What do you think?
Rate this book
The Inquisition War #1-3
Ian Watson teljes Warhammer 40000 univerzuma
A Warhammer-univerzum negyvenedik évezrede lidércnyomással terhes korszakot hozott. Az emberiség véres háborúja a Káosz erőivel rendületlenül folytatódik, csupán a léptékek változtak – lerombolt falvak helyett kiégett bolygók jelzik a kilátástalan küzdelem nyomait. S mintha ez nem volna elég, a galaxist meghódító ember kénytelen hátborzongatóan idegen földönkívüli fajokkal is szembeszállni. Ebben az örök háborúban az egyetlen reményt egy vén és könyörtelen isten jelenti, a tízezer éve mesterségesen életben tartott Császár.
A Warhammer-történetek a hősiesség és a kötelességtudat meséi. Főszereplőik elszántan, fanatikus hittel küzdenek mindazért, ami számukra a világot jelenti. Múlhatatlan és romolhatatlan eszmék vezérlik őket a végső cél felé, legyen az akár dicsőség, akár pusztulás…
A Warhammer-történetek a hősiesség és a kötelességtudat meséi. Főszereplőik elszántan, fanatikus hittel küzdenek mindazért, ami számukra a világot jelenti. Múlhatatlan és romolhatatlan eszmék vezérlik őket a végső cél felé, legyen az akár dicsőség, akár pusztulás…
760 pages, Hardcover
First published July 1, 2004
35 people are currently reading
342 people want to read
About the author
Ian Watson
300 books119 followersLibrarian Note: There is more than one author by this name in the Goodreads database.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews
September 8, 2011
Beautifully insane and masterfully written by an author with enough confidence and skill to unhinge his brain and let the daemonic possession flow through him and onto the page... and into you the reader.
Apparently this set of early Warhammer 40k books (and novellas) come from a slightly different angle than later 40k books. I can’t comment on that as these are the only 40k books I’ve read. To be honest, the 40k universe described here is so real and so overwhelming that I am reluctant to read Warhammer 40k books from other authors less they seem weak by comparison.
The main character of the inquisitor is a ruthless murderer, not because he is psychotic or cruel, nor because he places no value on human life. He is ruthless because he has no choice: in this dangerous universe, where human existence hangs on a delicate thread, we need people like the inquisitor to protect us. It is a tribute to the skill of the author that what appeared monstrous as I began to read the first novella soon began to seem logical and necessary.
If there was something that wasn’t quite perfect it was that the psychotic worlds the books moved through were so interesting (to this reader, and I suspect the author) that the characters occasionally took a backseat in order for us to marvel at the universe they inhabit. Having written that, in this omnibus format there are a lot of pages to read, and so taking the foot off the gas for the plot on occasion is probably a good thing. That’s not to say that they were cardboard cut-out characters that did not transform and did nothing but be a viewpoint for the authors. They had very different motivations, all felt constantly under threat, and not all of them made it...
Apparently this set of early Warhammer 40k books (and novellas) come from a slightly different angle than later 40k books. I can’t comment on that as these are the only 40k books I’ve read. To be honest, the 40k universe described here is so real and so overwhelming that I am reluctant to read Warhammer 40k books from other authors less they seem weak by comparison.
The main character of the inquisitor is a ruthless murderer, not because he is psychotic or cruel, nor because he places no value on human life. He is ruthless because he has no choice: in this dangerous universe, where human existence hangs on a delicate thread, we need people like the inquisitor to protect us. It is a tribute to the skill of the author that what appeared monstrous as I began to read the first novella soon began to seem logical and necessary.
If there was something that wasn’t quite perfect it was that the psychotic worlds the books moved through were so interesting (to this reader, and I suspect the author) that the characters occasionally took a backseat in order for us to marvel at the universe they inhabit. Having written that, in this omnibus format there are a lot of pages to read, and so taking the foot off the gas for the plot on occasion is probably a good thing. That’s not to say that they were cardboard cut-out characters that did not transform and did nothing but be a viewpoint for the authors. They had very different motivations, all felt constantly under threat, and not all of them made it...
September 24, 2013
The main characters are all in some form of psychosis, everything is horrible and the universe is fucked. All in all a definitive Warhammer 40k book.
September 22, 2012
Seems like the notes of a badly railroaded and deus-exed warhammer roleplaying game. This is one to skip.
March 21, 2012
Intuitions of great brass-bound, hex-stamped alien tomes, brittle with age, infested Azul. Sensations of arcane incunabula and palimpsests and chained libers. Of ranks of daemonic codices and opuscules – the very words of which might melt the eye to keep the brain from imbibing what was writ. Impressions of labyrinthine ebon passageways and inky halls and chambers and cubicles wherein books themselves were luminous, phosphorescent. Impressions of a maze so extensive that an ignorant wanderer might well leave his bones there. Of terrible immaterial guardians of these macabre archives. Could those brooding presences be chained, tamed daemons, embodiments of formulae inscribed within certain volumes locked in arabesque cages?In the preface, Watson writes about the difficulty of producing believable fiction on the basis of a set of game rules; his answer was "to go completely over the top in style and also in content - to be lurid and brooding and hyperbolic and generally crazy, although in an elegant, ornate way where a dark beauty pervades the atmosphere." This manifests itself in the range of insane settings Watson imagines, such as cities that look like coral brains and gargantuan alien ruins sculpted from sand, and the gruesome events that befall the characters, who are forced to eat the tentacles of some kind of immaterial psychic squid, or have their eye gouged out to reach a state of enlightenment.
More importantly, though, this lurid hyperbole take the form of a sheer linguistic joy in the absurd ripeness of the prose (which mirrors the richness of the "spiced foetal lambkin stuffed with truffles" on which the Inquisitor dines). This produces a kind of glorious aesthetic and affective derangement which Watson may well be right in saying is the only way the calculated madness of the Warhammer 40,000 setting could be made palpable. At times, Watson approaches the thesaurus-assisted stream-of-consciousness of R. L. Fanthorpe, with some of the same problems. Fanthorpe would famously get so carried away with the digressions he introduced in order to meet wordcount that he would end up without enough space left to conclude the narrative; something similar happens in the last book in the trilogy collected here, which is made up almost entirely of an extended digression. But what a digression! An extended adventure in the criminal underworld of a planet of bizarre religious fanatics, ending with a largely incomprehensible apocalypse.
The narrative doesn't make a great deal of sense and the characters are fairly thin, but then they are both subordinate, in the end, to the pleasures of the text, a grand guignol that appeals to the memories I have of the fourteen-year-old-boy who took the Warhammer 40,000 universe a little bit too seriously.
Which was worse? The vile actions undertaken by his body – or the dreams?
