What do you think?
Rate this book
Missing, Presumed Dead
In a dysfunctional marriage, it may seem convenient when the wife commits suicide, but things aren’t always what they seem.
Battling both a fractured marriage and the monsters in her cranium, Aisha leads a sequestered life on the outskirts of a town in the hills of North India. She struggles to stay functional and tries to wean herself off the pills that keep her from tipping over the edge. Meanwhile, Prithvi, the husband she once loved, seems as eager to be rid of her, as she is to flee from him. Only her children keep her tethered to her hearth.
One rainy afternoon, Heer, Aisha's half-sister, her father's illegitimate daughter from another woman, appears. Despite her misgivings, Aisha goes into town and never comes back. Seemingly unperturbed, Heer slips into her missing sister's shoes effortlessly, taking charge of the house, the kids-even Prithvi, who responds to her overtures willingly.
A note found in Aisha's wallet states that she has killed herself, although strange happenings leave room for doubts. But, if she is not dead, where is Aisha? Did she really commit suicide? has she been abducted or is she hiding? Why does Prithvi not grieve for his deceased wife? And why does Heer vanish without a trace one day, leaving no forwarding address?
Examining the destruction a dystopian marriage and mental illness leave in their wake, 'Missing Presumed Dead' confronts the fragility of relationships, the ugly truths about love and death and the horrifying loss of everything we hold dear, including ourselves.
Battling both a fractured marriage and the monsters in her cranium, Aisha leads a sequestered life on the outskirts of a town in the hills of North India. She struggles to stay functional and tries to wean herself off the pills that keep her from tipping over the edge. Meanwhile, Prithvi, the husband she once loved, seems as eager to be rid of her, as she is to flee from him. Only her children keep her tethered to her hearth.
One rainy afternoon, Heer, Aisha's half-sister, her father's illegitimate daughter from another woman, appears. Despite her misgivings, Aisha goes into town and never comes back. Seemingly unperturbed, Heer slips into her missing sister's shoes effortlessly, taking charge of the house, the kids-even Prithvi, who responds to her overtures willingly.
A note found in Aisha's wallet states that she has killed herself, although strange happenings leave room for doubts. But, if she is not dead, where is Aisha? Did she really commit suicide? has she been abducted or is she hiding? Why does Prithvi not grieve for his deceased wife? And why does Heer vanish without a trace one day, leaving no forwarding address?
Examining the destruction a dystopian marriage and mental illness leave in their wake, 'Missing Presumed Dead' confronts the fragility of relationships, the ugly truths about love and death and the horrifying loss of everything we hold dear, including ourselves.
- GenresMystery ThrillerFiction
268 pages, Paperback
Published July 15, 2018
7 people are currently reading
109 people want to read
About the author
Kiran Manral
27 books88 followersAfter quitting her full-time journalist’s job when her son was born, Kiran became a mommy blogger, on the internet, with a remarkably original voice. She was a journalist at The Asian Age, The Times of India, features editor Cosmopolitan, India Cultural Lead and Trendspotter at Gartner Iconoculture, Senior Consultant at Vector Insights and Ideas Editor, SheThePeople.TV. Kiran is currently a celebrated Author and an independent research and media consultant.
She was shortlisted for the Femina Women Awards for Literary Contribution in 2017. The Indian Council of UN Relations (ICUNR) with the Ministry of Women and Children, Govt of India, awarded her the International Women’s Day Award 2018 for excellence in the field of writing. In 2021 she was awarded the Womennovator 1000 Women of Asia award. In 2022, she was named amongst the 75 Iconic Indian women in STEAM by Red Dot Foundation and Beyond Black, in collaboration with the Office of the Principal Scientific Advisor, Government of India, and British High Commission, New Delhi.
Her novella, Saving Maya, was long-listed for the 2018 Saboteur Award, supported by the Arts Council of England in the UK. The Kitty Party Murder was shortlisted for the Popular Choice award at the 2021 JK Papers TOI AutHER awards and has been optioned for a series.
Her other books include The Reluctant Detective, Once Upon A Crush, All Aboard, Karmic Kids-The Story of Parenting Nobody Told You, A Boy’s Guide to Growing Up, True Love Stories, 13 Steps to Bloody Good Parenting, Raising Kids with Hope and Wonder in Times of a Pandemic and Climate Change, More Things in Heaven and Earth, Rising 30 Women Who Changed India, Rising 2.0: 20 More Women Who Changed India, All Those Who Wander and The Moon in the Lining of her Skin.
She also has published short stories in various magazines, in acclaimed anthologies like Have A Safe Journey, Boo, The Best Asian Speculative Fiction 2018, Grandpa’s Tales, Magical Women, City of Screams, The Hachette Book of Indian Detective Fiction and Hell Hath No Fury.
