"A story of old secrets and new beginnings, Shadow Sister explores the complexities of family, the bonds of sisterhood, and the crippling power of guilt. In Sarah, Katherine Scott Jones has created a woman struggling with her own demons but ultimately finding faith and discovering the beauty of forgiveness." --Lisa Wingate, bestselling author of Before We Were Yours
Working on her father's vineyard allows Sarah Lanning to bury memories of a lost love and a career that might have been. But then her fractured family receives word that her estranged sister, Jenna, is dead, leaving behind the unexpected request for Sarah to travel to Bolivia to scatter her ashes.
Accompanied by pilot Chase Maddox, Sarah embarks on an Andean journey that tests her devotion to home and exposes Jenna's secret life. Each staggering discovery creates new mysteries--until the last, which leaves Sarah questioning everything she understood about family loyalty. At a crossroads, she must decide whether truth is worth the cost of forgiveness--and whether she can lay claim to a future of happiness without it.
Bittersweet and bold, Shadow Sister explores the mysteries of the human heart and the bond of unquenchable love.
Katherine Scott Jones grew up in cities on every U.S. coast and overseas as her family moved with her father’s Navy career. Seattle became home when she married her husband twenty-eight years ago. After graduating from Whitworth University with a degree in communications, she established herself as a freelance writer before turning her hand to fiction. She blogs about books that celebrate beauty at www.katherinescottjones.com. Katherine and her husband have two teenage children. She is the author of SHADOW SISTER and HER MEMORY OF MUSIC.
Something niggled at the back of my mind after reading this book. The story, despite my struggles with the present tense author voice, did prove to stay interesting enough to keep my attention. The clues to Jenna's secret did feel a bit put off and contrived, but only a very little. I rather liked Sarah, and the variety of nationalities and personalities among the characters themselves showed through quite well most of the time. While the descriptions felt a little too descriptive for my taste, I consider that preference, and I really was able to picture the vineyards, the slopes, and the Bolivian village with great clarity, thanks to the colorful manner used by the author.
After consideration though, I finally hit upon what bothered me the most about Shadow Sister. For claiming to have a Christian undercurrent - for the majority of the main characters having claimed Christ and mentioning Jesus on multiple occasions, - this book did not have an undercurrent of Christian worldview. One of the characters is touted as almost a saint by the words of several characters, but almost none of her actions are ones that stem directly from a Biblical framework. The book claimed to be centered in an area where women are regarded as property and are presumably ill-used by their husbands, but with one single exception, the "mistreatment" is never shown. Instead, the life of a wife and mother is downplayed, and the need for an education, the ability to hold down a job, and be able to "stand up to" one's husband are the main things that are pushed for this Bolivian community. While, I won't ever say one shouldn't be able to read - it's a grand thing and reading the Bible should be one of the chief pleasures for an able Christian - none of these things are pushed in the Bible. It's not a requisite, while honoring one's husband is, and the tone of the book pushed education above that Biblical mandate.
The ghost of Sarah's sister passing around in two houses after death also threw me off. No where, do I see a Biblical framework for such a thing, though the book tried to make it link in with the story of Lazarus.
Perhaps my greatest issue with the book though is how the author dealt with the sin of marital infidelity. The Bible places strong emphasis on the importance of staying true to your own husband or wife. Jesus, Paul, the book of Proverbs... While one person mentions in, almost in passing, that "it was wrong" there was very little weight given to the sin. Sure, consequences are shown to an extent, but not really. It was almost excused. One of the people in question, treated with a pity that he in no way deserved. If this had been a secular book, I wouldn't have been surprised and would have rated the book higher - I wouldn't have expected a stronger moral compass. However, the claims of Christianity, led me to disappointment and sorrow at the way in which adultery and even fornication were handled. Why the characters fell into this sin doesn't matter, they did it, and it should be shown as the sin that it is, if it is to be included in the story.
Also, the lying behavior of another character in another topic altogether was excused on account of fear. While I can agree that fear will lead to sin, it does not excuse it. Lying, even by omission, is bearing a false witness and is, therefore, a sin. Exodus 20:16. It should not be justified. Forgiven? Yes. Grace extended? Yes. Absolutely. I agree with the forgiveness shown, but the reasons behind a sin do not mitigate the sin. The lies allowed by this character caused deep wounds in those nearest them, which were shown very well. The writer handled betrayal and rejection well, I thought, up until the moment the reason for the sin seemed to wipe away everything else.
In conclusion, while I give it two stars for an interesting story and even a good mystery, I could not recommend Shadow Sister.
But that won’t suffice. There’s so much to this book that I have to start with what I loved.
Characters: Katherine Scott Jones managed to create some of the most realistic and beautifully flawed characters I’ve seen in a long time. Every person in the story had multiple layers. Just as you became certain you knew what this one or that said or thought, another petal peeled away to reveal a sweeter, fresher fragrance to that person—one you didn’t know could exist.
She showed the strengths and the weaknesses of both protagonists and antagonists, and she never once fell into the trap of creating villains where they weren’t necessary just because that person was an antagonist. Neither did she justify people’s wrongs into poor, misunderstood fellows.
I loved that.
Settings: I don’t know if Ms. Jones has ever been to Bolivia or even to Washington state. I have no clue. What I do know is that she made me believe she had—that they were places deeply etched into her soul. This she did with careful, and where appropriate, lavish, description but never once with excess.
