What do you think?
Rate this book
Shadow Among Sheaves
A Timeless, Beautiful Allegory of the Biblical Love Story of Ruth and Boaz
The Great Rebellion of 1857 was a remarkably bloody business. At a time when Britain’s imperial influence in India was sparking brutal clashes on both sides, no one could have expected Rena, an Indian woman, to marry a British officer—nor do they understand her decision to follow her mother-in-law to England after her husband’s tragic death.
Once the two widows are in Abbotsville, the stern yet compassionate Lord Barric attempts to help them despite his better judgment. Soon he is torn between the demands of reputation and his increasing desire to capture Rena’s heart for his own.
The Great Rebellion of 1857 was a remarkably bloody business. At a time when Britain’s imperial influence in India was sparking brutal clashes on both sides, no one could have expected Rena, an Indian woman, to marry a British officer—nor do they understand her decision to follow her mother-in-law to England after her husband’s tragic death.
Once the two widows are in Abbotsville, the stern yet compassionate Lord Barric attempts to help them despite his better judgment. Soon he is torn between the demands of reputation and his increasing desire to capture Rena’s heart for his own.
317 pages, Paperback
First published April 1, 2019
93 people are currently reading
2436 people want to read
About the author
Naomi Stephens
5 books268 followersNaomi Stephens is a bookworm turned teacher turned writer. She received a B.A. in English from Concordia University in Ann Arbor, and an M.A. in English from Indiana University-Purdue University Fort Wayne.
In bookstores, Naomi gravitates towards 19th-century British novels—the broodier the better (i.e., Jane Eyre)—but she can also be found perusing the young adult, mystery, and fantasy sections. Anything that keeps her turning pages past midnight.
Though she has called many places home over the years, she currently lives in Ohio with her husband, her two children, and a rascal of a dog named Sherlock. When not writing or having adventures with her family, she can be found drinking tea, practicing photography, and pining for London.
In bookstores, Naomi gravitates towards 19th-century British novels—the broodier the better (i.e., Jane Eyre)—but she can also be found perusing the young adult, mystery, and fantasy sections. Anything that keeps her turning pages past midnight.
Though she has called many places home over the years, she currently lives in Ohio with her husband, her two children, and a rascal of a dog named Sherlock. When not writing or having adventures with her family, she can be found drinking tea, practicing photography, and pining for London.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 271 reviews
January 11, 2022
Oh how I loved this book! It's been a while since I have read a Biblical retelling. The story of Ruth is one of my favorites and I just loved this allegory. I appreciated thinking about Ruth as a foreigner in the land. I hadn't thought before about how that might have been for her. This book opened my eyes to that. I loved the love story between Rena and Barric. I loved his gruff exterior, but kind heart. He did have a lot of privilege and snobbery that was annoying at times, but probably realistic. I loved Rena's devotion to Nell and her strength and dignity in the face of so much opposition and ridicule. Overall I think it tracked well with the story in the Bible, but I think it could still be appreciated by those who are unfamiliar with that original text.
March 26, 2019
Ahhh!!! I feel conflicted writing this reviews. On the one hand, I love love love the premise and backdrop for this novel. A Ruth retelling with truly diverse characters—yes please! As a Moabite, Ruth would have suffered so much prejudice in Israel and the author expertly conveyed the social undertones of the Biblical story by setting this novel in Victorian England and the colonization of India. I just can’t get over it. It’s perfection. The conflicted part for me comes in the form of Barric, the hero. I didn’t just not love him with meh feelings, I very much *dislike* him, and that’s kind of hard to do—to write a hero I should love (since it is a romance) and I end up disliking so very much. He was so mercurial. Flirting one minute then downright rude the next. Even with that, though, I’m still telling all my reader friends that they need to read this book. It’s unique and clever and the diversity is so fresh and authentic.
September 14, 2022
India 1857.
A violent fight begins against British rule, called The Great Rebellion, due to forced social reforms and land tax. Rena falls in love with a British Army Officer Edric Hawley, after a quick courtship they marry and tragically he passes away.
Rena decides to travel with her mother-in-law Lady Hawley back to England and to Abbotsville. The women aren't prepared for how they would be treated once on British soil, none of widowed Lady Hawley’s extended family will help them because of Rena, they struggle to find a place to live and feed themselves.
Rena endures terrible prejudice, nasty remarks about her and most of all about her character. Rena lived a comfortable life in India, her father worked as a translator for the British Army and now she’s destitute. A desperate Rena goes searching for food, and she meets Lord Barric Fairfax. His tenant farmers are harvesting his wheat crop, he allows Rena to collect the left over grain and she sells it in Abbotsville for a few coins.
Soon everyone is talking about the Indian beggar woman, and why is Lord Barric helping her and it must because she’s granting him special favors? Rena is an outcast, imagine how she feels being the only person of color in Abbotsville and watching her beloved mother-in-law suffering?
I received a copy of Shadow Among Sheaves by Naomi Stephens from Barbour Publishing and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. This story really took me by surprise, it’s well written and held my attention. The narrative covers subjects such as racism, how widows struggled to survive at the time and how long was a suitable time of mourning, homesickness, poverty, duty, secrets, inheritance laws, and a finding love again. I highly recommend this book, based around a biblical story and four stars from me.
A violent fight begins against British rule, called The Great Rebellion, due to forced social reforms and land tax. Rena falls in love with a British Army Officer Edric Hawley, after a quick courtship they marry and tragically he passes away.
Rena decides to travel with her mother-in-law Lady Hawley back to England and to Abbotsville. The women aren't prepared for how they would be treated once on British soil, none of widowed Lady Hawley’s extended family will help them because of Rena, they struggle to find a place to live and feed themselves.
Rena endures terrible prejudice, nasty remarks about her and most of all about her character. Rena lived a comfortable life in India, her father worked as a translator for the British Army and now she’s destitute. A desperate Rena goes searching for food, and she meets Lord Barric Fairfax. His tenant farmers are harvesting his wheat crop, he allows Rena to collect the left over grain and she sells it in Abbotsville for a few coins.
Soon everyone is talking about the Indian beggar woman, and why is Lord Barric helping her and it must because she’s granting him special favors? Rena is an outcast, imagine how she feels being the only person of color in Abbotsville and watching her beloved mother-in-law suffering?
I received a copy of Shadow Among Sheaves by Naomi Stephens from Barbour Publishing and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. This story really took me by surprise, it’s well written and held my attention. The narrative covers subjects such as racism, how widows struggled to survive at the time and how long was a suitable time of mourning, homesickness, poverty, duty, secrets, inheritance laws, and a finding love again. I highly recommend this book, based around a biblical story and four stars from me.
January 19, 2022
This story is based on the story of Ruth. Rena is Indian and moves back to England with her Mother in Law after both of their husbands die. With nothing Rena begs to get grain from a field and the lord of the manor lets her glean. As time goes on the lord feels responsible for the woman giving them lodging and more food. Both start to have feeling for each other but since Rena comes to England she is made to feel worthless. When a will is found for the late husband house and money Rena must marry into the family for the woman to get the inheritance, can Rena marry the lord and could it possibly be love? I love this story of heartache and forgiveness. Rena character is amazing. Strong and bold she does whatever it takes to provide for her and her mother in law, even when she is meant to feel like trash because of her nationality. The love story is beautiful and it is fun to watch 2 people who has strong feeling for each other fight not to have those feelings. Such a wonderful book. I highly recommend the book and hope you will enjoy it as much as I have!!
April 7, 2019
Shadow Among Sheaves is my first read by author Naomi Stephens. I found her writing to flow well and pull me deep into her allegory based on the story of Ruth from the Bible.
Set in the mid 1800's in England, Neva, a woman of India, has followed her mother-in-law, Lady Hawley, back to England after the death of both of their husbands in India. Neva is well educated and comes from a wealthy Indian family. She is also quite beautiful. She could have stayed in India with her family; but, like Ruth, pledged to stay with her mother-in-law who now only has distant cousins. But neither of them have a way to support themselves while waiting to see if Lady Hawley will inherit her husband's estate.
