What do you think?
Rate this book
Twelve Lies That Hold America Captive: And the Truth That Sets Us Free
"America is a Christian nation."
"All men are created equal."
"We are the land of the free and the home of the brave."
Except when we're not.
These commonly held ideas break down in the light of hard realities, the study of Scripture, and faithful Christian witness. The president is not the messiah, the Constitution is not the Bible, and the United States is not a city on a hill or the hope for the world. The proclaimed hope of America rings most hollow for Native peoples, people of color, the rural poor, and other communities pressed to the margins.
Jonathan Walton exposes the cultural myths and misconceptions about America's identity. Focusing on its manipulation of Scripture and the person of Jesus, he redirects us to the true promises found in the gospel. Walton identifies how American ideology and way of life has become a false religion, and shows that orienting our lives around American nationalism is idolatry. Our cultural notions of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness are at odds with the call to take up our cross and follow Jesus.
Ultimately, our place in America is distinct from our place in the family of Jesus. Discover how the kingdom of God offers true freedom and justice for all.
"All men are created equal."
"We are the land of the free and the home of the brave."
Except when we're not.
These commonly held ideas break down in the light of hard realities, the study of Scripture, and faithful Christian witness. The president is not the messiah, the Constitution is not the Bible, and the United States is not a city on a hill or the hope for the world. The proclaimed hope of America rings most hollow for Native peoples, people of color, the rural poor, and other communities pressed to the margins.
Jonathan Walton exposes the cultural myths and misconceptions about America's identity. Focusing on its manipulation of Scripture and the person of Jesus, he redirects us to the true promises found in the gospel. Walton identifies how American ideology and way of life has become a false religion, and shows that orienting our lives around American nationalism is idolatry. Our cultural notions of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness are at odds with the call to take up our cross and follow Jesus.
Ultimately, our place in America is distinct from our place in the family of Jesus. Discover how the kingdom of God offers true freedom and justice for all.
224 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2019
56 people are currently reading
1118 people want to read
About the author
Jonathan Walton
1 book41 followersJonathan Walton is an area director with InterVarsity USA, leads its New York City Urban Project (NYCUP), founded the LoGOFF Movement, and is cofounder of Making Stewards. He writes regularly for medium.com and is the author of three books of poetry and short stories. He is a member of New Life Fellowship and lives with his wife, daughter, and dog in New York City.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 66 reviews
October 11, 2018
Summary: Discusses twelve cultural myths that form a kind of American folk religion that are in conflict with the hope we find in the gospel and the vision of the kingdom of God.
It is not uncommon in discussions of Christian mission efforts in other countries to confront the challenge of syncretism. In syncretism, either prior religious beliefs or cultural myths are fused with the newly adopted faith. Often these beliefs are in conflict and undermine vibrant Christian belief. If anything, the Bible is even more pointed about the issue and calls this idolatry, which may either be the worship of false gods, or the false worship of the true God.
Jonathan Walton proposes in this book that it not only happens in other countries but right here in America. He identifies twelve beliefs contrary to the gospel of Jesus Christ (and thus lies) that form a national cultural religion which he terms White American Folk Religion or WAFR. In an endnote, he explains this terminology:
"White = manmade racial-gender-class-culture-based hierarchy. American = national identity defined by citizenship and the level of adoption and mastery of whiteness. Folk religion = common set of popular beliefs and practices under the umbrella of a religion but outside of the religion's official doctrines and practices."
What this means, if I understand Walton correctly is that these are values promulgated by those who would identify as part of majority white culture, and that work best for them and thus become an ideal for all American citizens, internalized and often aspired to by other ethnic, class, and affinity groups, even though they don't always work equally well for all. Furthermore, these have been a part of American civil religion, often closely linked with the majority faith in this country, Christianity. While they aren't what we may confess in the liturgy or the creeds, they come to define both what it means for us to be American and Christian. They are beliefs that will be articulated by leaders in both of our political parties--so this isn't a partisan thing. And, in terms of the gospel of Christ, they are lies.
Here are the twelve lies Walton identifies:
Lie 1: We Are a Christian Nation
Lie 2: We Are All Immigrants
Lie 3: We Are a Melting Pot
Lie 4: All Men Are Created Equal
Lie 5: We Are a Great Democracy
Lie 6: The American Dream Is Alive and Well
Lie 7: We Are the Most Prosperous Nation in the World
Lie 8: We Are the Most Generous People in the World
Lie 9: America Is the Land of the Free
Lie 10: America Is the Home of the Brave
Lie 11: America Is the Greatest Country on Earth
Lie 12: We Are One Nation
I squirmed when I read this list. I've said some of these things, and if you search my blogs, I'm sure you will find some of this language. So if your temptation in reading this list is to say, "but...but" you are not alone. In his Introduction, Walton makes this plea:
"I ask you to resist judgment, the urge to look away, and the opportunity to move on. I invite you to carry your skepticism through the entire book while leaning in to understand. Hold your gaze on the picture I am painting and consider its implications for how you think, speak, pray, and act. Your salvation is at stake, and your evangelism is compromised if you claim to be a follower of Jesus while building dividing walls of hostility and allowing them to govern your life. We are to be his witnesses, living differently in this world so we point others to him, and we cannot do that if we are not willing to engage with our differences to seek his justice and reflect his kingdom. I once lived this way, but because of Christ and for the sake of his gospel, I do so no longer."
I leaned into this book. In each chapter, Walton explores the reasons why each of these beliefs is a lie that as Christians we ought repent from, and the liberating truth that we might embrace instead. I will not go through all of these but even the first chapter was persuasive. The problem of saying we are a Christian nation is that throughout our history, Christian faith has upheld slavery and racial hierarchies. I was reminded of learning recently that the church I grew up in endorsed Klan efforts in my home town during the 1920's and that many of our current national divisions are reflected in divisions within a church called to be one in Christ. Those "dividing walls of hostility" are brought up to me when I speak with students about Christ in my work on campus, and indeed compromise our witness.
Likewise, how can we say we are all immigrants, when a number were forcibly brought here as slaves, and the original inhabitants of the land were displaced? Instead of a melting pot, Christ offers a vision of diversity that is celebrated and gratefully embraced instead of assimilated into a majority culture. Democracy is undermined where voter suppression is practiced, where representation is gerrymandered and where wealthy interests have a much greater voice. A gospel-centered people advocate for the voices that are marginalized. Kingdom people are liberated from pursuing "their best lives now" to be rich in the things of God.
