortune’s Son. You can read my review of Fortune’s Son here
The Lost Valley opens in 1929 at the height of the Wall Street crash. Ten year old twins Tom and Harry Abbott are orphaned by a tragedy and are taken in by their estranged grandmother Isabelle Buchanon. The twins handle their parents’ death and the move to their grandmother’s country home, Binburra, in different ways. Tom, a quiet soul, connects with nature and finds comfort in his grandmother’s attention. Harry acts out his anger making life difficult and tumultuous for everyone. The once close brothers are now separated by a growing rift of resentment.
The Lost Valley is a sweeping tale spanning 25 years encompassing the great depression with crippling economies and rising unemployment leaving families destitute and highlighting the lengths people had to go to simply to keep a roof over their head and food on the table; many women turning to prostitution.
Scoullar adds historical events to place the story solidly in its time period.
From the Australian bush to war torn London and the horrors of war with a focus on the terrible toll on the families of men disfigured during war with many wives preferring to distance themselves from these men rather than live with the heartache.
Jennifer Scoullar has created an atmospheric story of unforgettable splendour, sibling rivalry at its worst and the effects of the war on all men and women.
As in Fortune’s Son conservation and endangered species are at the heart of the story.
The Lost Valley can be read alone however to get the full benefit from this story I would recommend reading Fortune’s Son first and fall in love with the characters and the Tasmanian wilderness.
*I received a copy of the book from the author and chose to review it.
August 16, 2018
The shocking death of Tom and Harry Abbott’s parents when they were only ten years old meant they were taken to Binburra, the home of their grandmother, Isabella, their father’s mother. Tom settled in well, taking to the vast and remote Tasmanian bush just like his great-grandfather, Daniel Campbell, had. But Harry was too much like his father – everything was a competition, including who would receive the most affection from their Nana; it had been the same when their father was alive. And the rivalry would intensify as the boys got older.
When the boys were sixteen, they travelled with their Nana to Hobart. Tom and Harry’s lives would change once again – but the sadness Tom felt as he noticed Harry drifting away from him was immense. They had been close as youngsters – now it seemed they were so far apart, nothing would breech the gap. Harry’s rage at Tom and the bitterness he felt about many things meant Harry would distance himself from his twin for a considerable period.
Tom’s desire to become a pilot saw him head to England and as World War II advanced, Tom flew Spitfires, becoming a Wing Commander. But once again lives changed immeasurably when the war ended, for both Tom in England, and Harry back in Tasmania. What would their lives become; these two men who had known tragedy and sadness all their lives? Would they overcome the past?
The Lost Valley is the second in The Tasmanian Tales series by Aussie author Jennifer Scoullar and it is just as well-written, heartbreaking and breathtaking as the first. When we meet the twins, they are ten years old. The story takes us from that young age, through their teenage years, into their twenties and beyond and is set in the rugged bushland of Tasmania as well as England in the 1930s. I loved the character of Isabella, Tom and Harry’s grandmother. She was a strong, kind and caring woman. A fabulous sequel, The Lost Valley is historical fiction at its best, and I have no hesitation in recommending it highly. A phenomenal read!
With thanks to the author for my digital ARC to read and review.
When the boys were sixteen, they travelled with their Nana to Hobart. Tom and Harry’s lives would change once again – but the sadness Tom felt as he noticed Harry drifting away from him was immense. They had been close as youngsters – now it seemed they were so far apart, nothing would breech the gap. Harry’s rage at Tom and the bitterness he felt about many things meant Harry would distance himself from his twin for a considerable period.
Tom’s desire to become a pilot saw him head to England and as World War II advanced, Tom flew Spitfires, becoming a Wing Commander. But once again lives changed immeasurably when the war ended, for both Tom in England, and Harry back in Tasmania. What would their lives become; these two men who had known tragedy and sadness all their lives? Would they overcome the past?
The Lost Valley is the second in The Tasmanian Tales series by Aussie author Jennifer Scoullar and it is just as well-written, heartbreaking and breathtaking as the first. When we meet the twins, they are ten years old. The story takes us from that young age, through their teenage years, into their twenties and beyond and is set in the rugged bushland of Tasmania as well as England in the 1930s. I loved the character of Isabella, Tom and Harry’s grandmother. She was a strong, kind and caring woman. A fabulous sequel, The Lost Valley is historical fiction at its best, and I have no hesitation in recommending it highly. A phenomenal read!
With thanks to the author for my digital ARC to read and review.
December 7, 2018
Ten year old twins Harry and Tom find themselves orphaned when tragedy hits Hobart and their parents are killed. The boys estranged grandmother, Isabelle take the boys in and begins the long journey of raising the boys, doing all she can to make they are looked after and well cared for.
As we follow the Harry and Tom's story we see them go from young boys into men where each of them discover love, loss and war. They were so close when they were young, but going into adulthood that was about to all change and the boys start to drift apart.
This book is set in the rugged bushland in Tasmania in the 1930's. I absolutely LOVED everything about this book, from the characters to the descriptions of the bushland. Aussie author Jennifer Scoullar has done a brilliant job in writing this fabulous book and I can't wait to see what she writes next.
With thanks to the author for my digital copy to read and review.
As we follow the Harry and Tom's story we see them go from young boys into men where each of them discover love, loss and war. They were so close when they were young, but going into adulthood that was about to all change and the boys start to drift apart.
This book is set in the rugged bushland in Tasmania in the 1930's. I absolutely LOVED everything about this book, from the characters to the descriptions of the bushland. Aussie author Jennifer Scoullar has done a brilliant job in writing this fabulous book and I can't wait to see what she writes next.
With thanks to the author for my digital copy to read and review.
October 26, 2018
*https://mrsbbookreviews.wordpress.com
4.5 stars
Jennifer Scoullar, a much respected writer who champions Australia’s flora and fauna in intricately woven narratives, makes her mark with her latest novel, The Lost Valley. A truly heartfelt and insightful tribute to Tasmania, this magnificent Australian saga ties in themes of brotherhood, jealously, sibling rivalry, love, career and personal aspirations, all within the one sprawling novel. The Lost Valley is also able to transverse time and place, shifting effortlessly between Tasmania and Britain, before, during and after the war. It is a timeless piece of Australian historical fiction.
It seems I was completely oblivious to the fact that this is book two of the Tasmanian Tales collection and I had not read the first yet. I did not feel any holes or gaps when following this new story. In fact, I happily devoured The Lost Valley from cover to cover. I would have been quite content for this story to continue further as I admired it very much. I am just hoping and praying that Jenifer Scoullar has another Tasmanian tale up her sleeve, I can’t get enough!
I delved head first into The Lost Valley by Jennifer Scoullar. The shocking prologue works as the perfect device to hook the reader in to this involving tale. It also sets the tone for what is to come and gives the reader at hint of the state of affairs that defines the direction of this novel. This trauma and resulting mystery overshadows the entire novel. Scoullar dips in and out of this tragic heritage line through her narrative. The eventual climax of events links to this stupefying episode in Harry and Tom’s family history. I admired the way in which Scoullar made these connections.
For a saga, The Lost Valley is not as weighty as novels that usually define this genre, but make not mistake, it is a grandiose tale. The Lost Valley is an accessible family saga, that weaves in and out of places and time frames with guided ease. So as a result, we are transported to the Battle of Britain flying a spitfire, or we are trekking the Tasmanian mountains, or living the depression in Hobart. Each moment in time is carefully illuminated by the expert storytelling skills of Jennifer Scoullar.