Several things about this story intrigued me. First, the fortitude of both Rena and Lady Hawley. I can not imagine sleeping in the places they slept, existing on what little food they found, and accepting what little charity that was given them. Second, the horrible treatment that Rena received due to her race. Even though she was the widow of an English military officer, that made no difference in how most of the people of Lady Hawley's town perceived her and anyone who associated with her. It made me think of how in childhood kids would say things like "keep away from her/him. He/she has cooties." But this was not just a funny game. It impacted both Rena and Lady Hawley every minute of every day. Finally, Lord Barric struggled with his feelings about mixed race relationships; but even while he was struggling, he continued to try and help Rena and Lady Hawley behind the scenes.
The spiritual element in this story was very strong. It was nice to see the roles that Lady Hawley, Lord Barric, William and Alice all played in not only growing their own faith; but also showing their faith in how they treated Rena so that she, in turn, began to understand and know the one True God.
An excellent read, and I look forward to more books from this author.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from Shiloh Run Press through NetGalley. Opinions are mine alone. I was not compensated for this review.
Set in the mid 1800's in England, Neva, a woman of India, has followed her mother-in-law, Lady Hawley, back to England after the death of both of their husbands in India. Neva is well educated and comes from a wealthy Indian family. She is also quite beautiful. She could have stayed in India with her family; but, like Ruth, pledged to stay with her mother-in-law who now only has distant cousins. But neither of them have a way to support themselves while waiting to see if Lady Hawley will inherit her husband's estate.
Several things about this story intrigued me. First, the fortitude of both Rena and Lady Hawley. I can not imagine sleeping in the places they slept, existing on what little food they found, and accepting what little charity that was given them. Second, the horrible treatment that Rena received due to her race. Even though she was the widow of an English military officer, that made no difference in how most of the people of Lady Hawley's town perceived her and anyone who associated with her. It made me think of how in childhood kids would say things like "keep away from her/him. He/she has cooties." But this was not just a funny game. It impacted both Rena and Lady Hawley every minute of every day. Finally, Lord Barric struggled with his feelings about mixed race relationships; but even while he was struggling, he continued to try and help Rena and Lady Hawley behind the scenes.
The spiritual element in this story was very strong. It was nice to see the roles that Lady Hawley, Lord Barric, William and Alice all played in not only growing their own faith; but also showing their faith in how they treated Rena so that she, in turn, began to understand and know the one True God.
An excellent read, and I look forward to more books from this author.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from Shiloh Run Press through NetGalley. Opinions are mine alone. I was not compensated for this review.
March 22, 2019
Wow! Just finished Shadow Among Sheaves by Naomi Stephens last night. I love the way that Christian fiction has changed over the past however many years. Loosely based on the story of Ruth in The Bible, Shadow Among Sheaves is the story of Rena (from India) and her mother in law, Lady Nell Hawley (England). Wow, this story just captivated me from the beginning. Author Stephens really captures the cultural and religious differences between Rena's belief systems and her sweet mother in law, Nell who is a Christian. I love the tone of this book. There are so many Christian novels that use a story to shower the reader with condemnation or conviction and this is not one of those stories. I found myself relating to both Rena and Nell (actually Nell's faith resembles my mom's unshakable faith). The story is beautifully written and does not follow the Biblical story exactly, so the reader does not know what to expect throughout the modernized story of Ruth. None of the characters are perfect (except maybe Nell, she is adorable!)
The writing really shows the reader what it is like to come from everything and end up with nothing. Rena came from a wealthy family of influence and power in India and Lady Nell Hawley lived a life of wealth and influence. After Rena's husband passed away, within a short time Nell's husband also passes away. The horrible place that they wind up leaving in a storage room at a brothel is actually a step up from gutters and alleys for the two women. Rena's love for her husband keeps her going so that she can provide a way to take care of her mother in law. As the plot develops, the tension builds... Really good character development, writing, and flow. It inspired me to re-read Ruth in the Bible!! To spot the similarities and differences. Well done, I can not wait until the next book from Naomi Stephens!!!
Thank you to NetGalley, Naomi Stephens, and Barbour Publishing for this ARC for me to read. As always my opinions are my own!!
The writing really shows the reader what it is like to come from everything and end up with nothing. Rena came from a wealthy family of influence and power in India and Lady Nell Hawley lived a life of wealth and influence. After Rena's husband passed away, within a short time Nell's husband also passes away. The horrible place that they wind up leaving in a storage room at a brothel is actually a step up from gutters and alleys for the two women. Rena's love for her husband keeps her going so that she can provide a way to take care of her mother in law. As the plot develops, the tension builds... Really good character development, writing, and flow. It inspired me to re-read Ruth in the Bible!! To spot the similarities and differences. Well done, I can not wait until the next book from Naomi Stephens!!!
Thank you to NetGalley, Naomi Stephens, and Barbour Publishing for this ARC for me to read. As always my opinions are my own!!
March 12, 2019
Wow! Wow! Wow! I am...Wow! I don't even know where to begin. This is a new author and this is her debut book. However, I would have thought her a seasoned writer. This book sucked me in from the get go. This is a re-telling of the story of Ruth and Boaz. Sigh! I loved the story of Ruth so much that my husband and I recited passages from this book of the Bible in our wedding vows over thirty-five years ago. So, when I saw the description, I was all in. Now, add in flavors of Mr. Darcy from Pride and Prejudice, (another fave of mine) then you know it is a winner in my opinion. I loved Rena, the Indian girl who was a young widow and her sweet mother in law Nell. They were so likeable and it broke my heart all of the trials and tribulations they experienced. I also loved how sacrificial Rena was in her love for Nell. Now, add in Lord Barric and I was smitten! It was a bit gritty, but a real look at life during that time for widows. It was a book that showed unconditional love and hope. This had a wonderful HEA! So, this may be my favorite or at least one of my favorite books I have read from this publisher. If you love romance, then this book is for you.
Now, for you sensitive readers, there are a few mild curse words throughout the book, which took me by surprise, but don't let that keep you from this amazing book.
I hope this author will write books for Alice, William and Charlie. ;)
*I was given a copy of this book by Barbour publishing. This is my honest opinion.
Now, for you sensitive readers, there are a few mild curse words throughout the book, which took me by surprise, but don't let that keep you from this amazing book.
I hope this author will write books for Alice, William and Charlie. ;)
*I was given a copy of this book by Barbour publishing. This is my honest opinion.
September 10, 2020
I enjoyed this story very much. It kept my attention from the beginning to the end. The relationship of Rena and Nell was so loving, and you could feel that each cared for the other. I also enjoyed the interaction of Rena and The Barric, and how they came to love each other. 4.5 stars for this read.
September 3, 2020
This book takes the Biblical story of Ruth and Boaz, and sets it in a different time and place...but it does it very well. The story was entertaining and fun, and the characters were likable. Fans of Biblical retellings will likely enjoy this.
March 31, 2019
Shadow Among Sheaves is the debut novel by Naomi Stephens. It is a clear winner in my opinion.
This is a re-telling of the story of Ruth set in England during Victorian times. The setting puts things in perspective for me. During the uprising in 1857, Sir Allistair, his wife Nell and son Edric are living in India. Edric takes an Indian wife, Rena. Both father and son die and the two widows travel back to England. Now I can see how out of place the younger widow is in a foreign land. How will they survive? Nell is penniless because she cannot inherit her husband’s lands or money. They are destitute and are forced to rely on relatives but no one wants to be associated with the Indian girl. They must rely on the charity of a distant cousin for their very subsistence. But people look down on Lord Barric for even giving Rena the gleanings of his fields.
All of this plays out with the author’s wonderfully descriptive prose. She weaves a believable tale among the strictures of the times. You will recognize the parallels to the Biblical story of Ruth and Boaz. This story will stay with me for quite a while.