One of the most important aspects of this book, then, is the subtitle: "and the truth that sets us free." Walton contends that these lies hold us captive, burden us down, and rob us of kingdom joy. The truth opens our eyes to the ways we've been compromised, and invites us into a bigger dream that has room enough for all, and that brings reconciliation across our deepest differences.
I wondered how Walton would address the question of proper love of place and country. At least some of the expressions Walton calls lies are affectional and aspirational for "the land that we love." Can we love a country without turning it into an idol? As embodied persons living in a place, what is proper care for that place?
Sadly though, we do often become captive to inordinate forms of these beliefs that take precedence over the claims of biblical faith and our kingdom hope. We put America before kingdom, a prosperity gospel before our heavenly inheritance, and sadly, our people before all peoples. Life becomes smaller, meaner, a struggle for self-preservation. Walton points us to a better way, if we are willing to face and repent from the lies.
____________________________
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary advanced reader copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
It is not uncommon in discussions of Christian mission efforts in other countries to confront the challenge of syncretism. In syncretism, either prior religious beliefs or cultural myths are fused with the newly adopted faith. Often these beliefs are in conflict and undermine vibrant Christian belief. If anything, the Bible is even more pointed about the issue and calls this idolatry, which may either be the worship of false gods, or the false worship of the true God.
Jonathan Walton proposes in this book that it not only happens in other countries but right here in America. He identifies twelve beliefs contrary to the gospel of Jesus Christ (and thus lies) that form a national cultural religion which he terms White American Folk Religion or WAFR. In an endnote, he explains this terminology:
"White = manmade racial-gender-class-culture-based hierarchy. American = national identity defined by citizenship and the level of adoption and mastery of whiteness. Folk religion = common set of popular beliefs and practices under the umbrella of a religion but outside of the religion's official doctrines and practices."
What this means, if I understand Walton correctly is that these are values promulgated by those who would identify as part of majority white culture, and that work best for them and thus become an ideal for all American citizens, internalized and often aspired to by other ethnic, class, and affinity groups, even though they don't always work equally well for all. Furthermore, these have been a part of American civil religion, often closely linked with the majority faith in this country, Christianity. While they aren't what we may confess in the liturgy or the creeds, they come to define both what it means for us to be American and Christian. They are beliefs that will be articulated by leaders in both of our political parties--so this isn't a partisan thing. And, in terms of the gospel of Christ, they are lies.
Here are the twelve lies Walton identifies:
Lie 1: We Are a Christian Nation
Lie 2: We Are All Immigrants
Lie 3: We Are a Melting Pot
Lie 4: All Men Are Created Equal
Lie 5: We Are a Great Democracy
Lie 6: The American Dream Is Alive and Well
Lie 7: We Are the Most Prosperous Nation in the World
Lie 8: We Are the Most Generous People in the World
Lie 9: America Is the Land of the Free
Lie 10: America Is the Home of the Brave
Lie 11: America Is the Greatest Country on Earth
Lie 12: We Are One Nation
I squirmed when I read this list. I've said some of these things, and if you search my blogs, I'm sure you will find some of this language. So if your temptation in reading this list is to say, "but...but" you are not alone. In his Introduction, Walton makes this plea:
"I ask you to resist judgment, the urge to look away, and the opportunity to move on. I invite you to carry your skepticism through the entire book while leaning in to understand. Hold your gaze on the picture I am painting and consider its implications for how you think, speak, pray, and act. Your salvation is at stake, and your evangelism is compromised if you claim to be a follower of Jesus while building dividing walls of hostility and allowing them to govern your life. We are to be his witnesses, living differently in this world so we point others to him, and we cannot do that if we are not willing to engage with our differences to seek his justice and reflect his kingdom. I once lived this way, but because of Christ and for the sake of his gospel, I do so no longer."
I leaned into this book. In each chapter, Walton explores the reasons why each of these beliefs is a lie that as Christians we ought repent from, and the liberating truth that we might embrace instead. I will not go through all of these but even the first chapter was persuasive. The problem of saying we are a Christian nation is that throughout our history, Christian faith has upheld slavery and racial hierarchies. I was reminded of learning recently that the church I grew up in endorsed Klan efforts in my home town during the 1920's and that many of our current national divisions are reflected in divisions within a church called to be one in Christ. Those "dividing walls of hostility" are brought up to me when I speak with students about Christ in my work on campus, and indeed compromise our witness.
Likewise, how can we say we are all immigrants, when a number were forcibly brought here as slaves, and the original inhabitants of the land were displaced? Instead of a melting pot, Christ offers a vision of diversity that is celebrated and gratefully embraced instead of assimilated into a majority culture. Democracy is undermined where voter suppression is practiced, where representation is gerrymandered and where wealthy interests have a much greater voice. A gospel-centered people advocate for the voices that are marginalized. Kingdom people are liberated from pursuing "their best lives now" to be rich in the things of God.
One of the most important aspects of this book, then, is the subtitle: "and the truth that sets us free." Walton contends that these lies hold us captive, burden us down, and rob us of kingdom joy. The truth opens our eyes to the ways we've been compromised, and invites us into a bigger dream that has room enough for all, and that brings reconciliation across our deepest differences.
I wondered how Walton would address the question of proper love of place and country. At least some of the expressions Walton calls lies are affectional and aspirational for "the land that we love." Can we love a country without turning it into an idol? As embodied persons living in a place, what is proper care for that place?
Sadly though, we do often become captive to inordinate forms of these beliefs that take precedence over the claims of biblical faith and our kingdom hope. We put America before kingdom, a prosperity gospel before our heavenly inheritance, and sadly, our people before all peoples. Life becomes smaller, meaner, a struggle for self-preservation. Walton points us to a better way, if we are willing to face and repent from the lies.
____________________________
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary advanced reader copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
January 9, 2019
This was a hard book for me to read. Not because of the author's writing style, that was fine. It was because of the subject matter. I am a white female evangelical Christian. I was shocked by the honesty of Walton's thoughts and feelings about the United States and its previous and current political leaders. Reading this book may be the closest I'll ever get to understanding the experiences of an Ivy League educated black Christian in America.
One of the lies Walton identifies is saying the United State is a Christian nation. He does a great job of showing that many actions taken by national leaders in the past and now are not “Christian” by any means. He also points out that calling the United States a Christian nation neutralizes the only people actually capable of critiquing the nation – followers of Jesus. (Loc. 451/2867) Christians have exchanged the mantle of truth and justice for the mantle of political power and have compromised their integrity.
And that is only the first lie. Another is identifying the slaves brought here against their will as “immigrants.” (Ben Carson's first address to federal workers, March 6, 2017.) (Loc 471/2867) Other lies he identifies include that we are a great democracy, that we are the land of the free and the brave, that America is the greatest nation on earth, and more.
