This is the first Sugarbury Falls mystery that I have read so I am not familiar with the character, but it still works very well as a standalone.
The Fox family return home from an extended trip to Scotland. Unfortunately, they miss one of the town's important holidays, but it was during this holiday that one of the college girls was found drowned in a nearby lake. Ruled as a possible accident at first, it became increasingly possible that Robby, a young man that Maddy befriended, may have murdered the student. Emily and Henry try to help clear his name, mainly for Maddy's sake.
This is a well written mystery, with good well rounded characters. I really like the ambiguity that Diane has instilled into the adopted parent-daughter relationship; it is always difficult to deal with moody teenagers, but I would imagine much harder when the prickly child is not your own - how far can you push your point, how heavy handed can you appear before you are accused of being controlling instead of loving. I think Emily Henry and Maddy have found a good working boundary against which they are able to slowly build a strong relationship. I enjoyed this book very much and look forward to more of her work. I received this ARC but my review is my honest opinion