Be sure and pick up a copy of this book by a fresh new voice in Christian Fiction. You will not be disappointed.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing. I was not required to give a favorable review. All opinions are my own. *
This is a re-telling of the story of Ruth set in England during Victorian times. The setting puts things in perspective for me. During the uprising in 1857, Sir Allistair, his wife Nell and son Edric are living in India. Edric takes an Indian wife, Rena. Both father and son die and the two widows travel back to England. Now I can see how out of place the younger widow is in a foreign land. How will they survive? Nell is penniless because she cannot inherit her husband’s lands or money. They are destitute and are forced to rely on relatives but no one wants to be associated with the Indian girl. They must rely on the charity of a distant cousin for their very subsistence. But people look down on Lord Barric for even giving Rena the gleanings of his fields.
All of this plays out with the author’s wonderfully descriptive prose. She weaves a believable tale among the strictures of the times. You will recognize the parallels to the Biblical story of Ruth and Boaz. This story will stay with me for quite a while.
Be sure and pick up a copy of this book by a fresh new voice in Christian Fiction. You will not be disappointed.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing. I was not required to give a favorable review. All opinions are my own. *
March 14, 2019
This book is written really well. The allegory is clear - it's a Ruth retelling. The characters are real and the story is deep and vivid. It's a really good book - but the content, unfortunately, was too much for me. There were just too many mentions of prostitutes and other such things. However, if it were cleaner, I'd totally hold the book in higher regard because except for the content, it's really enjoyable and so well-done. I love the idea of a Ruth retelling in Victorian England, and I think that the author transitioned Rena, an Indian girl, to England so well. Everything felt quite realistic. Rena was a really good character - so strong, but she was so human.
Overall I really enjoyed this book, except for the content. :/
*I was given a free copy of this book to review by NetGalley. These are all my honest thoughts and opinions.*
Overall I really enjoyed this book, except for the content. :/
*I was given a free copy of this book to review by NetGalley. These are all my honest thoughts and opinions.*
September 14, 2020
In this retelling of the story of Ruth and Boaz, the setting is 1857 England, which is a time period when the Great Rebellion was fresh on the minds of those in both countries: England and India.
The marriage of Rena to a British soldier was shocking. When Rena becomes a widow, she chooses to stay with her mother-in-law and journey to England. The reception of Nell and Rena is much less than welcoming and it quickly becomes clear what a desperate situation they are in.
This retelling was well done.
The marriage of Rena to a British soldier was shocking. When Rena becomes a widow, she chooses to stay with her mother-in-law and journey to England. The reception of Nell and Rena is much less than welcoming and it quickly becomes clear what a desperate situation they are in.
This retelling was well done.
June 27, 2019
Shadow Among Sheaves is the debut novel of author Naomi Stephens and what an incredible book it is. This is the retelling of the biblical Ruth and Boaz.
Rena was born in India but marries a British man. Traveling to England after his death she and her mother in law Nell are outcasts there. No one wants to hire them and they are starving. The story draws me right in . I could feel the compassion Rena has for her husband's mother Nell who she feels responsible for after his death.
Very well written.
Published April 1st 2019 by Shiloh Run Press
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
Rena was born in India but marries a British man. Traveling to England after his death she and her mother in law Nell are outcasts there. No one wants to hire them and they are starving. The story draws me right in . I could feel the compassion Rena has for her husband's mother Nell who she feels responsible for after his death.
Very well written.
Published April 1st 2019 by Shiloh Run Press
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
March 6, 2019
In an elegant writing style, Naomi Stephens moves Ruth & Naomi’s story to a brooding gothic setting to share the tale of determined heroine Rena, who sacrifices her dreams, her dignity, and her future to be true to her mother-in-law Nell. Rena suffers prejudice and ill-treatment by many before she is finally befriended, accepted, and loved. This is a quiet tale of those who rise above the ugliness of life to reach for what is true, noble, right, pure, and lovely. A treat for inspirational historical fiction lovers!
Thanks to the publisher & NetGalley for allowing me the opportunity to read this story!
Quotes I liked . . .
“You think your desert sands are everything, but there is a whole world beyond this heat. Someday I will take you to England. We’ll pluck apples from the trees and lie in the grass all evening while we eat them. And then I’ll whisper in your ear all the ways I love you.”
“But Nell. . .” Rena whispered after a moment, as if hearing his questions. “I could not watch her board that ship alone, with nothing. She begged me at the docks to stay behind in India. But Nell is my family too, as much as my parents, and I must take care of her.”
“No. I have spent more than enough time being taken care of. We all must suffer now and then, and I am strong enough to bear it. There is no other option than to endure.”
In the end, Rena’s own words had persuaded her to follow Nell to church that morning. “Your home is my home,” she’d said all those weeks ago, when she’d begged to remain at the woman’s side. “And everything you are and everything you love—that is all I ever wish to be.”
“She realized she’d stopped breathing. Blessed. The word clanged around inside of her. Blessed to mourn? To feel empty? Blessed to be poor and starving, she added bitterly, to have nowhere else to turn?”
“But I miss the sand that gathers between the tiles in the entryway of our home, and the hibiscus that grows outside my chamber. I miss the way my father’s study smells in the early evening, of spices and ink, and the way the endless heat drags on for forever, hazing the horizon until the monsoon season comes. And if you look just right from the outer terrace, you can see men and women as they walk to the market, or the crimson coats of soldiers as they pass. . . .”
Thanks to the publisher & NetGalley for allowing me the opportunity to read this story!
Quotes I liked . . .
“You think your desert sands are everything, but there is a whole world beyond this heat. Someday I will take you to England. We’ll pluck apples from the trees and lie in the grass all evening while we eat them. And then I’ll whisper in your ear all the ways I love you.”
“But Nell. . .” Rena whispered after a moment, as if hearing his questions. “I could not watch her board that ship alone, with nothing. She begged me at the docks to stay behind in India. But Nell is my family too, as much as my parents, and I must take care of her.”
“No. I have spent more than enough time being taken care of. We all must suffer now and then, and I am strong enough to bear it. There is no other option than to endure.”
In the end, Rena’s own words had persuaded her to follow Nell to church that morning. “Your home is my home,” she’d said all those weeks ago, when she’d begged to remain at the woman’s side. “And everything you are and everything you love—that is all I ever wish to be.”
“She realized she’d stopped breathing. Blessed. The word clanged around inside of her. Blessed to mourn? To feel empty? Blessed to be poor and starving, she added bitterly, to have nowhere else to turn?”
“But I miss the sand that gathers between the tiles in the entryway of our home, and the hibiscus that grows outside my chamber. I miss the way my father’s study smells in the early evening, of spices and ink, and the way the endless heat drags on for forever, hazing the horizon until the monsoon season comes. And if you look just right from the outer terrace, you can see men and women as they walk to the market, or the crimson coats of soldiers as they pass. . . .”
March 24, 2019
Find this and other reviews at: https://historicalfictionreader.blogs...
Naomi Stephens’ Shadow Among Sheaves is a story I didn’t know I needed. An allegorical retelling of the romance between Ruth and Boaz, the novel has clear Christian themes, but I genuinely feel that Stephens’ gentle handling of the material, lyrical prose, and unique historical content grant the title appeal beyond its primary market.
I don’t want to set the bar too high, but I admit to having flashbacks to Jane Eyre while reading this book. I can’t say whether or not Stephens struck this tone intentionally, but I found the ambiance strikingly similar and loved how it shaped my experience of the story.
I recognize the ethnic diversity within the narrative is a direct reference to Ruth’s heritage, but I felt Stephens’ effort to explore Indian culture through a British lens as the former fell under British rule absolutely fascinating. Lord Barric and Rena proved wonderfully dynamic in their own rights, but in a larger sense, I found myself falling hard for the inclusionary and composite nature of the story.
Refreshing, heartwarming, creative, and highly recommended.
Naomi Stephens’ Shadow Among Sheaves is a story I didn’t know I needed. An allegorical retelling of the romance between Ruth and Boaz, the novel has clear Christian themes, but I genuinely feel that Stephens’ gentle handling of the material, lyrical prose, and unique historical content grant the title appeal beyond its primary market.
I don’t want to set the bar too high, but I admit to having flashbacks to Jane Eyre while reading this book. I can’t say whether or not Stephens struck this tone intentionally, but I found the ambiance strikingly similar and loved how it shaped my experience of the story.