Walton is not afraid to name irresponsible Christian leaders who have bowed to political power at the expense of their faithfulness to the gospel. He is not afraid to point out where the church has denied the Savior for the gain of worldly power and influence. He calls Christians to task for promoting what he calls white American folk religion, a far cry from true Christianity.
I highly recommend this hard hitting book. I must say I did not understand all of it. Walton's experiences and thoughts are so very different from mine. I did not agree with everything he said. However, I did see the United States through another person's eyes, a valuable experience indeed.
It would be a great book for a group study. Walton has included questions for discussion or personal reflection at the end of each chapter. He also includes a number of exercises for further reflection and action in Appendixes. You must be willing to have your eyes opened to the truth of what has happened and is happening in the United States, seen through the eyes of a black Christian.
I received a complimentary egalley of this book from the publisher. My comments are an independent and honest review.
One of the lies Walton identifies is saying the United State is a Christian nation. He does a great job of showing that many actions taken by national leaders in the past and now are not “Christian” by any means. He also points out that calling the United States a Christian nation neutralizes the only people actually capable of critiquing the nation – followers of Jesus. (Loc. 451/2867) Christians have exchanged the mantle of truth and justice for the mantle of political power and have compromised their integrity.
And that is only the first lie. Another is identifying the slaves brought here against their will as “immigrants.” (Ben Carson's first address to federal workers, March 6, 2017.) (Loc 471/2867) Other lies he identifies include that we are a great democracy, that we are the land of the free and the brave, that America is the greatest nation on earth, and more.
Walton is not afraid to name irresponsible Christian leaders who have bowed to political power at the expense of their faithfulness to the gospel. He is not afraid to point out where the church has denied the Savior for the gain of worldly power and influence. He calls Christians to task for promoting what he calls white American folk religion, a far cry from true Christianity.
I highly recommend this hard hitting book. I must say I did not understand all of it. Walton's experiences and thoughts are so very different from mine. I did not agree with everything he said. However, I did see the United States through another person's eyes, a valuable experience indeed.
It would be a great book for a group study. Walton has included questions for discussion or personal reflection at the end of each chapter. He also includes a number of exercises for further reflection and action in Appendixes. You must be willing to have your eyes opened to the truth of what has happened and is happening in the United States, seen through the eyes of a black Christian.
I received a complimentary egalley of this book from the publisher. My comments are an independent and honest review.
October 16, 2018
I was really excited to read this book, however I did not realize it would be SO religious.
I anticipated the chapter about America being a Christian nation to have religious key points, and I understand that people write what they know, Walton is obviously a very religious person, so I can appreciate his books having a religious tone.
But I sometimes found myself forgetting the theme of the chapter I was reading, the 'lie' being dissected was getting lost amid the religious connotations. Because of this I found myself struggling through some of the book.
I really enjoyed the personal stories in the book and I found Waltons views on politics and society insightful and enlightened. The religious tie ins did offer another view on many topical situations, but it was just a little overwhelming.
I anticipated the chapter about America being a Christian nation to have religious key points, and I understand that people write what they know, Walton is obviously a very religious person, so I can appreciate his books having a religious tone.
But I sometimes found myself forgetting the theme of the chapter I was reading, the 'lie' being dissected was getting lost amid the religious connotations. Because of this I found myself struggling through some of the book.
I really enjoyed the personal stories in the book and I found Waltons views on politics and society insightful and enlightened. The religious tie ins did offer another view on many topical situations, but it was just a little overwhelming.
July 18, 2025
“No country, including America, is a replacement for the Kingdom of God.”
This book has put to words some of the heaviness surrounding the state of affairs in the United States particularly as it relates to followers of Jesus. This book made some intense claims that didn’t always sit well with me, but always led me back to the foot of the cross acknowledging my own need for restoration and healing and a desire to see others brought there as well. Jonathan Walton brought astute observation and biblical literacy to this conversation. As an InterVarsity staff I have personally benefitted from the compassion and hope that Jonathan brings to ministry and his writing.
If you’ve subscribed to statements like “God Bless America,” or “America is a Christian Nation,” I would encourage you to consider with an open heart Walton’s pushback in this book. It would be easy to write off this book as a political statement, but it would be worthwhile to consider how the claims he makes relate to the core message of the gospel. I believe it is crucial for those who claim the name of Christ to wrestle with. If you do decide to engage, have it be with an open heart and do the work of considering most importantly how He refutes the lies and points us to Christ -- I do not believe Walton refutes these lies just to arouse anger or promote an opposing political alignment. For those starting to consider how the bible talks about justice I would recommend Beyond Colorblind, Living in Color, this book, and Unsettling Truths in that order.
The world would be vastly different if Christians viewed every person as made in the image of God and valued the mission of Christ more than our own comfort, established hierarchy, and pleasure seeking. What if we contemplated the implications of Jesus entering the temple and quoting from Isaiah’s Scroll in Luke 4:18-19, “The Spirit of the Lord is on me, because he has anointed me to proclaim good news to the poor. He has sent me to proclaim freedom for the prisoners and recovery of sight for the blind, to set the oppressed free, to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favor.” Body of Christ, we cannot just “move on” from the systemic issues going on in our country and act as if harm hasn’t been done because “if one part of the body suffers, all other parts suffer with it” (1 Cor. 12:26). It is most helpful for us to confess, repent, and seek restoration and thriving for all peoples.
“Without acknowledgement there can be no confession. And without confession there can be no repentance. Without repentance there is no change of direction. And so, without this reorientation, justice isn’t possible. Thus the personal, relational, and systemic reconciliation and renewal that all of creation longs for is perpetually out of reach. In contrast, acknowledgement of our limits, confession of our brokenness, and turning toward redemption through an encounter with Jesus to pursue righteousness and justice is central to Christianity. The result of this personal and corporate confession is the present and eternal wholeness and shalom (peace) that God originally intended.” May it be so.
This book has put to words some of the heaviness surrounding the state of affairs in the United States particularly as it relates to followers of Jesus. This book made some intense claims that didn’t always sit well with me, but always led me back to the foot of the cross acknowledging my own need for restoration and healing and a desire to see others brought there as well. Jonathan Walton brought astute observation and biblical literacy to this conversation. As an InterVarsity staff I have personally benefitted from the compassion and hope that Jonathan brings to ministry and his writing.