Scoullar presents us with a set of characters that easily capture our sense of curiosity. From the twins, Harry and Tom, through to their grandmother and love interest Emma, this is a vibrant character set. Scoullar definitely ignited some strong feelings in me while I was reading The Lost Valley. I felt an incredible sense of regret for the twins and their divided relationship. Scoullar presents this dynamic well, tapping into their rivalry, jealously and favouritism that defines this twin relationship. It can be sobering at times, but we need to realise not all twin relationships are connective. Tensions are thrown into the mix with the interactions of love interest Emma and later a troubled Hollywood starlet who steals Tom’s heart. Emma’s story was just as beguiling as the two boys. The decisions Emma makes in her life, the sacrifices she makes and the devotion to demonstrates to her family offers up plenty for the reader to discover.
Those who are not familiar with the storytelling of Jennifer Scoullar, will soon be aware of her passion for conservation. The Lost Valley embodies Scoullar’s rich enthusiasm for extending our appreciation for Australia’s natural world. Within this tale, we are provided with a remarkable side story involving the destruction of the now extinct Tasmanian tiger, along with a set of other endangered species. This was by far my absolute highlight of the book and it is so well done. The sequences involving Emma’s connection to Beaumaris Zoo, its key figures and eventual downfall was enlightening, but so sad to read. It had me immediately trawling the web for more information on subject area.
Connected to the history of Beaumaris Zoo and the loss of one of Tasmania’s most iconic native animals, the Tasmanian tiger, is the placement of the ‘lost valley’ itself. This aspect of the narrative was also completely consuming. It reminded me in parts of The Hunter, a film about the search for the Tasmanian tiger that I enjoyed very much. This angle of the book really allows Scoullar to sink her teeth into issues of development, mining and the general environmental impacts on progress. The message Scoullar conveys through her book really works well to highlight the issues of contention for Tasmania both in the past and today. We must do all we can to protect this pristine environment.
I do hope we are able to revisit Tasmania again through another deftly woven tale from Jennifer Scoullar, a storyteller I admire greatly. If you haven’t discovered this golden nugget I do hope I have drawn your attention to this absolutely stunning rendition to Tasmania and its ecological historical history. This is also one fans of family sagas, historical fiction, romance and World War II do not want to miss.
*Thanks extended to the author, Jennifer Scoullar, for providing a free copy of this book for review purposes.
The Lost Valley is book #128 of the Australian Women Writers Challenge
4.5 stars
Jennifer Scoullar, a much respected writer who champions Australia’s flora and fauna in intricately woven narratives, makes her mark with her latest novel, The Lost Valley. A truly heartfelt and insightful tribute to Tasmania, this magnificent Australian saga ties in themes of brotherhood, jealously, sibling rivalry, love, career and personal aspirations, all within the one sprawling novel. The Lost Valley is also able to transverse time and place, shifting effortlessly between Tasmania and Britain, before, during and after the war. It is a timeless piece of Australian historical fiction.
It seems I was completely oblivious to the fact that this is book two of the Tasmanian Tales collection and I had not read the first yet. I did not feel any holes or gaps when following this new story. In fact, I happily devoured The Lost Valley from cover to cover. I would have been quite content for this story to continue further as I admired it very much. I am just hoping and praying that Jenifer Scoullar has another Tasmanian tale up her sleeve, I can’t get enough!
I delved head first into The Lost Valley by Jennifer Scoullar. The shocking prologue works as the perfect device to hook the reader in to this involving tale. It also sets the tone for what is to come and gives the reader at hint of the state of affairs that defines the direction of this novel. This trauma and resulting mystery overshadows the entire novel. Scoullar dips in and out of this tragic heritage line through her narrative. The eventual climax of events links to this stupefying episode in Harry and Tom’s family history. I admired the way in which Scoullar made these connections.
For a saga, The Lost Valley is not as weighty as novels that usually define this genre, but make not mistake, it is a grandiose tale. The Lost Valley is an accessible family saga, that weaves in and out of places and time frames with guided ease. So as a result, we are transported to the Battle of Britain flying a spitfire, or we are trekking the Tasmanian mountains, or living the depression in Hobart. Each moment in time is carefully illuminated by the expert storytelling skills of Jennifer Scoullar.
Scoullar presents us with a set of characters that easily capture our sense of curiosity. From the twins, Harry and Tom, through to their grandmother and love interest Emma, this is a vibrant character set. Scoullar definitely ignited some strong feelings in me while I was reading The Lost Valley. I felt an incredible sense of regret for the twins and their divided relationship. Scoullar presents this dynamic well, tapping into their rivalry, jealously and favouritism that defines this twin relationship. It can be sobering at times, but we need to realise not all twin relationships are connective. Tensions are thrown into the mix with the interactions of love interest Emma and later a troubled Hollywood starlet who steals Tom’s heart. Emma’s story was just as beguiling as the two boys. The decisions Emma makes in her life, the sacrifices she makes and the devotion to demonstrates to her family offers up plenty for the reader to discover.
Those who are not familiar with the storytelling of Jennifer Scoullar, will soon be aware of her passion for conservation. The Lost Valley embodies Scoullar’s rich enthusiasm for extending our appreciation for Australia’s natural world. Within this tale, we are provided with a remarkable side story involving the destruction of the now extinct Tasmanian tiger, along with a set of other endangered species. This was by far my absolute highlight of the book and it is so well done. The sequences involving Emma’s connection to Beaumaris Zoo, its key figures and eventual downfall was enlightening, but so sad to read. It had me immediately trawling the web for more information on subject area.
Connected to the history of Beaumaris Zoo and the loss of one of Tasmania’s most iconic native animals, the Tasmanian tiger, is the placement of the ‘lost valley’ itself. This aspect of the narrative was also completely consuming. It reminded me in parts of The Hunter, a film about the search for the Tasmanian tiger that I enjoyed very much. This angle of the book really allows Scoullar to sink her teeth into issues of development, mining and the general environmental impacts on progress. The message Scoullar conveys through her book really works well to highlight the issues of contention for Tasmania both in the past and today. We must do all we can to protect this pristine environment.
I do hope we are able to revisit Tasmania again through another deftly woven tale from Jennifer Scoullar, a storyteller I admire greatly. If you haven’t discovered this golden nugget I do hope I have drawn your attention to this absolutely stunning rendition to Tasmania and its ecological historical history. This is also one fans of family sagas, historical fiction, romance and World War II do not want to miss.
*Thanks extended to the author, Jennifer Scoullar, for providing a free copy of this book for review purposes.
The Lost Valley is book #128 of the Australian Women Writers Challenge
Want to read
December 1, 2018💝 FREE on Amazon & on iBooks today (12/1/2018)!💝
July 1, 2018
I was lucky enough to be contacted by the author to receive a digital copy of The Lost Valley in exchange for an honest review! I am so happy Jennifer picked me as I just loved it. Jennifer explained it can be a stand-alone or read after Fortune’s Son – so I thought to get the best experience I would read both. I am actually missing these amazing characters now and loved both books equally.