I recognize the ethnic diversity within the narrative is a direct reference to Ruth’s heritage, but I felt Stephens’ effort to explore Indian culture through a British lens as the former fell under British rule absolutely fascinating. Lord Barric and Rena proved wonderfully dynamic in their own rights, but in a larger sense, I found myself falling hard for the inclusionary and composite nature of the story.
Refreshing, heartwarming, creative, and highly recommended.
April 19, 2019
I love the story of Ruth from the Bible. I like to read retellings of it as well. When I read the synopsis for this book I saw that it contained Victorian elements and the Ruth character is from India (two things which I’m very interested in). "Shadow Among Sheaves" by Naomi Stephens is a book I ended up having mixed feelings on.
Naomi Stephens is a great writer and I love her descriptions. The pace moves fairly quickly, only lagging in a few parts. I love the concept of this story. Ms. Stephens deals especially well with describing the Indian culture and how that would clash with Victorian England. It’s crazy how much prejudice the people in England had against the Indians (even if a person was from the highest class in India). Both cultures are well researched.
But, there are two things that give this book a lower rating for me. I mistakenly thought it would also be a Naomi and Ruth story as well as a Ruth and Boaz. I really wanted to know more about Nell’s (the Naomi character) life and thoughts. I desired to see more of the beautiful relationship Naomi and Ruth share in the Biblical account.
Secondly, I just did not like the Boaz character in this story (Lord Barric). He says and does some really mean and hurtful things towards Rena (Ruth). I understand why he did them, but he just doesn’t seem like a hero character to me.
All in all, it was fun to see how this retelling would play out. I enjoyed the plot, setting and descriptions, but I just didn’t love the book overall. I would still recommend that you try it out for yourself!
Content: I give this book a PG-13 rating. Some examples of the content are: the main characters live in a brothel for a while (but do not become prostitutes); there are some violent descriptions of the Indian Mutiny; mention of prostitution and concubines; talk of lovers; a man swears, but the word isn’t actually written; a man hits a woman; a married couple is naked in bed together; the word “dammit” is used.
Rating: I give this book 3 stars.
Genre: Christian fiction; Historical; Romance; Victorian
I want to thank Barbour Publishing, Shiloh Run Press, Naomi Stephens, NetGalley and Celebrate Lit for the complimentary copy of this book for review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I express in this review are my own. This is in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s CFR 16, Part 255.
Naomi Stephens is a great writer and I love her descriptions. The pace moves fairly quickly, only lagging in a few parts. I love the concept of this story. Ms. Stephens deals especially well with describing the Indian culture and how that would clash with Victorian England. It’s crazy how much prejudice the people in England had against the Indians (even if a person was from the highest class in India). Both cultures are well researched.
But, there are two things that give this book a lower rating for me. I mistakenly thought it would also be a Naomi and Ruth story as well as a Ruth and Boaz. I really wanted to know more about Nell’s (the Naomi character) life and thoughts. I desired to see more of the beautiful relationship Naomi and Ruth share in the Biblical account.
Secondly, I just did not like the Boaz character in this story (Lord Barric). He says and does some really mean and hurtful things towards Rena (Ruth). I understand why he did them, but he just doesn’t seem like a hero character to me.
All in all, it was fun to see how this retelling would play out. I enjoyed the plot, setting and descriptions, but I just didn’t love the book overall. I would still recommend that you try it out for yourself!
Content: I give this book a PG-13 rating. Some examples of the content are: the main characters live in a brothel for a while (but do not become prostitutes); there are some violent descriptions of the Indian Mutiny; mention of prostitution and concubines; talk of lovers; a man swears, but the word isn’t actually written; a man hits a woman; a married couple is naked in bed together; the word “dammit” is used.
Rating: I give this book 3 stars.
Genre: Christian fiction; Historical; Romance; Victorian
I want to thank Barbour Publishing, Shiloh Run Press, Naomi Stephens, NetGalley and Celebrate Lit for the complimentary copy of this book for review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I express in this review are my own. This is in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s CFR 16, Part 255.
August 14, 2019
8/14/19 on sale for 0.99
This is a retelling of the story of Ruth in the Gentry era of British history. Our Rena is an Indian woman who married a British soldier. After her husband Edric and his father die, her mother in law Nell goes back to England with nothing, and her daughter in law goes with her to take care of her.
But people are mistrustful of the foreign Rena, and she and her mother in law live in poverty until a distant cousin of Nell - Lord Barric, has pity on them and lets Rena work on his land.
All in all, this was an excellent setting for the retelling of Ruth. It really emphasizes how Ruth was a foreigner, and how hard it must have been for her. It’s a Christian fiction novel that isn’t too preachy either.
I enjoyed this retelling of Ruth, and if you’re looking for a Christian fiction read, this may be the book for you.
I received this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This is a retelling of the story of Ruth in the Gentry era of British history. Our Rena is an Indian woman who married a British soldier. After her husband Edric and his father die, her mother in law Nell goes back to England with nothing, and her daughter in law goes with her to take care of her.
But people are mistrustful of the foreign Rena, and she and her mother in law live in poverty until a distant cousin of Nell - Lord Barric, has pity on them and lets Rena work on his land.
All in all, this was an excellent setting for the retelling of Ruth. It really emphasizes how Ruth was a foreigner, and how hard it must have been for her. It’s a Christian fiction novel that isn’t too preachy either.
I enjoyed this retelling of Ruth, and if you’re looking for a Christian fiction read, this may be the book for you.
I received this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
ebook-own-toread
May 11, 2019Won this as a Goodreads giveaway!
February 19, 2019
This novel takes the basic story of Ruth from the Old Testament of the Bible and weaves it together with elements of Pride and Prejudice. Now, I know that wasn't the intent of the author to weave P & P into the themes, but I couldn't help but make the comparison as Lord Barric appears to deal a lot from the element of Pride in relationship to his estate. And since it is set in the time that Jane Austen was writing, it just makes sense.
But the real story is based on the Biblical Account of Ruth the Moabite who returns to Bethlehem with her Israelite mother-in-law, Naomi. The two widows must work through the bleak aspect of being widows, homeless, penniless, etc.
In our current novel, Rena, a native of India has married a British officer who then passes away. Followed in death by his diplomatic father. This leaves Rena and her Mother-in-law, Nell, somewhat destitute. Lady Nell's husbands English estate is entailed to another. Thus she returns to England from India with no money, no home to return to and a daughter-in-law who is not well received.
You see, they return to England after the uprising in India where many insurgents rose up to try and oust the British and in doing so they killed women and children as well as British military. The feelings at home in England couldn't be worse for Rena to walk into. She is shunned by all and is left to beg for food.
She ends up in the fields of Lord Barric, gleaning grain. The Lord meets her and the story develops from there into a love story, or not. Lord Barric is conflicted as he wants to help, but he doesn't want to destroy is family name and standing in culture by associating with Rena.
I love the way that Naomi Stephens writes the modern version of the Ruth story. She takes great care to get the historical setting of England in the 1800's correct. She also takes great pains to get the human characteristics of pride, nationalism, racial prejudice and social standing correct.
I know you will love the way she weaves the story and the ending is excellent.
Enjoy!
But the real story is based on the Biblical Account of Ruth the Moabite who returns to Bethlehem with her Israelite mother-in-law, Naomi. The two widows must work through the bleak aspect of being widows, homeless, penniless, etc.
In our current novel, Rena, a native of India has married a British officer who then passes away. Followed in death by his diplomatic father. This leaves Rena and her Mother-in-law, Nell, somewhat destitute. Lady Nell's husbands English estate is entailed to another. Thus she returns to England from India with no money, no home to return to and a daughter-in-law who is not well received.
You see, they return to England after the uprising in India where many insurgents rose up to try and oust the British and in doing so they killed women and children as well as British military. The feelings at home in England couldn't be worse for Rena to walk into. She is shunned by all and is left to beg for food.
She ends up in the fields of Lord Barric, gleaning grain. The Lord meets her and the story develops from there into a love story, or not. Lord Barric is conflicted as he wants to help, but he doesn't want to destroy is family name and standing in culture by associating with Rena.