Story: We all know that for me it’s all about story. This one is a doozy. It jumps time, past and present, it shifts points of view, and it does it all without leaving the reader confused. Rather, she takes her time to anchor you into every moment before allowing it all to unfold, and she does this without dragging or weighing down the story.
You can understand why I said that I loved it, right? Who wouldn’t?
But I did say “yes” to whether I loved or hated it. There’s a reason for that. You see, despite the rich description, heart-rending story, and wonderful characterization, a shadow falls across the page that made every chapter work for me to read through.
Normally, I’d blame myself for that. You see, that shadow is that the entire book is written in present tense—both first and third person. I frankly despise present tense writing. If I'd noticed that when I saw it up for review, I might not have requested and received a review copy.
See, recently, I was introduced to a book where it was done so skillfully that I didn’t even realize it was until three-quarters through the book. And that taught me something. Present tense can be done amazingly well. That one element of this book just wasn’t—not for me.
I thought I’d knock two stars off for it (only because Goodreads defines three stars as "I liked it").
Because it was hard work to slog through the writing style. But as I sit here thinking about the story, about the characters, about everything that I loved in this book, I realize that I do love it despite its glaring flaw. Like one of the characters in this book, it has what I consider to be a “birth defect.” A gaping slash that mars its initial beauty.
But the true beauty of the story comes from a deeper place than the method of telling it. And because of that, I’m giving it five stars on Amazon and four here after all.
Recommended for people who love novels of family, broken and restored relationships, and mild romance. For those like me who find present tense difficult to read, I’d recommend doing the “see inside” portion before purchasing.
“Blood is blood.” This favorite saying of Sarah and Jenna’s father is both a promise and a curse in Katherine Scott Jones’s novel, Shadow Sister.
Family means everything to the Lanning family, until two tragic accidents begin to tear the remains of the family apart. When a third tragedy occurs, Sarah is left reeling and wondering what had ever come between her and Jenna.
Divided between the two sisters, the narrative starts at different points in the family’s history, one in the present tense and one in the past. At first, I wasn’t sure there was enough action to hold my attention. Shadow Sisters is an exploration of relationships and emotions, and what a deep and lovely book it turned out to be.
The characters are very fluid and realistic. It is this dichotomy of the human nature that allows for the puzzle in the relationships. Even those who know Jesus personally in the story struggle with handing over their foibles. Isn’t that so true of real life!
Quotables: “Remember, Sarah, shadow is as important as light. We need them both or we’re left with something flat and two-dimensional. Dull. But when we bring them together, shadow and light add depth. Interest. Life!”
“When the things that hurt God’s heart hurt ours too, that keeps us close to Him. And that’s always a good thing.”
I received a complimentary copy of this book through the author and Celebrate Lit. This is no way affects my opinions, for which I am solely responsible. I was not required to leave a positive review.
This novel takes the reader from Bolivia to a vineyard in Washington to tell the intertwined stories of two sisters. As usual, Jones pulls us in and makes us care about the characters and their family relationships, while opening our eyes to different cultures and unusual occupations. I've already loaned out my copy and I'm sure I'll be sharing it with others looking for a deeper women's fiction read.
This beautifully written story deals gracefully with some of the hardest emotions--grief, betrayal, abandonment--yet does so with a tenderness and precision that drew me straight through to the end. Thoroughly enjoyed.
This was a bittersweet, but thoroughly engrossing story—my first by Katherine Scott Jones, but not my last. It’s a story of sisters and families, of dreams and regrets, of love and loss, and of shadow and light, and I loved the way these contrasts were constantly in tension throughout the story.
The opening chapter packed an emotional punch that pulled me firmly into the story, and the second chapter only cinched its grip. That there were misunderstandings between these formerly close sisters was obvious, and it was the work of this story to unravel those misunderstandings, both for Sarah and the reader. It painted a very clear picture of the way in which our insecurities can colour our relationships and erect barriers between us and those we love most, and it played with the metaphor of shadow and light and the way these elements can influence our perspective, hiding or illuminating the truth.
Sarah’s chapters were narrated in the third person present tense, which is my least favourite point of view, but it couldn’t prevent me from becoming immersed in Sarah’s journey as she travels to Bolivia and meets the people her sister lived and worked with. Her discoveries there don’t just lead her to contemplate her relationship with her sister; they cause her to re-evaluate the course her life has taken since a skiing accident several years ago. And there’s a nice little bit of romantic tension added into the mix, too.
Interspersed with Sarah’s story were chapters that jump back a little in time and share Jenna’s side of the story through some of the key moments that influenced her relationship with her sister and the direction her life eventually took. And yet, even when everything was finally brought (very satisfactorily) into the light, there was still the bittersweet shadow of knowing that Jenna had not lived to experience the restoration of her relationship with Sarah. But as their mother once said to Sarah as they painted in her studio: “Remember, Sarah, shadow is as important as light. We need them both or we’re left with something flat and two-dimensional. Dull. But when we bring them together, shadow and light add depth. Interest. Life!”
A very satisfying read!
I received a copy of this novel from the publisher. This has not influenced the content of my review, which is my honest and unbiased opinion.
As much as this was a story about the unraveling of Jenna's secret life, I think it was also a story about Sarah finding her way in the world. The story isn't titled Shadow Sister for nothing - she truly was like a shadow to her sister, never feeling like she measured up and was second best. While I do not have an older sibling and did not think I'd be able to relate to Sarah, the author wrote her part in a way that I could easily empathize with her as well as connect with Sarah on her journey. And while you think that you immediately will have a problem with Jenna (aka you don't like her!), as you learn more about her past, you empathize with her as well. It's almost like you're not sure who's side to be on, and in the end the only side you can be on is neither.