At the age of 10, twin boys Harry and Tom are orphaned. These boys are descendants of characters in the first book as we follow this family now into the early 1900’s. We once again are taken to Tasmania (Australia) both the city life and again in the beautiful mountains and again the way nature is described is just enchanting. Jennifer is a beautiful story teller that has the ability to take you there and feel a part of it all. We are also introduced to Emma in this story and I equally loved her story as well. From being there with the boys (and Harry’s rivalry of Tom) through their teens and into adulthood, through love, heartbreak, loss and war, I thoroughly enjoyed every single page. This is an historical saga at its best and I so hope there is another one in this series! I highly recommend reading it as a series and first reading Fortune’s Son to fully immerse yourself in this fantastic story that Jennifer has created. 5+
At the age of 10, twin boys Harry and Tom are orphaned. These boys are descendants of characters in the first book as we follow this family now into the early 1900’s. We once again are taken to Tasmania (Australia) both the city life and again in the beautiful mountains and again the way nature is described is just enchanting. Jennifer is a beautiful story teller that has the ability to take you there and feel a part of it all. We are also introduced to Emma in this story and I equally loved her story as well. From being there with the boys (and Harry’s rivalry of Tom) through their teens and into adulthood, through love, heartbreak, loss and war, I thoroughly enjoyed every single page. This is an historical saga at its best and I so hope there is another one in this series! I highly recommend reading it as a series and first reading Fortune’s Son to fully immerse yourself in this fantastic story that Jennifer has created. 5+
June 22, 2018
This book was offered to me as an ARC and as I have loved every one of Jennifer's books, I didn't hesitate to accept.
Two little boys, Harry and Tom, twins, are orphaned at the age of 10. And so begins the rivalry between the two boys as they grow from children to men. The Lost Valley is a story rich in its characters, either lovable or not so much, but so very well and beautifully drawn with the strength and frailty of human nature. The story is mainly situated in the heart of Tasmania but takes us also to a world torn apart by World War II and to the glamour and glitz of the world of the movies. This is a beautiful story by Jennifer Scoullar, it contains a whole lot of heartbreak and pain but a number of the characters bring us back to joy and hope. And I cannot help but mention my own personal grief for the loss of the Thylacine from the world. These Tasmanian tigers are an important theme through this series of stories (as indeed in any of Jennifer Scoullar's books), the need to save our wildlife from extinction. I loved the first book in the series, Fortune's Son, and I loved this one too and just had to keep on reading to the end! I very highly recommend both books. I really don't know how I will be able to wait for book number 3!! Thank you Jennifer Scoullar, and my very best wishes.
Two little boys, Harry and Tom, twins, are orphaned at the age of 10. And so begins the rivalry between the two boys as they grow from children to men. The Lost Valley is a story rich in its characters, either lovable or not so much, but so very well and beautifully drawn with the strength and frailty of human nature. The story is mainly situated in the heart of Tasmania but takes us also to a world torn apart by World War II and to the glamour and glitz of the world of the movies. This is a beautiful story by Jennifer Scoullar, it contains a whole lot of heartbreak and pain but a number of the characters bring us back to joy and hope. And I cannot help but mention my own personal grief for the loss of the Thylacine from the world. These Tasmanian tigers are an important theme through this series of stories (as indeed in any of Jennifer Scoullar's books), the need to save our wildlife from extinction. I loved the first book in the series, Fortune's Son, and I loved this one too and just had to keep on reading to the end! I very highly recommend both books. I really don't know how I will be able to wait for book number 3!! Thank you Jennifer Scoullar, and my very best wishes.
December 2, 2018
The Lost Valley- a treasure
Ms. Scoullar has written one of the most enjoyable books I have read in a long time. The characters are real and the outcome is fabulous. I will look for her additional books. CE Williams-Free from Bookbub
Ms. Scoullar has written one of the most enjoyable books I have read in a long time. The characters are real and the outcome is fabulous. I will look for her additional books. CE Williams-Free from Bookbub
October 17, 2018
This is the second in rural lit author Jennifer Scoullar’s Tasmanian Tales series. The first book introduced us to a part of Tasmania that had remained mostly untouched – old growth forest teeming with wildlife, including the elusive thylacine, or Tasmanian tiger. It gave us a love story that spanned decades of heartache and separation and this book picks up into the future with the grandchildren of Isabelle, 10 year old twins Tom and Harry who unexpectedly come into her care after a family tragedy.
Belle has to adjust to having two young children to care for, at a time in her life when it wouldn’t be particularly expected. She takes to the task with enthusiasm however, wanting to give them safety and sanctuary, a place to heal their grief. They retreat to country Tasmania, to her family’s old property and there the boys explore and play, scaring off private tutor after private tutor. It’s not all fun and games though – the boys have their challenges and Harry in particular has a darkness that lurks inside of him, shadowing his relationship with his brother into their adulthood.
Woven into the story of Tom and Harry is that of Emma, a young girl the twins meet when their grandmother takes them to the city. Emma has passion for wildlife and spends her days trying to bulk up the feed of animals at the local zoo, which has fallen into mismanagement. The animals are starving, pacing their cages. Nocturnal animals have their burrows or hidey holes shut off in the day, forcing them to stay out in the open for people to observe them. It seems that no one wants to pay to go to the zoo and then have all the animals be sleeping and out of sight. This messes with their body clocks and makes them miserable and this part of the story was truly hard to read. I’ve been to zoos plenty of times, when animals haven’t been visible. One of my favourite animals is a wombat – try spotting any of them when you visit a zoo or sanctuary! They’re always asleep and so they should be, because that’s how they are. Thankfully zoo-type conservation has moved on and the animals are given habitats and routines as close to their wild and native habitats as can be perfected. There are still plenty of issues surrounding zoos and the like but the way they are run has definitely changed for the better.
Emma is soon forced to return home to care for her mother and her story takes such an interesting turn. She’s motivated by a need to earn money to care for her mother, who needs round-the-clock nursing. Her brothers are mostly unhelpful and useless and it falls to Emma to assume responsibility for not just herself but her mother as well. She crosses paths with one twin or the other over the years, her destiny tied to theirs in the most complicated of ways. I thought Emma’s story was handled remarkably well, providing a different insight into a certain sort of life that I don’t think many authors have portrayed so well. I think the reader was really given the chance to understand Emma’s position and her motivations and the ways in which she was able to make these choices for herself. It perhaps may not have started that way but she did use what happened to take control and power for her own destiny. She really does use what happened to her, the position she was put in, to better her own life and to be the one in charge. She goes from being very helpless to financially independent, reclaiming herself and her ability to choose her future. She is a really interesting character and I enjoyed the time devoted to her a lot.
As always, conservation is a strong thread running through this book, from the beginning of the boys exploring their new home to Belle confiding her secrets so that they may be preserved for many years to come. This creates conflict between the two siblings, amplifying the chip Harry seems to have on his shoulder regarding his brother and his confused and muddled feelings after their parents’ deaths. This builds so well throughout the novel novel, Scoullar expanding on the tension that has simmered between the boys since their childhood until it explodes.
This was a fantastic follow up to the first book – these books just flow so well and they’re so readable. I read both on my iPad and sometimes it can be difficult to judge how long you have to go until the finish but these simply fly by so fast I don’t even get time to wonder. I fall into the story of this family so easily – their loves and losses, the passion for the land that underpins everything. I think there’s another book to come and I can’t wait to see where it goes next.
***A copy of this book was provided by the author for the purpose of an honest review***
Belle has to adjust to having two young children to care for, at a time in her life when it wouldn’t be particularly expected. She takes to the task with enthusiasm however, wanting to give them safety and sanctuary, a place to heal their grief. They retreat to country Tasmania, to her family’s old property and there the boys explore and play, scaring off private tutor after private tutor. It’s not all fun and games though – the boys have their challenges and Harry in particular has a darkness that lurks inside of him, shadowing his relationship with his brother into their adulthood.