If you’ve subscribed to statements like “God Bless America,” or “America is a Christian Nation,” I would encourage you to consider with an open heart Walton’s pushback in this book. It would be easy to write off this book as a political statement, but it would be worthwhile to consider how the claims he makes relate to the core message of the gospel. I believe it is crucial for those who claim the name of Christ to wrestle with. If you do decide to engage, have it be with an open heart and do the work of considering most importantly how He refutes the lies and points us to Christ -- I do not believe Walton refutes these lies just to arouse anger or promote an opposing political alignment. For those starting to consider how the bible talks about justice I would recommend Beyond Colorblind, Living in Color, this book, and Unsettling Truths in that order.
The world would be vastly different if Christians viewed every person as made in the image of God and valued the mission of Christ more than our own comfort, established hierarchy, and pleasure seeking. What if we contemplated the implications of Jesus entering the temple and quoting from Isaiah’s Scroll in Luke 4:18-19, “The Spirit of the Lord is on me, because he has anointed me to proclaim good news to the poor. He has sent me to proclaim freedom for the prisoners and recovery of sight for the blind, to set the oppressed free, to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favor.” Body of Christ, we cannot just “move on” from the systemic issues going on in our country and act as if harm hasn’t been done because “if one part of the body suffers, all other parts suffer with it” (1 Cor. 12:26). It is most helpful for us to confess, repent, and seek restoration and thriving for all peoples.
“Without acknowledgement there can be no confession. And without confession there can be no repentance. Without repentance there is no change of direction. And so, without this reorientation, justice isn’t possible. Thus the personal, relational, and systemic reconciliation and renewal that all of creation longs for is perpetually out of reach. In contrast, acknowledgement of our limits, confession of our brokenness, and turning toward redemption through an encounter with Jesus to pursue righteousness and justice is central to Christianity. The result of this personal and corporate confession is the present and eternal wholeness and shalom (peace) that God originally intended.” May it be so.
February 24, 2019
The book presents the author's take on twelve statements that shape American civil religion ( The American Dream is Alive and Well, We are a Christian Nation, All Men are Created Equal, etc. ). His argument is two-fold: the statements are lies and they are contrary to a Christian worldview. He develops his argument by weaving historical data, personal stories, and biblical exegesis and reflection. Most chapters conclude with discussion and reflection questions.
The book is engaging and thought-provoking. At times, I needed to put it down so I could digest its content before moving ahead. The author is direct and even confrontational at times which conveys a sense that the stakes are high for him. He cares that his audience doesn't simply read the book, but engages deeply with it.
Some of the chapters seemed to spend an amount of time on his personal story to a point where it made it feel unbalanced as it related to the historical and biblical cases he was building.
Note: I received an advanced copy of the text and know and support the author's work.
The book is engaging and thought-provoking. At times, I needed to put it down so I could digest its content before moving ahead. The author is direct and even confrontational at times which conveys a sense that the stakes are high for him. He cares that his audience doesn't simply read the book, but engages deeply with it.
Some of the chapters seemed to spend an amount of time on his personal story to a point where it made it feel unbalanced as it related to the historical and biblical cases he was building.
Note: I received an advanced copy of the text and know and support the author's work.
April 13, 2019
I so badly wanted this to be a well written book, I was fully behind each chapter’s argument but was underwhelmed by the evidence and weakness of Walton’s approach. Unfortunately the author chose to rely on straw men to lambaste the opposition, which isn’t necessary. His main opponent were those in “White American Folk Religion”, a group he made to be bigger and stronger than they are.
December 16, 2018
Twelve Lies that Hold America Captive is a compelling walk of life with the author Jonathon Walton. I was expecting an argument, provided with research, into a compelling narrative of how American culture fails. But while I still got the facts, I was led into Mr. Walton's personal life experiences as an African-American man trying to find his place in the world of Christianity. This books deals a lot with White American Folks Religion (WAFR) or otherwise known as white Christianity, and its shortcomings from the past to the present. While I have not finished reading the book, it is deeply thought-provoking and deals with a multitude of issues coming from a Christian perspective. It is a step in the right direction in dealing with culture and race when it comes to communities inside of churches, not a final solution. The conversations and the talking points are great and challenging for those with an open mind and heart.
January 1, 2019
If you think you know what America is all about, you should read this book. Whether you consider yourself a Jesus-following Conservative or Liberal, you should read this book. With equal amount of compassion and courage, Jonathan Walton invites the reader into a self-reflective discussion on twelve American "ideals" that have shaped the lives of many of us who grew up in this country. This book will challenge you, break you, and hopefully show you the path toward healing.
January 26, 2021
the implications of our beliefs are no joke. Walton writes well and is poetic at times. He builds a good case for most arguments and leads with personal examples which is helpful for application. recommend for believers. enjoyed this book a lot more than i thought i would.
also just really encouraging sometimes which was a mood.
also just really encouraging sometimes which was a mood.
November 24, 2018
Conversations about Christian Faith and American Politics tend to be predictable parodies of their secular right or left talking points. (Who knew Jesus was a progressive socialist 2000 years ahead of his time? Oh, that's right, Jesus was more of a laissez-faire capitalist who favored a big military, I forgot.)
Jonathan Walton offers refreshing perspective, questioning the presuppositions of American political life from an African American Christian perspective. The, '12 lies' that give the book its name are the anchors of American Civil Religion, a religion Jonathan argues is racist by design.
Jonathan invites his readers to think critically about their assumptions, but also to sit with him in the ambiguities and vulnerabilities of family relationships, impostor syndrome, and loneliness. The book reads like a conversation with a well informed, deeply religious, friend. You may, or may not, agree with all of Jonathan's perspective, but you'll be grateful for his companionship.
Jonathan Walton offers refreshing perspective, questioning the presuppositions of American political life from an African American Christian perspective. The, '12 lies' that give the book its name are the anchors of American Civil Religion, a religion Jonathan argues is racist by design.
Jonathan invites his readers to think critically about their assumptions, but also to sit with him in the ambiguities and vulnerabilities of family relationships, impostor syndrome, and loneliness. The book reads like a conversation with a well informed, deeply religious, friend. You may, or may not, agree with all of Jonathan's perspective, but you'll be grateful for his companionship.
