First, if ever a heroine grated on my nerves, it was Pepper, I really couldn't stand her. Second, Thoreau was never one of my favorites, but now I can't stand him, if I hear one more quote, I may scream. Rather than enhancing the book it detracted from it. I know I groaned every time another one made its appearance, which was CONSTANT. Third, it seems (and I have found this in numerous Cozy mysteries) that once Mom grows older, she becomes a severe pain/trial and there are groans and sighs every time her name comes up on the telephone. All I can say, is I never looked at my Mom that way and sincerely hope my children don't look at me that way. Fourth, since our author seems to be enamored/involved/ obsessed with literature, she might try using a better proof reader, thereby lifting her books to a higher literary standard.
As to the actual basis of the book, the plot was very good and laid out succinctly, it kept you guessing and the ending was a surprise. Except for all of the above, it would have been a great book, but it wasn't. I know I will never read one of Eryn Scott's books again.