Woven into the story of Tom and Harry is that of Emma, a young girl the twins meet when their grandmother takes them to the city. Emma has passion for wildlife and spends her days trying to bulk up the feed of animals at the local zoo, which has fallen into mismanagement. The animals are starving, pacing their cages. Nocturnal animals have their burrows or hidey holes shut off in the day, forcing them to stay out in the open for people to observe them. It seems that no one wants to pay to go to the zoo and then have all the animals be sleeping and out of sight. This messes with their body clocks and makes them miserable and this part of the story was truly hard to read. I’ve been to zoos plenty of times, when animals haven’t been visible. One of my favourite animals is a wombat – try spotting any of them when you visit a zoo or sanctuary! They’re always asleep and so they should be, because that’s how they are. Thankfully zoo-type conservation has moved on and the animals are given habitats and routines as close to their wild and native habitats as can be perfected. There are still plenty of issues surrounding zoos and the like but the way they are run has definitely changed for the better.
Emma is soon forced to return home to care for her mother and her story takes such an interesting turn. She’s motivated by a need to earn money to care for her mother, who needs round-the-clock nursing. Her brothers are mostly unhelpful and useless and it falls to Emma to assume responsibility for not just herself but her mother as well. She crosses paths with one twin or the other over the years, her destiny tied to theirs in the most complicated of ways. I thought Emma’s story was handled remarkably well, providing a different insight into a certain sort of life that I don’t think many authors have portrayed so well. I think the reader was really given the chance to understand Emma’s position and her motivations and the ways in which she was able to make these choices for herself. It perhaps may not have started that way but she did use what happened to take control and power for her own destiny. She really does use what happened to her, the position she was put in, to better her own life and to be the one in charge. She goes from being very helpless to financially independent, reclaiming herself and her ability to choose her future. She is a really interesting character and I enjoyed the time devoted to her a lot.
As always, conservation is a strong thread running through this book, from the beginning of the boys exploring their new home to Belle confiding her secrets so that they may be preserved for many years to come. This creates conflict between the two siblings, amplifying the chip Harry seems to have on his shoulder regarding his brother and his confused and muddled feelings after their parents’ deaths. This builds so well throughout the novel novel, Scoullar expanding on the tension that has simmered between the boys since their childhood until it explodes.
This was a fantastic follow up to the first book – these books just flow so well and they’re so readable. I read both on my iPad and sometimes it can be difficult to judge how long you have to go until the finish but these simply fly by so fast I don’t even get time to wonder. I fall into the story of this family so easily – their loves and losses, the passion for the land that underpins everything. I think there’s another book to come and I can’t wait to see where it goes next.
***A copy of this book was provided by the author for the purpose of an honest review***
July 11, 2018
Review to follow
August 24, 2018
4.5***** Thanks to Beauty and Lace Book Club and Pilyara Press for providing me with an ARC of this fabulous book.
This book certainly put my emotions through the wringer, being an empath I tend to really feel for the characters I connect with in books and Jennifer doesn't shy away from putting her characters through some highly emotional and trying situations. This is the second book in the series, though it can be read as a standalone.
This story covers quite a few years, concentrating on the lives of twin brothers Tom and Harry who couldn't be more different from the other. Set in Tasmania and stretching to the UK during WW2 we follow these boys who become men as they pursue their dreams, fall in love and fight the demons they've carried with them.
Focusing once again on the protection of the environment, we fall in love with Binburra and its flora and fauna.
The ending of this book was very enjoyable and hopefully we get to visit this family and the land again somewhere in the future.
This book certainly put my emotions through the wringer, being an empath I tend to really feel for the characters I connect with in books and Jennifer doesn't shy away from putting her characters through some highly emotional and trying situations. This is the second book in the series, though it can be read as a standalone.
This story covers quite a few years, concentrating on the lives of twin brothers Tom and Harry who couldn't be more different from the other. Set in Tasmania and stretching to the UK during WW2 we follow these boys who become men as they pursue their dreams, fall in love and fight the demons they've carried with them.
Focusing once again on the protection of the environment, we fall in love with Binburra and its flora and fauna.
The ending of this book was very enjoyable and hopefully we get to visit this family and the land again somewhere in the future.
August 13, 2018
‘Fortune’s Son’ and ‘Lost Valley’ can be read on their own or in sequence. Together they explore multiple avenues and portray Tasmania’s emerging development, and the struggle to protect its unique natural surroundings for later generations. It does this by telling a family saga spanning four generations.
Lost Valley has also a thread of its own: persistent sibling rivalry that moves implacably towards confrontation through page-turning twists and turns of the plot. Will history repeat itself and Cain slay Abel once again?
Lost Valley has also a thread of its own: persistent sibling rivalry that moves implacably towards confrontation through page-turning twists and turns of the plot. Will history repeat itself and Cain slay Abel once again?
January 13, 2020
A new excellent author that I had never read. Want to read all her books. Good story and interesting reading about Tasmania. Would like to go to Australia some day.
January 18, 2020
An exciting, highly entertaining and informative piece of literature that is hard to put down.
First, informative with the introduction of the main characters with revealing incidents of personal battles to come. Then they separate and deal with trials and tribulations that mould their strengths and take advantage of their weaknesses. Then, they all come together to deal with the past, and forge futures that are not compatible with one anothers goals. You cannot wait to determine the outcomes for each, and putting the book down is not an option.
First, informative with the introduction of the main characters with revealing incidents of personal battles to come. Then they separate and deal with trials and tribulations that mould their strengths and take advantage of their weaknesses. Then, they all come together to deal with the past, and forge futures that are not compatible with one anothers goals. You cannot wait to determine the outcomes for each, and putting the book down is not an option.
July 8, 2018
The long awaited sequel to Fortune's Son which I loved reading. Jennifer writes with such knowledge about the environment and the animal world. Much research has obviously gone into each one of her books. The Lost Valley continues the story of the Abbott family and starts off with a bang (literally). The orphaned twins Tom & Harry are very different and are doomed to become rivals throughout their lives. Tom is very much like his grandparents whereas Harry is determined to win back the family business which their father lost. When their grandmother passes away, she leaves the family home to Tom as she believes he will uphold the secrets that she shares with him, whereas Harry would sell it all out just for the money. This book has it all - tragedy, romance, betrayal. I will be interested to see where the third book in the trilogy takes us. I was offered an ARC by the author for an honest opinion. My deepest thanks to Jennifer Scoullar, and I'm looking forward to the conclusion with book 3.
July 9, 2018
The Lost Valley is the second of The Tasmanian Tales. It follows Fortune's Son, but can be read as a stand alone book.
I enjoyed this book, but not quite as much as the Fortune's Son, still it is a good read. This story is set during the depression and World War 2 and features the twin grandsons of the characters from Fortune's Son. The story arc is actually very similiar to Fortune's Son and in some parts it's a bit over the top. I enjoyed finding out what happened to the previous characters and following the new generation.
This book is suitable for a wide range of readers including those who enjoy historical romance, suspense, social justice, the environment and Australian stories.
I received a digital ARC in return for an honest review.
I enjoyed this book, but not quite as much as the Fortune's Son, still it is a good read. This story is set during the depression and World War 2 and features the twin grandsons of the characters from Fortune's Son. The story arc is actually very similiar to Fortune's Son and in some parts it's a bit over the top. I enjoyed finding out what happened to the previous characters and following the new generation.
This book is suitable for a wide range of readers including those who enjoy historical romance, suspense, social justice, the environment and Australian stories.
I received a digital ARC in return for an honest review.
July 9, 2021
This is the second book in the Tasmanian Tales series, a series of stand alone novels, and it draws you in like the tempting music of a carnival. Twin brothers, set against each other almost from birth, growing up in 1930s, Tasmania. They take separate paths into adulthood, one driven by greed, the other driven by heartache.
The characters are so well crafted it’s sickening. You don’t only see the transformations in the twins from boyhood to adulthood, but the factors that build their characters, both good and bad. The secondary and tertiary characters are also well crafted, something that’s difficult to do with tertiary characters.