He dreamed of luscious lethal daemonettes. He dreamed of poisonous fiends which were half human and half scorpion. He dreamed of ostrich-horses with voluptuous legs and lashing blue tongues, upon which daemonettes rode.
It seemed that soon those daemonettes and fiends might try to rip their way into the world through his very own flesh – which was his own no more. They might tear a gateway open in his bowels. They might emerge through his anus and then expand to full-size.
How his mind fought against this hideous prospect
July 29, 2010
This book is difficult. I like it because it harks back to a bygone era of Warhammer 40,000 where the game was more squad based skirmishes than full scale battles. Namely, Rogue Trader. Being a gamer from the early nineties (when this book was written) I can understand where the author's coming from, and smile wryly at the peculiar goings-on a references. Someone reading this without the advantage of having been there would not have a clue what the author was prattling on about.
Even so, this now replaced/retconned version of the grim dark far future is difficult to really get into. I find myself feeling awkward when I read Jaq's internal monologue because of the uncomfortable way he seems to think it. Certain characters (such as the Space Marines and the Custodes) are so very different from how they are now that it seems as if the writer has almost no knowledge of the 40k universe.
Of course, that's not true. Ian Watson was a gamer himself at the time of his writing the books, so he knew what he was talking about. But compared to the later writings (even those dealing with the subject of Inquisitors, such as Dan Abnett's marvellous Eisenhorn and Ravenor trilogies) set in ostensibly the same universe, it is clunky, confusing, and out of place. This isn't helped by the authors writing, which includes unnecessarily obscure words and references that most casual readers (particularly of sci-fi) will be left confused by. His character interaction seems stilted and unnatural - even for the grim darkness of the far future - and makes it incredibly hard to relate or even care about most of the characters - except for the Squat, Grimm, who talks almost normally!
I've not read anything else by Ian Watson, and I can't say this book inspires me to do so out of anything other than an idle sense of curiosity. I want to see if all his books are this uncomfortable.
In short, I wouldn't recommend this book unless you're a staunch die-hard Warhammer 40,000 fan, or an old school gamer who has fond memories of Rogue Trader.
Even so, this now replaced/retconned version of the grim dark far future is difficult to really get into. I find myself feeling awkward when I read Jaq's internal monologue because of the uncomfortable way he seems to think it. Certain characters (such as the Space Marines and the Custodes) are so very different from how they are now that it seems as if the writer has almost no knowledge of the 40k universe.
Of course, that's not true. Ian Watson was a gamer himself at the time of his writing the books, so he knew what he was talking about. But compared to the later writings (even those dealing with the subject of Inquisitors, such as Dan Abnett's marvellous Eisenhorn and Ravenor trilogies) set in ostensibly the same universe, it is clunky, confusing, and out of place. This isn't helped by the authors writing, which includes unnecessarily obscure words and references that most casual readers (particularly of sci-fi) will be left confused by. His character interaction seems stilted and unnatural - even for the grim darkness of the far future - and makes it incredibly hard to relate or even care about most of the characters - except for the Squat, Grimm, who talks almost normally!
I've not read anything else by Ian Watson, and I can't say this book inspires me to do so out of anything other than an idle sense of curiosity. I want to see if all his books are this uncomfortable.
In short, I wouldn't recommend this book unless you're a staunch die-hard Warhammer 40,000 fan, or an old school gamer who has fond memories of Rogue Trader.
December 11, 2018
What a long, strange journey this trilogy is. A very different take on the setting in terms of style, I really appreciated the raw adult and mystical tone rather than the stock military scifi prose that probably dominates much of the franchise now. It could be quite adventurous in its inclusion of the strange, the taboo and the real. In a nutshell: a Flash Gordon style romp through the criminally overlooked 1981 movie "Galaxy of Terror"... one where the hero is a jaded and nearly broken Bruce Wayne at the start.
It's not perfect though. At times it was not very fun or engaging, mostly in large chunks of the mid-to-late second book. I wonder how much of that was just the sudden focus of the Eldar with their stereotypical space elf plot points or how much of it was fatigue from the arbitrary, seemingly unfocused directions the protagonists' journey makes. Quite often I felt, "ok so now we're going here and doing this because we have to I guess..." But it picked up again in Chaos Child. And after the amazing vista we are treated to at the Battle of Genost, the climax of Jaq Draco's arc comes to bear, however disturbing and seemingly unfulfilling it may be; it certainly fits the tone of the series and packs a powerful punch while leaving us hungry for more (which sadly, will never come).
I would recommend the first book of the three, Draco as well as the Eisenhorn series as excellent primers to the setting, though the different approaches in each make for fascinating comparison. It's certainly a rare thing for franchise fiction to ever have someone of Ian Watson's level grace it. His masterful balancing of the impersonal and the intimate adds so much more gloom and terror to what is essentially supposed to be gloomiest and most terrifying of scifi settings.
It's not perfect though. At times it was not very fun or engaging, mostly in large chunks of the mid-to-late second book. I wonder how much of that was just the sudden focus of the Eldar with their stereotypical space elf plot points or how much of it was fatigue from the arbitrary, seemingly unfocused directions the protagonists' journey makes. Quite often I felt, "ok so now we're going here and doing this because we have to I guess..." But it picked up again in Chaos Child. And after the amazing vista we are treated to at the Battle of Genost, the climax of Jaq Draco's arc comes to bear, however disturbing and seemingly unfulfilling it may be; it certainly fits the tone of the series and packs a powerful punch while leaving us hungry for more (which sadly, will never come).
I would recommend the first book of the three, Draco as well as the Eisenhorn series as excellent primers to the setting, though the different approaches in each make for fascinating comparison. It's certainly a rare thing for franchise fiction to ever have someone of Ian Watson's level grace it. His masterful balancing of the impersonal and the intimate adds so much more gloom and terror to what is essentially supposed to be gloomiest and most terrifying of scifi settings.
August 7, 2012
This book is quite difficult, especially if this is one of the first of your books set in the Warhammer 40k universe. There are some parts in which Watson goes over the top, yet he manages to do so while keeping a specific atmosphere. The narrative is quite awkward, the characters are thin and the interaction between them could have been better, yet the action and events make up for most of it.
February 17, 2012
This is my first foray into the Warhammer 40K universe and I really enjoyed it!
The world is amazing - I LOVE it and really wish I had created it lol.
Watson's writing is gorgeous, although I did find his narrative to be a little disjointed and fragmented. But wow - it's great stuff.
The third part of the trilogy/omnibus was the weakest for me, although it still had really cool lore.
I understand that this trilogy is considered 'old school' amongst 40K aficionado's so I am interested to see what the newer books are like. I will certainly be spending more time in the 40Kverse.
The world is amazing - I LOVE it and really wish I had created it lol.