This story shows the impact that secrets can have over a lifetime, none of them are good. But it also shows the impact of forgiveness, letting go, and looking to the Lord for strength during difficult times. Sarah had been through so much in her lifetime, and learns more than one secret in this book that rocks her world. I couldn't imagine being in her position. I am pretty sure I would just want to run away! But that gentle reminder that the Lord is where we get our strength and help from is there throughout the whole story, and this is the time that Sarah's character really spoke to me. I enjoyed seeing her growth throughout the course of the story.
This is not the last time I'll be reading a book by Katherine Scott Jones. I enjoyed her writing style, her characters, and the interesting facts she placed here and there throughout the story. I look forward to reading more of her books in the future! I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Shadow Sister was a story of layers and uncovering them of a relationship between two sisters who have grown apart. This was a bittersweet tale of discovering a person and the secrets they kept after they passed away. I think it also really shows how important it is to keep communication lines open between family and friends no matter the hurt or cost. However, people are a stubborn lot and sometimes we must journey to find these answers on our own.
Taking place in the beautiful wine country of Washington State and traveling to Bolivia, we step into Sarah’s shoes as she must do the last wishes of her estranged sister Jenna. I really liked how the author wrote Jenna’s voice, that even though she is gone, we still get her viewpoint- especially in the snippets of her past.
This was a beautifully told story, with a subtle love story, family secrets, and the message that the truth can only set you free. I look forward to more work from author Jones, a new to me author.
I received a complimentary copy of this novel. I was not required to post a positive review and all views and opinions are my own.
This novel took a while to grab me but when it did, I could not put it down. There were early allusions to troubles and I grew a bit impatient. All was revealed little by little as the narrative alternated between the present and the past. While the technique can be troublesome, it worked well in this novel. We discover secrets as Sarah does and that made me sympathetic to her character.
There are many family relationship issues in the novel and that kept my interest. Like any family, I suppose, there are secrets and when they are uncovered they can be life changing. Another issue Jones included deals with the work of NGOs in less developed areas. Sometimes the humanitarian improvements made can change a culture that has been unchanged for centuries, causing unrest or other trouble. That idea was thought provoking.
My favorite line from the novel: “[Jenna] liked to say stories had a way of bypassing the intellect and creeping through the back door to the soul.” (Loc 2964/5308) Ah, maybe that's why we read fiction.
I recommend this novel to readers who enjoy a well crafted story dealing with family relationships.
I received a complimentary digital copy of this book through Celebrate Lit. My comments are an independent and honest review.
This is one of those books that I'd really like to be able to tack on a half star. It's not quite a four star, but three isn't quite enough. In the spirit of generosity, I'll go for the four star review.
When Sarah receives word that her long-absent sister has died in South America, she embarks upon a journey which begins to reveal the extent to which the sisters were estranged. Jenna's sudden death reveals additional rifts in their fractured family and shakes Sarah's perceptions and presuppositions. As Sarah seeks to make sense of the events which drove a wedge between them years earlier, she encounters her sister's friends, co-workers, and neighbors whose accounts of Jenna leave her more confused than comforted. What drove Jenna away so many years ago? Why was Jenna planning to come home before her death? Why did she so completely exclude Sarah from the new life she had been building in Bolivia? And do the shadows of the past mean danger for Sarah today?
Shadow Sister takes readers on a journey from Washington state's wine country to the jagged mountain roads and remote villages of Bolivia. It explores fractured family dynamics and how brokenness often drives us away from those whom we love.
Shadow Sister is told from both Sarah and Jenna's perspective, and the narrative bounces between these two perspectives and both past and present time frames. The author chose to use a present tense narrative, which I found highly distracting at the beginning of the novel. For the first several chapters, I felt disoriented and couldn't get into the story. The bouncing between time frames, perspectives, and locations while consistently using present tense was problematic. Once I settled into the story, however, I appreciated the author's development of the characters and setting.
Ms. Scott Jones develops a complex web of family dynamics, many of which are shrouded in shadow. Her characters are flawed - possibly to a greater extent than some readers would prefer for Christian fiction. Their choices and the consequences of those choices are well within the range of plausibility, though, and the author's exploration of the fissures which those choices would cause within a family had a ring of authenticity. The author's narrative style (again, the bouncing between perspectives and time frames) led to some frustration, though, since it was evident from the beginning that certain elements of the story were intentionally obscured. The allusion to these obscured elements was too overt, and became frustrating.
While I enjoyed Shadow Sister, I didn't love it. I appreciated the author's development of flawed characters whose brokenness led them toward the healing only possible through Jesus' example of love and forgiveness. I appreciated the author's portrayal of characters - including the missionaries! - as human beings rather than idealized saints. I appreciated her exploration of difficult dynamics within families and the impact of traumatic events upon relationships. The story ticked a lot of boxes in women's fiction from a head-on perspective (difficult family dynamics and a bit of mystery with a side of romance, international travel, and a vineyard), but the delivery fell a bit flat for me because of the stilted narrative. I would recommend this book with reservation. Reader beware - the narrative style may distract you, and the characters aren't sinless saints. The entire premise of the story is based on sorrow and fractured family dynamics. That said, Shadow Sister was a well-developed redemptive tale and I liked it.
