✨4.5 stars✨
I really wasn’t expecting to love this book quite so much, and I’m so pleasantly surprised by how entirely captivated I was reading it. It’s not that I thought I wouldn’t like it, it's just that I couldn’t have predicted quite how much I truly do love it. This review will undoubtedly have spoilers sprinkled throughout so bewaaaaaare (nice one George, very well written).
Serina and Nomi are, at a first glance, complete opposites. Serina is on the road to becoming a Grace: Viridia’s perfect example of a woman, she follows the rules to a tee and has accepted that whatever her life is, she’ll just have to make the most of it rather than questioning it. Nomi is rebellious and unaccepting of the treatment of women within Viridia, defying and questioning her way through everything. As the book progresses, however, both sisters become so much more than just this initial impression. I adore Nomi, and I sympathised with her the most throughout the book. I’m living for the feminist messages laced throughout, they’re so bloody important, and they were conveyed so perfectly. Women in Viridia have, essentially, zero rights other than cooking, cleaning, and looking pretty. It’s against the law for them to even read. Nomi is strong-willed and determined to fight this, and I loved watching her do so. Her intentions are so powerful, her passion for her beliefs is so strong and resolute, and I just really adored her.
I loved Nomi from the minute she sassed Malachi to high heaven upon first meeting him. I must say, I was less sure about Serina to begin with. She took a minute to grow on me, but her character development was so brilliant. Watching her realise her true worth, and the weight of Nomi’s defiant beliefs, was so satisfying, and her standing up for herself was bloody wonderful. I was so enthralled in her story, and even though she is put through hell, it felt so glorious that she was the start of the revolt against the guards. I really appreciated her inner battle with her annoyance and blame toward Nomi- she knows Nomi isn’t to blame, but sometimes she can’t help but feel angry about the way things played out, and even though this could come across as an annoying character flaw, it actually came across as realistic as hell. If this was me and my sister, no matter how much I love her, I imagine I would probably be at least a little bit irritated at her for landing me in the worst prison in the land. Just a teensy bit annoyed. It also made Serina’s character arc that bit more satisfying and impressive, as she really does change so hugely from who she is at the start of the book.
‘It isn’t a choice when you don’t have the freedom to say no. A yes doesn’t mean the same thing when it’s the only answer you’re allowed’ !!!! so important !!!!
At first I was worried that the alternating perspectives were going to get frustrating or annoying, but they actually lend themselves perfectly to the pace and intrigue/suspense, and I was hooked so bloody quickly. The plot progression went in and out of being both predictable and being shocking as hell. I wasn’t expecting so many aspects of it (Nomi being chosen, Serina being sent to Mount Ruin, the Superior’s end), however I was kind of expecting Asa’s plot twist. As the book went on, I wanted to know more about Malachi, as despite being told he’s this manipulative and awful man, he never really came across that way. He was intriguing and confusing, and I can’t really resist being pulled into wanting to find out more about characters like that. Asa also seemed to be more than he appeared- he felt like he was coming across as trying to be this absolute perfect thing that Nomi wanted him to be, and I was wary trusting him, so it didn’t really surprise me when it was all revealed.
Despite it being something I had suspected would happen, I still really enjoyed it, and I’m desperate for the next book (waaaah I hate waiting). Cliffhanger type endings can sometimes feel like they’re solely there to set up for more books, but the ending genuinely did feel like a perfect place to leave it for this book. It didn’t feel like a cop-out to sell a sequel, it made sense to leave it here to create the perfect amount of suspense for what’s to come, especially after everything that takes place. I really enjoyed this book- it’s hard to read at times, as the characters really are dragged through the wringer, but it’s brilliant. As I was reading, I just kept thinking ‘wow yes I am in LOVE with this story’, and I’m so happy about it (I was nervous beforehand that maybe it would come across as too dystopian, a genre I definitely exhausted myself with back in 2013, but I needn’t have worried). The problem I have now is that I want the next book asap, so maybe I should have waited to read this book, at least until the publication date. Oops. It also kind of pulled me out of this weird little reading slump I’ve been going through, so yay for this book!!