Her nonfiction book, Karmic Kids: The Story of Parenting Nobody Told You, was listed amongst the top five books on parenting by Indian authors in 2015 by the Sunday Guardian.
The Face at the Window, released in 2016, was listed amongst the top 30 books written by women authors in 2016 by The Ladies Finger, as among the must read books by contemporary women authors by BuzzingBubs and received much critical acclaim. The Times of India stated that “Manral may have very well pioneered the "Himalayan Gothic" genre” with this book. Her novella, Saving Maya, was long listed for the 2018 Saboteur Awards, UK, supported by the Arts Council England, The Kitty Party Murder was shortlisted for the AutHER Awards 2020 Popular Choice Awards. The Face at the Window was long listed at Jio MAMI Word to Screen and showcased at the Singapore International Film Festival. Monster Complex listed her in their global list titled "Urban Fantasy Showcase: 100 Authors To Know and Their Works." Desi Blitz listed her amongst the top seven horror writers from India. Her book, The Face at the Window, was listed in HoneyKids Asia's list of top picks of Asian Horror books alongside books like Han Kang's The Vegetarian, and The Ring. Bookstr.com listed her amongst "6 Fascinating Asian and Pacific Islander Horror Authors."
She was shortlisted for the Femina Women Awards for Literary Contribution in 2017. The Indian Council of UN Relations (ICUNR) with the Ministry of Women and Children, Govt of India, awarded her the International Women’s Day Award 2018 for excellence in the field of writing. In 2021 she was awarded the Womennovator 1000 Women of Asia award. In 2022, she was named amongst the 75 Iconic Indian women in STEAM by Red Dot Foundation and Beyond Black, in collaboration with the Office of the Principal Scientific Advisor, Government of India, and British High Commission, New Delhi.
Her novella, Saving Maya, was long-listed for the 2018 Saboteur Award, supported by the Arts Council of England in the UK. The Kitty Party Murder was shortlisted for the Popular Choice award at the 2021 JK Papers TOI AutHER awards and has been optioned for a series.
Her other books include The Reluctant Detective, Once Upon A Crush, All Aboard, Karmic Kids-The Story of Parenting Nobody Told You, A Boy’s Guide to Growing Up, True Love Stories, 13 Steps to Bloody Good Parenting, Raising Kids with Hope and Wonder in Times of a Pandemic and Climate Change, More Things in Heaven and Earth, Rising 30 Women Who Changed India, Rising 2.0: 20 More Women Who Changed India, All Those Who Wander and The Moon in the Lining of her Skin.
She also has published short stories in various magazines, in acclaimed anthologies like Have A Safe Journey, Boo, The Best Asian Speculative Fiction 2018, Grandpa’s Tales, Magical Women, City of Screams, The Hachette Book of Indian Detective Fiction and Hell Hath No Fury.
Her nonfiction book, Karmic Kids: The Story of Parenting Nobody Told You, was listed amongst the top five books on parenting by Indian authors in 2015 by the Sunday Guardian.
The Face at the Window, released in 2016, was listed amongst the top 30 books written by women authors in 2016 by The Ladies Finger, as among the must read books by contemporary women authors by BuzzingBubs and received much critical acclaim. The Times of India stated that “Manral may have very well pioneered the "Himalayan Gothic" genre” with this book. Her novella, Saving Maya, was long listed for the 2018 Saboteur Awards, UK, supported by the Arts Council England, The Kitty Party Murder was shortlisted for the AutHER Awards 2020 Popular Choice Awards. The Face at the Window was long listed at Jio MAMI Word to Screen and showcased at the Singapore International Film Festival. Monster Complex listed her in their global list titled "Urban Fantasy Showcase: 100 Authors To Know and Their Works." Desi Blitz listed her amongst the top seven horror writers from India. Her book, The Face at the Window, was listed in HoneyKids Asia's list of top picks of Asian Horror books alongside books like Han Kang's The Vegetarian, and The Ring. Bookstr.com listed her amongst "6 Fascinating Asian and Pacific Islander Horror Authors."
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 36 reviews
September 4, 2018
Aisha is caught between a dysfunctional marriage with Prithvi. They live on the outskirts of a town up in the hills in North India that keeps them socially unavailable. Aisha , who is fighting demons of her own has to rely on pills to keep her "sane" and functioning.
The only thing keeping her and Prithvi together despite a broken marriage are their children.
On a chaotic day with the weather gone all rough and the roads blocked , someone knocks not only at Aisha's door but also her married life. The person on the other side of the door is Heer , a young woman who looks exactly the younger version of Aisha and also happens to be her half-sister.
Despite the unfavorable weather , Aisha steps out of the house only to never return. Heer not only takes charge but also steps into the shoes of her sister's life , with the kids as well as Prithvi. A suicide note found in Aisha's wallet suggest she has attempted suicide but a strange discomfort leaves room for suspicions.
