Part historical and part riveting thriller, J Robert Kennedy’s medieval knight detective series met and exceeded my expectations. I love historical mysteries particularly when they are well settled in their historical backdrop as much as offer a cunningly crafted mystery and an engaging detecting character to solve it.
The Templar Detective and the Sergeant’s Secret is the third in the Templar Detective series of medieval mysteries set in 13th century France. In after thought, I would definitely recommend not jumping in here, but getting the series in order. I didn’t have trouble following the story line or picking up where the last book must have left off, but I could see that this one built on the last.
Knight Templar, Sir Marcus de Rancourt, retired and returned home to France to take up the running of his late sister’s farm and rearing her children. His retinue including his sergeant, Simon Chastain, a loyal and true brother in arms came with him. They have all been through a great deal together and Sir Marcus, back in the Templar fold and given special dispensation to remain on the farm, has a growing ‘found family’ and brotherhood about him now.
But Simon is having a sort of crisis of faith and calling and not sure this new life is for him. Marcus being the type of leader he is tells Simon to go home and give thought to it all.
And, then his loyal comrade is gone much longer than expected with no word and seems to have left them. Sir Marcus knows this is unlike Simon so he goes looking and finds a dark and sinister, long-in-the-making plot of revenge has been sprung. Simon’s past history is laid out even as Sir Marcus gets to the bottom of things.
This was more action and taunt physical danger than the average historical mystery. Men at arms work and intrigue all fueled by a revenge plot that was laid out. I was enthralled to see how the end game would be achieved. It got gritty and plunged dark depths with the torture and imprisonment in the dungeon part right from the opening chapter before it went on to a scene back at the farm when the situation of Simon’s leaving began and Sir Marcus had to way the truth of Simon’s character and loyalty up against the seeming facts.
The Templar Detective and the Sergeant’s Secret was narrated by new to me Philip Battley. I had no trouble settling into his storytelling or voice for the characters. I would definitely listen to more of his work.
All in all, the Templar Detective and the Sergeant’s Secret got me excited that a new series I was trying landed well and made me want to go back for the first two stories and keep right on going until I caught up with the rest of the released books. I would definitely recommend the audio edition and wait for each of those releases for historical mystery fans who like it pulse-pounding at times and on the gritty side with some solid bromancing and occasional banter.
I rec'd an audio digital from Tantor Audio to listen to in exchange for an honest review.
My full review will post at Caffeinated Reviewer 12.17.25.