When YouTube makeup guru Amelia Montgomery got divorced, she expected that she was in fact getting divorced. But when her should-be-ex husband decides to contest the divorce and generally attempts to make her life miserable, Amelia and her lawyer decide she needs to get away from LA for a while. So Amelia packs up bags and temporarily relocates to her hometown of Seattle. Her future may be on hold, but at least the home she’s staying in is absolutely gorgeous. As is her new neighbor, Wyatt Crawford… After being cheated on by his ex-wife, Wyatt has a hard time trusting women. Even so he’s pretty content with his life, at least until the mysterious and attractive Amelia storms her way into it.
While Amelia and Wyatt’s chemistry and then relationship all felt a little rushed and like instalove for me, I ultimately really liked them together and felt like the story benefited from them not doing the “will they, won’t they” dance around each other for a significant portion of the story. Both were mostly fun and lovable characters, each with their own baggage to overcome to be together.
I really loved Amelia’s career- it’s something that I haven’t encountered in other romance novels before and it made for an interesting story. Because she was an internet celebrity and a brand influencer, there was a lot of discussion about being in a relationship where the woman makes more money, which I felt was an intriguing topic to consider. I found Amelia charming and sassy and wonderful, especially when she just went after what she wanted.
After a while, I got fed up of all the other men in the story being so aggressively alpha males and wanting to grill/beat up/generally harass Wyatt just for being with Amelia. But Wyatt’s reactions to them and how he handled Amelia’s family actually made me like his character more, so I found myself more forgiving of the behavior. I thoroughly enjoyed Wyatt - he’s smart and kind and thoroughly charming - until I didn’t. For the most part, the small amount of drama and conflict was pretty predictable, but I actually took real issue with the way Wyatt behaved during their obligatory breakup. To a certain extent I could understand why he was upset. In his mind, Amelia lied to him and was technically cheating on her husband, something that Wyatt can’t handle. But I had serious issues with all the blame from everyone being put entirely on Amelia when really the problem was Wyatt’s inability to listen and his impulse to punish Amelia for the sins of ex wife. It just rubbed me the wrong way. And while he did ultimately redeem himself and they had a good ending, it still put a bit of a sour taste in my mouth for Wyatt.
I haven’t read all of the With Me in Seattle series and the ones I did read, I read an awful lot of years and books ago, so I was nervous about jumping back into the series. But Proby did a magical job of merging the old characters with the new ones. The beloved characters definitely make appearances, but I never felt like I was being bombarded with characters I was supposed to remember every detail about. The story, like it should, focused on Amelia and Wyatt and everyone else just made for good cameos and supporting characters.
Despite the book taking a bad turn for me in the last 20%, overall, I thoroughly enjoyed what was mostly a pretty easy and sweet love story.