The setting of the book is brilliantly thought of. An abode in the outskirts of a town in the hills , the rough weather and the suspense created behind Aisha's suicide fits well with each other. The story gives you a realistic outlook on how mental illness screws up a person , eating on the inside and then affecting their relationship and close ones. The author also focuses on how the sexual life of a couple is disrupted after the birth of her child since it leaves an impact on the woman's physical appearance and how the man can't seem to come in terms with that. She knock downs the saying of "love the internal beauty" and how the physical outlook of a woman overpowers that. Manral speaks the mind of those hundred woman out their who battle anxiety , depression and what not , yet they wake up each day and fight their battle.
The author knows her way of making the characters feel realistic. The characters are woven with perfection and flaws alike. Aisha, who battles her demons keeps functioning for her children. She is the spying wife , thanks to her husband's lack of love towards her. Prithvi , the arrogant and disinterested husband (or so it seems) is never in the frame. He retires home at night after work and dozes off without much communication. The character progresses in the later stage when he sets on a journey to find the mystery about Heer and her disappearance. (Note- Aisha goes missing and yet this dotting husband that didn't give a damn but he filed a missing complaint when Heer went missing). Heer , the oh-so-charming young woman that catches Prithvi's lustful eyes and body that have been deprived of physical love.
The words just seem to flow in a speed that not only grips you to the story but doesn't let you to keep the book down. Manral's writing is one of a kind. Despite the dark nature of the book , she keeps the pace going and there isn't a dull moment in the entire book. Never have I ever read any book that explores the repercussions of mental health on a marriage with such an intensity.
Final Verdict
A dystopian setting , a disrupted married life and the demons inside the head , nobody could have pulled this off soo effortlessly than Manral. Spare an entire day out for this one , you'd want to complete this in just one sitting.
The only thing keeping her and Prithvi together despite a broken marriage are their children.
On a chaotic day with the weather gone all rough and the roads blocked , someone knocks not only at Aisha's door but also her married life. The person on the other side of the door is Heer , a young woman who looks exactly the younger version of Aisha and also happens to be her half-sister.
Despite the unfavorable weather , Aisha steps out of the house only to never return. Heer not only takes charge but also steps into the shoes of her sister's life , with the kids as well as Prithvi. A suicide note found in Aisha's wallet suggest she has attempted suicide but a strange discomfort leaves room for suspicions.
The setting of the book is brilliantly thought of. An abode in the outskirts of a town in the hills , the rough weather and the suspense created behind Aisha's suicide fits well with each other. The story gives you a realistic outlook on how mental illness screws up a person , eating on the inside and then affecting their relationship and close ones. The author also focuses on how the sexual life of a couple is disrupted after the birth of her child since it leaves an impact on the woman's physical appearance and how the man can't seem to come in terms with that. She knock downs the saying of "love the internal beauty" and how the physical outlook of a woman overpowers that. Manral speaks the mind of those hundred woman out their who battle anxiety , depression and what not , yet they wake up each day and fight their battle.
The author knows her way of making the characters feel realistic. The characters are woven with perfection and flaws alike. Aisha, who battles her demons keeps functioning for her children. She is the spying wife , thanks to her husband's lack of love towards her. Prithvi , the arrogant and disinterested husband (or so it seems) is never in the frame. He retires home at night after work and dozes off without much communication. The character progresses in the later stage when he sets on a journey to find the mystery about Heer and her disappearance. (Note- Aisha goes missing and yet this dotting husband that didn't give a damn but he filed a missing complaint when Heer went missing). Heer , the oh-so-charming young woman that catches Prithvi's lustful eyes and body that have been deprived of physical love.
The words just seem to flow in a speed that not only grips you to the story but doesn't let you to keep the book down. Manral's writing is one of a kind. Despite the dark nature of the book , she keeps the pace going and there isn't a dull moment in the entire book. Never have I ever read any book that explores the repercussions of mental health on a marriage with such an intensity.
Final Verdict
A dystopian setting , a disrupted married life and the demons inside the head , nobody could have pulled this off soo effortlessly than Manral. Spare an entire day out for this one , you'd want to complete this in just one sitting.
October 29, 2018
The beauty of this book lies in the immaculate character building and pristine storytelling skills. You empathise with every character and his or her mental state. So kudos to Kiran Mangal for the delectable descriptions and narrative.
The end though did not work for me. I don't know if I missed a point somewhere but it didn't give me a closure. Apart from this the book is a definitely a visual and literature treat.
The end though did not work for me. I don't know if I missed a point somewhere but it didn't give me a closure. Apart from this the book is a definitely a visual and literature treat.
August 31, 2018
The book begins with Aisha being startled by the doorbell. She is surprised to find that her half-sister Heer is on the other side of the door asking to be let in and to be a family. Heer looks deceptively similar to Aisha and takes on the responsibility of her Niece and Nephew like it was second nature. It is only when Aisha goes into town leaving the kids under Heer's jurisdiction, does she begin to suspect that Heer might not be as loving as she first appeared.