Watson's writing is gorgeous, although I did find his narrative to be a little disjointed and fragmented. But wow - it's great stuff.
The third part of the trilogy/omnibus was the weakest for me, although it still had really cool lore.
I understand that this trilogy is considered 'old school' amongst 40K aficionado's so I am interested to see what the newer books are like. I will certainly be spending more time in the 40Kverse.
January 1, 2013
Being a big fan of Warhammer 40,000 Inquisition stories and fluff, I realize that this is some of the earlier fiction of the setting which is still appealing but lacks the development that is found in the later Inquisition-related works (such as the Eisenhorn and Ravenor series). With this is mind, I still give kudos to Ian Watson for spinning an intriguing (though depressing) story that lives up to the bleak Warhammer 40K universe.
October 11, 2017
Not quite as bonkers as his previous Space Marine, and not quite as much of a piss-take, either. Watson seems more willing to explore the 40k universe here, revelling in the richness and madness to considerable effect. The schoolboy humour is still evident, but is not detrimental. Like Space Marine, this must surely be a must-read for any Black Library fan.
January 8, 2020
The most interesting piece in Games Workshop's vast, clanking archives. It isn't canon: Watson does too much in this, messes with the profitable stasis of the last years of the 41st millennium too much. The nearest thing to Illuminatus! or Snow Crash.
September 7, 2022
Ian Watson’s “the inquisition war is from a different time. Warhammer 4OK as we know it today had not quite settled into the mold, quite a few things where still in flux or would be changed shortly or a bit later after these books had been published. Reading this book today leaves one who is familiar with the current lore on space marines, the imperium and universe at times confused and other times frustrated and bewildered. I won’t beat around the bush with this, I hated these three books. I Intensely disliked the main character, found most side characters to be equally annoying and or pointless, the plot was a bloated mess that has had little to no impact on the lore of warhammer 40K and it is quite badly written to the point of boring.
The main character is an inquisitor named Jaq Draco who along with his team which consists of a navigator, a squat and an imperial assasin, is sent to a planet currently under going a purging of genestealer cultists. Their mission to make sure the inquisitor in charge is on the level, not showing any signs of overzealous action which might indicate taint by chaos, for Jaq Draco is part of the ordo malleus out to check for the most vile of threats to the imperium, chaos demons and those that are in league with them. So far so good but the problems with the book start really quickly. In short there is a secret plot which involves a segment of the inquisition who plan to infect every world of the imperium with a fabricated warp entity called the Hydra which in time will infect every human and when sparked unite all of mankind in a single mind entity thus driving off chaos as it would not find willing minds to tempt anymore. The first thing any modern reader of warhammer will remark is, Hydra? Is this an Alpha legion plan? But no, this is a time before those guys where brought into the lore. Secondly, why have we never heard of this idea later? Well neither does the main character. In fact this whole plot of the hydra plan and a secret segment of the inquisition working on this gets pushed to the back and by second half of book two it is barely remembered anymore. The rest of this first book is is dedicated to Jaq and his team first traveling to the eye of terror to find the place where this hydra entity came from and afterwards infiltrating the imperial palace on terra to talk to the emperor and find out if he authorized this insane plan. Any modern reader would raise his or her eyebrows at this, as it would make Jaq Draco one of the few persons to speak to emperor in 10,000 years but he does and learns nothing besides that the emperor is basically a sort of mind collective or a subconscious mind at odds with itself?
That for book one and two things really stood out for me as eyesores, first of all distance. I’m sorry but even a high level inquisitor with a state of the art ship like his would not be able to cross the galaxy as easily and quickly as Jaq Draco does nor would it be that easy to enter either the palace or the eye of terror as he did. Secondly I got the feeling that the main characters act like they are playing a role game, you know like the role playing game that launched warhammer 40k in the first place, rogue trader. Their dynamics and the way the plot developed feels as role playing game fan fiction than a proper story plot. In particular the casualness of their interaction is at odds with their profile of inquisitor and imperial assassin, the love plot between them is exceedingly so.
The second book takes us a hundred years in the future and having been placed in stasis the main trio of inquisitor, assasin and navigator is cast back into the galaxy, their squad team mate had been separated from them but no worries they find him again on the first planet they set down (once again do we even acknowledge how vast the universe is?) This second book adds a twist to the whole hydra plot, you see there are these illuminated people, who had been possessed by a demon and freed from this hellish embrace now dedicated themselves to fighting it. These have realized that the hydra plot is insane, will most likely cause a fith chaos god to be born and want to stop it. They want to stop it by finding the secret immortal sons of the emperor and unite them to become at time of chaos rapture to unite into a new psychic being, the numen to take over from the rotting corpse that is the emperor in his throne. So yeah….. the problem here is that the persona of the emperor has changed quite a bit since this book; in short the emperor has become more and more otherworldly and less human so to have plot where he fathered children with random women across the galaxy? It is not compatible anymore. Secondly names as Horus and Rogal Dorn are dropped and used as companions of the emperor not the gene enhanced and designed primarchs of the legions. It almost feels as if the idea of sons of emperor stuck but was merged with these erstwhile companions. In the same vein of having become less human, the space marines make their intro in the story and these too feel way to human and are not treated as the gene altered human originated persons they are today, in particular references to lingering remembrance to sexuality is weird.
The main focus of the story diverts away from the inquistor himself and towards the eldar and harlequins who, unbeknownst to their supposed human allies the illuminati, want to set up the whole sons of the emperor thing to assure mutually assured destruction of both the sane galaxy and chaos to deny chaos its final victory. This adds yet another plot and complexity to the story which it already had plenty off but added for good measure is another inquisitor whom we met in book one and was connected to the hydra plot but has been mind swiped or something yet harbours hatred for Jaq Draco. Finally there is the harlequin man, a human illuminati who was taken under the wings of the eldar and is connected to all of it adding yet another layer of complexity. So what do the main characters do then? Why infiltrate the webway portals of the eldar, make it to their most secret place, the black library and steal the book of fate and end of the universe off course. This is such a casual disregard of the momentous nature of their actions in this wider universe that it baffles and once again I am remembered of role playing game fan fiction and can’t take this story serious anymore.
The third book brings us a shake up of the party as the assassin was killed by the casual introduction of an eldar phoenix lord that lets them enter their most precious place in the whole of existence anyways. She is replaced by a captain of the imperial fist space marines, Lex. Lex as I said does not feel like the space marines as we know them today, for starters it seems he is shorter and less imposing then we would picture them today. He can hide as a tall yet not exceedingly imposing human. His motivations are strange and I don’t buy them especially since that after the events of book two Jaq Draco is no longer concerned about the hydra plot, the sons of the emperor plot or anything else, he is motivated with finding the heart of the webway portal system where supposedly time can be reversed to bring back his dead lover, the imperial assassin Mehlindi. If the plot had been way over the top, now the plot is ludicrously mundane. Added to the mix are chaos space marines of the thousand sons who interfere and then watch but don’t act anymore? What are they doing? Yeah Tzeentch is unpredictable but he is not some passive actor. Why is that space marine captain going along with this, get my lover back plot? To make it worse a new character is introduced, a thief that kinda looks like Mehlindi so they capture her and use rare drugs to transform her body to look like Mehlindi so when they reach the heart of the webway they can use here body to put Mehlindi soul in…… What is this story??? Remember the hydra plot? The sons of the emperor? The whole imperium is at stake?