I received an Advance Reader Copy of this book from the author through Celebrate Lit. All opinions contained in this review are my own.
There are so many reasons why I love this book. It is a beautifully written story that left me in suspense until the very end. Yes, it is filled with clues but there are also secrets and we readers are reminded that the secrets that we think will prevent hurt can actually cause the most pain. I assumed that the title was a reference to the relationship between Sarah and her older sister Jenna but now, as I write this, I believe that it was a feeling shared by both. Perhaps Jenna felt as much in Sarah's shadow as Sarah felt in hers.
Shadow Sister is the story of two sisters, Jenna and Sarah Lanning, and she includes both the present and the past to explain their deep but perhaps tenuous bond. Jenna was an artist of words who wanted to be a writer and she was very attached to her father; Sarah felt closer to her artist mother and she herself possessed the ability to create with paints and easel. And then, a tragic accident altered all of their lives and Jenna and Sarah both set their talents and their dreams aside. Jenna left their family vineyard to work in Bolivia and Sarah was left with a sense of both estrangement and abandonment. Suddenly, Sarah and her father receive word that Jenna has died in a bus crash and that Jenna's husband is seriously hurt. As she travels to Bolivia to tend to funeral details Sarah becomes involved with the people that Jenna was trying to help. She also meets a man who may alter her future as she discovers two secrets that completely undermine all that she has ever believed.
Katherine Scott Jones has an amazing way with words! Both Jenna and Sarah have lost their first loves but both are given a second chance at great love. In one scene Jenna's husband Jonas tells Sarah "And I'm scared that I might forget her altogether. We weren't together very long. A little over a year. What if I forget what she was like? Who she was! My wife!" (p. 140-141) How many of us have felt those very same thoughts when we've lost someone?
There is also a strong element of faith throughout the story. As Sarah returns to the crash sight where her sister died, she feels as if someone is right behind her. "There is no one. And yet... The hairs on her arms stand up, a breeze licks her forehead. Jesus. His nearness brings a settling to her spirit, an easing of tension, as if a coiled spring has sprung. And then, out of nowhere, a tiny lift of joy." (p. 145) Oh, the peace and joy that comes from knowing Jesus!
Shadow Sister has 365 pages filled with intrigue, sadness, and grief but there is also hope and the promise of forgiveness. Most of, there is also the reminder that family is important and that God's Grace means everything!
I received a complimentary copy of this book and was under no obligation to post a favorable review. These are my honest opinions.
WOW! I will be honest when I say there were a few moments in the beginning where I wasn’t sure how I was going to feel about this one, but the deeper I got into it the more I felt emotionally entangled in Sarah’s journey for answers to her sister’s life and death far from home in Bolivia. Their relationship had been strained to say the least when Jenna hopped on a plane to Bolivia, but the more I discovered about their story, the more I felt like an actual part of it. I won’t give a recap of the relationship because I will allow you to read it for yourself, but allow me to sum it up in one simple word: complicated. Which is life isn’t it? I think the more I learned of the girl’s fractured relationship, the more I felt a part of it. Have you ever sat down with a friend or relative (maybe even a sister), who shares with you their deepest longings for a restored relationship with another? Or have you been the person yourself with that longing? The conversation skips right over the surface and goes right to the heart. That level of desperation is the driving force of this story, and it will captivate you until the very end. Here is my full warning that you may want to have some tissues nearby the further you read in. A story fueled by emotions like this is sure to ignite your eyes’ water production. So the one part of the story that had me wondering how I was going to feel about this book was actually about right after Jenna’s death. (Don’t worry, not spoiling anything here). I know that when a family member dies, it’s common for people to talk about (and be comforted by) hearing that their loved ones are “looking down on them,” or “still beside them even if they can’t see them.” I don’t think that’s all bad, but I think when it gets to the point of talking about a “spirit lingering” or “stopping to say goodbye,” it creeps me out, and feels more like making the person a “temporary ghost.” The book tries to make the statement that it’s her “spirit” and not like a ghost, but I still felt uneasy about it. Honestly, it was such a small part in the book that it’s not that big of a deal, but I think because it was so close to the beginning it had me worried about her presence remaining like a ghost through the whole story. Thankfully that wasn’t the case. One of the things I loved about this story, was actually Sarah being able to catch glimpses of what Jenna had seen in Bolivia that made her fall in love with it. It wasn’t only about running away from home, but also coming alongside a people that could benefit from caring and supportive hands. Things that we take for granted like clean drinking water, was life-altering for the people-especially the women and young girls. By having easier access to fresh water, they didn’t have to spend their days travelling to bring fresh water home anymore. This opened opportunities for them to spend their time getting educated and trying to better themselves. Life wasn’t easy for them, and Jenna and those she worked with her working alongside them to help make their lives easier and more fulfilling. She also taught them about the love of Jesus. In Bolivia, women are often thought of as merely the property of their husbands. They aren’t taught to expect much out of life. Jenna and her peers were seeking to help them and change their futures for the better. I felt as if I was getting to know them right alongside Sarah. It made my heart want to help them as well. One quote (not found in the story), that I had going through my mind is the one that says to “always be kind, because people are facing battles you know nothing about.” Jenna and Sarah both had their own battles that they were dealing with, but instead of going to each other and sharing in them, they grew farther and farther apart. I think it’s something that happens so often in life that we don’t even realize it when it happens. Have you ever had an argument with a best friend, and 10 years later you wonder what you were even fighting about? Or have you ever needed someone, but you pushed them away instead because you couldn’t handle the emotions it would bring up to talk about it? Have you ever walked into a room and felt you didn’t belong, so you don’t even bother sticking around? Have you ever felt like the “odd man out” and it makes you question your own identity? Have you ever told a lie that you’re afraid to reveal the truth? I ask all these questions not saying they are all in the book, but rather stating the fact that we all have battles we deal with, and we can allow those battles to divide us, or help us to grow closer. If we wait too long, we may not have the chance anymore. Something of small mention, is that there is a bit of Spanish sprinkled into some of the conversations, or a bit of “Spanglish” if you know what I mean. In most cases you see the translation right after, but I noticed it wasn’t always present or made obvious. I know enough that I knew what they were saying anyways, but I caught myself wondering in a few spots if someone who didn’t know would be able to figure it out as well. I don’t consider it a huge deal, but thought it might be worth the mention. This was definitely one of those stories that made me feel something. It was an emotional journey, but one I’m glad I went on. This is certainly a story that I know is going to stay with me for a very long time. I highly, highly recommend it! *I was given a complimentary copy of this book from the author through CelebrateLit Tours. I was not required to share a positive review. Thoughts and opinions expressed are mine alone.