The plot is absolutely wonderful, with foreshadowing and redemption and edge of your seat plot twists. It has all the drama of Colleen McCullough’s Thorn Birds along with vivid descriptions of Tasmania’s wildlife, nature, and mining towns.
While it is lengthy (over 500 pages), it pulls you in and refuses to let go until you’re forcibly torn away by dinners that need to be made or sleep that won’t be forestalled. Touted as a Tasmanian East of Eden, The Lost Valley is an epic tale that should be made into a movie. I can’t wait to read the other books in the series.
The characters are so well crafted it’s sickening. You don’t only see the transformations in the twins from boyhood to adulthood, but the factors that build their characters, both good and bad. The secondary and tertiary characters are also well crafted, something that’s difficult to do with tertiary characters.
The plot is absolutely wonderful, with foreshadowing and redemption and edge of your seat plot twists. It has all the drama of Colleen McCullough’s Thorn Birds along with vivid descriptions of Tasmania’s wildlife, nature, and mining towns.
While it is lengthy (over 500 pages), it pulls you in and refuses to let go until you’re forcibly torn away by dinners that need to be made or sleep that won’t be forestalled. Touted as a Tasmanian East of Eden, The Lost Valley is an epic tale that should be made into a movie. I can’t wait to read the other books in the series.
March 6, 2023
I started off really liking this book in its first few chapters. I loved the character of Nana and the description of the wildlife areas and I wanted the book to be more about this secret valley.
But not quite. I wasn’t keen on most of the characters in the book. Harry was annoying and full of ego - not to mention an a-hole for what he did to Tom. Tom was a bit of a wet drip and the woman he married just needed a time out and told to shh. I really liked Emma up until she (obviously needed to(!)) become a prostitute - this bit annoyed me the most as why did it need to happen? It didn’t add anything to the plot.
Gets 3 stars as the wildlife aspect was great and the ending tied things together nicely. The characters all needed to climb into a pot and stay with the lid on unfortunately.
But not quite. I wasn’t keen on most of the characters in the book. Harry was annoying and full of ego - not to mention an a-hole for what he did to Tom. Tom was a bit of a wet drip and the woman he married just needed a time out and told to shh. I really liked Emma up until she (obviously needed to(!)) become a prostitute - this bit annoyed me the most as why did it need to happen? It didn’t add anything to the plot.
Gets 3 stars as the wildlife aspect was great and the ending tied things together nicely. The characters all needed to climb into a pot and stay with the lid on unfortunately.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 8, 2018
3.5 stars for the sequel to ‘Fortune’s Son’. Not quite as good as ‘Fortune’s Son’ but still a very good read. This one is about the twin grandsons of Luke and Isabella. The descriptions of the plants and wildlife of Tasmania are reason enough to read the book but it does have a good story to go along with it.
March 11, 2019
Interesting take
It was a slow starter, but after a few chapters I couldn't put down. A perfect blend of love, war, tragedy,and the impact of truth and secrets impact have on one's life.
It was a slow starter, but after a few chapters I couldn't put down. A perfect blend of love, war, tragedy,and the impact of truth and secrets impact have on one's life.
December 22, 2019
Good people will be rewarded
It is a family history, full of romance and tragic. Withe passing of old generation, new generation standup. The story tells life of greedy, pretentious, naive and honesty.
It is a family history, full of romance and tragic. Withe passing of old generation, new generation standup. The story tells life of greedy, pretentious, naive and honesty.
September 4, 2018
The Lost Valley is a sweeping family saga in the tradition of Di Morrissey, lined with drama and beating with a conservationists heart. Taking us back to Tasmania in the 1930s and spanning through to beyond the second world war, we get an intimate look at life in Tasmania during the depression era and prosperous post war years following the hardship.
As well as telling the story of twins, Tom and Harry, we meet Emma, a bright young woman on the cusp of a prosperous future, only to have circumstances beyond her control snatch it away and steer her onto a path she would never have otherwise contemplated. The inclusion of Emma’s story was a bonus for me. She was smart, determined, so dedicated to her mother; but above all, full of intent with regards to her independence. Her story highlights the more tragic side of Australian society in the 1920s and 1930s, a place where the options for women’s employment were still so limited, their roles still defined by a misogynistic view that was not in keeping with the rampant poverty prevalent. Emma’s story wasn’t a pretty one, but it was fundamentally realistic.
Tom and Harry were a complicated pair, both bearing such a tragic legacy, each wanting to prove himself and his worth. It was sad, to see their sibling relationship so fractured, and in all honesty, despite her very best of intentions and overall motivations, their nana really fostered much of this contention through her affinity with Tom, and her subsequent inflammatory favouritism. In many ways this is a cautionary tale, about the dangers of putting one child over another. You can’t give all to one and very little to another without serious consequences. In this case, the tensions between the brothers build and build, until it all rises to the fore in an explosive situation with roots buried deep in the past. It was very tragic indeed.
There were many instances of shallow behaviour demonstrated between the brothers, Harry more than Tom, but it didn’t always sit well with me. In many ways, this is a very compressed novel, with events unfolding rapidly with great chunks of time passing quickly. This did lead to some moments, particularly with Tom and his rushed wedding for example, where I just felt as though things had moved too fast with events jolting out of character. There was little breathing space, to just be in the moment with the story unfolding, and some of the behaviours that Tom and Harry indulged in that bothered me might have been less so if the events had been slowed. Much of this is me though, and my expectations around a family saga. I did expect the novel to be much longer, and in essence, it could have been, another third again, to allow that slower pacing and more authentic unravelling of the drama and increased enrichment of the character development.
The shining part of this novel was the conservation angle, the animal welfare and preservation of endangered species. Any story that has a mismanaged zoo or circus from the past tugs at me. I am often overcome after reading historical novels with these themes on the utter wastage that we have indulged in. Species critically endangered, extinct, under threat; that these animals were allowed to die in captivity due to poor management is such a terrible legacy we hold as humans. Jennifer’s focus on the zoo in Hobart as one such example was utterly heartbreaking. On the flip side of course is Tom’s focus on protecting the thylacines. I loved this part of the story and the magic of the lost valley really entranced me. It was all so atmospheric and deeply meaningful.
‘The tiger yawned wide in an intimidating display of threat. Tom stood transfixed. Here was more than stories and tracks and cries in the night. Here was a living, breathing thylacine, an animal that had walked the earth for millions of years longer than humans had. An animal the world believed to be extinct.’
The Lost Valley was an absorbing read that I raced through. I may have wished for it to be longer, but only because I enjoyed it so much and craved for more. I highly recommend The Lost Valley to those who love Australian history, family dramas and stories with a strong environmental theme. It would make a pretty good book club selection too, as there is much to ponder and a whole host of discussion points to ricochet off.
Thanks is extended to the author for providing me with a copy of The Lost Valley for review.
As well as telling the story of twins, Tom and Harry, we meet Emma, a bright young woman on the cusp of a prosperous future, only to have circumstances beyond her control snatch it away and steer her onto a path she would never have otherwise contemplated. The inclusion of Emma’s story was a bonus for me. She was smart, determined, so dedicated to her mother; but above all, full of intent with regards to her independence. Her story highlights the more tragic side of Australian society in the 1920s and 1930s, a place where the options for women’s employment were still so limited, their roles still defined by a misogynistic view that was not in keeping with the rampant poverty prevalent. Emma’s story wasn’t a pretty one, but it was fundamentally realistic.