I don’t care about spoilers here, basically they pull it off yet Mehlindi, still thinking she is in a fight with the phoenix lord kills Jaq and is killed herself. The squat and the imperial fist make it back to the imperium while Jaq merges with a super entity of illumination at the hear of the webway…… what??
In short this book is a mess, the plot is overbloated, the characters act like a role playing game group not as persona’s in their own world, the style of writing is often bizarre with the following line standing out like the most ridiculous example “the universe is like a sparrows fart”…… what? Besides that Ian Watson has this tendency to interject the sounds of guns in the text so we have TUB TUB TUB and RAARKpopWOOSHtudCRUMP to enjoy. Like honestly what is that supposed to sound like? Almost everything relating to the wider universe, the nature of the emperor, the numen, the hydra plot, space marines, squats has radically changes since this book. It is lore wise dead end that has been buried and there is little to no point to these three books anymore.
I would be remiss however if I did not admit that some parts of the lore where good. The inside of the imperial palace is good, the queing to eternity, the mad inefficient bureaucracy, the squalor in the rotting hart of the imperium is really good. Likewise in the second and third book the segments of the eldar where good and fun to read. Finally in the third book, the setting of the desert planet who sun goes super nova makes for some harrowing and haunting scenes of human desperation in the uncaring universe, which is what warhammer 40K is all about. The bundle starts off with the Mehlindi character in a short story where she infiltrated a genestealer cult which was enjoyable yet it does not come close to redeeming this book. Only if your really interested in finding out what warhammer 40K was like in the late 80ties and early 90ties and what crossroads it had taken could this be remotly interesting but then you would still have to suffer hundreds of pages of badly written story and dialogue.
The main character is an inquisitor named Jaq Draco who along with his team which consists of a navigator, a squat and an imperial assasin, is sent to a planet currently under going a purging of genestealer cultists. Their mission to make sure the inquisitor in charge is on the level, not showing any signs of overzealous action which might indicate taint by chaos, for Jaq Draco is part of the ordo malleus out to check for the most vile of threats to the imperium, chaos demons and those that are in league with them. So far so good but the problems with the book start really quickly. In short there is a secret plot which involves a segment of the inquisition who plan to infect every world of the imperium with a fabricated warp entity called the Hydra which in time will infect every human and when sparked unite all of mankind in a single mind entity thus driving off chaos as it would not find willing minds to tempt anymore. The first thing any modern reader of warhammer will remark is, Hydra? Is this an Alpha legion plan? But no, this is a time before those guys where brought into the lore. Secondly, why have we never heard of this idea later? Well neither does the main character. In fact this whole plot of the hydra plan and a secret segment of the inquisition working on this gets pushed to the back and by second half of book two it is barely remembered anymore. The rest of this first book is is dedicated to Jaq and his team first traveling to the eye of terror to find the place where this hydra entity came from and afterwards infiltrating the imperial palace on terra to talk to the emperor and find out if he authorized this insane plan. Any modern reader would raise his or her eyebrows at this, as it would make Jaq Draco one of the few persons to speak to emperor in 10,000 years but he does and learns nothing besides that the emperor is basically a sort of mind collective or a subconscious mind at odds with itself?
That for book one and two things really stood out for me as eyesores, first of all distance. I’m sorry but even a high level inquisitor with a state of the art ship like his would not be able to cross the galaxy as easily and quickly as Jaq Draco does nor would it be that easy to enter either the palace or the eye of terror as he did. Secondly I got the feeling that the main characters act like they are playing a role game, you know like the role playing game that launched warhammer 40k in the first place, rogue trader. Their dynamics and the way the plot developed feels as role playing game fan fiction than a proper story plot. In particular the casualness of their interaction is at odds with their profile of inquisitor and imperial assassin, the love plot between them is exceedingly so.
The second book takes us a hundred years in the future and having been placed in stasis the main trio of inquisitor, assasin and navigator is cast back into the galaxy, their squad team mate had been separated from them but no worries they find him again on the first planet they set down (once again do we even acknowledge how vast the universe is?) This second book adds a twist to the whole hydra plot, you see there are these illuminated people, who had been possessed by a demon and freed from this hellish embrace now dedicated themselves to fighting it. These have realized that the hydra plot is insane, will most likely cause a fith chaos god to be born and want to stop it. They want to stop it by finding the secret immortal sons of the emperor and unite them to become at time of chaos rapture to unite into a new psychic being, the numen to take over from the rotting corpse that is the emperor in his throne. So yeah….. the problem here is that the persona of the emperor has changed quite a bit since this book; in short the emperor has become more and more otherworldly and less human so to have plot where he fathered children with random women across the galaxy? It is not compatible anymore. Secondly names as Horus and Rogal Dorn are dropped and used as companions of the emperor not the gene enhanced and designed primarchs of the legions. It almost feels as if the idea of sons of emperor stuck but was merged with these erstwhile companions. In the same vein of having become less human, the space marines make their intro in the story and these too feel way to human and are not treated as the gene altered human originated persons they are today, in particular references to lingering remembrance to sexuality is weird.
The main focus of the story diverts away from the inquistor himself and towards the eldar and harlequins who, unbeknownst to their supposed human allies the illuminati, want to set up the whole sons of the emperor thing to assure mutually assured destruction of both the sane galaxy and chaos to deny chaos its final victory. This adds yet another plot and complexity to the story which it already had plenty off but added for good measure is another inquisitor whom we met in book one and was connected to the hydra plot but has been mind swiped or something yet harbours hatred for Jaq Draco. Finally there is the harlequin man, a human illuminati who was taken under the wings of the eldar and is connected to all of it adding yet another layer of complexity. So what do the main characters do then? Why infiltrate the webway portals of the eldar, make it to their most secret place, the black library and steal the book of fate and end of the universe off course. This is such a casual disregard of the momentous nature of their actions in this wider universe that it baffles and once again I am remembered of role playing game fan fiction and can’t take this story serious anymore.