I love the way that Naomi Stephens writes the modern version of the Ruth story. She takes great care to get the historical setting of England in the 1800's correct. She also takes great pains to get the human characteristics of pride, nationalism, racial prejudice and social standing correct.
I know you will love the way she weaves the story and the ending is excellent.
Enjoy!
April 2, 2019
I am going to say right off the bat that writing a review like this actually kind of pains me. I like reading Christian fiction and the biblical story of Ruth (which this book is very loosely based on) is a favorite of mine. However, I am very sad to say that I didn’t enjoy this book. Here are my pros and cons:
Pros
• I thought it was creative to bring the Ruth story into the Victorian era.
Cons
• This is so loosely based on the story of Ruth and Boaz that is it almost unfamiliar. If you are looking to learn about biblical Ruth at all, this isn’t the book to do that.
• Almost the entire first half of the book was about Rena’s circumstances… talking about how she was suffering, why she was suffering, dwelling on the suffering. Nothing was happening. It was boring. I honestly almost stopped reading about 40% in.
• I think the book reads like a YA angsty romance. There was bickering between Rena and another woman over Barric’s affections (or lack thereof). There was way too little communication and way too many rumors and innuendos. It bordered on silly. We are talking about adults here, yet it smacked of high school shenanigans and really disappointed me.
• The “found” will! My goodness, I think that is when I almost stopped reading for good. I don’t want to give too many details here – and if you fear a spoiler you can stop reading - but I seriously cannot believe we are supposed to accept that Rena’s father-in-law changed his will before his death that required the widowed Rena to marry someone in order for her mother-in-law (his wife!!) to inherit any family money or property. He’d rather have them penniless unless she remarries? SERIOUSLY? I know a reason was provided in the story for the marriage requirement, but I absolutely will never accept that a man that supposedly adores and loves his wife and daughter-in-law would rather have them indigent unless Rena remarries. This was a contrived plot point that was completely unrealistic and it absolutely ruined the book for me.
I love the biblical story of Ruth. My wedding vows included passages from the book of Ruth. I know Ruth. This book did not evoke Ruth for me, other than Rena followed her mother-in-law to a foreign land after her husband died and gleaned grain from a landowner to survive. Everything else was a silly romantic game with contrived plot points in my opinion. The book simply didn’t have the depth and breadth of the real Ruth for me. If you want to read a great story about Ruth go grab a copy of Unshaken by Francine Rivers.
I’m going to close by saying that even though I did not like this book, the author has actually achieved something I will never be able to do myself – she wrote a book! That is an achievement I admire tremendously and I’m actually a bit jealous of people that have the time and talent to put stories on paper and provide books for me to read. Books are art… and like art, tastes vary and not everyone will like the same things. Just because I had some serious issues with this book doesn’t mean you shouldn’t read it if you are interested. It also doesn’t mean I won’t read future books from this author. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions and this novel just didn’t work for me.
Thank you NetGalley and Barbour Publishing, Inc. / Shiloh Run Press for a free eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. Opinions are my own.
Pros
• I thought it was creative to bring the Ruth story into the Victorian era.
Cons
• This is so loosely based on the story of Ruth and Boaz that is it almost unfamiliar. If you are looking to learn about biblical Ruth at all, this isn’t the book to do that.
• Almost the entire first half of the book was about Rena’s circumstances… talking about how she was suffering, why she was suffering, dwelling on the suffering. Nothing was happening. It was boring. I honestly almost stopped reading about 40% in.
• I think the book reads like a YA angsty romance. There was bickering between Rena and another woman over Barric’s affections (or lack thereof). There was way too little communication and way too many rumors and innuendos. It bordered on silly. We are talking about adults here, yet it smacked of high school shenanigans and really disappointed me.
• The “found” will! My goodness, I think that is when I almost stopped reading for good. I don’t want to give too many details here – and if you fear a spoiler you can stop reading - but I seriously cannot believe we are supposed to accept that Rena’s father-in-law changed his will before his death that required the widowed Rena to marry someone in order for her mother-in-law (his wife!!) to inherit any family money or property. He’d rather have them penniless unless she remarries? SERIOUSLY? I know a reason was provided in the story for the marriage requirement, but I absolutely will never accept that a man that supposedly adores and loves his wife and daughter-in-law would rather have them indigent unless Rena remarries. This was a contrived plot point that was completely unrealistic and it absolutely ruined the book for me.
I love the biblical story of Ruth. My wedding vows included passages from the book of Ruth. I know Ruth. This book did not evoke Ruth for me, other than Rena followed her mother-in-law to a foreign land after her husband died and gleaned grain from a landowner to survive. Everything else was a silly romantic game with contrived plot points in my opinion. The book simply didn’t have the depth and breadth of the real Ruth for me. If you want to read a great story about Ruth go grab a copy of Unshaken by Francine Rivers.
I’m going to close by saying that even though I did not like this book, the author has actually achieved something I will never be able to do myself – she wrote a book! That is an achievement I admire tremendously and I’m actually a bit jealous of people that have the time and talent to put stories on paper and provide books for me to read. Books are art… and like art, tastes vary and not everyone will like the same things. Just because I had some serious issues with this book doesn’t mean you shouldn’t read it if you are interested. It also doesn’t mean I won’t read future books from this author. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions and this novel just didn’t work for me.
Thank you NetGalley and Barbour Publishing, Inc. / Shiloh Run Press for a free eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. Opinions are my own.
September 6, 2020
I knew from the beginning that this was a 'retelling' of the story of Ruth, Naomi, and Boaz. It was interesting to see the elements of that story throughout the novel, but it almost didn't feel like a retelling to me . . . it felt like the author used the story's framework to explore additional ideas.
For instance, though Ruth is a Moabitess who chose to live among the Israelite people, I never get a sense that she was truly viewed as an outsider from the Bible's telling of the story. This story had Rena painted not only as an outsider, but one who was actively hated (or at the very least mistrusted) by the majority of the people she encountered in Nell's hometown in England. It made me wonder what it would have been like for Ruth at the beginning before people got to know her as a 'virtuous woman' (see Ruth 3:11). In fact, even at the end of the book, there are accusations against Rena's virtue consistently flung in her face, untrue though they may have been.
I liked that Rena was willing to give up everything (and I do mean everything) to make sure that her mother-in-law Nell was cared for. I also loved that she was able to understand what it meant for Nell's God (and her late husband's God) to be her God as well.
I must admit to having mixed feelings about Barric. In the Bible, Boaz is portrayed as a kind and generous benefactor, but Barric seems very begrudging of the support he allows (I don't know that I can say 'gives'?) Rena and Nell. Yes, there ended up being a kind side to him, but far too often it was shadowed by his gruff, stern side.
Speaking of shadows, I absolutely loved the imagery of Rena as a shadow among the sheaves of the harvest. Beautiful writing.
All in all, I enjoyed the book.
For instance, though Ruth is a Moabitess who chose to live among the Israelite people, I never get a sense that she was truly viewed as an outsider from the Bible's telling of the story. This story had Rena painted not only as an outsider, but one who was actively hated (or at the very least mistrusted) by the majority of the people she encountered in Nell's hometown in England. It made me wonder what it would have been like for Ruth at the beginning before people got to know her as a 'virtuous woman' (see Ruth 3:11). In fact, even at the end of the book, there are accusations against Rena's virtue consistently flung in her face, untrue though they may have been.
I liked that Rena was willing to give up everything (and I do mean everything) to make sure that her mother-in-law Nell was cared for. I also loved that she was able to understand what it meant for Nell's God (and her late husband's God) to be her God as well.
I must admit to having mixed feelings about Barric. In the Bible, Boaz is portrayed as a kind and generous benefactor, but Barric seems very begrudging of the support he allows (I don't know that I can say 'gives'?) Rena and Nell. Yes, there ended up being a kind side to him, but far too often it was shadowed by his gruff, stern side.
Speaking of shadows, I absolutely loved the imagery of Rena as a shadow among the sheaves of the harvest. Beautiful writing.
