I don't get it.
Authors tend to write the loser trope when it comes to isekais. The nobody that no one looks twice at has to do the impossible and save the world. Because the loser protagonist trope became the norm, almost every single book, show, movie and anime must follow it. Look, I know this may sound stupid, especially because isekai books are my guilty pleasure, but I dislike it when, I pick up an isekai book, and the protagonist is a pathetic loser. It's uninteresting and leads to a boring and aggravating read.
The loser MC trope mostly works in YA stories. This is due to that demographic being around late teens and early adulthood. In that age range most people are going to be unsure about themselves. Mostly everyone is at their most vulnerable, because they are coming out of school and starting a new. So it is understandable that most people would like to read a story where the protagonist has the same challenges that we all face on a daily basis. With that being said, that same approach doesn't work when you write an adult, fantasy series with excessive violence, sex and darker themes. Adult fantasy stories tend to be more mature hence the protagonist should be written to match. HaremLit books tend to lean more on the adult side. That doesn't mean it's dark fantasy or whatever, is just the overly sexual nature and excessive violence that these books have suggest to me that it's an adult book. So I approach these books with the mind set that this is a story for an adult so I tend to take the story and characters a lot more serious.
In GameLit books, this is one of the most prevalent trope that I see. I know, I just said that I disliked the loser guy trope but, that doesn't mean I absolutely hate it. I think when done good, it can be a way more enjoyable story as we get to see the journey of the nobody essentially becoming a god. This also can be true for books in the HaremLit genre. An example of this type of trope that is done well in this genre is, the American Dragon Series by Aaron Crash. It is not the best book ever written, but the way the author handled the main protagonist was done really well. We have the loser guy that everyone looks down on, and makes fun of, but at no point do we believe that Steven is a loser.
Steven is never shown to be pathetic and I think this is the reason why I tend to hate loser MCs. Authors feel like if they give us a pathetic MC character that we would gravitate to them more. Maybe? Like I said, that might be true in YA stories but for adult stories, it tends to suck. Having to follow a spineless MC who constantly pisses his pants when anything remotely dangerous or scary comes tend to suck out any enjoyment from the story. Also when you have that MC unable to think like and adult and handle anything with any sort of dignity, you instantly lose respect from me.
If I pick up an adult story, (it doesn't matter if it's a erotica book or harem lit, or just a regular fantasy) I expect these characters to be a bit mature in their mannerism. Who wants to read a story where at the first sight of danger the MC pisses himself? Maybe there are people who like that, but for me it makes me disinterested. I don't mind being afraid but the moment you cross that line into cowardice, it is just a turn off. Just because you write a loser character, doesn't mean he has to be pathetic. Writing a pathetic imbecile who is incompetent and weak is not fun to read. Remember this is a story for adults. Writing this type of character for an adult demographic is the single worst thing to do. Let me ask this question who out there liked Noah?
Plus the duality of the this MC is throwing me off. 95% of the time he is a coward who shits himself if he has to face something dangerous or make tough decisions, then 5% of the time he is like an alpha male who does what he wants, when he wants to. If you're writing someone like this, it has to be approach with a bit more finesse or else it would come off as you looking like an idiot. Instantly flipping from one extreme to the other was weird, confusing and stupid.
Then let's talk about the main character. He sucks. No redeeming characteristic, nothing to make him likeable just a FUCKING CUCK. Who is this story for? This is a fucking serious question. To elaborate on my question I need to talk about his character.
Let's talk about what a fucking helpless idiot this character is. Every time this dude is put in a situation with him having to make some tough decisions, or make an action to determine something, he always has to complain about I didn't ask for this. We get it! But why I say he is such an idiot is how he approaches everything. He approaches everything with such fear and unwillingness, I can't help but hate his character. Everything that happens, he complains about him not wanting to be their and then shits himself. HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO GET INVESTED WHEN THE MAIN CHARACTER IS SO UNLIKEABLE?
Look I was born into a hellish life. For most of my life (until I reached 17) I suffered a lot. We barely had food on the table, we were homeless and then lived out of a fucking small garage for 5 years of my life. All the while I had to deal with some seriously fucked up shit, yet at no point did I complain. What good does it do? What does complaining get you, does it solve anything? What good does it do to be frustrated at your life, when the current moment your are in, if you didn't act, you would have lose someone close to you. I know how it feels like to constantly be in situations where you didn't ask to be in the world, but I never complained to anyone, never had a panic attack. You want to know why? I had no one but myself, and if I faltered even for a second, the people I cared for would not be alive. And I had to go through those things as a child and teen.
Look I am not saying I am perfect in anyway. There have been many times that things went wrong and it was my fault. I am no saint, but the premise I am trying to get at is if you are writing a hero, having him constantly complaining and faltering isn't how to set him up. You can have him be scared and whatever but at least give him a backbone. A hero isn't necessarily the strongest person, but the person who stands tall in the face of adversity.
So mister author I ask you this question. Who are you writing this book for? Noah's plight of something constantly not going his way and having to deal with situations should appeal to me right? No, because every time Noah has to deal with something, he faltered and whines and complains like a baby. I am just as awkward as the main character but I never made myself into a pathetic idiot. Trying to setup Noah as some sort of hero is a joke. He is no hero. He isn't even a character worth rooting for. So I iterate, Who is this book for? Who wants to follow the story of a pathetic pussy? Why do authors thing just because he is the protagonist, that writing a weak will, meek, poor excuse for a man that it would mean that we'll root for them. FUCK THIS.
REFUNDED.
P.S
I have no idea why I went on a tirade here. Maybe it's because this is like the 5th adult harem series I picked up and it reads like a middle schooler story that has sex and excessive violence to warrant a mature rating. I don't get why authors insist on writing mature content in the format of a middle schooler book. Hell YA/Middle schooler books handle themes like in this book way better. Rick Riordan anyone. If you want to write a mature story, then write something for adults. Writing as if you believe only horny 16 year old are buying your book is retarded. What adults wants to read about a protagonist constantly complaining, being a coward and fumbling is way to a harem. So again who is this book for?