Jenna was part of a Christian organization that was involved in helping the people in third-world countries access clean, pure water. As strange as this may sound, they had to overcome centuries of superstition and tradition to help the people change their way of life and be willing to have wells installed. In my naivety, I have always assumed that when offered better access to clean water, people jumped at the opportunity!
Secret Sister showed many aspects of life in Bolivia. It is a harsh, yet beautiful place to be. Just reading about the bugs and creatures that came through the walls into the houses creeped me out! Eww!
I loved the way that Jenna and her sister Sarah saw Jesus and His love for women. I had never noticed what the author pointed out, that in His interactions, Jesus never rebuked or reprimanded women the way he did the men. As I read through the Gospels, I will be watching for this, though my memory is already confirming this fact.
Jenna realized that the secrets she had been keeping were holding her captive and after all these years was finally ready to return home and confess. Sadly, she was too late! Dear friends, don’t hold on to secrets. Jesus told us that the truth would set us free. The description of the book fascinated me and had me wanting to read it. I wasn’t sure what to expect. . .
The ending of the prologue had me a little concerned that the “shadow sister” was going to end up being a spirit speaking to her sister but I was quickly reassured that was not the case. Whew! That wasn’t what I had signed up for!
There were a few things that I did not like in the story. It was told in a third-person, present tense style, except for the flashbacks. I am not a fan of present-tense writing and have not read many stories where it “worked”. The only ones I can think of that didn’t feel awkward were told in the first person.
There is a place near the beginning where the author speaks of abominable treatment of young girls and goes into far more detail than I think was necessary. I was completely unprepared to encounter this in the book and felt blindsided and my stomach was turned. I do think I understand why this was there – to set the stage and soften my heart for the plight of women and girls in other countries. I believe it could have been presented in a way that wasn’t as detailed and yet still impactful. Because of this inclusion, I would hesitate recommending this for anyone other than adults.
Read the full review of Shadow Sister by Katherine Scott Jones with a Preview at AmongTheReads.net
I was given a free copy of this item. This gift did not influence my opinion or review.
Shadow Sister is an engrossing read, a poignant story that plumbs the depth of the reader’s emotions, an absolute gem. This well-crafted story is exquisitely written, making new-to-me author Katherine Scott Jones a must read. It’s rare to find a relationship drama of this quality in the Christian fiction genre, and this is a difficult review to write because there’s no way any words of mine can do it justice.
This multi-faceted story spans from rural Bolivia to the vineyards of Washington State, from the present to past years leading up to a tragedy that challenged the close bond between two sisters. There’s a richness and complexity in the narrative that extends to father/daughter relationships, the Lanning family vineyard business, and a faith-based outreach in rural Bolivia. That the best wines are produced under stress makes a great analogy for our Christian walk …
“The right amount of drought, when the vine had to cast its roots down … down … summoning all its strength and will to survive – those vines were capable of creating a wine able to hold its own among the finest in the world.” - Sarah and Jenna’s mom
Sisters Sarah and Jenna literally touched my soul. I loved Sarah’s strength and determination in deciding to travel to Bolivia alone, and adored the pilot, Chase Maddox, as their friendship and sweet romance grew. For Sarah, the physical journey became one of self-discovery, with twists and turns revealing all was not as it seemed. Secondary characters, such as little Sofia, stole my heart.
Social issues, such as the gender inequality that reigned supreme in Bolivia, is a major theme. I enjoyed learning about Jenna’s work at the mission and was inspired by her vision for helping the women, with a goal of “bringing them out of the shadows and into the light” by educating them so they could offer their families a better life. These words of wisdom from Sarah’s mom, shared by Sarah, especially spoke to me and are so relevant: “Don’t let not being able to solve the problem keep you from being part of the solution.”
Shadow Sister is a memorable story of the highest quality, one that captured my emotions from the very first page and never let go. 5 stars, “best of the best” for me.
Very highly recommended.
I received a copy of this book through Celebrate Lit Tours. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
Shadow Sister is the first novel by author Katherine Scott Jones that I have had the pleasure of reading. It was a haunting story that has stayed with me long after finishing it. Filled with family, suspense, secrets, love, hope, grace, and redemption. It is beautifully written and unlike anything I have read. Shadow Sister is a 365 page Christian Fiction packed with intrigue, sadness, and grief, but there is the element of forgiveness and reassurance of God's love and the importance of family.