All in all, I enjoyed the book.
February 12, 2019
Thoroughly enjoyed this author's debut novel. This period take of the story of Ruth and Boaz is both interesting and easily captivates the reader in the story. Stephens beautifully illustrates the characters in a way that swoops you into the story within the first chapter. Personally, I enjoyed the strong female characters and their meaningful bond in the book. I quite enjoyed the strength and sass of the main female character, Rena. The author's ability to weave in cross cultural pieces (specifically of India) into the story was delightfully surprising. Particularly in the first half of the book, I found myself so satisfied with the author's metaphors. For example, in depicting the strength in one female character's attitude in suffering, "Nell wore a determined expression that swept away the dusty gloom of the room and made her mistress of even the cobwebs." Mistress of the cobwebs!? C'mon, that is so good. I'm hooked! I'm definitely following the author in anticipation for the next novel.
If historical fiction or biblically inspired love stories are your jam, this is the book for you! I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review. BUT I did anyway because I love those cobwebs! #MistressoftheCobwebs
If historical fiction or biblically inspired love stories are your jam, this is the book for you! I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review. BUT I did anyway because I love those cobwebs! #MistressoftheCobwebs
April 18, 2019
This was a beautifully written debut novel by Naomi Stephens. When I saw that this was a retelling of Ruth and Boaz, I was quite excited, because that is one of my favorite Bible books. When I started this story, I wondered how the author will write a novel from such a short book, and with interesting secondary characters, like Charlie, William and Alice, and historical facts which was smoothly intertwined with the Biblical retelling, the Victorian story came to life.
The author did a great job of making me as reader feel the hardships Rena and Nell endured, the prejudice against Rena, her difficulty to fit in, her pure surrendering heart and Lord Barric's tug to help her. There were a few things which if I compared it to the story of Ruth, I felt the characters were represented a bit different to how I experienced them in the Bible - Naomi was for me a stronger person of input in Ruth's life - Nell's influence was there, but more to the background, except at the end. My perception of Boaz was a bit different from the prideful Lord Barric who has this internal struggle to help and not let his title dictate his actions.
All in all I did enjoy this story and see a lot of potential in the author. She did a great job of making me think the difficulties Ruth had to experience. I would love it if she adds a novel about "life after Ruth", since Alice, William and Charlie is characters I would love to see again.
Content issues which will bother some readers:
* Some swearing (limited)
* Word "whore" used a few times
* Prostitution mentioned/referred to.
* The scene where Ruth went to Boaz might make some readers uncomfortable because of kissing.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Books through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.*
The author did a great job of making me as reader feel the hardships Rena and Nell endured, the prejudice against Rena, her difficulty to fit in, her pure surrendering heart and Lord Barric's tug to help her. There were a few things which if I compared it to the story of Ruth, I felt the characters were represented a bit different to how I experienced them in the Bible - Naomi was for me a stronger person of input in Ruth's life - Nell's influence was there, but more to the background, except at the end. My perception of Boaz was a bit different from the prideful Lord Barric who has this internal struggle to help and not let his title dictate his actions.
All in all I did enjoy this story and see a lot of potential in the author. She did a great job of making me think the difficulties Ruth had to experience. I would love it if she adds a novel about "life after Ruth", since Alice, William and Charlie is characters I would love to see again.
Content issues which will bother some readers:
* Some swearing (limited)
* Word "whore" used a few times
* Prostitution mentioned/referred to.
* The scene where Ruth went to Boaz might make some readers uncomfortable because of kissing.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Books through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.*
April 28, 2019
Following the death of her British husband and father-in-law, Indian widow Rena relocates to England with her mother-in-law with the hope of a fresh start. While in Abbottsville, Lord Barric is torn betweeen maintain his reputation and aiding these two widows. Despite his better judgement, he is soon torn over this increasing affection for Rena.
This Victorian retelling of the story of Ruth and Boaz was well done with great flow. Stephens highlights various themes that are still relevant in the 21st century such as inter-racial relationships and the clash of culture and religion. She also highlighted the plight of Indian widows who are disowned by the families. Unfortunately, this sad practice is still practiced today not only in India but in other parts of the world.
A great addittion to the book would have been a historical note to provide context for the Great Rebellion of 1857 and also to seperate fact from fiction. Since, I received an eARC from the publisher via Netgalley, therefore I am not sure if a historical background was included in the final copy. I would be interested in reading reviews from Indian Reviewers.
Overall, I think it is interesting take on the story of Ruth and would a good summer read.
This Victorian retelling of the story of Ruth and Boaz was well done with great flow. Stephens highlights various themes that are still relevant in the 21st century such as inter-racial relationships and the clash of culture and religion. She also highlighted the plight of Indian widows who are disowned by the families. Unfortunately, this sad practice is still practiced today not only in India but in other parts of the world.
A great addittion to the book would have been a historical note to provide context for the Great Rebellion of 1857 and also to seperate fact from fiction. Since, I received an eARC from the publisher via Netgalley, therefore I am not sure if a historical background was included in the final copy. I would be interested in reading reviews from Indian Reviewers.
Overall, I think it is interesting take on the story of Ruth and would a good summer read.
March 11, 2019
This story was set in 1861 in England. The plot only vaguely resembles the story of Ruth and Boaz in the Bible, and the characters were nothing like the people described in the Bible. However, the attempt to make it remotely like Ruth and Boaz meant that the main characters sometimes didn't act correctly for 1861 England, either, and it made the ending completely unbelievable.
Nell (Naomi) has a strong faith in God that leaves her cheerful even when in mourning, deep in poverty, and rejected by her extended family. Rena (Ruth) has little interest in the Christian God and has left her loving family so that she can take care of Nell. Driven by starvation, Rena's caught stealing some abandoned bits of grain by Lord Barric's steward, who allows her to take the grain out of pity and compassion. Lord Barric (Boaz) is upset when he discovers this and looks down on her, but he allows her to continue gleaning the leftovers because she's so pretty. He lusts after her.
Barric's rude and says cruel things to Rena. He humiliates her. He allows other people to be rude towards her when he rightfully ought to tell them to stop. He puts her in compromising positions, ruins her reputation, and even tries to kiss her when he has her in private (and with no intention of marrying her). Yet he's angry when she states that she will not be his mistress even though that is what everyone assumes is his intent. He feels so honorable because he doesn't force Rena, but the parson points out that he's still responsible for ruining her reputation. He tries to shame and verbally abuse her into saying she loves him (or at least into his bed). He's a jerk, so I don't understand why Rena is at all attracted to him. (I can see being grateful that he helps provide for her and Nell, but he's not a nice person and never apologizes for his behavior.) Their relationship has little to redeem it, and she's treated much better by the steward, the parson, and even his brother.
The second will is completely unbelievable for that time period. Plus it makes absolutely no sense that Nell's husband never told them about the changes he made and that the pertinent people didn't know about this will when he died.
The story did highlight how a hated foreigner would be very vulnerable and treated badly. But Rena was treated so badly and was so despised (except for a few people showing Christian compassion) that it's unreasonable to assume that she'll ever be accepted or feel welcome. There were no sex scenes, though there were two bedroom scenes (one of which described physical contact right before sex). There were a few uses of bad language.
I received an ARC review copy of this book from the publisher through Amazon Vine.
Nell (Naomi) has a strong faith in God that leaves her cheerful even when in mourning, deep in poverty, and rejected by her extended family. Rena (Ruth) has little interest in the Christian God and has left her loving family so that she can take care of Nell. Driven by starvation, Rena's caught stealing some abandoned bits of grain by Lord Barric's steward, who allows her to take the grain out of pity and compassion. Lord Barric (Boaz) is upset when he discovers this and looks down on her, but he allows her to continue gleaning the leftovers because she's so pretty. He lusts after her.
