As author of "The Last Toltec King" and a trained historian from the Mexican National University (UNAM), I approached the novel "Aztec" by Colin Falconer with a highly critical eye. Though, after all was said and done, I found myself pleasantly surprised. Well researched with attention to historical detail, "Aztec" is a visually rich re-telling of legendary, heroic exploits, devastating treacheries, a brutal clash of cultures, and the human struggle for survival in a world filled with greed, lust, and revenge.
In 1519, Spanish conquistador Hernan Cortes led an expedition into the heart of Mexico, which ultimately caused the demise of the Aztec empire and brought large portions of the New World under Spanish rule. The novel "Aztec" is the story of Hernan Cortes and his march to Tenochtitlan, the Aztec capital, as seen through the eyes of the woman Malinali. Also known through history as Doña Marina and/or La Malinche, Malinali is gifted to the Spaniards early in their expedition, and because of her intelligence and knowledge of languages, she becomes Cortes' interpreter as well as his paramour.
As a reader who is coming from an academic point of view, I much appreciated the author's historical subtleties that must have taken place between two, so very different cultures. I find I just have to share this, one of my favorite scenes from the book. I don't think it's a spoiler, being such a small snippet of text;
***
My Lord sits astride his great warhorse at the crest of a hill. He takes a magical charm from the pocket of his long-sleeved doublet. Our Mexica guides murmur among themselves, pointing.
I clutch at the stirrups of the beast, no longer afraid of its size, its smell. "Our guides would like to know what is in the box you are looking at."
"It is a compass," he says, and shows it to me. "The needle always points to the north. This way I can judge in which direction we are headed."
It is a ridiculous answer and one I cannot repeat to men of position and intelligence. I turn back to our Mexica guides. "It is a mirror for looking into the future," I tell them. "It can also read men's minds."
The Mexica stare at Cortes and their eyes go wide.
***
I found author Colin Falconer's ability to surmise such historically relevant reactions on the part of the characters to be quite plausible. More simply put, the author "gets it" that Native Americans were living in the Stone Age (based on their weapons and tools) when the first Europeans arrived and naturally would have responded to Europeans and their advanced civilization in ways they, themselves could understand.
I believe the audience that would most appreciate the novel "Aztec" would be fans of both historical fiction as well as non-fiction history of Ancient Mexico.
I've noticed that readers who love this genre tend to be divided over the difficult, Nahuatl terminology. When an author uses too many Nahuatl names and terms, there are those who get frustrated. They want to be able to follow the storyline without the hindrances of mind-boggling words like "Tlahuizcalpantecuhtli" that take five times to sound out and a glossary at the end to comprehend. At the other side of the field of fans is the sock-it-to-me crowd that craves to be intellectually challenged at every turn. These are the readers who put the book down so they can "Google it."
"Aztec" by Colin Falconer is not filled up with difficult Nahuatl terms which makes it perfect for anyone looking for an accessible, unencumbered story from this time period.
One criticism that stands out beyond measure for "Aztec" is the poor quality of editing. It is obvious that author Colin Falconer put a great deal of research and effort into his narrative, and for this he deserves a highly qualified editor. I would like to see Mr. Falconer's future editions properly edited, so that the quality of his writing is commensurate with the level of his research and story telling.
Despite this lack of attention to detail, I highly recommend that you read "Aztec!" You might think you know how the story ends, but do you really know how it all came to pass? Unimaginable things happened, and if you read Colin Falconer's "Aztec" I guarantee you'll feel like you were there to see it all.
Julie Black
Author, "The Last Toltec King"