Tom and Harry were a complicated pair, both bearing such a tragic legacy, each wanting to prove himself and his worth. It was sad, to see their sibling relationship so fractured, and in all honesty, despite her very best of intentions and overall motivations, their nana really fostered much of this contention through her affinity with Tom, and her subsequent inflammatory favouritism. In many ways this is a cautionary tale, about the dangers of putting one child over another. You can’t give all to one and very little to another without serious consequences. In this case, the tensions between the brothers build and build, until it all rises to the fore in an explosive situation with roots buried deep in the past. It was very tragic indeed.
There were many instances of shallow behaviour demonstrated between the brothers, Harry more than Tom, but it didn’t always sit well with me. In many ways, this is a very compressed novel, with events unfolding rapidly with great chunks of time passing quickly. This did lead to some moments, particularly with Tom and his rushed wedding for example, where I just felt as though things had moved too fast with events jolting out of character. There was little breathing space, to just be in the moment with the story unfolding, and some of the behaviours that Tom and Harry indulged in that bothered me might have been less so if the events had been slowed. Much of this is me though, and my expectations around a family saga. I did expect the novel to be much longer, and in essence, it could have been, another third again, to allow that slower pacing and more authentic unravelling of the drama and increased enrichment of the character development.
The shining part of this novel was the conservation angle, the animal welfare and preservation of endangered species. Any story that has a mismanaged zoo or circus from the past tugs at me. I am often overcome after reading historical novels with these themes on the utter wastage that we have indulged in. Species critically endangered, extinct, under threat; that these animals were allowed to die in captivity due to poor management is such a terrible legacy we hold as humans. Jennifer’s focus on the zoo in Hobart as one such example was utterly heartbreaking. On the flip side of course is Tom’s focus on protecting the thylacines. I loved this part of the story and the magic of the lost valley really entranced me. It was all so atmospheric and deeply meaningful.
‘The tiger yawned wide in an intimidating display of threat. Tom stood transfixed. Here was more than stories and tracks and cries in the night. Here was a living, breathing thylacine, an animal that had walked the earth for millions of years longer than humans had. An animal the world believed to be extinct.’
The Lost Valley was an absorbing read that I raced through. I may have wished for it to be longer, but only because I enjoyed it so much and craved for more. I highly recommend The Lost Valley to those who love Australian history, family dramas and stories with a strong environmental theme. It would make a pretty good book club selection too, as there is much to ponder and a whole host of discussion points to ricochet off.
Thanks is extended to the author for providing me with a copy of The Lost Valley for review.
August 11, 2019
The Tasmanian Tales:
Fortune’s Son #1 – So sad and so heartbreaking, the heartwarming multiple storylines about Tasmania, her culture and her creatures was so interesting and intriguing; it was another hard to put down story. The well-written characters, the author’s vivid descriptions, and talented storytelling abilities place the reader deep into the weave of a beautiful tapestry of love, sacrifice and the culture and wildlife of Tasmania, with glimpses of AU. Bear is my favorite character next to Tasmania. 5*
The Lost Valley #2 – This story begins in 1929 with most of the family involved from Fortune’s Son. This book is so sad and so heartbreaking, as well as so heartwarming, intriguing, interesting and uplifting. The vivid descriptions woven with the old and new storylines make a substantial tapestry of love and sacrifice amongst the history of Tasmania, her people and her creatures and her culture. The 600 plus pages just flew by and I could not put this book down until I read the last page. I chain read all the books I had by this author and never once was bored or tired of reading about AU and Tasmania. the excitement over finding such a talented and creative storyteller/author never stopped. Rereading these books in the future, which is something I seldom do anymore, is a certain possibility. 5*
The Tasmanian Tales end.
The Wild Australia Stories Series:
Brumby’s Run #1 – This is my first read by this author and I love it. I felt like I was there in those areas of AU. The vivid descriptions, the variety of everyday characters, the horses and all the background information just kept me glued to the pages. I could not put the book down and I had another book to review: this book came from my library. I took my time savoring every word and the storylines and was happy the author stayed home, instead of writing about the US or some other place, sharing the lifestyles and traditions in her neck of AU. The extra material not usually found in many books was extremely interesting and enjoyable to read about: the depth of the training; horse breeds; and even the proper handling of the environment. All the background information added substance to the tapestry of the story. I will read every book I can find from Ms. Scoullar. 5*
Currawong Creek #2 – This book is just as great to read as Brumby’s Run. Clare is a difficult person to like. She flip-flops between sensible and plain stupid too much and to extremes. She does running away well but not working out problems. Good storylines full with plenty of love, sacrifice and the power of healing with the use of therapy animals. The other main characters were good and interesting, along with most of the secondary characters. There are good expectations and a couple of surprises concerning friendship. Again, I felt as if I was there through Ms. S’s vivid descriptions. This is a feel good story complete with romance and shared loves. 4*
Turtle Reef #4 – This story is wonderful and heartbreaking. I found Ms. S’s vivid descriptions about the sea and her creatures, and the reefs, their functions and survival against man interesting and intriguing. The dugongs are very interesting and I learned quite a bit about them. Through Einstein the octopus, I gained a respect for the species, especially after learning about the sacrifices the females make for their young. This is y favorite of the three books that I’ve read so far. As interesting as the creatures were, the human characters held up their end – interesting, talented and varying from wonderful to damaged but always believable. Einstein and Aisha were my favorites with Zoe pulling in third. 5*
Journey’s End #5 – Wonderful and heartbreaking, this heartwarming story has a touch of romance making Journey’s End another top favorite of mine. All four stories were great, but Turtle and Journey grabbed my heart and made tears flow. I enjoyed Ms. S’s wild AU stories with her well-written characters and her vivid descriptions placing the reader deep into the tapestry of intriguing storylines and interesting background on AU and her wildlife. Dusty was my favorite character and Taj lent a mysterious element to a well-written story. 5*
The Wild Australia Stories Series end.
Fortune’s Son #1 – So sad and so heartbreaking, the heartwarming multiple storylines about Tasmania, her culture and her creatures was so interesting and intriguing; it was another hard to put down story. The well-written characters, the author’s vivid descriptions, and talented storytelling abilities place the reader deep into the weave of a beautiful tapestry of love, sacrifice and the culture and wildlife of Tasmania, with glimpses of AU. Bear is my favorite character next to Tasmania. 5*
The Lost Valley #2 – This story begins in 1929 with most of the family involved from Fortune’s Son. This book is so sad and so heartbreaking, as well as so heartwarming, intriguing, interesting and uplifting. The vivid descriptions woven with the old and new storylines make a substantial tapestry of love and sacrifice amongst the history of Tasmania, her people and her creatures and her culture. The 600 plus pages just flew by and I could not put this book down until I read the last page. I chain read all the books I had by this author and never once was bored or tired of reading about AU and Tasmania. the excitement over finding such a talented and creative storyteller/author never stopped. Rereading these books in the future, which is something I seldom do anymore, is a certain possibility. 5*
The Tasmanian Tales end.