Author Jones alternates between past and present, tenses, and people in the telling of this inspiring story. It took me a few chapters to become invested, but then I was all in. The characters were described so well that they came to life on the pages. I have never been to Bolivia but feel like I have now. The author has a descriptive writing style that is engaging.
This is the tale of two close sisters, Jenna and Sarah Lanning. Misunderstandings drove them apart. The emotions transferred from the characters to me, and I was saddened. The mystery that kept me reading was what could do this to sisters. Unfortunately family disagreements and grudges go back to Bible times.
Jenna was part of a Christian organization that helps people in third-world countries get clean, water, something Americans take for granted. In Bolivia she encounters superstitions, harsh conditions, injustice, and creepy crawlers. After some tragic news Sarah goes to Bolivia.
I really liked the Christian element and inspiration in this book. If a book is classified as Christian I don’t want it lightly sprinkling it. Give me a heavy handed dose. This book did. Encouraging me to draw closer to God and help others was a result of reading this. Valuing family even more and realizing the preciousness of time spent together stuck with me.
Yes, I would definitely recommend this book. The subject matter and descriptions seem to me better suited for older teens and adults. Parts of the book were hard for me to read, realistic as they might be. I rated it 4 out of 5 stars and will definitely be reading more from this author.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book from the author through CelebrateLit Tours. I was not required to write a positive review. The review and opinions are my own honest ones.
Katherine Scott Jones uses wonderful word pictures to constantly describe the surroundings for the reader, which leaves one feeling immersed in the story. The descriptions of Sarah and Jenna’s time in Bolivia reminded me of how exhilarating, and truly life-changing, missions work is. It is something one must experience for oneself. The author does a fabulous job showing that in how Sarah relates to the people and in the transformations that take place in her over time.
I don’t read fiction strictly to be entertained but I read it to learn and grow as well. This novel was a reminder of my own grief walk. It was mind-opening to see the various reactions of the characters to Jenna’s death. It was also a great reminder that the grieving process is a necessary one in order to cultivate healthy relationships.
Which leads to another topic touched on. Family relations. In a nutshell, the verse that best describes their family issues is Ephesians 4:25-27.
“So stop telling lies. Let us tell our neighbors the truth, for we are all parts of the same body. And ‘don’t sin by letting anger control you.’ Don’t let the sun go down while you are still angry, for anger gives a foothold to the devil.”
We all have issues. Even Christian families. And this family does as well. I was thankful that through the book some of these issues were worked through but there is also the warning that we need to deal with things before it’s too late.
“Shadow Sisters” is an intriguing story filled with twists and turns. The settings, characters, and emotions feel authentic even though deceit plays a major roll in their lives. While that’s not a character trait to exemplify, I believe the author shows the ramifications of living such a life. If you enjoy descriptive fiction with a good lesson to learn, this is a book for you.
Disclaimer: I received this novel complimentary the author, and the ebook complimentary Celebrate Lit, and was under no obligation to post a positive review. The opinions expressed are my own.
I really enjoyed this book. It was interesting to read about the difference between the two sisters. At first I was a little confused and wasn't sure I was going to like it, just a few chapters because it was written like someone was just reporting what was happening and then it switched to a different style of writing but I am glad I kept reading because the twists, turns, and hinted-at secrets were worth the little confusion I had. I wanted to know why they all acted the way they did. I admit that when the secrets were revealed I wasn't surprised at some things, but one secret really did surprised me.
It's a wonderful story of hurt and loss and hope and forgiveness.
This story shows that sometimes things are really not the way they seem at all.
I wish there was going to be a another novel with these characters because I would love to read more about the women and the work that Jenna's friends continue on for her. I also think the romance that started at the end of the book would make a great story, but the ending of this book is great even if a second book isn't written.
I recommend "Shadow Sister " by Katherine Scott Jones to anyone that likes books about sisters and readers that likes to pretend that the stories that are fiction might just be true somewhere in the "real world". While reading this book I was thinking this author must have sisters to be able to write about the love and the sometimes need to outdo each other.
I am going to share a sentence from the author's guest post from the blog tour, so you can get a more complete picture of what the book is and why she wrote it, "Shadow Sister is a work of inspirational women’s fiction with a global accent—written for women with a heart for complex relational issues as well as a passion for biblical justice."
I have now added her first book to my to be read list.
I was given a complimentary copy by the author and Celebrate Lit. These opinions are my own.
Working on her father’s vineyard allows Sarah to bury memories of a lost love and a career that might have been. But then her fractured family receives word that her estranged sister, Jenna, is dead, leaving behind an unexpected request: that Sarah travels to Bolivia to scatter her ashes.
Accompanied by pilot Chase Maddox, Sarah embarks on an Andean journey that tests her devotion to home and exposes Jenna’s secret life. Each staggering discovery creates new mysteries—until the last, which leaves Sarah questioning everything she understood about family loyalty. At a crossroads, she must decide whether truth is worth the cost of forgiveness—and whether she can lay claim to a future of happiness without it.
Bittersweet and bold, Shadow Sister explores the mysteries of the human heart and the bond of unquenchable love.
My Thoughts: This was an enjoyable read, its main focus is on family loyalty with romance in the background. In this story, we find Sarah summoned to Bolivia to retrieve her sister's ashes after a horrible bus accident even though they haven't been close for years.
