Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Enjoy this sports romance with a mistaken identity twist today!

Because she knows what it’s like to be homeless, Clover Maes does all she can for the homeless community in St. George. When she spots a man in dirty clothes, with a beard down to his chest, she decides to help. Drawn in by his silent strength and clear eyes, she offers him an essentials bag and tells him there are people who care and want to help him get back on his feet.

Dustin Colt, shortstop for the St. George Redrocks Baseball Team, was in bad shape on the field. Apparently he was in such bad shape that he looked like a homeless man. With the embarrassment of Clover’s insinuation heavy on his mind, he argues with the do-gooder and then plays his best game of the season. Thinking he’s found the key to hitting doubles, Dustin goes out of his way to argue with Clover every chance he gets.

Clover can't seem to shake the determined baseball player and she can’t tell Dustin to head to the outfield and stay there because he’s donating a large sum to the local soup kitchen where she volunteers. She has to play nice—even if that means playing catch with the hot-shot ball player at midnight on a deserted golf course. In the wee hours of the morning, Dustin's true nature comes out taking Clover off guard. The more Clover learns about baseball, the harder she falls for the game, for the short stop, and for the Redrocks.

190 pages, Kindle Edition

Published May 31, 2018

296 people are currently reading
139 people want to read

About the author

Lucy McConnell

189 books1,594 followers
Please hit the follow button. I'd love to keep in touch!

Lucy McConnell loves romance, chocolate, Christmas, horses, music, crochet, and fun!

She believes that romance books should:

Keep you up past your bedtime.

Make you laugh out loud.

Have happy endings.

With that in mind, she's written over 200 novels full of fun and flirty characters who navigate the turbulent waters of romance with open hearts and creativity.

If you enjoy closed-door romance, follow her on Goodreads.♥️

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
122 (45%)
4 stars
95 (35%)
3 stars
44 (16%)
2 stars
7 (2%)
1 star
2 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 25 of 25 reviews
Profile Image for Kathy * Bookworm Nation.
2,162 reviews704 followers
June 13, 2018
Fun, this was a great addition to the series. I liked the unique characters and fun setting.

Clover was raised by her single gypsy mother, she was homeless for her whole upbringing. It's hard to imagine someone having to grow up that way, but Clover met some nice people along the way who really helped her out and now that she has her life together she wants to do her part to help other homeless people. She helps work at a local soup kitchen and really goes out of her way to be there for the people that come there for help. She was a really likeable and interesting character. I also liked our leading man, Dustin. A star baseball play who helps his brother run his construction business on the side. Dustin and Clover had a fun meet-cute when she mistakes him for a homeless man! They have fun banter and great chemistry. It was fun watching their relationship unfold.

My only complaint is I wish there had been an epilog! I love those. Overall, a fun read and great addition to this fun series.

Content
Romance: Clean
Language: None
Violence: None
Religious: Very mild
Series: Mr Baseball, Book Three

Source: KU

Nominated for a 2018 Swoony Award, vote here http://bit.ly/2CWYB9U
Profile Image for Aimee .
3,072 reviews298 followers
June 19, 2018
Yes!

I love baseball and I love a good, clean romance. Combine those two things and I am a happy girl! This book stays on the light side, even though it had the potential of becoming deeper. I'm missing the overall resolution for Seth and the deeper emotional resolution for Clover. But this was a fun diversion and left me desperate to head to the ball field to catch a game!
Profile Image for  The Flipped Page (Susan K).
1,835 reviews39 followers
September 17, 2018
Romance, clean; Series, but stand alone read
Lovely romantic read! Fun baseball setting, deals with some hard issues with the homeless situation, but in a clever way. Seeing how they fall for each other after a misunderstanding as Clover tries to do good from where she came from was a heartfelt, fun read. Clever misunderstandings, a bit of pride, but two honest hearts finding each other made for a fun read! My wish, that it was longer!
His play, his slump, his desire to be part of the team all made for an interesting back story to this novella. Love this series with the baseball team and players.
2,389 reviews17 followers
June 20, 2018
Loved it!