The Wild Australia Stories Series:
Brumby’s Run #1 – This is my first read by this author and I love it. I felt like I was there in those areas of AU. The vivid descriptions, the variety of everyday characters, the horses and all the background information just kept me glued to the pages. I could not put the book down and I had another book to review: this book came from my library. I took my time savoring every word and the storylines and was happy the author stayed home, instead of writing about the US or some other place, sharing the lifestyles and traditions in her neck of AU. The extra material not usually found in many books was extremely interesting and enjoyable to read about: the depth of the training; horse breeds; and even the proper handling of the environment. All the background information added substance to the tapestry of the story. I will read every book I can find from Ms. Scoullar. 5*
Currawong Creek #2 – This book is just as great to read as Brumby’s Run. Clare is a difficult person to like. She flip-flops between sensible and plain stupid too much and to extremes. She does running away well but not working out problems. Good storylines full with plenty of love, sacrifice and the power of healing with the use of therapy animals. The other main characters were good and interesting, along with most of the secondary characters. There are good expectations and a couple of surprises concerning friendship. Again, I felt as if I was there through Ms. S’s vivid descriptions. This is a feel good story complete with romance and shared loves. 4*
Turtle Reef #4 – This story is wonderful and heartbreaking. I found Ms. S’s vivid descriptions about the sea and her creatures, and the reefs, their functions and survival against man interesting and intriguing. The dugongs are very interesting and I learned quite a bit about them. Through Einstein the octopus, I gained a respect for the species, especially after learning about the sacrifices the females make for their young. This is y favorite of the three books that I’ve read so far. As interesting as the creatures were, the human characters held up their end – interesting, talented and varying from wonderful to damaged but always believable. Einstein and Aisha were my favorites with Zoe pulling in third. 5*
Journey’s End #5 – Wonderful and heartbreaking, this heartwarming story has a touch of romance making Journey’s End another top favorite of mine. All four stories were great, but Turtle and Journey grabbed my heart and made tears flow. I enjoyed Ms. S’s wild AU stories with her well-written characters and her vivid descriptions placing the reader deep into the tapestry of intriguing storylines and interesting background on AU and her wildlife. Dusty was my favorite character and Taj lent a mysterious element to a well-written story. 5*
The Wild Australia Stories Series end.
August 29, 2018
Fortune's Son is superb, but The Lost Valley is simply magnificent! FIVE GLORIOUS STARS!
Sequels seldom surpass the first book in a series, but this one does! OH MY GOSH! I could use all the superlatives and cliches and still come up short. Please, just experience this story for yourself, because my words can't do it justice. But don't expect to do anything else once you start reading, because you won't put it down until the end. Seriously. You won't. (Just be sure to breathe now and then.)
Sweeping from the stock market crash of 1929 to Post-World War II, The Lost Valley covers the lives of Tom and Harry Abbott, twin grandsons of Luke and Belle from Fortune's Son. The estranged brothers follow different paths: Tom becomes a famous flying ace in the war, while Harry reclaims their father's lost fortune. But their lives dramatically intertwine when they fall in love with the same women: strong, compassionate Emma and grasping, nefarious Kitty.
As in Fortune's Son, the author's descriptive powers pulled me right into the settings in Tasmania and England during that eventful twenty-year period in history. But the strength of this book lies with its complex characters and suspenseful plot, leading to a literally breath-stealing ending. (You'll be tempted to jump ahead, but don't spoil it!)
I don't know how the author manages to create so much drama in less than 400 pages, but she does. It's almost magical. You will love this story and want more. Thankfully, there's a third book in this series. I hope it arrives soon!
There are no explicit sex scenes, and the language is appropriate for all readers. Highly recommended.
Sequels seldom surpass the first book in a series, but this one does! OH MY GOSH! I could use all the superlatives and cliches and still come up short. Please, just experience this story for yourself, because my words can't do it justice. But don't expect to do anything else once you start reading, because you won't put it down until the end. Seriously. You won't. (Just be sure to breathe now and then.)
Sweeping from the stock market crash of 1929 to Post-World War II, The Lost Valley covers the lives of Tom and Harry Abbott, twin grandsons of Luke and Belle from Fortune's Son. The estranged brothers follow different paths: Tom becomes a famous flying ace in the war, while Harry reclaims their father's lost fortune. But their lives dramatically intertwine when they fall in love with the same women: strong, compassionate Emma and grasping, nefarious Kitty.
As in Fortune's Son, the author's descriptive powers pulled me right into the settings in Tasmania and England during that eventful twenty-year period in history. But the strength of this book lies with its complex characters and suspenseful plot, leading to a literally breath-stealing ending. (You'll be tempted to jump ahead, but don't spoil it!)
I don't know how the author manages to create so much drama in less than 400 pages, but she does. It's almost magical. You will love this story and want more. Thankfully, there's a third book in this series. I hope it arrives soon!
There are no explicit sex scenes, and the language is appropriate for all readers. Highly recommended.
February 27, 2020
Brief synopsis from the book cover:
Tasmania, 1929: Ten-year-old-twins, Tom and Harry Abbott, are orphaned by a tragedy that shocks Hobart society. They find sanctuary with their reclusive grandmother, growing up in the remote and rugged Binburra ranges – a place where kind-hearted Tom discovers a love of the wild, Harry nurses a growing resentment towards his brother and where the mountains hold secrets that will transform both their lives.
The chaos of World War II divides the brothers, and their passion for two very different women fuels a deadly rivalry. Can Tom and Harry survive to heal their rift? And what will happen when Binburra finally reveals its astonishing secrets?
From Tasmania’s highlands to the Battle of Britain, and all the way to the golden age of Hollywood, 'The Lost Valley' is a lush family saga about two brothers whose fates are entwined with the land and the women they love.
My rating:
Plot: 3 out of 5 stars
Writing: 4 out of 5 stars
Character development: 3.5 out of 5 stars
Overall: 3.5 out of 5 stars
Recommended for readers of:
Women’s fiction
General fiction
Historical fiction
Review:
This book is atmospherically written it shows the great love and care the author has for Tasmania’s beautiful nature and wildlife. The story is takes place from the 1930’s depression till post WII. It gives you an inside how Tasmania and its people were affected by these moments in history. It also tells the tale of demise of the Tasmania Tiger and the desperate plight of a few to protect the last remaining animals.
The characters are decent people who try their best but make mistakes which made them realistic.
Tasmania, 1929: Ten-year-old-twins, Tom and Harry Abbott, are orphaned by a tragedy that shocks Hobart society. They find sanctuary with their reclusive grandmother, growing up in the remote and rugged Binburra ranges – a place where kind-hearted Tom discovers a love of the wild, Harry nurses a growing resentment towards his brother and where the mountains hold secrets that will transform both their lives.
The chaos of World War II divides the brothers, and their passion for two very different women fuels a deadly rivalry. Can Tom and Harry survive to heal their rift? And what will happen when Binburra finally reveals its astonishing secrets?
From Tasmania’s highlands to the Battle of Britain, and all the way to the golden age of Hollywood, 'The Lost Valley' is a lush family saga about two brothers whose fates are entwined with the land and the women they love.
My rating:
Plot: 3 out of 5 stars
Writing: 4 out of 5 stars
Character development: 3.5 out of 5 stars
Overall: 3.5 out of 5 stars
Recommended for readers of:
Women’s fiction
General fiction
Historical fiction
Review:
This book is atmospherically written it shows the great love and care the author has for Tasmania’s beautiful nature and wildlife. The story is takes place from the 1930’s depression till post WII. It gives you an inside how Tasmania and its people were affected by these moments in history. It also tells the tale of demise of the Tasmania Tiger and the desperate plight of a few to protect the last remaining animals.
The characters are decent people who try their best but make mistakes which made them realistic.
July 16, 2020
*Contains Spoilers*
It's well edited, good grammar, but lacking in so many ways. The story starts with something interesting, but that start isn't a prologue, or a lead-in to a story. It's just an excuse to dump exposition. Interesting, yes, but could have created suspense by feeding it into the real story piecemeal. What is the real story?
Nothing, really. Two brothers are followed through their childhood, one meets the girl he probably should follow up when she/he go different paths.
Passive characters, these two. No agency. Stuff happens to them, and it's not their fault. So many opportunities to create suspense and they just don't happen. It's a one-way street, no lumps or bumps, no emotional build or explosion. Flat.
That's not the worst of it.
And even though the bad brother has a bit more guts, he's so one dimensional that a cardboard box has more depth of character.