The story talks about Schizophrenia and depression in a very matter-of-fact way that is not usually found in books written by Indian authors. I appreciate the effort that the author put in to get the medical facts correct. However, I found that there were other inconsistencies in the story. It was very surprising to find that while everyone seemed to know the name of her half-sister, Aisha does not. I also wish that the author went back and forth between Prithvi's and Aisha's points of view in the latter half of the book like she did in the beginning. It would have made for better reading had the author explored more the relationship between Heer, the mysterious man, Aisha, and Prithvi. I personally am not a fan of ambiguous endings and in this book too I found the lack of closure a tad bit upsetting.
The book was slow to begin, the story only picking up after the first half. The aptly named 'Book 2' is where I found most of the action. I loved the way that the kids were described. Their avoidance of their quarreling parents, the maternal instincts of the big sister towards her younger brother, the anguish at the death of their mother, the nonacceptance of a new lady in the house and the grief of being sent away were heartbreaking. I just wish that the book was better edited to avoid repetition of redundant sentences.
However, I did like the concept of the book and the premise was interesting. It was indeed the thriller that it claimed to be albeit lacking a bit in execution. There were a couple of pages that gave me chills and had me staying up past my bedtime to know what was going to happen next.
The story talks about Schizophrenia and depression in a very matter-of-fact way that is not usually found in books written by Indian authors. I appreciate the effort that the author put in to get the medical facts correct. However, I found that there were other inconsistencies in the story. It was very surprising to find that while everyone seemed to know the name of her half-sister, Aisha does not. I also wish that the author went back and forth between Prithvi's and Aisha's points of view in the latter half of the book like she did in the beginning. It would have made for better reading had the author explored more the relationship between Heer, the mysterious man, Aisha, and Prithvi. I personally am not a fan of ambiguous endings and in this book too I found the lack of closure a tad bit upsetting.
The book was slow to begin, the story only picking up after the first half. The aptly named 'Book 2' is where I found most of the action. I loved the way that the kids were described. Their avoidance of their quarreling parents, the maternal instincts of the big sister towards her younger brother, the anguish at the death of their mother, the nonacceptance of a new lady in the house and the grief of being sent away were heartbreaking. I just wish that the book was better edited to avoid repetition of redundant sentences.
However, I did like the concept of the book and the premise was interesting. It was indeed the thriller that it claimed to be albeit lacking a bit in execution. There were a couple of pages that gave me chills and had me staying up past my bedtime to know what was going to happen next.
August 1, 2018
Note: I read very few fiction books in a year.
Having read and liked Kiran Manral's debut novel, a funny murder mystery of a unique kind, and knowing a bit about (though not having read) her subsequent novels spanning a romance and a tale with other-worldly presence, I looked forward to a good read with her latest novel, "Missing, Presumed Dead". I did read and like her spooky sci-fi short story published online by Juggernaut Books.
Without including revealing spoilers, let me say that this novel does not disappoint from the genre-busting plots that Kiran manages to weave. The blurbs and reviews already set the reader up to expect mystery surrounding a protagonist suffering from mental illness. The author has said that she is fascinated with spooky elements so this story has an undercurrent of that, too.
The significant thing about this novel is the writing. Any simple dialogue or thought by the characters is turned into a tantalising portent of dark happenings. Beautiful phrases abound, and encapsulate a sweeping commentary on the times we live. The fragility of well presented appearances and relationships is examined, almost mercilessly exposed for its more realistic dimensions, but the author manages to still create an empathy in the reader for the characters. None of the characters is without flaws but they are all believable, even if it is just a passerby who comes and disappears within a few lines of the story.
The build up to something disastrous about to happen is continuous, right from the first two chapters. As the apparently disconnected events begin to coalesce, the mental states of the characters unravels, and the plot unfolds but Kiran manages to inject enough twists to pile up the puzzles rather than gradually demystify the goings on for the reader.
At one point I felt there are not enough pages to have one grand illuminating finale accounting for everything with a level of satisfactory consistency and clarity. In a way my suspicion proved correct and though there is no other ending I would have probably liked more, there are enough elements left without explanation for an interesting sequel at some point in time.
What I most admired about Missing, Presumed Dead is that within a readable and racy story, Kiran Manral--based on research and interviews as mentioned in the acknowledgement--has presented the agonies of a person suffering from mental illness as well as the anguish that their near ones go through, without simplifying it to a one-sided narrative.
Having read and liked Kiran Manral's debut novel, a funny murder mystery of a unique kind, and knowing a bit about (though not having read) her subsequent novels spanning a romance and a tale with other-worldly presence, I looked forward to a good read with her latest novel, "Missing, Presumed Dead". I did read and like her spooky sci-fi short story published online by Juggernaut Books.