The third book brings us a shake up of the party as the assassin was killed by the casual introduction of an eldar phoenix lord that lets them enter their most precious place in the whole of existence anyways. She is replaced by a captain of the imperial fist space marines, Lex. Lex as I said does not feel like the space marines as we know them today, for starters it seems he is shorter and less imposing then we would picture them today. He can hide as a tall yet not exceedingly imposing human. His motivations are strange and I don’t buy them especially since that after the events of book two Jaq Draco is no longer concerned about the hydra plot, the sons of the emperor plot or anything else, he is motivated with finding the heart of the webway portal system where supposedly time can be reversed to bring back his dead lover, the imperial assassin Mehlindi. If the plot had been way over the top, now the plot is ludicrously mundane. Added to the mix are chaos space marines of the thousand sons who interfere and then watch but don’t act anymore? What are they doing? Yeah Tzeentch is unpredictable but he is not some passive actor. Why is that space marine captain going along with this, get my lover back plot? To make it worse a new character is introduced, a thief that kinda looks like Mehlindi so they capture her and use rare drugs to transform her body to look like Mehlindi so when they reach the heart of the webway they can use here body to put Mehlindi soul in…… What is this story??? Remember the hydra plot? The sons of the emperor? The whole imperium is at stake?
I don’t care about spoilers here, basically they pull it off yet Mehlindi, still thinking she is in a fight with the phoenix lord kills Jaq and is killed herself. The squat and the imperial fist make it back to the imperium while Jaq merges with a super entity of illumination at the hear of the webway…… what??
In short this book is a mess, the plot is overbloated, the characters act like a role playing game group not as persona’s in their own world, the style of writing is often bizarre with the following line standing out like the most ridiculous example “the universe is like a sparrows fart”…… what? Besides that Ian Watson has this tendency to interject the sounds of guns in the text so we have TUB TUB TUB and RAARKpopWOOSHtudCRUMP to enjoy. Like honestly what is that supposed to sound like? Almost everything relating to the wider universe, the nature of the emperor, the numen, the hydra plot, space marines, squats has radically changes since this book. It is lore wise dead end that has been buried and there is little to no point to these three books anymore.
I would be remiss however if I did not admit that some parts of the lore where good. The inside of the imperial palace is good, the queing to eternity, the mad inefficient bureaucracy, the squalor in the rotting hart of the imperium is really good. Likewise in the second and third book the segments of the eldar where good and fun to read. Finally in the third book, the setting of the desert planet who sun goes super nova makes for some harrowing and haunting scenes of human desperation in the uncaring universe, which is what warhammer 40K is all about. The bundle starts off with the Mehlindi character in a short story where she infiltrated a genestealer cult which was enjoyable yet it does not come close to redeeming this book. Only if your really interested in finding out what warhammer 40K was like in the late 80ties and early 90ties and what crossroads it had taken could this be remotly interesting but then you would still have to suffer hundreds of pages of badly written story and dialogue.
December 30, 2016
This is one of the first (if not the very first) WH40K series. This is also one of the most mature, almost high-brow, WH40K books I've come across. Ian Watson writes using sometimes very obscure adjectives and adverbs that might considerably slow down your reading speed, but succeeds in casting the world of WH40K in an even more dark and disturbing light than usual. That being said, this is still an action-packed and fun novel that you'll want to read when you should be doing your errands.
The story is told as a narration (in the third person) by Inquisitor Jaq Draco. This is a story about him and his personal trials. Even though major Universe-altering subjects are brought up in this series, keep in mind that the story is really only about Draco. His character reminds me in some ways of Abnett's Eisenhorn, but being much more melancholy and doubting of his ideals. Both Draco, his companions (Meh'Lindi, Grimm, and Lex), and the antagonists are extremely compelling characters that each hide their own secrets but are easy to fall in love with. They are, in my opinion, the best part of this series.
Ian Watson's view of the WH40K universe differs in many aspects from that of most other authors, and while it upsets many die-hard 40K fans, you have to keep in mind that these books were written when the universe was really underdeveloped (especially when compared to the present). His version is even darker than most, and the near-total despair and miserableness he portrays casts the universe in a very grim light. Grotesque piercings, tattoos, and scars seem nearly universal in these books, with every character having severe bodily alterations. Personally, I don't like this vision as much as those of Abnett and King, who tend to make the WH40K universe a lot more livable.
Draco is the first book of the trilogy. Here, you are introduced to most of the cast of characters as well as the beginnings of the extremely bizarre and complicated Hydra Conspiracy. Jaq and Co. doggedly follow the mysterious Harlequin Man, eventually becoming wrapped up in a plot within the Inquisition itself that threatens the very future of mankind. This is the only WH40K novel that I know of that actually gives the reader a peak into the very heart of the Imperium. In the Emperor's palace on Terra, you get a rather disturbing glimpse of the Emperor himself as an almost Wizard of Oz type character.
The second book of the series, Harlequin, delves into some of the most obscure aspects of the WH40K universe. Probably the first book to provide a good look at the Eldar, HARLEQUIN gives some detail to the ancient enigmatic race. A significant part of the book takes place within the Eldar interdimensional Webways, where the heroes face unstoppable-seeming adversaries as they travel to discover the mysterious Black Library. Also, some of the inner workings of the Inquisition are uncovered, revealing the shadowiness of the galaxy's secret police.
The concluding volume of the series diverges significantly from the first two. In Chaos Child, the primary focus switches to Jaq's obsessions and away from the overall plot presented in the previous volumes of the Hydra conspiracy and such. This is the book that has disappointed the most people, who feel that Watson should have done a better job of concluding all the various plot threads previously introduced. Instead, it turns out the entire story is about Jaq Draco, and only Jaq Draco. Events that impact the entire galaxy are left for others to relate, as Watson follows his intentions and focuses on the story of Draco's fate and his trials with Chaos. To me, this last book is the best and most important of the trilogy.
The Inquisition War is a non-stop, action-packed thrill ride that will keep you on the edge of your seat with brutal battles and intriguing riddles. Death and brutality are widespread throughout the books, with entire worlds being destroyed and characters coming and going quite frequently. Nearly every aspect of the WH40K universe is somehow involved in the tale, with Eldar, Tyranids, Space Marines, Imperial guardsmen, Titans, and all sorts of chaos beasts and demons playing roles throughout. Ian Watson has received a lot of criticism from fans of WH40K because of his somewhat lofty writing style and his slightly altered view of the WH40K universe, but I'd recommend giving him a try.
The story is told as a narration (in the third person) by Inquisitor Jaq Draco. This is a story about him and his personal trials. Even though major Universe-altering subjects are brought up in this series, keep in mind that the story is really only about Draco. His character reminds me in some ways of Abnett's Eisenhorn, but being much more melancholy and doubting of his ideals. Both Draco, his companions (Meh'Lindi, Grimm, and Lex), and the antagonists are extremely compelling characters that each hide their own secrets but are easy to fall in love with. They are, in my opinion, the best part of this series.