The worst part (except the lack of any high points in the story and all the passivity in the characters) is the misrepresentation of the love-interest. She gets into the bad side of life, and this is blamed for her lack of child-bearing. A tiny bit of research would reveal that during the timeline of this story, many, many, many people, on the wrong side of the tracks and the right side, suffered the same diseases. It isn't, and wasn't, purely a problem of the working girls. Those working girls also had children. And she didn't get pregnant, even when she wasn't a 'professional' in a 'clean' joint.
Bad jolt out of the story with the lack of fact-checking.
Very disappointed.
It's well edited, good grammar, but lacking in so many ways. The story starts with something interesting, but that start isn't a prologue, or a lead-in to a story. It's just an excuse to dump exposition. Interesting, yes, but could have created suspense by feeding it into the real story piecemeal. What is the real story?
Nothing, really. Two brothers are followed through their childhood, one meets the girl he probably should follow up when she/he go different paths.
Passive characters, these two. No agency. Stuff happens to them, and it's not their fault. So many opportunities to create suspense and they just don't happen. It's a one-way street, no lumps or bumps, no emotional build or explosion. Flat.
That's not the worst of it.
And even though the bad brother has a bit more guts, he's so one dimensional that a cardboard box has more depth of character.
The worst part (except the lack of any high points in the story and all the passivity in the characters) is the misrepresentation of the love-interest. She gets into the bad side of life, and this is blamed for her lack of child-bearing. A tiny bit of research would reveal that during the timeline of this story, many, many, many people, on the wrong side of the tracks and the right side, suffered the same diseases. It isn't, and wasn't, purely a problem of the working girls. Those working girls also had children. And she didn't get pregnant, even when she wasn't a 'professional' in a 'clean' joint.
Bad jolt out of the story with the lack of fact-checking.
Very disappointed.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 9, 2021
Love me a good family saga
Even though this is the second book in the Tasmanian Tales series, it confidently stands on its own, drawing you in like the tempting music of a carnival. Twin brothers, set against each other almost from birth, growing up in 1930s, Tasmania. They take separate paths into adulthood, one driven by greed, the other driven by heartache.
The characters are so well crafted it’s sickening. You don’t only see the transformations in the twins from boyhood to adulthood, but the factors that build their characters, both good and bad. The secondary and tertiary characters are also well crafted, something that’s difficult to do with tertiary characters.
The plot is absolutely wonderful, with foreshadowing and redemption and edge of your seat plot twists. There are enough moments of explanation that bring you slowly up to speed from the first book so you don’t feel you’re missing anything other than the pleasure of actually reading it
It has all the drama of Colleen McCullough’s Thorn Birds along with vivid descriptions of Tasmania’s wildlife, nature, and mining towns.
While it is lengthy (over 500 pages), it pulls you in and refuses to let go until you’re forcibly torn away by dinners that need to be made or sleep that won’t be forestalled. Touted as a Tasmanian East of Eden, The Lost Valley is an epic tale that should be made into a movie. I can’t wait to read the rest of the series.
Even though this is the second book in the Tasmanian Tales series, it confidently stands on its own, drawing you in like the tempting music of a carnival. Twin brothers, set against each other almost from birth, growing up in 1930s, Tasmania. They take separate paths into adulthood, one driven by greed, the other driven by heartache.
The characters are so well crafted it’s sickening. You don’t only see the transformations in the twins from boyhood to adulthood, but the factors that build their characters, both good and bad. The secondary and tertiary characters are also well crafted, something that’s difficult to do with tertiary characters.
The plot is absolutely wonderful, with foreshadowing and redemption and edge of your seat plot twists. There are enough moments of explanation that bring you slowly up to speed from the first book so you don’t feel you’re missing anything other than the pleasure of actually reading it
It has all the drama of Colleen McCullough’s Thorn Birds along with vivid descriptions of Tasmania’s wildlife, nature, and mining towns.
While it is lengthy (over 500 pages), it pulls you in and refuses to let go until you’re forcibly torn away by dinners that need to be made or sleep that won’t be forestalled. Touted as a Tasmanian East of Eden, The Lost Valley is an epic tale that should be made into a movie. I can’t wait to read the rest of the series.
July 31, 2020
I'm always a little sceptical when the author's name is 10 times larger than the book's title, as it was with Australian author Jennifer Scoullar's novel 'The Lost Valley'. I've generally enjoyed this writer's stories, but this one just didn't grab me - and I lived in Tasmania for 10 years. I did enjoy the descriptions of the bush and the animals, but the plot seemed so contrived. To me it was full of cliches and unfolded like a 1930's potboiler B-grade movie. Oh, that does sound harsh, but I was expecting more than this. Two brothers who were always at loggerheads with each other; one brother a war hero pilot, the other was ruthless and out to make as much money as he could; a young girl on hard times resorting to desperate ways to make money for her invalid mother; a glamorous film star; poor-choice marriages; a devastating accident; family secrets..... And then there was the environmental aspect which this author is always good at. These parts were lovely. Perhaps it was the 1940s setting and the researched history that the author wove into the story that did not appeal to me. Perhaps having lived in Tasmania I knew a lot of it already. Whatever, this will definitely appeal to those who love Australian stories with a bit of romance, family secrets and vivid descriptions of the Tasmanian wilderness.
July 1, 2021
Into the Wilds of Tasmania and Beyond!
Twins Tom and Harry went to live with their grandmother in Tasmania when their parents died. Their grandmother introduced the boys to the unusual plants and animals of the area and tried to instill in the boys her love of the area. They hiked together with her to see the habitat of nearly extinct species that lived nearby.
Tom grew up and became a pilot during World War II. He also married a movie star. Tom's plane crashed and he was badly burned and was badly disfigured by the scarring. His movie star wife was ashamed of his scars.
Harry spent his time exploring the cave area where he and Tom had visited with their gandmother as boys and discovered species that were thought to be extinct and introduced his wife to nature's surprises in the area.
Read this book to see how life and love treated these young men. I hope you enjoy the book as much as I did.
Twins Tom and Harry went to live with their grandmother in Tasmania when their parents died. Their grandmother introduced the boys to the unusual plants and animals of the area and tried to instill in the boys her love of the area. They hiked together with her to see the habitat of nearly extinct species that lived nearby.
Tom grew up and became a pilot during World War II. He also married a movie star. Tom's plane crashed and he was badly burned and was badly disfigured by the scarring. His movie star wife was ashamed of his scars.
Harry spent his time exploring the cave area where he and Tom had visited with their gandmother as boys and discovered species that were thought to be extinct and introduced his wife to nature's surprises in the area.
Read this book to see how life and love treated these young men. I hope you enjoy the book as much as I did.
September 22, 2018
This was a fabulously well written novel!
Huge congratulations to Jennifer Scoullar.
The novel was set in the 1920s with young twin brothers tragically loosing their parents.
The story sees them grow up into men and how their lives drift apart from greed and hatred.
The characters are based in Tasmania and set around the War.
In the novel you learn of a young girl, who faces poverty but will do anything to help her mother, even if that means selling herself.
The novel has 3 strong characters, it keeps you interested and begging you to read more!
I loved this book. Can't wait to read more!
Huge congratulations to Jennifer Scoullar.
The novel was set in the 1920s with young twin brothers tragically loosing their parents.
The story sees them grow up into men and how their lives drift apart from greed and hatred.
The characters are based in Tasmania and set around the War.
In the novel you learn of a young girl, who faces poverty but will do anything to help her mother, even if that means selling herself.
The novel has 3 strong characters, it keeps you interested and begging you to read more!
I loved this book. Can't wait to read more!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 83 reviews