Without including revealing spoilers, let me say that this novel does not disappoint from the genre-busting plots that Kiran manages to weave. The blurbs and reviews already set the reader up to expect mystery surrounding a protagonist suffering from mental illness. The author has said that she is fascinated with spooky elements so this story has an undercurrent of that, too.
The significant thing about this novel is the writing. Any simple dialogue or thought by the characters is turned into a tantalising portent of dark happenings. Beautiful phrases abound, and encapsulate a sweeping commentary on the times we live. The fragility of well presented appearances and relationships is examined, almost mercilessly exposed for its more realistic dimensions, but the author manages to still create an empathy in the reader for the characters. None of the characters is without flaws but they are all believable, even if it is just a passerby who comes and disappears within a few lines of the story.
The build up to something disastrous about to happen is continuous, right from the first two chapters. As the apparently disconnected events begin to coalesce, the mental states of the characters unravels, and the plot unfolds but Kiran manages to inject enough twists to pile up the puzzles rather than gradually demystify the goings on for the reader.
At one point I felt there are not enough pages to have one grand illuminating finale accounting for everything with a level of satisfactory consistency and clarity. In a way my suspicion proved correct and though there is no other ending I would have probably liked more, there are enough elements left without explanation for an interesting sequel at some point in time.
What I most admired about Missing, Presumed Dead is that within a readable and racy story, Kiran Manral--based on research and interviews as mentioned in the acknowledgement--has presented the agonies of a person suffering from mental illness as well as the anguish that their near ones go through, without simplifying it to a one-sided narrative.
August 3, 2019
As much as I love reading books, there are some books which leave an impression and even when the read is over the mind still stays glued to it, and the characters within the story.
Kiran Manral's book "Missing, Presumed Dead" is one such book, which left me thinking for a long time. It's a Mystery thriller, categorized as "Fiction" series and is published by "Amaryllis" (An imprint of Manjul Publishing House Pvt. Ltd)
To begin with, the 'Cover page' of the book itself is quite interesting. A female face revealing only the lips and nose overshadowed by the valley and trees. It gives the hint that the story is about a female who probably lives in fear and isolation.
The book is written in two parts :
"Book 1" reveals the story of "Aisha" the mentally disturbed mother and a wife who has suicidal tendencies.
"Book 2" gives way to her husband "Prithvi" who is an academician working on a private project for a US based organization who has opted to stay in small Himalayan town away from city hustle bustle.
Aisha and Prithvi were in love who gets married and have two kids, elder daughter "Maya" and a younger son "Aryan"
The trouble starts in their marriage more after the birth of Aryan and this makes the plot of this Novel.
The distance between them grows to an extent that their relationship has come to a stage where Aisha wants to flee with her children to some far off place where she could not be found. Prithvi too is sick of Aisha and wants to get rid of her.
"Heer" Aisha's half sister (her father's illegitimate daughter) whom she had never seen before, arrives one day all of a sudden at her house, which is located far from town in isolation.
It was raining and the weather too bad, but Aisha needs to go to town to collect her package. Road leading to town is closed and she can go no further unless she march on foot.
"Daljeet" who is in the town for work sees Aisha and offers help by driving her to town in his SUV.
The weather makes it impossible for Aisha to return home, and she stays with Daljeet in his summer home which is a closely guarded mansion.
Daljeet is a divorcee and Aisha a vulnerable woman, two broken hearts reach out to each other. A perfect setting for two strangers who will never see each other again, leads to series of steaming sex.
But little did Aisha knew what she was getting into, until the day she found herself confined to a dark and isolated out house.
Heer in Aisha's absence takes charge of the house, and kids and most importantly Prithvi.
From the time Prithvi lay her eyes on Heer he wanted her. Aisha's absence made it all the more easier for him.
A local shepherd finds Aisha's wallet lying on the road where the bridge was broken, with a suicide note in it and hands it over to the Police. Inspector SD Pant calls Prithvi enquiring about Aisha.
The story takes a new turn, now that Aisha is declared "Missing, Presumed Dead" by the police.
There is an ancestral Kothi and other properties which belonged to Aisha. Prithvi wanted to sell it earlier but Aisha was against the idea.
The plot gets so intriguing that as I kept reading further and as new facts revealed themselves I kept wondering, and tried fitting the pieces together ( in my mind) as in jigsaw puzzle and kept asking myself, what next? The characters and their behavior is very unpredictable, and kept me hooked to the book. I finished book in one go with little breaks.
Only when you will read the book will you unfold the mystery which will keep you spell bound in a way you won't even imagine...What was Heer's motive, why did she come all of a sudden to Aisha's house? Why Prithvi kept his family out of town? What happened to Aisha? Was she really dead or managed to put her plan into action? Why was Daljeet in town, and was it just a coincidence or a well laid plan to bump into Aisha?
