As much as it PAINS me to say this (and yes, I know how ridiculous that is), Ren did not cheat on Cade.
And I'm glad we got dual POV for this one because while it's easy to see why Cade was the way he was, it requires no assumptions to see why Ren did what he did.
I'll even go so far as to say I'm okay with Ren doing it.
Cade knew that man had just gotten out of a DL situationship with his engaged best friend. Hell, Cade's word were partly why Ren finally found the courage to walk away from it.
Only for Cade to then take Tex's place.
Stood there, told Ren that he deserves a man that wouldn't hide him, wouldn't reciprocate, then when Cade got the chance to be that man.....he wasn't.
So forgive me (not sorry) for really REALLY not being mad at Ren for trying his best to give 75% in his situationship (because that wasn't a relationship, either) with Cade, and after finding that Cade wouldn't or couldn't give the 25% that was being asked of him, moving on.
It's just Cade's bad luck that this happened to coincide with Ren's bestie Situationship General™ Tex coming back onto the scene and saying, hey, remember when you said we had to stop because I wasn't willing to give you what you wanted?
"I'm willing."
No way you compete with a childhood love and you're already not even on the playing field.
Whether Cade knew it or not, he'd become Tex. His words were pretty but I don't blame Ren for not wanting to have another go with a man who fucks him like he'll die if he doesn't then avoids him like the plague while the sun's out.
Most importantly, you can't cheat on someone you're not with.
If you fuck someone, disappear for 5 days, come back just long enough to fuck, then disappear for five days AGAIN, that's a booty call.
And people aren't owed exclusivity from booty calls unless expressly discussed beforehand. Sorry but them's the breaks🤷🏾♀️
Sad thing was, Cade's issue was communication. Man couldn't communicate with a gun to his head. All of this could have been avoided if he'd just picked up a phone but nooooooo. He had to be out here assuming Ren was an inanimate object whom he'd find exactly where he'd placed him before he left.
Now look it him. Chest heavy, eyes HOT.
Because God loves me and Cade got to see Ren GET IT from the guy he's been in love with since he was 14💀
Sure. Not cheating, but I enjoyed that scene regardless.
I get Ren, honestly. At least Tex promised nothing. Went OUT of his way and around a few times to clarify how little he had to offer, even at the risk of ending their friendship. Cade was out here saying the most but no action to back it up.
The way Ren saw it, if you ABSOLUTELY have to be a fool, be it for one man but not two of them back to back.
Now your new crush is tweaking, and the man you've been in love with forever is on his knees with your cock in his mouth and saying,
“You don’t ever have to beg me for anything either, Ren.”
Honestly? I get it. Get your nut, boo.
No judgment from me.
But yeah, TW for those who may require it, this book contains graphic detail of one MC having sex with another man who is NOT the other MC - with all the bells on.
***This book also contains an instance of one MC's anus being called a chute, and I'm warning others because I wish someone had warned me.
Anyway.
Kind of sick that Cade couldn't even get to hope the sex wasn't good because Ren was hooting and hollering about how good it was DURING 💀
Oh, well. Sometimes bad things happen to emotionally unavailable men. What to do?
Also, to be clear, my feelings on Ren's predicament don't mirror his. He absolutely believed that he'd cheated, and was sick about it immediately.
But not sick enough NOT to get defensive about it when Cade called him out on it later that very night 💀
Unfortunately Tex is another friend that would HAVE to bite the dust. No way I'm Cade and I'm okay with you two staying friends after you've been in love with him half your life AND I heard how good he gives it to you.
No way he can come over for Sunday dinner. Cross the road when you see that man, baby.
Also because Tex is a ridiculous man.
First order of business - strong advice that Ren not say anything about this to Cade because they're not going to do it again and it will only hurt Cade.
Which would be fine, except Cade already saw and heard every moan, every "Oh, God! So good! Fuck me good!"
Also, HE'S planning to tell his fiancée everything. Well. Not EVERYthing.
“But starting today, other than the sex between you and me, I am going to find a way to man up and tell Shelley everything.”
My best part of cheating books is when the confrontation happens. When they're saying reckless, hurtful things to each other.
Because wdym Cade who hardly talks is now shouting entire paragraphs. We love to see it.
Going all, oh, I'm sorry? You're saying it's my fault you fucked another man because I didn't talk to you for six days? You're right, my bad, all is forgiven. Should we just throw down and fuck each other senseless on the couch? Should I just drop trou and let you take me? Because God knows your ass must be sore after what you were crying out for Tex to do to you earlier?