While Sarah is in Bolivia, she finds a side to her sister she never knew, some untold secrets and unexpected love.
This was an encouraging book to read. It was about family and how they look out for one another. It's also about learning to forgive and what can happen when we keep secrets.
The reader will learn what it is like to live as a missionary in a foreign country. How they have to overcome the traditions and superstitions of the people. Most of all trust is the key when working overseas.
I was moved how the author brought you into the ministries that the characters were working in.
This is a book that I recommend and truly enjoyed reading.
I will admit to being a book snob. In order for me to enjoy reading a story, there are certain criteria that must be present. The characters need to have depth and be real—flaws and all. The story needs to move at a good pace. I don’t want to read pages and pages of description when a few well-drawn images will do. And the dialogue needs to be natural. And if I can learn something along the way, that’s a real bonus. It doesn’t seem like this is much to ask, but I can count the number of authors who pull this off on one hand. After reading Shadow Sister by Katherine Scott Jones, that number increased by one.
From the opening prologue to the words THE END, I was hooked. Katherine’s descriptions are beautiful, bordering on poetic, with fresh metaphors and vivid word pictures. She knows how to create three-dimensional characters who leap off the page. Real characters who struggle with real emotions. And though this is Christian fiction, she weaves truth in and through these characters naturally. It doesn’t feel contrived or artificial.
Shadow Sister has two settings—Washington state and Bolivia. Within these two settings, I learned something about wine making as well as the poverty and challenges of a third-world country. I love that Katherine Scott Jones doesn’t wrap everything up at the end with a shiny red bow, but allows that there are hurts in this life from which we may never recover on this side of heaven. Believing the Gospel does not protect us from tragedies—but gives us the hope we need to look to a better eternal home.
I highly recommend Shadow Sister to anyone interested in reading good literature.
I was given a free copy of Shadow Sister in order to write this review with the understanding that I would offer my honest opinion, which is what I did.
The story line of this book immediately grabbed and made me want to read it. I love books like this one--books about family relationships, life and it's difficulties, especially if there's a bit of mystery involved.
I broke open the cover and was shocked. It's written in a present tense, and this just feels so different from what I'm used to. I don't know if I've ever read a book that's written this way, and it just threw me for a loop! I kept catching myself wanting to correct each sentence.
First you get to know Jenna, who lives in Bolivia, far away from her family.
Then, she is unexpectedly killed and we go to meet the rest of her family, who live in Washington. Her sister Sarah is the other main character. You quickly learn that they have not been on speaking terms for several years.
So Sarah is completely surprised when Jenna's will reveals that she (Sarah) needs to travel to Bolivia, alone, to fulfill her last wishes.
As the story unfolds, their lives are revealed, bit by bit. Scene by scene.
This story is full of depth, in relationships, in setting, in reality.
A story of family. Of sisters. Deception. Secrets.
Once I finally got used to the present tense of the story, I really did like this one. It has an incredible message, and it has many unexpected twists and turns.
If you like stories that challenge you in your Christian life, I recommend this one.
Disclaimer: I receive complimentary books from various sources, including, publishers, publicists, authors, and/or NetGalley. I am not required to write a positive review, and have not received any compensation. The opinions shared here are my own entirely. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255
Do you ever read a book and wish you could meet the characters in real life? Like your mind tricks you and you think the characters are real people hiding out in plain sight in the setting of the book... This is how I felt at the end of this book! After a bit of difficulty getting into the book initially, once the plot took off and I knew the characters better, the twists and turns kept me interested til the end. I loved the plot. The setting dually set in Bolivia and Washington was intriguing. As a person who loves foreign culture, this was especially of interest to me. I loved learning about Bolivian culture. My favorite part of the story was the way the author released information slowly. At the beginning I found myself in a hurry wanting to know what in the world was going on right away. I came to like the slow way the author gave the information as the characters were realizing it or finding it out within the natural flow of the story. This kept me reading and wanting more! I also loved the little bit of romance, sisterly struggles, family secrets, and themes of forgiveness, loyalty, love and grace. One thing that I struggled with in the story was the point of view in which the story was told. Jenna's story was written in first person and Sarah's was written mostly in third person but would sometimes jump into first person. I felt like I would have preferred it the other way around. Sarah seemed to be the main character of the story so I would have connected with her more had she been written in first person. Overall, this wasn't really a huge deal but I do feel I would have liked the story even better than I do had the point of views been reversed. I gave this book 4 out of 5 stars.
I received a digital copy of this book. This has in no way influenced my review. All thoughts are my own.
This is a book about how holding on to secrets—no matter how much we tell ourselves we are doing it for the good of everyone else—builds walls around hearts and relationships.
Jenna and Sarah have spent the past six years with distance—both physical and relational—between them. When news of Jenna’s death reaches her family, Sarah is surprised and confused by the insistence she travel from Washington to Bolivia to spread her sister’s (the one who has wanted little to do with her for years) ashes and collect her belongings.
Katherine Scott Jones gives readers a book filled with flawed and broken characters who are relatable enough to garner our compassion. As secrets are uncovered (the book alternates between Sarah in the present and Jenna through the years in the past without bogging the reader down), Jenna’s pain and guilt are laid bare for Sarah to see.
Shadow Sister also gives us a peek into the lives and challenges of the Bolivian people and the hearts of those who commit their lives to serve them.