Ian Watson's view of the WH40K universe differs in many aspects from that of most other authors, and while it upsets many die-hard 40K fans, you have to keep in mind that these books were written when the universe was really underdeveloped (especially when compared to the present). His version is even darker than most, and the near-total despair and miserableness he portrays casts the universe in a very grim light. Grotesque piercings, tattoos, and scars seem nearly universal in these books, with every character having severe bodily alterations. Personally, I don't like this vision as much as those of Abnett and King, who tend to make the WH40K universe a lot more livable.
Draco is the first book of the trilogy. Here, you are introduced to most of the cast of characters as well as the beginnings of the extremely bizarre and complicated Hydra Conspiracy. Jaq and Co. doggedly follow the mysterious Harlequin Man, eventually becoming wrapped up in a plot within the Inquisition itself that threatens the very future of mankind. This is the only WH40K novel that I know of that actually gives the reader a peak into the very heart of the Imperium. In the Emperor's palace on Terra, you get a rather disturbing glimpse of the Emperor himself as an almost Wizard of Oz type character.
The second book of the series, Harlequin, delves into some of the most obscure aspects of the WH40K universe. Probably the first book to provide a good look at the Eldar, HARLEQUIN gives some detail to the ancient enigmatic race. A significant part of the book takes place within the Eldar interdimensional Webways, where the heroes face unstoppable-seeming adversaries as they travel to discover the mysterious Black Library. Also, some of the inner workings of the Inquisition are uncovered, revealing the shadowiness of the galaxy's secret police.
The concluding volume of the series diverges significantly from the first two. In Chaos Child, the primary focus switches to Jaq's obsessions and away from the overall plot presented in the previous volumes of the Hydra conspiracy and such. This is the book that has disappointed the most people, who feel that Watson should have done a better job of concluding all the various plot threads previously introduced. Instead, it turns out the entire story is about Jaq Draco, and only Jaq Draco. Events that impact the entire galaxy are left for others to relate, as Watson follows his intentions and focuses on the story of Draco's fate and his trials with Chaos. To me, this last book is the best and most important of the trilogy.
The Inquisition War is a non-stop, action-packed thrill ride that will keep you on the edge of your seat with brutal battles and intriguing riddles. Death and brutality are widespread throughout the books, with entire worlds being destroyed and characters coming and going quite frequently. Nearly every aspect of the WH40K universe is somehow involved in the tale, with Eldar, Tyranids, Space Marines, Imperial guardsmen, Titans, and all sorts of chaos beasts and demons playing roles throughout. Ian Watson has received a lot of criticism from fans of WH40K because of his somewhat lofty writing style and his slightly altered view of the WH40K universe, but I'd recommend giving him a try.
March 18, 2018
Along with
Space Marine
, the three books of the Inquisition War trilogy - Draco, Harlequin, and Chaos Child - are some of the earliest examples of official published Warhammer 40k fiction. All are by Ian Watson, already a well-known sci-fi author. Unlike today's Black Library writers, Watson was given near-complete freedom and the result is . . . interesting. Thankfully, there is little of the weird scat fetish that marred Space Marine (seriously, WTF was that about), but still plenty of reeling madness that can actually be kind of funny in the way this Beksinski painting is kind of funny with its cartoony heads.
That being said, the trilogy as a whole has some serious pacing problems. Draco, for instance, features a trip into the Eye of Terror and breaking into the Emperor's throne room, two enormous undertakings worthy of their own books yet are handled much too quickly and casually. Maybe Watson was aiming for a tragicomic jaunt through the 40k universe, except I barely even remember what happened in Harlequin even though I just read it several days ago, while Chaos Child is mostly Draco idling on a single planet and naval-gazing (isn't there an Inquisition war going on . . . ?), so I don’t see why Watson couldn't spread these events out across the entire trilogy. *goes to Harlequin's GR page* Oh right, they broke into the Eldar's Black Library, yet another huge accomplishment that should have been given way more attention than just another little adventure surrounded by mostly forgettable filler.
Also, Watson's treatment of female character is gross. They are constantly being sexualized, either grotesquely (i.e. that fat housewife in "Warped Stars") or as fanservice. Lots of one-handed typing going on when depicting Meh'Lindi in particular. (Compare that to the Ciaphas Cain series, which was also a straight male author writing a straight male protagonist with a hot girlfriend, yet didn't constantly drool over her and also featured a wide variety of other women with different roles and personalities.) Then . So glad Black Library has grown up since then.
This omnibus also includes the short stories "The Alien Beast Within" (a prequel about Meh'Lindi first getting her genestealer implants) and "Warped Stars," which features Grimm during the period between Harlequin and Chaos Child.
That being said, the trilogy as a whole has some serious pacing problems. Draco, for instance, features a trip into the Eye of Terror and breaking into the Emperor's throne room, two enormous undertakings worthy of their own books yet are handled much too quickly and casually. Maybe Watson was aiming for a tragicomic jaunt through the 40k universe, except I barely even remember what happened in Harlequin even though I just read it several days ago, while Chaos Child is mostly Draco idling on a single planet and naval-gazing (isn't there an Inquisition war going on . . . ?), so I don’t see why Watson couldn't spread these events out across the entire trilogy. *goes to Harlequin's GR page* Oh right, they broke into the Eldar's Black Library, yet another huge accomplishment that should have been given way more attention than just another little adventure surrounded by mostly forgettable filler.
Also, Watson's treatment of female character is gross. They are constantly being sexualized, either grotesquely (i.e. that fat housewife in "Warped Stars") or as fanservice. Lots of one-handed typing going on when depicting Meh'Lindi in particular. (Compare that to the Ciaphas Cain series, which was also a straight male author writing a straight male protagonist with a hot girlfriend, yet didn't constantly drool over her and also featured a wide variety of other women with different roles and personalities.) Then . So glad Black Library has grown up since then.
This omnibus also includes the short stories "The Alien Beast Within" (a prequel about Meh'Lindi first getting her genestealer implants) and "Warped Stars," which features Grimm during the period between Harlequin and Chaos Child.
February 26, 2016
The Inquisition War combines three separate novels, telling the story of Jaq Draco, Imperial Inquisitor and his companions, as they battle an Eldar plot. Inquisition War is readable and enjoyable, the only real problem is that it's fairly easy to tell it was written as three books, the first book introduces the menace of the Hydra, a creature with psychic abilities that is introduced to countless worlds in order to eventually control the minds of all humans to destroy Chaos once and for all. In the second book more conspiracies are thrown in as the nature of the threat is expanded and Jaq isn't sure who he can trust inside the inquisition.