Kiran Manral's book will keep you hooked till the last page, the suspense keeps building as you progress reading to find out more. Well defined characters, with intricate details of their surroundings and locations and a gripping story, is what you will come across.
The writing is elegant (with some heavy words) and I enjoyed reading this riveting book thoroughly (all 260 pages of it)
My rating for the book is good 4/ 5 and I strongly recommend that you read this book.
Kiran Manral's book "Missing, Presumed Dead" is one such book, which left me thinking for a long time. It's a Mystery thriller, categorized as "Fiction" series and is published by "Amaryllis" (An imprint of Manjul Publishing House Pvt. Ltd)
To begin with, the 'Cover page' of the book itself is quite interesting. A female face revealing only the lips and nose overshadowed by the valley and trees. It gives the hint that the story is about a female who probably lives in fear and isolation.
The book is written in two parts :
"Book 1" reveals the story of "Aisha" the mentally disturbed mother and a wife who has suicidal tendencies.
"Book 2" gives way to her husband "Prithvi" who is an academician working on a private project for a US based organization who has opted to stay in small Himalayan town away from city hustle bustle.
Aisha and Prithvi were in love who gets married and have two kids, elder daughter "Maya" and a younger son "Aryan"
The trouble starts in their marriage more after the birth of Aryan and this makes the plot of this Novel.
The distance between them grows to an extent that their relationship has come to a stage where Aisha wants to flee with her children to some far off place where she could not be found. Prithvi too is sick of Aisha and wants to get rid of her.
"Heer" Aisha's half sister (her father's illegitimate daughter) whom she had never seen before, arrives one day all of a sudden at her house, which is located far from town in isolation.
It was raining and the weather too bad, but Aisha needs to go to town to collect her package. Road leading to town is closed and she can go no further unless she march on foot.
"Daljeet" who is in the town for work sees Aisha and offers help by driving her to town in his SUV.
The weather makes it impossible for Aisha to return home, and she stays with Daljeet in his summer home which is a closely guarded mansion.
Daljeet is a divorcee and Aisha a vulnerable woman, two broken hearts reach out to each other. A perfect setting for two strangers who will never see each other again, leads to series of steaming sex.
But little did Aisha knew what she was getting into, until the day she found herself confined to a dark and isolated out house.
Heer in Aisha's absence takes charge of the house, and kids and most importantly Prithvi.
From the time Prithvi lay her eyes on Heer he wanted her. Aisha's absence made it all the more easier for him.
A local shepherd finds Aisha's wallet lying on the road where the bridge was broken, with a suicide note in it and hands it over to the Police. Inspector SD Pant calls Prithvi enquiring about Aisha.
The story takes a new turn, now that Aisha is declared "Missing, Presumed Dead" by the police.
There is an ancestral Kothi and other properties which belonged to Aisha. Prithvi wanted to sell it earlier but Aisha was against the idea.
The plot gets so intriguing that as I kept reading further and as new facts revealed themselves I kept wondering, and tried fitting the pieces together ( in my mind) as in jigsaw puzzle and kept asking myself, what next? The characters and their behavior is very unpredictable, and kept me hooked to the book. I finished book in one go with little breaks.
Only when you will read the book will you unfold the mystery which will keep you spell bound in a way you won't even imagine...What was Heer's motive, why did she come all of a sudden to Aisha's house? Why Prithvi kept his family out of town? What happened to Aisha? Was she really dead or managed to put her plan into action? Why was Daljeet in town, and was it just a coincidence or a well laid plan to bump into Aisha?
Kiran Manral's book will keep you hooked till the last page, the suspense keeps building as you progress reading to find out more. Well defined characters, with intricate details of their surroundings and locations and a gripping story, is what you will come across.
The writing is elegant (with some heavy words) and I enjoyed reading this riveting book thoroughly (all 260 pages of it)
My rating for the book is good 4/ 5 and I strongly recommend that you read this book.
July 30, 2018
A Riveting, Spine-tingling Whodunit
Kiran Manral has done it again. Delved into an entirely new genre, after expertly exploring diverse ones—from romance to parenting to horror. With 'Missing, Presumed Dead', Manral has ventured into the arena of suspense and crime. The protagonist, Aisha Thakur, who lives a cloistered life on the outskirts of a bustling tourist town in the hills of North India, battles the demons in her brain every day, struggling to stay functional and sane, and be a caring parent to her two children. Her marriage to Prithvi is long over, and what remains is a frictional relationship, in which both Aisha and Prithvi have grown to distrust each other, leading to unpredictable behaviour. Enter Heer, Aisha’s half sister from her father’s relationship with another woman, and the already teetering Thakur household is thrown completely out of gear. Unforeseeable events ensue that disrupt their lives completely.