April 24, 2019
As Puritan leader and future governor of Massachusetts John Winthrop said circa 1630, "[W]e are a city on a hill," linking this new country to Jesus' Sermon on the Mount (Matthew 5). That would become the United States' supposed covenant with God to be his beacon of freedom, prosperity, democracy, and a place where all people can achieve their economic potential. And thus, with a God-ordained destiny to fulfill, citizens must at all costs fight to protect their peace, prosperity, and freedom as defined by the framers of this nation. This "Christian" white nationalism is un-Christian, unbiblical, and antithetical to the Jesus of Scripture but core to [white American folk religion]. This belief and its practices are toxic, tragic, and unfortunately still in operation today. There is no other place where this lie about bravery and its link to violence is more destructive than in the treatment of American military service members, law enforcement officers, their families, and those who engage in this false bravery and the praise they receive for it from nearby and worldwide. (148)
In Twelve Lies, Jonathan Walton exposes and breaks down the myth of American exceptionalism by confronting twelve areas, or "lies", which are believed and upheld by "white American folk religion" (which he refers to as WAFR). These lies are:
Lie 1: We Are a Christian NationWalton's approach is factual and historical in basis, as well as religious from a specifically Protestant viewpoint. His thesis is essentially that not only are these lies untrue, they are in fact biblically unfounded and un-Christlike. Walton argues that (white Christian) American nationalism has become a religion unto itself, and that those who practice this religion are guilty of idolatry.
Lie 2: We Are All Immigrants
Lie 3: We Are a Melting Pot
Lie 4: All Men Are Created Equal
Lie 5: We Are a Great Democracy
Lie 6: The American Dream Is Alive and Well
Lie 7: We Are the Most Prosperous Nation in the World
Lie 8: We Are the Most Generous People in the World
Lie 9: America Is the Land of the Free
Lie 10: America Is the Home of the Brave
Lie 11: America Is the Greatest Country on Earth
Lie 12: We Are One Nation
To claim that the white American church does not embody and enforce the ethnic, social, and political division and call it "Christian" is to live in denial. (7)Not only nationalism, but also capitalism, racism, misogyny, militarism, classism, and religious bigotry all come under fire. Walton doesn't shy away from naming names when he accuses religious leaders of cronyism and hypocrisy, and he specifically denounces the quasi-deification of the "founding fathers."
Though those on both sides of the aisle and of differing political stripes may say the system needs fixing and can't be trusted, we must understand that the system is working as designed. [...]Are [the] meetings of white men with means who write laws today truly any different than those who gathered for [the] constitutional conventions that founded this nation? (89)
There were times when the writing veered too far in a personal direction (there were multiple random references to Walton's struggles with pornography addiction) rather than resting on statistical and scriptural analysis. In particular, "Lie 7: We Are the Most Prosperous Nation in the World" and "Lie 11: America Is the Greatest Country on Earth" could have used even more statistical debunking than they had, because these are such deep delusions many Americans hold. "Lie 5: We Are a Great Democracy" was a bit of a confusing chapter-- Walton's main points seemed to be that the founders intended for America to be a republic not a democracy, that several political party tactics keep America from being democratic (gerrymandering, voter suppression, etc., though no mention of the electoral college which seems like quite the oversight), and that democracy isn't a God-ordained government system anyway. But I couldn't quite figure out what Walton's conclusion was-- he points out many things which block us from being a democracy, but not solutions to removing those blocks, and then seems to indicate that we shouldn't be a democracy anyway. If we're not meant to be a democracy, then are we meant to be something else? If so, what, and how do we make that happen?
On a relational level the lie that "we are one nation" is particularly harmful because it dismisses the history of the many Native nations present in the United States. [...]Systemically, it is painfully inaccurate to say we are one nation in the wake of continued educational inequality, segregation by race and class, mass incarceration, and other ills sustained by our inability to reconcile our historical divisions. (184)
Overall, though, I think Walton supports his "lie" claims well, both factually and biblically, and presents a solid case against American exceptionalism in general. I think this book would make for a fantastic church book club pick, and catalyze some deep, challenging conversations about American Christianity. 3.5 stars
January 8, 2019
If the title of this book makes you feel uneasy, I recommend that you pick up a copy and consider what Jonathan Walton has to say. In Twelve Lies That Hold America Captive Walton takes a sober look at twelve principles of American rhetoric, including:
1. We are a Christian Nation.
2. We all are immigrants.
3. We are a melting pot.
4. All men are created equal.
5. We are a great democracy.
6. The American Dream is alive and well.
7. We are the most prosperous nation in the world.
8. We are the most generous people in the world.
9. America is the land of the free.
10. America is the home of the brave.
11. America is the greatest country on Earth.
12. We are one nation.
Walton calls these twelve statements "lies" because of the way they have pervaded and become a central part of Christianity in America--even though these lies are at odds with reality, Scripture, and faithful Christian witness. The result of this intermingling of the twelve lies and American Christianity is false religion and idolatry in Walton's perspective, and his book challenges its readers to see that the gospel of Jesus Christ is antithetical with the lies. The book also encourages us to reflect on the ways we've capitulated to and perpetuated the twelve lies, and to resist the idolatry of America.
Walton implores for readers to "press in, don't look away," and for good reason. Although I agreed with much of what Walton had to say, I still found it uncomfortable to read the book at times. Many of the things that Walton confronts in Twelve Lies are ideas I've heard from both secular and non-secular sources, and I realized that I had internalized some of those perspectives as the book challenged them with facts, personal anecdotes, and Scripture. One critique I have of the book is the method in which it calls out certain prominent Christian leaders. While I believe Walton has valid reasons for doing so, I found some of his criticism too broad-based for readers to accurately assess his statements.
Nevertheless, I continued to read because I believe this book is important for today. Most of those who are devoted followers of Jesus will freely admit that there are problems with the American Church in its current expression--culturally, politically, racially, and more. Twelve Lies will cause you to reevaluate your beliefs and to cry out for the eyes of your heart to be opened. The book, at its heart, is one of lament, and if you allow its call to reach your heart, I believe you will be led into deeper fellowship with God and others as you pursue the kingdom of God.
Twelve Lies also does a great job of guiding readers in their response by including questions at the end of each chapter. The questions help you process the material, and they direct you in reflecting on your personal experiences. The book is well-designed to be read in pairs or groups; in fact, that is probably the best way to experience it. If you are thinking about tackling this book in a small group, I highly recommend you pick up a few copies.
1. We are a Christian Nation.
2. We all are immigrants.
3. We are a melting pot.
4. All men are created equal.
5. We are a great democracy.
6. The American Dream is alive and well.
7. We are the most prosperous nation in the world.
8. We are the most generous people in the world.
9. America is the land of the free.
10. America is the home of the brave.
11. America is the greatest country on Earth.
12. We are one nation.
Walton calls these twelve statements "lies" because of the way they have pervaded and become a central part of Christianity in America--even though these lies are at odds with reality, Scripture, and faithful Christian witness. The result of this intermingling of the twelve lies and American Christianity is false religion and idolatry in Walton's perspective, and his book challenges its readers to see that the gospel of Jesus Christ is antithetical with the lies. The book also encourages us to reflect on the ways we've capitulated to and perpetuated the twelve lies, and to resist the idolatry of America.