The problem is that basically all of this is thrown aside in the third book as it focuses on Jaq trying to resurrect the spirit of a lost companion. Then it is all wrapped up, sort of, in the last twenty pages with no resolution to the over-arching plot of the book. It was as if Ian Watson was running out of pages and just had to come up with some kind of conclusion to wrap it up.
Watson is still a solid writer and he has fun exploring the universe. He manages to stuff in everything but orks, you get Eldar, Chaos Marines, and Tyrannid, as well as Titans, assassins and rogue inquisitors.
I have no problem recommending the first 2 books to anyone who is a fan of WH40K novels, as long as you can accept that it's not a finished story and judging by how old it is, probably is going to remain that way.
The problem is that basically all of this is thrown aside in the third book as it focuses on Jaq trying to resurrect the spirit of a lost companion. Then it is all wrapped up, sort of, in the last twenty pages with no resolution to the over-arching plot of the book. It was as if Ian Watson was running out of pages and just had to come up with some kind of conclusion to wrap it up.
Watson is still a solid writer and he has fun exploring the universe. He manages to stuff in everything but orks, you get Eldar, Chaos Marines, and Tyrannid, as well as Titans, assassins and rogue inquisitors.
I have no problem recommending the first 2 books to anyone who is a fan of WH40K novels, as long as you can accept that it's not a finished story and judging by how old it is, probably is going to remain that way.
January 29, 2012
This book is intensely, intensely disturbing. Written in the early history of the evolution of the Warhammer 40K universe it shows just how appalingly grim and more than anything else, hopeless, the universe is. As you read, ou realize that the characters are insane and that they are unreliable narrators. It's absolutely breathtaking in it's depth of depravity and lunacy. This is not for the faint of heart. Reading this is the start of a deep and existential crisis of faith (for Imperium lovers that is!). It's psychotic!
July 31, 2019
A rather confusing narrative about a universe that I know little about. I don't play tabletop RPGs like Warhammer or D&D, so I don't know how close this novel follows the mythos of the established story. It's not as disturbing as anything Alejandro Jodorowsky has written in his Incal-verse graphic novels, but it comes close. Also, the characters are thoroughly unlikable and quite detestable. I will need to read more about the Warhammer 40k universe to fully understand this story...
May the Force be with you!
May the Force be with you!
February 18, 2025
Ian Watson was one of the first writers to tackle Warhammer 40K fiction in novel form. Generally disdained and rejected by the modern 40K "lore fans" because of its goofiness and how contrary it is to modern 'canon', the Inquisition War series (and also Watson's very hard to find novel SPACE MARINE, which shares a character with Inquisition War) were - by necessity - for a while the benchmark for this kind of fiction, but not too long after this series ended in 1995 Black Library started getting it moving with publishing more fiction - short fiction in 'Inferno' at first, but soon more books (I think Gaunt's Ghosts started in the late 90s, and there were the William King Space Wolf books around the same time). But as more books pumped out and the fictional world of Warhammer 40,000 deepened, the approach to canon got more and more serious and restrictive, plus the books seemed more and more concerned with large scale battles and demonstrating the worth of particular units which, what do you know, you can buy and use in your armies right now. (Hell - you can see the push to include more pitched battles and more accurate descriptions of Eldar and Chaos and Titan units towards the end of this series.)
It's a funny experience reading a book from where the Warhammer universe was still pretty new and not that similar to how it is now or even was a few years later - I started my fandom with 2nd edition, but for at least the first novel of this series, the source would have been Rogue Trader, about as different from modern 40K as Warhammer Fantasy was. As such, the background of the fictional world is a lot more spongy. At times, yes, Watson is faithfully hewing to what the games developers have come up with - a few times you can tell paragraphs are slightly rephrased from Warhammer rule books (I swear I recognise a lot from my beloved 2nd ed Codex Imperialis). Yet if it was just outdated takes on established lore I doubt this would have the reputation for insanity it has - a lot of this is wild, wacky and to my knowledge goes to places which weren't ever navigated again in quite this way. A polite way of saying it's not canon and the tone is far more breathless and full of bad jokes than you might expect, with secret and illogical Inquisitorial conspiracies, illegitimate non-Primarch sons of the Emperor, and very slapdash approaches to how easy it is to travel in the Eldar Webway. As well as strange teen-comix humour which often falls flat, the pace is pretty terrible - there are often long stretches of inaction and then too much happens all at once, especially in the earlier books and stories (Chaos Child, the finale, feels like the only one which really moves). For quite a lot of its page count, it's truly hilarious how off it seems - stuff wasn't codified quite so rigidly back then, but even in the mid-90s, it feels like this wasn't really the established way for Space Marines in particular to behave, but hell, almost everything we'd think we 'know' about the Imperium is contradicted here - religion, culture, function, military conduct. The tone just isn't really the monastic, self-serious tone I expect from 40K writing. Aptly, it feels like it's heavily influenced by Dune and Judge Dredd (two undeniable inspirations for 40K in general) but with a heavy dash of British dorky humour, think Python or Pratchett, not the darkness of 2000AD. But it is an odd experience for someone who likes or is used to the modern stuff - it's like watching a film dubbed in an unfamiliar language, you think you recognise things and then it stops making sense.
There's a pulpiness to the writing for sure - Watson loves comic book sound effects, particularly his annoying repeated SFX overload when boltguns fire. Like many pulp SF writers he loves to create grotesquely ugly characters and treat them cruelly, and create beautiful and sexualised women and, well, also treat them cruelly. He has some authorial quirks that become oddly endearing (the constant shit and piss references) and some which over time get insanely annoying (the tendency to drop a lot of rhetorical questions in the middle of the action). Partly I think you just get used to his quirks, partly he may actually have improved at 40K fiction as he went - but while the first novel and short stories were, to me, something of a chore, by the last book I was all in. (I also think it seems very likely that 'Chaos Child' wasn't meant to be the last chapter of Jaq Draco's story - too many plot points are left unresolved and are promised to be addressed in the very last moments of the novel - but unfortunately, this was all we got, and the current 'vibe' for Black Library surely doesn't fit with a new Ian Watson novel.)
Inquisition War is full of misjudged jokes, schlocky drama and frequently terrible dialogue. It's kind of awful, yet it's enjoyably different; I maybe read too much modern Astartes / Chaos fiction which tends to the over-serious and to pomposity, but it's hard not to wish there was a bit more of Watson's sense of fun in modern 40K. I definitely think, having read this, that Dan Abnett absolutely took inspiration from this Gonzo space opera stuff but added "grimdark" to the books much more effectively than Watson could. I suspect Dan would be writing a lot more in this style if he was allowed.
I'd say any fan of older editions of 40k should have a crack at this. It is not the first Warhammer book you should read - or even the hundredth - but it has its place.