I loved this story and how two people from very different backgrounds came together. I also loved the baseball theme. This was a really sweet, clean romance with great characters.
Profile Image for Meg.
1,214 reviews15 followers
May 11, 2025
Another totally clean, christian story about Clover who grew up sometimes on the streets with her free spirit gypsy mom who left her at age 18. She was lucky enough to get help from a christian organization and now has her life together and devotes time to help the homeless.

Clover mistakenly gives an essential package to a man on the street that looks homeless. He is actually a baseball player and is razed by his teammate about this. He then sees her in a club (as her gal pal forced her to go out) and he goes out of his way to embarrass her for thinking he was homeless.

He then gets roped by the team into doing charity hours with the same shelter as part of team plan to make players contribute to the community.

This is a sweet clean story sort of like I used to read in high school. It takes time with the characters and their stories as well as the romantic angle. There is wanting but no sex. Sometimes as a palate cleanser I just need something light
1,430 reviews12 followers
December 15, 2025
I had a free copy of this book, but this is my voluntary and honest opinion. Clover Maes who once was homeless, now helps homeless people and works in a homeless shelter. She mistakenly gives an essentials bag to professional baseball shortstop, Dustin Colt. The nest time they see each other he tries to embarrass her. When he has to do community service at the homeless shelter, they meet again and end up arguing, but she intrigues him and improves his game and they begin to date. A heartwarming book about love and second chances.
2,870 reviews11 followers
March 8, 2024
A charming contemporary romance. Clover Maes grew up homeless, and then, once she turned eighteen, her mom abandoned her. Now, she works in a food kitchen for the homeless. Dustin Colt is a member of the St. George Redrocks major league baseball. Mistaking him for a homeless man, she accidentally embarrassed him. Thus, the relationship starts off rocky.

Easy-to-read. Entertaining. Happily Ever After. Romantic. Unpredictable. Whimsical. Wonderful characters.
Profile Image for Courtney.
4,298 reviews
January 23, 2021
OMGosh, OMGosh, OMGosh!!!! Each and every page... 😍😍😍

I thoroughly enjoyed this novel from the first page until the very last. It has been a very rare occurrence that I could just pick up a book and read it in one day; but, I was captivated by these characters and their amazing love story instantaneously.
Profile Image for Shanna Johnson.
548 reviews23 followers
January 10, 2024
Fun read with amazing heart behind it

I'm really getting hooked on Lucy McConnells baseball themed books, they are fun and so different from what I used to. I loved that this story brought in some tougher subjects in regards to homeless and shelters, it was really cool to see attention being brought to it. I definitely enjoyed this book and can't wait to start the next one.
Profile Image for Rachael.
58 reviews2 followers
Read
October 2, 2021
I haven't read a sport focus romance in along time. I enjoyed this story. I started and finished this book in day I couldn't stop reading it.

I can't tell you anymore than the blub has already told you without giving more of the story of away.

Do I recommend it this story? Yes
1,075 reviews6 followers
May 15, 2024
fun book

This is a sweet story and a fun addition to the series. I loved the characters and their struggles and how they overcame came them. Clover and Dustin are a great couple with so much chemistry, sweet kisses and fun banter.
Profile Image for Cici.
1,308 reviews
February 14, 2021
Good one

Good one for continuing the series. This has a very interesting setup. The perspective of someone with out. And willing to always give
Profile Image for Karen.
5,385 reviews74 followers
June 2, 2018
I appreciate this book's story because I don't think about a story with a girl whose whole life was as homeless. It's hard to believe but it could happen. So meeting a baseball player and having to interact with him at the food pantry where she now volunteers isn't hard to believe. Where my mind is engaged is how she feels about him because he's had a normal middle class upbringing and she's behind all the things she's missed not having gone to school or dating. She doesn't know how to catch or throw balls because she'd never played organized sports.

None of the book puts down that way of life. It was her mother's choice and she hadn't been abused...just made invisible until her 18th birthday when her mom kicked her out.

