What do you think?
Rate this book


Audiobook
First published April 4, 2017
This book is an example of a great trilogy crashing and burning in the home stretch. I really enjoyed the first two books: the characters are fun, and the world is one of the best I've come across so I was extra disappointed when this book was just OK. There were some pacing issues in this book with the middle section of plotting and investigation stretching out for a loong time but I enjoyed most of the book regardless. Things only went downhill in the last fifty pages or so when it became apparent that there was just too much ground to cover to have a satisfying ending. There were a couple of gut-punch twists in the opening chapters and while some of the implications had me excited (and were actually played out quite well) I would argue that introducing all these extra elements in the last book just complicated things unnecessarily. I really enjoyed reading about and the insight into Thratia's character is both great and very confusing (I respect her so much more now but I'm also very disappointed in her?) but if the time spent on that could have been used on giving the book a better ending I would given much of it up with no issues!
A big part of this book is the development of Detan's powers which was very interesting and his struggle between wanting to be able to control his abilities and having to put himself at Aella's mercy was one of the most interesting components but one again it's resolution left me cold - what on earth was the climax on about?
However! I did really enjoy Hond Steading as a setting and Dame Honding was pretty cool. This book isn't bad really, and I guess even the ending is OK but it feels messy and unsatisfying and Detan's whole character arc kind of faceplants.
Also whoever wrote the blurb of this book has done a really weird job - much of the events mentioned happen but not in the order suggested and for different reasons so rereading it after I finished I felt like I much have read an alternate version.