Walton implores for readers to "press in, don't look away," and for good reason. Although I agreed with much of what Walton had to say, I still found it uncomfortable to read the book at times. Many of the things that Walton confronts in Twelve Lies are ideas I've heard from both secular and non-secular sources, and I realized that I had internalized some of those perspectives as the book challenged them with facts, personal anecdotes, and Scripture. One critique I have of the book is the method in which it calls out certain prominent Christian leaders. While I believe Walton has valid reasons for doing so, I found some of his criticism too broad-based for readers to accurately assess his statements.
Nevertheless, I continued to read because I believe this book is important for today. Most of those who are devoted followers of Jesus will freely admit that there are problems with the American Church in its current expression--culturally, politically, racially, and more. Twelve Lies will cause you to reevaluate your beliefs and to cry out for the eyes of your heart to be opened. The book, at its heart, is one of lament, and if you allow its call to reach your heart, I believe you will be led into deeper fellowship with God and others as you pursue the kingdom of God.
Twelve Lies also does a great job of guiding readers in their response by including questions at the end of each chapter. The questions help you process the material, and they direct you in reflecting on your personal experiences. The book is well-designed to be read in pairs or groups; in fact, that is probably the best way to experience it. If you are thinking about tackling this book in a small group, I highly recommend you pick up a few copies.
January 11, 2019
This book is thought provoking in many ways and comes at a timely moment in America's history-where we are more politically divided and polarized than ever before, and where leaders have shown their true colors in worshipping power, sex, pride, and manipulation. It also timely has come during what is soon to be one of the longest, if not the longest government shutdowns in American history. I am so appreciative of Jonathan and his ability to speak truth to power, challenge our assumptions and beliefs about what is right, and push us to seek the truth. Readers should know this book is written from a Christian perspective, but I would urge those who are not religious NOT to overlook reading this book. It is honestly written very differently than a lot of Christian books and challenges the dominant cultural narrative that we see in American Christianity today. In this book, Jonathan presents a lot of insights that are relevant to our culture today that help to explain why America is so broken. We have failed to understand our history, have created a narrative in which America is a "city on the hill" to the world, and have failed to question how many things in American history have contradicted its stated ideals and perpetrated racism, sexism, and exploitation. Don't expect it to be an easy read, but expect it to be a powerful read that challenges you in your worldview and pushes you to repent and seek justice.
July 18, 2024
I thought this was going to be a fleshing out the reality of America's foundation being in direct contrast to the political fervor that gets stirred up too often. It was that but also a personal experience narrative of living as a black man in America + comparing his faith/theology to the lies the country holds. It ended up being almost a treatise of how it's virtually impossible to be a Jesus loving Bible following Christian and still embrace "the American dream," which he points out using historical quotes, news incidents, and political realities to show that is still not for everyone regardless of the rhetoric preached in the public square.
The "lies" he discusses are ones I've wrestled with my own self, and wish more people would be open to wrestling with. I think we'd all be better off, whether you're a Christian or not, if we'd really accept that these are not true for everyone in our country. Despite these phrases being so hammered into our national psyche, when one examines them closely, as Walton does, one sees they're simply not factual statements--either currently or in historical past.
Lie 1: We Are a Christian Nation
Lie 2: We Are All Immigrants
Lie 3: We Are a Melting Pot
Lie 4: All Men Are Created Equal
Lie 5: We Are a Great Democracy
Lie 6: The American Dream Is Alive and Well
Lie 7: We Are the Most Prosperous Nation in the World
Lie 8: We Are the Most Generous People in the World
Lie 9: America Is the Land of the Free
Lie 10: America Is the Home of the Brave
Lie 11: America Is the Greatest Country on Earth
Lie 12: We Are One Nation
The "lies" he discusses are ones I've wrestled with my own self, and wish more people would be open to wrestling with. I think we'd all be better off, whether you're a Christian or not, if we'd really accept that these are not true for everyone in our country. Despite these phrases being so hammered into our national psyche, when one examines them closely, as Walton does, one sees they're simply not factual statements--either currently or in historical past.
Lie 1: We Are a Christian Nation
Lie 2: We Are All Immigrants
Lie 3: We Are a Melting Pot
Lie 4: All Men Are Created Equal
Lie 5: We Are a Great Democracy
Lie 6: The American Dream Is Alive and Well
Lie 7: We Are the Most Prosperous Nation in the World
Lie 8: We Are the Most Generous People in the World
Lie 9: America Is the Land of the Free
Lie 10: America Is the Home of the Brave
Lie 11: America Is the Greatest Country on Earth
Lie 12: We Are One Nation
December 27, 2018
This is a great read for anyone struggling to reconcile what we have been taught to believe about the United States as the premier democratic land of the free where all are equal and have equal opportunity to achieve the American dream, and what you have experienced or witnessed in person or in the news of the clear inequality, lack of generosity, and systems that continue to allow these things to flourish. It will likely make you at least a little uncomfortable and certainly will help you to rethink your own framework of thinking about what’s right, what’s true and what’s “typical” or “normal.”
This book may hold a different kind of weight for Christians, as the author is a Christian and honestly, earnestly challenges some of the lies that many American Evangelical churches seem to claim and be founded upon. However, his arguments are all well thought out (& researched/supported with a plethora of well-documented sources, see the Notes) in a way that can resonate with anyone who seeks to understand truth and ways of thinking that have stifled the US and allowed it to grow in such systematic cruelty.
On a more practical note, after the first couple chapters, it can be a bit challenging to follow. And if you are a slow reader who gets easily distracted like I am, you may need to keep rereading the chapter title (the lie that each chapter is focusing on) as you are reading to refocus yourself and better understand to which thesis or sub-points the author is leading.
I encourage you to patiently take the time to understand each of these chapters, and to review Appendix 3 “Lament, Confess, Repent, Reconcile” to seal and take action in response to what has been presented in this book.
This book may hold a different kind of weight for Christians, as the author is a Christian and honestly, earnestly challenges some of the lies that many American Evangelical churches seem to claim and be founded upon. However, his arguments are all well thought out (& researched/supported with a plethora of well-documented sources, see the Notes) in a way that can resonate with anyone who seeks to understand truth and ways of thinking that have stifled the US and allowed it to grow in such systematic cruelty.
On a more practical note, after the first couple chapters, it can be a bit challenging to follow. And if you are a slow reader who gets easily distracted like I am, you may need to keep rereading the chapter title (the lie that each chapter is focusing on) as you are reading to refocus yourself and better understand to which thesis or sub-points the author is leading.