The book has church references but is not preachy. It is used to show different ministries such as the food pantry.

I loved the romance between our main characters. Sweet book!!
Profile Image for Jill.
835 reviews39 followers
August 27, 2018
So I totally loved the previous book in this Mr. Baseball series. It’s pretty much my favorite sports book of all time. So I had really big hopes for this one. Sad to say I was a little disappointed. Don’t get me wrong it was still a good book to read but I think I just kept comparing it to the first one that I loved so much more.

This had a very interesting basis: a young woman, Clover, who had grown up on the streets with her gypsy of a mother missed out on a lot of “normal life experiences” including baseball. Feeling socially inapt in most situations, she doesn’t know what to make of Dustin the Baseball player other than being strangely drawn to him. Dustin knows exactly what he wants with Clover but is afraid to scare her off. The funniest part was when he realized she didn’t know how to catch. I can just see the scene happening in my head. LOL.

Anyway, in this book you get to watch her fall in love twice! Yes, twice! First with baseball and then with Dustin. Cute clean book.
305 reviews
July 2, 2018
Oops! Caught lookjng!

Dustin's a shortstop for the St. George Redrocks. He's a down to earth guy that helps his brother with a construction business on the side. With his unruly beard, filthy clothes, and broken boot, he's easily mistaken for a homeless man. Clover's mom is a gypsy. Having been raised in a car without a place to call home makes Clover sensitive to those on the street and Dustin, unfortunately, looks like he fits that definition. He's not amused that anyone would think so. A simple case of mistaken identity leads to sparks flying, first in spite but then in love.
Profile Image for Rocky.
209 reviews9 followers
September 17, 2018
Clover and Dustin

Clover Maes stops a homeless man and gives him an essentials bag and the address to to a soup kitchen. The thing is, the homeless man is actually the starting shortstop for the St George Redrocks baseball team.
When Dustin humiliates Clover at a club in Las Vegas the barbs start to fly.
Caught Looking is fast-paced and filled with sarcastic humor as two people from different worlds come together and Clover discovers that baseball is more than a bunch of oversized boys playing a kids game.
778 reviews20 followers
August 31, 2018
Cute and Sweet

This was a cute and sweet read that I thoroughly enjoyed. I liked seeing the Redrocks team again and it was interesting to see just how fickle playing baseball well can be. I also appreciated the formerly homeless background of the female protagonist and how it added an additional measure of depth to this story. This was a cute and clean book that I would rate PG.
Profile Image for Herman Fassett.
187 reviews10 followers
July 17, 2018
The premise was amusing but the rest of the book was should-i-care brow-raise inducing. Not much depth to frankly either the characters or the story and the drama was just annoying. If you're a fan of baseball, which I'm not, this may increase your ability to enjoy this book; not saying it's awful but it was mediocre at best imho.
1,915 reviews9 followers
October 11, 2018
Because she knows what it’s like to be homeless, Clover Maes does all she can for the homeless community in St. George. When she spots a man in dirty clothes, with a beard down to his chest, she decides to help.
2,237 reviews3 followers
June 7, 2018
Ebook

She’s a young woman that has grownup homeless, and has many insecurities. He’s a baseball player with something to prove, can they make a life together?
Profile Image for Sue Stinnett.
1,374 reviews3 followers
June 14, 2018
Mistaken Identity

Such a cute and funny love story. Can a girl whose life has been difficult at best trust a cocky ball player with her heart?
1,903 reviews
July 24, 2018
Great way to spend a few hours. Sweet and fun. It made me want to watch a baseball game☺️
1,030 reviews17 followers
August 25, 2018
Fun baseball romance

If you like baseball and a clean romance this is a fun little read.

Content: Clean
Language: Clean
Religious: No

Happy reading!!
2,836 reviews8 followers
April 12, 2019
I liked the premise of this book, but the execution didn't quite meet my standards. The drama felt forced and got on my nerves, and I didn't really connect with the characters.
Displaying 1 - 25 of 25 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.