💀💀💀💀💀💀
Like oh my God none of this would have happened if you'd shown all this passion before?
But also, how ridiculous is it that Ren saw this man breaking down, crying and thought to himself - you know what Cade needs? A kiss.
Unfortunately for him, “You fucked me over, and I will not let you seduce me into thinking it wasn’t a big deal. It was. It was the biggest fucking deal of my life.”
Welp.
FORTUNATELY for him, Ren's a loverboy.
Like, if ever there was a man dying to prove his love to another, it's Ren.
Literally been preparing for this since he was 14. I had no doubts he'd succeed.
That said, maybe saying, “You’re one of the strongest, least compromising men I know." is NOT the best way to convince someone you 'cheated' on to forgive you.
Ren, baby, what is you doing?
“I mean I fell in love with you, you unthinking, unfeeling son of a bitch."
WHAT A GREAT TIME FOR A LOVE DECLARATION. Really. No notes. Impeccable timing.
Okay. So a LOT happens on the journey back together for these two. Over the course of more than 8 months. I won't get into the details but I feel like a lot of the people in Ren's life eventually gaslit him into cementing the idea that he cheated on Cade. And I don't know if I'm going crazy because he didn't cheat on that man. But everyone kept making him feel incredibly bad about it(like he wasn't already doing a great job at that on his own) and eventually I also got mad about it.
Everyone, including and especially Cade, acts like it happened in a vacuum and that's simply NOT what happened. Cade can rewrite history all he likes but at the end of the day, Ren wasn't his boyfriend, and intentional or otherwise, Cade went to great lengths to make Ren feel unwanted, hidden, uncared for, then turned around and acted shocked when Ren took him at face value.
Now Ren has to fall asleep crying and praying every night for God to forgive him for cheating on his boyfriend but, again, NOT HIS BOYFRIEND.
Not then, not now.
I think I finally found a book in which I can forgive the cheater. This one! BECAUSE REN DID NOT CHEAT ON THAT MAN.
Honestly, it got to the point where it felt like they were beating a dead horse. I love a good extended grovel as much as the next girl but let the man have at least committed the crime, damn!
Cade's going around, not forgiving this man, but FOLLOWING HIM AROUND when he sees him with Tex.
So the way I see it, there's two choices. Take that man back and lay down the law about Tex needing to be gone. Or decide you can't forgive and leave that man alone and let him have his best friend.
“I thought I had moved past everything that happened between us. I thought I could let go and forgive you. Then I saw you get into Tex’s truck and immediately thought you were about to cheat on me again. I didn’t even think twice. I just followed you to confirm my suspicions.”
WHAT DO YOU MEAN CHEAT ON YOU AGAIN?!
I swear, this thing was Schrödinger's relationship based on whatever mood Cade was in at any given moment.
I'll never forgive you and we're not together but also if you have a friendship with your best friend you're cheating on me.
PICK. A. STRUGGLE!
“I can’t be with you,” Cade finally said. “Definitely not today, and I don’t know if ever.”
Okay. Good. Go away, then?
I swearrrrrrr by this point I wanted Cade to just get gone and stay gone.
Then.... I can't see you with Tex. Great, because Tex is leaving. We decided we can't be friends if we want our relationships to work. And I want us to work. Okay, but that's not the kind of man I want to be, dictating which friends you can have.
?????????
I repeat, WHAT THE FUCK?!
Cade loves being a victim more than he loves Ren.
Honestly the grovel in this is exquisite. The punishment urelenting. The sort of dragging him across the coals I keep wanting to see cheaters get and rarely do in books. I really, really would have loved it.
If Ren had actually cheated.
“I need time. I don’t expect you to wait for me."
“I’ll wait for you.”
“It might never happen.”
“I’ll wait for you.”
“I have no right to ask --”
“I’ll wait for you.”
Guess the point at which Cade remembered his inability to move on?
Yep. Right after nutting in this man.
I don't think I can express how much I HATED Cade by this point.
More than Shane Hollander. More than Frankie from The Fishermen, even.
And I get him feeling like people have hurt him and gotten away with it all his life, I get him not wanting everyone to know he forgave being cheated on (because everyone in town knows what happened), I get not wanting to be the public fool.
And all that would be valid IF Ren had actually chea—
You know what, I can't.
I CAN'T.