I encourage you to patiently take the time to understand each of these chapters, and to review Appendix 3 “Lament, Confess, Repent, Reconcile” to seal and take action in response to what has been presented in this book.
January 8, 2019
Jonathan Challenges us to see the Kingdom of God as much, much, larger than our United States. He reminds of that “white evangelical is NOT the admission price of Heaven”.
He brings to light that “unfamiliar to whites American Christians does not equal unbiblical!”
He covers
-using scripture out of context,
-our disturbing systemic racism,
-American history,
-Biblical community,
-Wealth & power
-our own unique stories
In covering the 12 Lies that we believe he challenges us to think deeper about what those 12 statements mean. How we have or do believe them, how we have acted upon those beliefs and what it means to re-think those beliefs under a lense of Christ-follower-first. Ultimately he offers a BIblical path forward to be one who works toward reconciliation in all relationships.
He is bold enough to say things that *Should* cause us to stop and think. He is bold and asks us to consider if our life aligns more with the Kingdom of God, or the Kingdom of America. This is NOT a “we are the answer” kind of book - he keeps us humble - we cannot save everyone or fix everything, even in out best activist efforts. He admonishes us that “We cannot BE the hope we’ve been waiting for and trust in the hope of Christ as the same time.” We are not anyones Savior.
You cannot read this book without confronting sin in your own life. Specifically the sins of lying, greed, selfishness, and having other gods(culture & country) before Him.
Ultimately He calls us out of cultural Christianity into a beautifully difficult process of being a disciple of Christ in community with those different from us - because everyone is made in the Image of God, not just white American citizens.
He brings to light that “unfamiliar to whites American Christians does not equal unbiblical!”
He covers
-using scripture out of context,
-our disturbing systemic racism,
-American history,
-Biblical community,
-Wealth & power
-our own unique stories
In covering the 12 Lies that we believe he challenges us to think deeper about what those 12 statements mean. How we have or do believe them, how we have acted upon those beliefs and what it means to re-think those beliefs under a lense of Christ-follower-first. Ultimately he offers a BIblical path forward to be one who works toward reconciliation in all relationships.
He is bold enough to say things that *Should* cause us to stop and think. He is bold and asks us to consider if our life aligns more with the Kingdom of God, or the Kingdom of America. This is NOT a “we are the answer” kind of book - he keeps us humble - we cannot save everyone or fix everything, even in out best activist efforts. He admonishes us that “We cannot BE the hope we’ve been waiting for and trust in the hope of Christ as the same time.” We are not anyones Savior.
You cannot read this book without confronting sin in your own life. Specifically the sins of lying, greed, selfishness, and having other gods(culture & country) before Him.
Ultimately He calls us out of cultural Christianity into a beautifully difficult process of being a disciple of Christ in community with those different from us - because everyone is made in the Image of God, not just white American citizens.
August 25, 2020
I’ll be honest, I was reluctant to read this book. It was on my shelf for over a year before I decided to sit down with it. I was hesitant because I knew this book would radically shape me and I was afraid of that. I had a fear about confronting what I had been told to be true over and over again since I was a little kid.
But now I am an advocate of #12Lies. I’m an advocate because I believe that Jonathan Walton’s book allows the gospel to speak through in ways our American church needs to hear. His book puts language to much of the grumblings I’ve felt in my heart recently - and in certain places, he’s added new ones.
I believe this to be an extremely important read for anyone looking to fight for Justice as a Christian. His experiences, tied with hope from the Word bring life. Jonathan Walton, you are a prophetic voice who needs to keep writing simply because we in the US need to keep hearing what you have to say.
But now I am an advocate of #12Lies. I’m an advocate because I believe that Jonathan Walton’s book allows the gospel to speak through in ways our American church needs to hear. His book puts language to much of the grumblings I’ve felt in my heart recently - and in certain places, he’s added new ones.
I believe this to be an extremely important read for anyone looking to fight for Justice as a Christian. His experiences, tied with hope from the Word bring life. Jonathan Walton, you are a prophetic voice who needs to keep writing simply because we in the US need to keep hearing what you have to say.
September 6, 2020
"The United States [has a] supposed covenant with God to be his beacon of freedom, prosperity, democracy, and a place where all people can achieve their economic potential. And thus, with a God-ordained destiny to fulfill, citizens must at all costs fight to protect their peace, prosperity, and freedom as defined by the framers of this nation. This 'Christian' white nationalism is un-Christian, unbiblical, and antithecal to the Jesus of Scripture."
A clear, impactful, and unapologetic callout of religious & faith-based hypocrisy in past and present white America. I had no idea how much I needed to read this book until I did. Walton hits home in every chapter, and provides profound & accurate vocabulary to describe the mass injustices in the US today. I will never stop recommending this book.
A clear, impactful, and unapologetic callout of religious & faith-based hypocrisy in past and present white America. I had no idea how much I needed to read this book until I did. Walton hits home in every chapter, and provides profound & accurate vocabulary to describe the mass injustices in the US today. I will never stop recommending this book.
January 5, 2023
Reading this book has opened my eyes, broken my heart and refocused many of my prayers. I want to sow and grow seeds of fairness and peace in this country of mine…a country with a long history of pain and strife for so many.
This book will give the reader many thoughts and insights for evaluating their own political and historical beliefs and opinions. I encourage you to lean in and to read this book with an open mind. Be prepared for some discomfort. Truth can hurt and growth can be painful.
As I read this book, I let the discomfort of these lies settle in. I thought deeply about them and prayed about them and for our country. It is time to sink into the real truths and to pray and work for real change. We can and we must do better.
Reading this book gave me a deep insight into this author’s ongoing journey of life and faith. To the author I want to say, you are seen, you are heard, you are valued and I am grateful that you wrote this book. And, I loved the poetry that you shared…such profound and beautiful words!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
This book will give the reader many thoughts and insights for evaluating their own political and historical beliefs and opinions. I encourage you to lean in and to read this book with an open mind. Be prepared for some discomfort. Truth can hurt and growth can be painful.
As I read this book, I let the discomfort of these lies settle in. I thought deeply about them and prayed about them and for our country. It is time to sink into the real truths and to pray and work for real change. We can and we must do better.
Reading this book gave me a deep insight into this author’s ongoing journey of life and faith. To the author I want to say, you are seen, you are heard, you are valued and I am grateful that you wrote this book. And, I loved the poetry that you shared…such profound and beautiful words!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
December 11, 2018
Like a fine wine, this is a book to taste slowly and deliberately. Like poetry that flows smoothly but carries a message that can be unsettling, it is tempting to read this book too quickly, before the unsettling message has a chance to take root.
When does our devotion to America become a religious conviction? This false religion Jonathan Walton calls White American Folk Religion; WAFR. The book takes 12 statements of faith that are typical of WAFR and argues that they are indeed falsehoods. For instance; we are not a Christian nation, the American dream is not alive and well, and we are not one nation (lies 1,6,12). Furthermore, WAFR is at variance with the Kingdom of God. We must choose whom or what we worship, God or America. If this book doesn't challenge some of your ideas about American culture, you need so slow down your reading.
The book is written from a personal perspective intertwined with a historical and contemporary social narrative. It is here that the poetic training of Jonathan Walton shines though, with the effortless transition from history, to lived experience, to lived theological expression. This is more than an academic or theological treatise, more than an historical summary of the ugly side of American History, it is the lived experience of a young articulate bright southern black male, trying to make sense of it all through the eyes of Jesus. How does one follow Jesus in a society that wants to supplant the will of God by the false narrative of white american folk religion?
As an older white male, perhaps the biggest challenge is to start by just listening, not just to the words, but to the experience and person behind the words; to put listening and prayer ahead of a three step action plan, or to quote the text:
"You might wonder, What do I do now? I’ve asked that question as well. And if everyone who flipped through these pages took the same three action steps, we would be missing the point. Following Jesus is about engaging the messiness of this world with the beauty of the risen King, not creating structures to avoid feelings of discomfort, powerlessness, and uncertainty."
I strongly recommend this book.
Note: I received an advanced copy of the text and am delighted to know Jonathan, follow and support his work, and to call him friend and Brother in Christ.
When does our devotion to America become a religious conviction? This false religion Jonathan Walton calls White American Folk Religion; WAFR. The book takes 12 statements of faith that are typical of WAFR and argues that they are indeed falsehoods. For instance; we are not a Christian nation, the American dream is not alive and well, and we are not one nation (lies 1,6,12). Furthermore, WAFR is at variance with the Kingdom of God. We must choose whom or what we worship, God or America. If this book doesn't challenge some of your ideas about American culture, you need so slow down your reading.
The book is written from a personal perspective intertwined with a historical and contemporary social narrative. It is here that the poetic training of Jonathan Walton shines though, with the effortless transition from history, to lived experience, to lived theological expression. This is more than an academic or theological treatise, more than an historical summary of the ugly side of American History, it is the lived experience of a young articulate bright southern black male, trying to make sense of it all through the eyes of Jesus. How does one follow Jesus in a society that wants to supplant the will of God by the false narrative of white american folk religion?
As an older white male, perhaps the biggest challenge is to start by just listening, not just to the words, but to the experience and person behind the words; to put listening and prayer ahead of a three step action plan, or to quote the text:
"You might wonder, What do I do now? I’ve asked that question as well. And if everyone who flipped through these pages took the same three action steps, we would be missing the point. Following Jesus is about engaging the messiness of this world with the beauty of the risen King, not creating structures to avoid feelings of discomfort, powerlessness, and uncertainty."
I strongly recommend this book.
Note: I received an advanced copy of the text and am delighted to know Jonathan, follow and support his work, and to call him friend and Brother in Christ.
August 22, 2021
This is a definite must-read for anyone no matter your belief system or religious affiliation. It explains how political parties use the Christian Bible out of context for their own agenda skewing it for their own purpose. Also, it outlines how ignorant the masses are because they follow whatever media tells them instead of knowing the truth of our country's history, civics, or policies. It also infuriates me that our education system is so inadequate that the subject of social studies (history, civics, geography, government policy, etc.) is not prioritized to the point that it is almost pushed aside. When I look at the current events surrounding me, I can clearly see how much of the disturbing happenings could be prevented or solved if we just understood how we got to where we are in the first place. Our country was not founded on democracy, instead it is a republic that is designed to favor one certain race, class, and gender while oppressing all others- and it is written as plain as day in all of our founding documents! This book also points out the truths of God that our type of government is actually blatantly opposing while claiming to be otherwise. I highly recommend this book for all to read.
January 9, 2019
This book is a must read for anyone who grew up in majority white conservative Christian world. Jonathan describes this "white american folk religion" and I resonated with his description because it was similar to my own experience. As a white male from conservative Christian spaces this book was a hard read, but a necessary one. In reading this book I struggled with feelings of guilt or feeling like I was being attacked, but Jonathan politely encourages you to stick with the book and to hear him out. There are questions at the end of each chapter for further reflection and discussion. I found these questions helpful for my own reflection and would even recommend reading this book in a group using the discussion questions.
January 4, 2022
Overall, the premise of the book is good and there are some important ideas here. The author combines social analysis and commentary with his own personal experience and references to Scripture in a way that sometimes comes across as artificial and forced. However, despite the stylistic awkwardness I found the narrative to be compelling as it gave me the opportunity to see and appreciate things from a significantly different perspective than my own.
January 8, 2019
Thought provoking book.
A great blend of how history and the foundation of the nation are informing the current social atmosphere of America on a large scale and the local church on a small scale. Walton lays his life bare for the reader to enter into and glean some experience of what life looks like as you walk through his shoes.
A great blend of how history and the foundation of the nation are informing the current social atmosphere of America on a large scale and the local church on a small scale. Walton lays his life bare for the reader to enter into and glean some experience of what life looks like as you walk through his shoes.
July 17, 2020
An engaging and humble dismantling of major lies of “White American folk religion” as defined in the book from the perspective of a Black Christian man. Enlightening, challenging, and helpful in its use of Scripture, US history, personal anecdotes, and statistics.
December 19, 2018
At times eye-opening, at times confessional. Jonathan's is exactly the kind of book American Christians need to take the scales off their eyes.
Just awesome.
Plus a dope cover never hurts.
Just awesome.
Plus a dope cover never hurts.
December 13, 2020
In my opinion every white Christian should read this.
January 9, 2019
Jonathan boldly addresses critical issues in American culture that are either blatantly false or twisted versions of reality that end up eclipsing a true life of following Jesus. This is a must read, but requires an open mind, an open heart!
April 22, 2020
This book contrasts Biblical Christianity with what the author calls White American Folk Religion (WAFR). It preaches some heavy truths that more Christians need to confront especially in a era where the American church is so epicly mucked up in political hypocrisy. Yet, I fear it is too much truth for many to handle in such a partisan time. Not that the author doesn't try to make it digestible. It even includes reflection questions and a generous portion of personal stories and hand-holding to take readers through the rough waters.
December 21, 2018
Pulls back the curtain on the myth of American exceptionalism. Vitally important reading for today's troubled world.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 66 reviews