Prep-school senior Brandon Hardy is brilliant, athletic, popular and charming—the kind of student that makes St. Joe's School for Boys proud to call its own. However, his privileged life threatens to collapse when a disturbing videotape is found on campus. As the resulting scandal takes unexpected turns, Brandon's mother Elizabeth must sort fact from fiction from family and confront unsettling truths about her son, herself, and their life.
Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa is an American playwright, screenwriter, and comic book writer best known for his work for Marvel Comics and for the television series Glee, Big Love, Riverdale, and Chilling Adventures of Sabrina. He is Chief Creative Officer of Archie Comics. Aguirre-Sacasa grew up liking comic books, recalling in 2003, "My mom would take us out to the 7-Eleven on River Road during the summer, and we would get Slurpees and buy comics off the spinning rack. I would read them all over and over again, and draw my own pictures and stuff." He began writing for Marvel Comics, he explained, when "Marvel hired an editor to find new writers, and they hired her from a theatrical agency. So she started calling theaters and asking if they knew any playwrights who might be good for comic books. A couple of different theaters said she should look at me. So she called me, I sent her a couple of my plays and she said 'Great, would you like to pitch on a couple of comic books in the works?'" His first submissions were "not what [they were] interested in for the character[s]" but eventually he was assigned an 11-page Fantastic Four story, "The True Meaning of...," for the Marvel Holiday Special 2004. He went on to write Fantastic Four stories in Marvel Knights 4, a spinoff of that superhero team's long-running title; and stories for Nightcrawler vol. 3; The Sensational Spider-Man vol. 2; and Dead of Night featuring Man-Thing. In May 2008 Aguirre-Sacasa returned to the Fantastic Four with a miniseries tie-in to the company-wide "Secret Invasion" storyline concerning a years-long infiltration of Earth by the shape-shifting alien race, the Skrulls,and an Angel Revelations miniseries with artists Barry Kitson and Adam Polina, respectively. He adapted for comics the Stephen King novel The Stand.
In 2013, he created Afterlife with Archie, depicting Archie Andrews in the midst of a zombie apocalypse; the book's success led to Aguirre-Sacasa being named Archie Comics' chief creative officer.
It's a play on an important topic, but it veers a bit too often towards melodrama ... and both character development and dialogue don't quite ring true on occasion.
This little play was recommended to me by an old friend who has his PhD in theater. It has since been on my TBR for years. LOL. I finally got around to reading it to fulfill the Popsugar Reading Challenge. It was the shortest book on my TBR. And boy. What this play lacks in length, it more than makes up for in power. It's a searing (but also somehow personal) indictment of patriarchy: a look at rape culture, the good old boys club, and homophobia and the ways all three work to disempower and exploit non-white/straight/MEN. It's truly insane how good this play is.
Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa's play Good Boys and True has a compelling story to tell, a well-developed moral center, and enormous conviction. For all of this it is to be greatly admired. The questions it raises about our responsibilities to one another are fundamental and demand exploration.
The time is the fall of 1988, the place is an affluent Washington, D.C. suburb where the Hardy family resides. The father, Michael (whom we never see during the play) is a prominent doctor and do-gooder; he's currently in a "flying hospital" bringing medical care to the needy in Ecuador. The mother, Elizabeth, is a surgeon and also the protagonist of the play. Their only son, Brandon, is 17, a senior at St. Joseph's Preparatory School for Boys. Brandon is handsome, smart, athletic, and on the fast track to an Ivy League college (specifically, Dartmouth) and an apparently limitless future.
It is worth mentioning that Michael attended both St. Joseph's and Dartmouth himself.
The riveting plot of Good Boys and True begins when Russell Shea, Brandon's coach at school and a lifelong friend of the Hardys, brings Elizabeth in for an interview at his office. A videotape has been found, he tells her, that shows a young man having sex with a young woman. "How graphic?" she asks. He replies: "Whatever you're imagining....That times three."
The face of the boy on the tape is obscured, but the rest of the boy's body looks like Brandon's.
Aguirre-Sacasa skillfully lays this all out in a single scene that lasts perhaps five minutes. The rest of the play convulses from this bombshell. Some of what happens is relatively easy to guess (starting with Brandon's vehement and reasonably convincing denial that it is indeed him on this tape). The situation quickly escalates into a scandal and then explodes into a catastrophe, at least for those closely involved. The playwright shrewdly focuses on only a few people affected by it: Brandon and his mom, her sister Maddy (who is a teacher at a public high school nearby), his best friend Justin (whose sexuality and whose feelings for Brandon are a source of enormous worry for Brandon). Late in the play, we also meet Cheryl, the young woman on the tape, who is at once the clearest victim of this arrogant prank and the clearest-eyed of its survivors. Aguirre-Sacasa has written all of these characters beautifully and authentically, but Cheryl rings truest of all.
To disclose more would do a disservice both to the terrific suspense that the playwright builds here and to the arc that we travel vicariously with Elizabeth as she uncovers more and more of the truth of what transpired. I was surprised that she, and not her son, is the one who takes the most meaningful journey in Good Boys and True; the place she ends up is a place she knows she should always have been, one of honestly and completely owning every action and every omission in a life that privilege has made too easy and careless.
This was a beautiful commentary on rape culture, the issues with privilege and lack of exposure to diversity, the need for less and of course, familial love and the possibility for mistakes in life.
Not to mention the commentary on sexuality, denial of one’s own self, the traumas and truths it can bring to light and of course- societal picture as a whole and the view on difference within a world where “normal” is classified on the majority belief. (And the change society has had for LGBTQ+ over the last 30 years)
I’m excited to Play Cheryl in my upcoming scene work and I can truly related and have beautiful substitutions already for her as a character. Her struggle in poverty, support of her Mother and strong work ethic, and especially the social divide and perception on the more rich and intellectual and empathic view on others wrongdoings connect with me deeply. I think, considering she’s only directly depicted for one scene the play does a great job of still building up a definition of who she is, what she stands for, and of course why she put herself in such a scenario in the first place.
2.5, there’s no doubt that Aguirre-Sacasa writes really snappy dialogue, but this premise feels restricted by the scope of it. If this were a two person chamber drama between mother and son, or a wide ensemble cast of characters, I think this would’ve been a way more effective execution of this idea.
As is, it’s totally fine, but just scratches the surface of the ideas it presents. Every playwright seems contractually obligated to write some version of a critique of toxic masculinity/rape culture at some point, but so rarely do they ever explore it in a way that doesn’t end up feeling like a very special episode of One Tree Hill.
This is an interesting look at how institutionalized rape-culture is within the fabric of American Culture. Aguirre-Sacasa delivers another wonderful play that deals with a difficult, and very topical, issue.