I found this book a little difficult to get into at first, but after a few chapters I was drawn into the curious oddities of this story and found myself speeding through it to see what happened next.
Ava and her brother Matthew move back to Wyse after the death of their parents, a small town on the border between England and Wales, the only place left where magic still exists. Conjurors demand magical items from the fairy world on the other side of their magic mirrors because of a magical contract made long ago between the fairy and human worlds. The people of Wyse are strange and nosy, Ava and Matthew's only family frosty towards them, and everywhere are cheap enchantments that make the place feel like a tacky tourist spot. Ava dislikes it, but she's determined to make the best of her situation and prove her worth. When a boy she meets causes her to start suspecting that their benefactor, Mr Skinner, is not the fine gentleman he seems, and she sees the face of a green-haired boy in a long-dead magic mirror, an adventure begins!
Mirror Magic is a compelling and fast paced read, packed with lots of crazy fun and magic, and I was at no point bored, but mostly I've found myself wishing there was more to it all. The plot was pretty basic in its structure with not much in the way of subplots. Fayers creates an intriguing world beyond the mirrors but we don't really get to see much of it, and the history around the two worlds and the mirrors felt underdeveloped, leaving me with a lottt of unanaswered questions. Wyse, especially once magic got involved, was delightfully mad and whimsical, but Unwyse still felt too unknown and I longed to see and know more about it. I did love how each chapter was also headed by a passage by The Book. The wry humour and sarcastic melodrama about what might be happening/happening next kept me on my toes and unable to stop reading at chapter breaks. These were also places where I felt Fayer's writing really stood out, getting really into the voice and humour of The Book's personality in a way that didn't really happen with either of the main characters.
I didn't think this book did its other characters enough justice, though, and that is partly possibly because there were too many of them with not enough role in the story. Lunette is fun when she's first introduced but she serves her purpose pretty quickly and then doesn't seem to have much to do. Charles felt like a mirror to Lunette in some ways (heh), being less useful for the first half of the book and more useful at the end. Matthew felt like a damsel-in-distress most of the time, with no real point or purpose to him. From the beginning, Ava's anxiety about her relationship with her brother is important to her sense of self, and I'd hoped its prominence throughout the story would lead to some meaningful development between them. Instead, there's just one line where Matthew says he'd be alone without her (while reaching for love-interest's hand, so technically he wouldn't be?). It felt too little and too careless for me, and I'm not sure why that was enough to convince Ava he really cared about her. I wanted more for her.
I also saw Mr Skinner's secret coming from about chapter 4, so the twist wasn't much of a surprise for me, but I enjoyed the pace and smaller details of the plot that built up to the reveal, all the magic and danger. Fayers' description is wonderfully visual, making everything easy to imagine. The exploration of Mr Skinner's character felt very well done, in contrast to the other characters, and his final scenes were some of my favourites in the whole book. I'm worried this sounds like a negative review, but I think that while there was a lot I could pick at in this book that I think could have been improved, this story was still wonderful fun, really compelling, and I enjoyed it anyway.