Barric's rude and says cruel things to Rena. He humiliates her. He allows other people to be rude towards her when he rightfully ought to tell them to stop. He puts her in compromising positions, ruins her reputation, and even tries to kiss her when he has her in private (and with no intention of marrying her). Yet he's angry when she states that she will not be his mistress even though that is what everyone assumes is his intent. He feels so honorable because he doesn't force Rena, but the parson points out that he's still responsible for ruining her reputation. He tries to shame and verbally abuse her into saying she loves him (or at least into his bed). He's a jerk, so I don't understand why Rena is at all attracted to him. (I can see being grateful that he helps provide for her and Nell, but he's not a nice person and never apologizes for his behavior.) Their relationship has little to redeem it, and she's treated much better by the steward, the parson, and even his brother.
The second will is completely unbelievable for that time period. Plus it makes absolutely no sense that Nell's husband never told them about the changes he made and that the pertinent people didn't know about this will when he died.
The story did highlight how a hated foreigner would be very vulnerable and treated badly. But Rena was treated so badly and was so despised (except for a few people showing Christian compassion) that it's unreasonable to assume that she'll ever be accepted or feel welcome. There were no sex scenes, though there were two bedroom scenes (one of which described physical contact right before sex). There were a few uses of bad language.
I received an ARC review copy of this book from the publisher through Amazon Vine.
May 2, 2019
What a fantastic idea for a book! The story of Ruth and Boaz has to be one of the most beautiful and well-loved stories in the Bible, and I love the idea of retelling that story in a different time and place. This particular time and setting worked really well because Rena’s situation brought out similar racial, cultural, and religious issues to those Ruth would have struggled with as a Moabitess trying to assimilate into Jewish culture. It was interesting, too, to learn a little bit about Indian culture, particularly the stigma surrounding widows.
That said, there was one scene that I felt didn’t translate well from Ruth and Boaz’s story. Whereas this scene had cultural significance in the original story, it didn’t do credit to either character in this setting, and I think the story would have been better served by retaining the spirit rather than the specifics of the original.
I also found myself getting a little angry with the hero at times. To put it bluntly, he could be a jerk. He was something of a Darcy figure in that his attraction butted against his better judgment, though Barric was even less the gentleman than Darcy on occasion. Yet there were enough glimpses of the decent, steadfast soul behind that exterior that I couldn’t totally dislike him. On the whole, I would have to say I was intrigued by the contradictions in Barric’s character more than I was irritated by them, but if you’re expecting Lord Barric’s character to be modelled after Boaz, you may be disappointed.
Despite these observations, I thought this story was well written, and I found myself thoroughly invested, reluctant to put it down once I’d been drawn in. There is a lovely cadence to Naomi Stephens’ writing, and I hope I’ll be able to read more from her in the future.
I received a copy of this novel from the publisher. This has not influenced the content of my review, which is my honest and unbiased opinion.
That said, there was one scene that I felt didn’t translate well from Ruth and Boaz’s story. Whereas this scene had cultural significance in the original story, it didn’t do credit to either character in this setting, and I think the story would have been better served by retaining the spirit rather than the specifics of the original.
I also found myself getting a little angry with the hero at times. To put it bluntly, he could be a jerk. He was something of a Darcy figure in that his attraction butted against his better judgment, though Barric was even less the gentleman than Darcy on occasion. Yet there were enough glimpses of the decent, steadfast soul behind that exterior that I couldn’t totally dislike him. On the whole, I would have to say I was intrigued by the contradictions in Barric’s character more than I was irritated by them, but if you’re expecting Lord Barric’s character to be modelled after Boaz, you may be disappointed.
Despite these observations, I thought this story was well written, and I found myself thoroughly invested, reluctant to put it down once I’d been drawn in. There is a lovely cadence to Naomi Stephens’ writing, and I hope I’ll be able to read more from her in the future.
I received a copy of this novel from the publisher. This has not influenced the content of my review, which is my honest and unbiased opinion.
April 1, 2019
The prologue sucked me in and I knew this would be a tale I’d read until the very end. Which I did. No worrying of not finishing here. I loved Rena as a heroine, a woman, and just an interesting character to follow. She’s amazing and I was pulling for her through the entire story.
And that leads me to Lord Barric, because what’s a Ruth retelling without a Boaz? Barric is very stern but he has his moments of kindness that peek out every now and then. And although I wasn’t in love with him, I didn’t dislike him either. But about 80% in there’s a scene that turned my opinion. In the end, I can say that I don’t think he deserved Rena. I feel like she deserved someone wholly gallant and worthy of her and all that she sacrificed. Because Barric wasn’t that for me, I would lower the rating, but that’s the only reason why.
Because this story is rich in history. Filled with beautiful wealth of emotion. I was invested in the story and that’s saying a lot because not every historical story moves me. I will be reading more of Ms. Stephens in the future.
*I received a complimentary copy through NetGalley. My review was not required nor influenced.
And that leads me to Lord Barric, because what’s a Ruth retelling without a Boaz? Barric is very stern but he has his moments of kindness that peek out every now and then. And although I wasn’t in love with him, I didn’t dislike him either. But about 80% in there’s a scene that turned my opinion. In the end, I can say that I don’t think he deserved Rena. I feel like she deserved someone wholly gallant and worthy of her and all that she sacrificed. Because Barric wasn’t that for me, I would lower the rating, but that’s the only reason why.
Because this story is rich in history. Filled with beautiful wealth of emotion. I was invested in the story and that’s saying a lot because not every historical story moves me. I will be reading more of Ms. Stephens in the future.
*I received a complimentary copy through NetGalley. My review was not required nor influenced.
June 4, 2019
Shadow Among Sheaves was amazing, which is why I gave it five stars! Rena was so beautifully written on paper, it was impossible not connect with her, even though I'm not from India or a widow living in Victorian England. Her slow processing to truly leaving India(and her family) and allowing her heart to grieve the loss of her husband, and doing everything she can to make sure that Nell would be taken care of no matter what her circumstances.
I loved the slow-burning romance simmering and swirling between Lord Barric and Rena, the emotions that battled in them just below the surface made this story so satisfying.
I loved the slow-burning romance simmering and swirling between Lord Barric and Rena, the emotions that battled in them just below the surface made this story so satisfying.
May 5, 2019
What Do I Think of This Biblical Retelling?
Will you forgive me if I say I don’t know? I really don’t. So, I think I’m going to just give you the good, the bad, and the verdict. Maybe that’ll help me sort out my thoughts.
The good:
Brilliant writing. Seriously, this woman can spin a lovely tale that holds your attention and keeps you wanting more.
Ms. Stephens knows how to write a consistent character who holds your interest. Even Lord Barric, who is rather erratic, is consistent in being so.
The story is interesting, compelling, holds your attention for the most part, and does it all without being pretentious. One of the best things that Naomi Stephens did was to stick to the spirit of Ruth and Boaz rather than attempt recreating the exact story in two cultures so very different from the original cultures.
The bad:
This is more of a warning for others than my problem. I read a paperback that I requested for review purposes was not marked ARC, which might be why I didn’t have some of the problems others did. I also could have gotten interrupted at just the right moment so I missed it. But supposedly there is an idiom of the time that uses the word “bastard.” This is not used in a swearing way—but rather in a common speech way. It would have been said, at the time, in mixed company.
I caught sight of a use of hell, and while I don’t remember the exact place, I do remember thinking, “Well, she didn’t use it for swearing.” Still, some people are complaining that the book has unnecessary language in it. So, I either missed it because of having to start and stop so much, OR… they had ARCS (which I suspect) and it was all removed later.
Lord Barric/Boaz. I didn’t like him. The whole time I felt like a likable, relatable Barric was right on the edge… just hovering there. But he didn’t arrive. I suspect this is due to the character wrestling against caring for someone who will bring censure on his title. The guy is an Earl. This is a real concern for him. However, this deviated so far from the part of the real story that I was disappointed. See, Boaz is my favorite character in God’s version of this story. He wasn’t in Ms. Stephens’s.
The vitriol.
Look, I know she needed to show us just how badly Rena would be treated in Victorian society, but Ms. Stephens did treat us to a lot of reminders of the uncouth things men would say to and about her. Instead of making me sympathetic to her, it just got wearisome.
