What do you think?
Rate this book


288 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2018
I’m always wary of comic book adaptations of beloved TV properties. Partly it’s the ‘you can’t go home again’ feeling that it’s just too different a medium to capture the same type of joy. Partly it’s just because you want to leave the memories untainted. But who can resist new Firefly adventures? Not I.
I’m not sure if this is a good place to start, but it’s what I found.
It starts with a great introduction by Nathan Fillion.
The story is by Brett Matthews and it’s good Firefly dialog. The art is by Will Conrad and it’s also good. Being good likenesses and good comic book art that is not too painterly.
That was okay. The character moments were a little bit forced. Some of the action was as well. I’ll give this 2 stars.
Um. That was kind of unsatisfying. What happened to the blue hand guys that appeared to be ON THE SHIP!? Never explained. Voices were good. The rest was good. The art good. But story wise it was a little fuzzy in a couple of places.
2 stars
So maybe the plan was to capture this thing all along and the robbery was just to get its attention?
That was fine. 3 stars
This was okay. The art is good. The voices right. 3 stars
That was okay. 2 stars
That was also just okay. 2 stars
Another story that hints at stuff we already know. 2 stars
This is really, really fuzzy. It’s not clear exactly what happened or how Book was responsible. It may be deliberately unclear, but it’s still bogus.
Lots of ‘tell-not-show’ in this story so far.
I’m torn on this one. It’s told very badly. Almost an info dump. The art is compelling and well done. You do in fact learn more about Book’s history. In fact you learn all of it. And it’s not as interesting or surprising as you’d have thought.
As far as I know, this is the first time his having only one eye is mentioned. I wonder if it’s ever come up before?
So this story is a 2 with a plus 1 for art. 3 stars
The stories are filled with so much terminology they are hard to follow. The art is okay. But except for the pregnancy there’s not much new. 3 stars
That was a cute story. I wasn’t fond of the art work but it worked. 3 stars.
Well, out of 10 stories it comes out a 3 star book. Only the first story was really exceptional. The others mostly reaffirmed what we already knew. Almost like a clip-show or greatest hits record.
For some, that would be enough to bring a smile. It is not an unpleasant read despite the highly variable art.
But I wouldn’t recommend it unless you are a completest. It doesn’t really add to the lore.
I might take another look at this series later when their success allows them to feel freer to expand.