Well written with vivid descriptions of both Bolivia and central Washington’s wine country, this book transported me to new places and mired me in the emotions of one sister who always felt she lived in the shadow of the other. While the other sister lived as a shadow of her former self.
Disclosure statement: I receive complimentary books from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, including NetGalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
Shadow Sister is a Christian inspirational fiction novel by author Katherine Scott Jones. The female protagonist, Sarah Lanning, is left instructions on what to do if, and when her sister, Jenna, dies. She is to go to Bolivia to retrieve Jenna's belongings and scatter her ashes.
I love the quote from chapter six that reads, "Too often we see only what we expect to see and become blind to everything else."
I learned that Bolivians believe newly departed spirits return to places they knew as home during their life and that dogs recognize their presence (Chapter 13).
I appreciate how the author points out that Jesus frequently rebuked men, he never did that to women. Even though women are so often seen standing on the lowest rung of the social ladder. Jesus treated women as first class citizens. I also like how the plan of salvation was intertwined throughout the pages.
This story is written in prose and was hard for me to fully grasp it. However, I want to thank the author, and Celebrate Lit, for the chance to review this novel.
Disclaimer: I received this novel complimentary the author, and the ebook complimentary Celebrate Lit, and was under no obligation to post a positive review. The opinions expressed are my own.
Shadow Sister is full of secrets and regrets that divide a family. These secrets cast long shadows over the family and keep two sisters apart. With Jenna's sudden death, Sarah is left to pick up the pieces and come to terms with her feelings for her sister. The story is told in the alternating perspectives of Jenna and Sarah and is set in Bolivia and in a vineyard in Washington state. Sarah's journey to pick up her sister's ashes soon becomes something more meaningful and she is forced to deal with her grief and her personal ambitions in ways she has avoided. Can she overcome their secrets? This is a story about regrets and facing the possibility of not having a second chance. It's about what it means to love someone deeply, even after their death. This is a powerful, life-changing story, one not to be missed! Its message will resonate with readers from many backgrounds. I received a digital copy of this book from the author with no obligations. These opinions are entirely my own.
A richly woven, deeply touching, vibrant and exquisitely written novel. This poignant and powerfully memorable story gracefully wraps around your heart and tenderly squeezes. Here is a stirring narrative that is best read in a comfortable place with plenty of tissues at hand. A story to savor and consider; one to remember and allow to change you in positive, loving ways. The earnest way the author speaks of Jesus’ abiding love for women is especially touching. I am extraordinarily grateful for the deep blessing of experiencing this story.
I give my very highest rating for this novel, its author and her expertise. I enthusiastically recommend Shadow Sister as a must-read!
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy of this book. A favorable review was not required, no compensation was received, and all views expressed are my own.
SHADOW SISTER is Katherine Scott Jones' second novel, and it proves her ability as a skilled, subtle storyteller.
HER MEMORY OF MUSIC was Jones' first book and it is filled with layers of meaning that help build a solid storyline.
With SHADOW SISTER Jones continues her artistic journey, using a similar technique, but with a much more developed story and characters. In fact, there isn't a single character in SHADOW SISTER that doesn't contribute, directly, to the development of the plot. (A storyline that includes miscommunication, regret and redemption between two siblings, kept together by deep bonds of love.)
I also appreciated Jones' ability to portray her characters warts-and-all. Oftentimes in faith-fiction, there is a tendency to gloss over faults and misdeeds. But Jones' story runs deep and true to life.
This is my first book by Katherine Scott Jones. I enjoyed her writing, the flow of the story was really good. Some surprises along the way.
Sarah goes to Bolivia to get her sister remains after Jenna passes away in a bus accident. She meets some very interesting people, good friends of her sister. The book goes from present time and back to when Jenna and Sarah was younger. Basically Jenna telling her side of things during different stages of her life, explaining things that happened. That made the story more interesting. I definitely recommend this book and I look forward to reading more from Katherine.
I received an complementary copy of the book from Celebrate Lit. I was not required to write an positive review.
Sarah Lanning wants to run away from her past and the things she lost. Like her close relationship with her sister, Jenna. When news arrives that Jenna has passed and she leaves an unexpected request. Sarah still coming to terms with her sister's death but, she abides to Jenna's request and travels to Bolivia. During her time in Bolivia, Sarah finds out about Jenna's secret life along with a few buried secrets. Will Sarah be able to forgive?
The novel was a good read about familial bonds, love, loyalty, and forgiveness. I like the portion of the books that spoke about Bolivia's culture and way of life. I found the bond between Sarah and Jenna realistic and endearing. Although I did find some parts of the novel slow, it was a good read overall.
This book grabbed me from the start with the story of two sisters who once were close but due to circumstances had drifted so far apart. This is a story of sisters and two different cultures and they are blended so well. Katherine Scott Jones is a wonderful writer and has a way with words that draws you into the story. There is a mystery that evolves slowly as the reader moves through the story. It is a story of love and forgiveness and an element of faith. I look forward to reading more books by this author.
While I was provided a copy of this book, it in no way influenced this review as these are my thoughts and opinions.
I enjoyed this book! The style of writing was different then what I typically read but it didn't take away from the story. I liked the themes of forgiveness and love weaved throughout the book. It's also about relationships between sisters. I found it to be a wonderful story with many layers. I think there is a lot the reader can learn as well. I didn't know a lot about Bolivia before reading this book. This is a wonderful story that will capture your heart.
I received this book from the publisher to read and give my honest opinion.