6/10
It's a funny experience reading a book from where the Warhammer universe was still pretty new and not that similar to how it is now or even was a few years later - I started my fandom with 2nd edition, but for at least the first novel of this series, the source would have been Rogue Trader, about as different from modern 40K as Warhammer Fantasy was. As such, the background of the fictional world is a lot more spongy. At times, yes, Watson is faithfully hewing to what the games developers have come up with - a few times you can tell paragraphs are slightly rephrased from Warhammer rule books (I swear I recognise a lot from my beloved 2nd ed Codex Imperialis). Yet if it was just outdated takes on established lore I doubt this would have the reputation for insanity it has - a lot of this is wild, wacky and to my knowledge goes to places which weren't ever navigated again in quite this way. A polite way of saying it's not canon and the tone is far more breathless and full of bad jokes than you might expect, with secret and illogical Inquisitorial conspiracies, illegitimate non-Primarch sons of the Emperor, and very slapdash approaches to how easy it is to travel in the Eldar Webway. As well as strange teen-comix humour which often falls flat, the pace is pretty terrible - there are often long stretches of inaction and then too much happens all at once, especially in the earlier books and stories (Chaos Child, the finale, feels like the only one which really moves). For quite a lot of its page count, it's truly hilarious how off it seems - stuff wasn't codified quite so rigidly back then, but even in the mid-90s, it feels like this wasn't really the established way for Space Marines in particular to behave, but hell, almost everything we'd think we 'know' about the Imperium is contradicted here - religion, culture, function, military conduct. The tone just isn't really the monastic, self-serious tone I expect from 40K writing. Aptly, it feels like it's heavily influenced by Dune and Judge Dredd (two undeniable inspirations for 40K in general) but with a heavy dash of British dorky humour, think Python or Pratchett, not the darkness of 2000AD. But it is an odd experience for someone who likes or is used to the modern stuff - it's like watching a film dubbed in an unfamiliar language, you think you recognise things and then it stops making sense.
There's a pulpiness to the writing for sure - Watson loves comic book sound effects, particularly his annoying repeated SFX overload when boltguns fire. Like many pulp SF writers he loves to create grotesquely ugly characters and treat them cruelly, and create beautiful and sexualised women and, well, also treat them cruelly. He has some authorial quirks that become oddly endearing (the constant shit and piss references) and some which over time get insanely annoying (the tendency to drop a lot of rhetorical questions in the middle of the action). Partly I think you just get used to his quirks, partly he may actually have improved at 40K fiction as he went - but while the first novel and short stories were, to me, something of a chore, by the last book I was all in. (I also think it seems very likely that 'Chaos Child' wasn't meant to be the last chapter of Jaq Draco's story - too many plot points are left unresolved and are promised to be addressed in the very last moments of the novel - but unfortunately, this was all we got, and the current 'vibe' for Black Library surely doesn't fit with a new Ian Watson novel.)
Inquisition War is full of misjudged jokes, schlocky drama and frequently terrible dialogue. It's kind of awful, yet it's enjoyably different; I maybe read too much modern Astartes / Chaos fiction which tends to the over-serious and to pomposity, but it's hard not to wish there was a bit more of Watson's sense of fun in modern 40K. I definitely think, having read this, that Dan Abnett absolutely took inspiration from this Gonzo space opera stuff but added "grimdark" to the books much more effectively than Watson could. I suspect Dan would be writing a lot more in this style if he was allowed.
I'd say any fan of older editions of 40k should have a crack at this. It is not the first Warhammer book you should read - or even the hundredth - but it has its place.
6/10
Want to read
December 4, 2008This craptacular pulp was bought at the library, because I've been curious about the Warhammer series and...and it has this blurb:
'A ceaseless flow of ideas' - J.G. Ballard
Well, then.
'A ceaseless flow of ideas' - J.G. Ballard
Well, then.
December 5, 2013
Overlooked, this is one of the greatest Omnibi in the 40k universe. It is interesting to consider what is canon and why, but this series offers a very unique and intriguing perspective into the Warhammer 40k universe. One that is entirely unrepeated elsewhere.
March 29, 2014
The prose is hard to follow at times but the characters are interesting from the get go. Sadly the plot loses steam in the third book/act which acts more like a drawn out closure, but overall a good story in the 40K universe.
March 4, 2013
Not sure how this book series received low marks but I was impressed by it. I've always had penchant for Imperial Commissars & Inquisitors in the WH40K universe.
September 25, 2017
Well, my English vocabulary has certainly broadened.
But good grief, the sheer amount of needlessly complicated words and sentence structures got old really fast, and contributed to the amount of time it took me to forge my way through the whole book. The characters and plot would've been just as interesting without the elaborate prose.
With that out of the way, the story certainly is captivating, the main personae multi-faceted and deep, and it doesn't limit itself to standard notions about the 40K universe. At least those are undeniable positives.
But good grief, the sheer amount of needlessly complicated words and sentence structures got old really fast, and contributed to the amount of time it took me to forge my way through the whole book. The characters and plot would've been just as interesting without the elaborate prose.
With that out of the way, the story certainly is captivating, the main personae multi-faceted and deep, and it doesn't limit itself to standard notions about the 40K universe. At least those are undeniable positives.
August 19, 2021
Quick impressions: The stories do explore some interesting ideas, and they provide a look at the depths of the Inquisition, but the execution and telling of the stories leave a lot to be desired. It is a pity really. This book is mainly for the seriously hardcore fans of Warhammer 40,000, though I think even a few of them might agree with my assessment. For casual readers of this series, this is a book to skip.
(Full review posted on my blog)
(Full review posted on my blog)
May 21, 2020
It dragged a little by the end and something about the language didn't gel well with me, but the series was also a wealth of knowledge about the Warhammer 40K universe. It brought social and cultural aspects to the various demographics so for that I'm grateful. Essentially 800 pages of imaginative technology, not a book for everyone though.
August 23, 2018
Writing style was hard to follow.
September 26, 2023
Actually thought this started out really good but over time I gradually lost interest. I guess I am just not a fan of military sci-fi. Abandoned about 1/3 of the way through the first book.
August 20, 2025
Quite boring.
September 7, 2024
This collects three main stories and a few short stories. I only read the beginning short and the first main story “Draco”. I won’t continue to read the other collected stories.
I picked this up as a nostalgia read since “Draco” was the first WH40K novel I read. Unfortunately, as an adult, I didn’t quite care for this story. I love WarHammer, but this wasn’t as entertaining for me as recent reads. It had its moments, but moments can’t carry the whole.
I picked this up as a nostalgia read since “Draco” was the first WH40K novel I read. Unfortunately, as an adult, I didn’t quite care for this story. I love WarHammer, but this wasn’t as entertaining for me as recent reads. It had its moments, but moments can’t carry the whole.
February 17, 2015
very good
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews