Now established on their Nevisian sugar plantation with her sisters, Verity longs to seek a measure of independence of her own, separate from the shelter of her family. She determines to open a mercantile, providing hard-to-find goods and importing high-quality horses for her fellow islanders. Leaving the island to trade has a two-fold purpose - to grow her business and search for the sea captain who has so long intrigued her. In New York she encounters colonists chafing under British rule and the brother of the sea captain she seeks, as intriguing as his sibling but even more dedicated to the cause of freedom. Captain Ian McKintrick's determination seek justice for the personal losses inflicted by British rule brooks no distraction - but the siren call of the inimitable Verity threatens the focus his quest requires. As the simmering conflict in the colonies begins to impact life on Nevis, Verity and Ian are faced with a choice - with whom does their allegiance lie, and can they dare withstand the cost of threatening the status quo?
While I enjoyed the previous volume in this series, focused on the elder sister Keturah, this book is my JAM. Verity's personality never tried my patience quite like Keturah's did, the simmering romance between Verity and Ian is TO DIE FOR (that Scottish brogue! SWOON!!), and there are spies and privateers and intrigue and all sorts of Ruth catnip throughout. I really enjoyed looking at the birth pangs of the American Revolution from a different - in this case off-shore - atypical point-of-view. Both Ian and Verity's pivot toward sympathy with the Patriot cause unfolds organically and believably. What I most appreciated is that Bergren is careful to never discount the cost of their allegiance to the rebel cause, particularly in Verity's case. Although committed, she struggles with the potential impact of her actions on her family and those on each side of the conflict - a much more nuanced view than some other fiction that takes the black and white point of view of "YAY AMERICA GOOD, BRITISH EVIL"!
I love the fact that this series is a shade or two grittier and more realistic than comparable titles in the market. Bergren is a welcome fresh voice unafraid to incorporate unsavory realities into her fiction - here never to titillate or exploit, but to acknowledge the struggle faced by women and people of color in the 18th century. Although as a white woman Verity occupies a distinct position of privilege, both she and her sisters face sexual advances and harassment from those who view women as commodities to be seen and not heard, and certainly never business owners or planters without the "benefit" of male oversight. This treatment comes with a visceral emotional cost that rings true and is refreshing to see acknowledged on the page. This is where Bergren's storycraft shines: she is a master at creating strong women, true to the time period in which they live, and heroes whose best quality is arguably their desire to meet these women as true partners. I want to avoid spoilers, but I will say this: I loved the development of Verity and Ian's relationship. Bergren had an uphill task ahead of her as I was rooting for the brother prior to this book, but Ian won my heart completely.
Verity is another winner - a rich, meaty, thought-provoking historical with unforgettable, nuanced characters and a deliciously smart plot. The pacing and plotting are exquisitely done, the tension of the growing discontent in the colonies expertly woven throughout the threads of Verity's island life. Verity's story is thoroughly engaging, beautifully rendered, with a swoon-worthy romance and thought-provoking themes of ethics, freedom, and agency. This is new favorite!