The proposition: Where Rena has to offer herself to Barric’s family (not a spoiler. We know it has to happen some way) is where the entire story broke down for me. I’ve seen reviews talk about it—how “racy” it and the post-marriage scenes were. While they are more sensual than some books, I wasn’t actually uncomfortable, and we all know what a prude I am.
What I was uncomfortable with was the method. It absolutely does not work for the height of the Victorian Era (right as Prince Albert dies.). What the Naomi character recommends Rena do just would not have happened. Period.
This actually ruined the book for me.
I promptly deducted a star for it because in a book that was so good to stick to the theme and tone of Ruth/Boaz without being too “on the nose,” that’s exactly what Ms. Stephens did there. The scene on the threshing floor in the Bible isn’t a sexual one, but it did have the potential to ruin Ruth’s reputation if she was observed. Perhaps that’s why the author used it so literally, but it rang untrue to me in reading Rena in Barric’s bedroom at night when there were many alternate options that would have worked in English society.
That’s what God did in His version of the story—He used the customs of the society in which Ruth and Naomi lived to play out His plan for their lives.
The verdict:
While Shadow Among Sheaves didn’t live up to its potential or my hopes, it was a good book, well written, and engaging. The spiritual content wasn’t there on Boaz’s side, which bothered me, but Rena’s saving faith felt natural and understandable as a result both of Nell (Naomi)’s example and the parson’s involvement in their lives.
All in all, I wanted to love it, but I didn’t. I liked it, but it was just a bit above “okay.”
Still, I’ll be watching Naomi Stephens’s books in the future. I do really enjoy her writing.
Will you forgive me if I say I don’t know? I really don’t. So, I think I’m going to just give you the good, the bad, and the verdict. Maybe that’ll help me sort out my thoughts.
The good:
Brilliant writing. Seriously, this woman can spin a lovely tale that holds your attention and keeps you wanting more.
Ms. Stephens knows how to write a consistent character who holds your interest. Even Lord Barric, who is rather erratic, is consistent in being so.
The story is interesting, compelling, holds your attention for the most part, and does it all without being pretentious. One of the best things that Naomi Stephens did was to stick to the spirit of Ruth and Boaz rather than attempt recreating the exact story in two cultures so very different from the original cultures.
The bad:
This is more of a warning for others than my problem. I read a paperback that I requested for review purposes was not marked ARC, which might be why I didn’t have some of the problems others did. I also could have gotten interrupted at just the right moment so I missed it. But supposedly there is an idiom of the time that uses the word “bastard.” This is not used in a swearing way—but rather in a common speech way. It would have been said, at the time, in mixed company.
I caught sight of a use of hell, and while I don’t remember the exact place, I do remember thinking, “Well, she didn’t use it for swearing.” Still, some people are complaining that the book has unnecessary language in it. So, I either missed it because of having to start and stop so much, OR… they had ARCS (which I suspect) and it was all removed later.
Lord Barric/Boaz. I didn’t like him. The whole time I felt like a likable, relatable Barric was right on the edge… just hovering there. But he didn’t arrive. I suspect this is due to the character wrestling against caring for someone who will bring censure on his title. The guy is an Earl. This is a real concern for him. However, this deviated so far from the part of the real story that I was disappointed. See, Boaz is my favorite character in God’s version of this story. He wasn’t in Ms. Stephens’s.
The vitriol.
Look, I know she needed to show us just how badly Rena would be treated in Victorian society, but Ms. Stephens did treat us to a lot of reminders of the uncouth things men would say to and about her. Instead of making me sympathetic to her, it just got wearisome.
The proposition: Where Rena has to offer herself to Barric’s family (not a spoiler. We know it has to happen some way) is where the entire story broke down for me. I’ve seen reviews talk about it—how “racy” it and the post-marriage scenes were. While they are more sensual than some books, I wasn’t actually uncomfortable, and we all know what a prude I am.
What I was uncomfortable with was the method. It absolutely does not work for the height of the Victorian Era (right as Prince Albert dies.). What the Naomi character recommends Rena do just would not have happened. Period.
This actually ruined the book for me.
I promptly deducted a star for it because in a book that was so good to stick to the theme and tone of Ruth/Boaz without being too “on the nose,” that’s exactly what Ms. Stephens did there. The scene on the threshing floor in the Bible isn’t a sexual one, but it did have the potential to ruin Ruth’s reputation if she was observed. Perhaps that’s why the author used it so literally, but it rang untrue to me in reading Rena in Barric’s bedroom at night when there were many alternate options that would have worked in English society.
That’s what God did in His version of the story—He used the customs of the society in which Ruth and Naomi lived to play out His plan for their lives.
The verdict:
While Shadow Among Sheaves didn’t live up to its potential or my hopes, it was a good book, well written, and engaging. The spiritual content wasn’t there on Boaz’s side, which bothered me, but Rena’s saving faith felt natural and understandable as a result both of Nell (Naomi)’s example and the parson’s involvement in their lives.
All in all, I wanted to love it, but I didn’t. I liked it, but it was just a bit above “okay.”
Still, I’ll be watching Naomi Stephens’s books in the future. I do really enjoy her writing.
May 14, 2019
India born widow, Rena Hawley returns with her also widowed mother-in-law to the homeland of her late husband. In England she is met with disdain, and shamed for her exotic heritage. Rena works hard to help provide for herself and Nella, but the only productive work she can find is to glean in Lord Barric's field picking up what is left behind by the harvesters.
Lord Jack Barric is intrigued by the beautiful woman who has come to glean in his fields, he allows her to stay and even arranges a place for her and her mother-in-law to live. But as the townspeople begin to chatter and spread malicious gossip about him and his relationship to Rena, things become strained and choices must be made.
A Victorian re-telling of Ruth, Shadow Among Sheaves is a fresh new take on the story we all know so well. It made me admire Rena's bravery to travel to an unknown land and people, leaving everything familiar behind.
Barric is honorable to a fault, constantly thinking about his reputation while also juggling his duty to do what is right. I liked how the characters were all flawed and imperfect, yet were not without redeeming qualities, which brought a realness to them that was refreshing.
In some ways it was a slower read, and maybe it just felt that way because I did have a pretty good inkling on how it would likely end up. I also thought that there was a lot of justifying and overthinking going on inside the heads of Barric and Rena which had me skimming here and there. But I did really like how the author transposed the story into the late 1850's of Great Britain, with the culture clash of Rena's Indian upbringing, I could tell that the author had done her research with this genius re-telling.
Overall, a promising read, good tension and that paints a picture of the societal challenges that a woman such as Rena would have faced in Britain in the mid-1800's. Strong themes of faith, family, and trust, the whole time I was reading this book I kept thinking what a great movie it would make. A wonderful new way of looking at Ruth and Boaz, set during Queen Victoria's reign.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Lord Jack Barric is intrigued by the beautiful woman who has come to glean in his fields, he allows her to stay and even arranges a place for her and her mother-in-law to live. But as the townspeople begin to chatter and spread malicious gossip about him and his relationship to Rena, things become strained and choices must be made.
A Victorian re-telling of Ruth, Shadow Among Sheaves is a fresh new take on the story we all know so well. It made me admire Rena's bravery to travel to an unknown land and people, leaving everything familiar behind.
Barric is honorable to a fault, constantly thinking about his reputation while also juggling his duty to do what is right. I liked how the characters were all flawed and imperfect, yet were not without redeeming qualities, which brought a realness to them that was refreshing.
In some ways it was a slower read, and maybe it just felt that way because I did have a pretty good inkling on how it would likely end up. I also thought that there was a lot of justifying and overthinking going on inside the heads of Barric and Rena which had me skimming here and there. But I did really like how the author transposed the story into the late 1850's of Great Britain, with the culture clash of Rena's Indian upbringing, I could tell that the author had done her research with this genius re-telling.
Overall, a promising read, good tension and that paints a picture of the societal challenges that a woman such as Rena would have faced in Britain in the mid-1800's. Strong themes of faith, family, and trust, the whole time I was reading this book I kept thinking what a great movie it would make. A wonderful new way of looking at Ruth and Boaz, set during Queen Victoria's reign.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 271 reviews