It is this unpredictability that Manral keeps alive throughout as she examines the wreckage of a dystopian marriage and its impact on the family, especially the children. Through Aisha, Manral probes the dark, lonely, tormented world of a woman, whose post partum depression goes unattended and who struggles to stay on an even keel, even as she resists the medication that keeps her mental illness on a leash. Manral portrays this oscillation in evocative language, as she creates an eerie, tense and suspenseful atmosphere. The characters, be it the unhinged Aisha, the ill-tempered Prithvi, the manipulative and sly Heer, the creepy inspector, or the chillingly smooth and dangerous Daljeet, are fleshed out wonderfully, their complexities, eccentricities and mind-games making them admirably nuanced. Through Aisha, the author brings out the imperativeness of tender care and empathy for those on the brink, the devastating aftermath of rejection, the havoc body shaming can wreak on the psyche of the vulnerable, and the mechanics of a disturbed mind that can drive a woman to leave home.
'Missing Presumed Dead' keeps the readers guessing, as its unreliable characters ensure that the plot has enough twists and turns that add to the constant sense of impending doom. The narrative brings us face to face with the fragility of relationships, the ugly truths about love, and the horrifying loss of everything we hold dear. The prose is strong, the style racy, and the language eloquent. The writing effectively blends action with memorable characterisation, steamy sex, an unexpected ending, and an all-over feeling of unease. A solidly crafted story, Missing, Presumed Dead is an impressive, gripping, disquieting read.
Kiran Manral has done it again. Delved into an entirely new genre, after expertly exploring diverse ones—from romance to parenting to horror. With 'Missing, Presumed Dead', Manral has ventured into the arena of suspense and crime. The protagonist, Aisha Thakur, who lives a cloistered life on the outskirts of a bustling tourist town in the hills of North India, battles the demons in her brain every day, struggling to stay functional and sane, and be a caring parent to her two children. Her marriage to Prithvi is long over, and what remains is a frictional relationship, in which both Aisha and Prithvi have grown to distrust each other, leading to unpredictable behaviour. Enter Heer, Aisha’s half sister from her father’s relationship with another woman, and the already teetering Thakur household is thrown completely out of gear. Unforeseeable events ensue that disrupt their lives completely.
It is this unpredictability that Manral keeps alive throughout as she examines the wreckage of a dystopian marriage and its impact on the family, especially the children. Through Aisha, Manral probes the dark, lonely, tormented world of a woman, whose post partum depression goes unattended and who struggles to stay on an even keel, even as she resists the medication that keeps her mental illness on a leash. Manral portrays this oscillation in evocative language, as she creates an eerie, tense and suspenseful atmosphere. The characters, be it the unhinged Aisha, the ill-tempered Prithvi, the manipulative and sly Heer, the creepy inspector, or the chillingly smooth and dangerous Daljeet, are fleshed out wonderfully, their complexities, eccentricities and mind-games making them admirably nuanced. Through Aisha, the author brings out the imperativeness of tender care and empathy for those on the brink, the devastating aftermath of rejection, the havoc body shaming can wreak on the psyche of the vulnerable, and the mechanics of a disturbed mind that can drive a woman to leave home.
'Missing Presumed Dead' keeps the readers guessing, as its unreliable characters ensure that the plot has enough twists and turns that add to the constant sense of impending doom. The narrative brings us face to face with the fragility of relationships, the ugly truths about love, and the horrifying loss of everything we hold dear. The prose is strong, the style racy, and the language eloquent. The writing effectively blends action with memorable characterisation, steamy sex, an unexpected ending, and an all-over feeling of unease. A solidly crafted story, Missing, Presumed Dead is an impressive, gripping, disquieting read.
Read
November 23, 2018Missing Presumed Dead is in the genre of suspense thrillers that I absolutely love. I read it on my Kindle over the last weekend. Once the book catches pace, it is unputdownable. I read it in 4 hours flat and stayed up till 1.30 at night reading it.
This is a story of Aisha, who suffers from mental health issues. The book opens with Heer, Aisha's half sister, visiting her home in the mountains in the middle of a storm. With her visit, things start spiralling out of control. The first half of the book covers the tale from Aisha's point of view who is an unhappy middle-aged woman who knew love at one time but now feels unwanted, unloved and battling demons inside her head. She struggles to stay sane for the sake of her children who are facing the repercussions of an unhealthy home environment. Her husband, Prithvi, who comes across as a villain in the first half gets to tell his side of the story in the second half.
Things pick up pace when Aisha meets Daljeet, a handsome stranger who seems to fill the void in her mind and life. Uncannily, he understand her very well. But things are not as they seem. The author, Kiran Manral, makes sure that you keep guessing the next move. She also deftly covers mental illness and taboos surrounding it and how it is extremely harsh on the caregivers. In the initial parts, I found some of her descriptions rambling and repetitive but the narrative becomes tighter as the book moves forward.
The end leaves many unanswered questions, and I wonder if there will be a sequel coming up. Overall, an engrossing read and a book worth every penny.
Kiran is a master storyteller, slowly revealing the complexities in the tale little by little. She fleshes out the characters really well and the best part is that her characters are very real and relatable. This is not just a mystery tale but a story that deftly handles mental illness and its consequences, relationships and their intricacies, parenthood and much more. My recommendation -- go read it!
This is a story of Aisha, who suffers from mental health issues. The book opens with Heer, Aisha's half sister, visiting her home in the mountains in the middle of a storm. With her visit, things start spiralling out of control. The first half of the book covers the tale from Aisha's point of view who is an unhappy middle-aged woman who knew love at one time but now feels unwanted, unloved and battling demons inside her head. She struggles to stay sane for the sake of her children who are facing the repercussions of an unhealthy home environment. Her husband, Prithvi, who comes across as a villain in the first half gets to tell his side of the story in the second half.
Things pick up pace when Aisha meets Daljeet, a handsome stranger who seems to fill the void in her mind and life. Uncannily, he understand her very well. But things are not as they seem. The author, Kiran Manral, makes sure that you keep guessing the next move. She also deftly covers mental illness and taboos surrounding it and how it is extremely harsh on the caregivers. In the initial parts, I found some of her descriptions rambling and repetitive but the narrative becomes tighter as the book moves forward.
The end leaves many unanswered questions, and I wonder if there will be a sequel coming up. Overall, an engrossing read and a book worth every penny.
Kiran is a master storyteller, slowly revealing the complexities in the tale little by little. She fleshes out the characters really well and the best part is that her characters are very real and relatable. This is not just a mystery tale but a story that deftly handles mental illness and its consequences, relationships and their intricacies, parenthood and much more. My recommendation -- go read it!
November 4, 2018
This is a fantastic read. Set in a perfect location, the story unfolds beautifully and reaches the unexpected ending. Kiran has surpassed herself with this book. Not everyone can write about mental illness so deftly. The intricacies of human life, the complexities of relationships and self all are integrated with utmost precision by the author. It is a change from regular marital narratives where most of the time women’s stories take a backseat. Here the focus is on the woman as an individual and not on th various social roles she plays all though her life. The story explores her inner self and how she tries endlessly to balance who she is and what she is supposed to be. One must read the book to find out not just about Aisha but about oneself too. I connected with her story at many levels and I am sure she has managed to touch the lives of many women who battle anxiety, depression, panic and disillusionment each day and struggle to find an escape. You know the feeling of having one foot in the abyss and another on a loose rock. Through her fluid narration and well crafted characters Kiran managed to keep me engaged. There was never a dull moment in the story. I definitely recommend it to all. I bet you will be mulling over this searing narrative for a long time.
August 18, 2018
Kiran Manral cements herself as legend in the genre of Mystery with Missing, Presumed Dead.
"There is a trembling eloquence to certain silences that words would only diminish, that can draw two people together the same way other silences tear two people apart."
Missing, Presumed Dead by Kiran Manral is the perfect mystery because it fools you - the reader. It presents all the possible facts from within the lives of its central characters. So much so that you are absolutely absorbed by them, undoubting of the intentions of seemingly mundane characters that are lurking, marching forth strategically from the recesses of the background. Do you think you know your family? Well, think again.
Narrated in two parts, the characters unravel like the twisty folktales of childhood. They dance at the altar of pragmatism and informed choices of adulthood, just as much as they blend and mingle with their need for freedom, their primal natures and the greedy clutches of insidious human forces. This book deals with darkness, both the physical manifestations of it and the monsters within. But what sets the characters apart are the reasons and sources of their varying depravity. One is at the mercy of her mind, while the others are working for their vices. There is absolutely nothing mundane about these characters - they reel you in and you are compelled to read their story. But most importantly, you want to know how it all ends.
Kiran Manral grips you with her writing -
each line is lyrical and haunting, building up to suspense that spurs you on. The action and dialogue are paced brilliantly, with just the right amount of give while maintaining an air of mystery.
Missing, Presumed Dead is one of those books that come along after an interlude of mind-numbing narratives. Aisha's history, psyche, actions and story are to be delved into. Because once you start reading, you won't stop turning the pages and opening the doors that the characters leave ajar - inviting you to tap into their dark and alluring world. Nothing is as it seems and Kiran Manral crafts a tale resplendent in both intrigue and terror. Missing, Presumed Dead is an absolute must read!
"There is a trembling eloquence to certain silences that words would only diminish, that can draw two people together the same way other silences tear two people apart."
Missing, Presumed Dead by Kiran Manral is the perfect mystery because it fools you - the reader. It presents all the possible facts from within the lives of its central characters. So much so that you are absolutely absorbed by them, undoubting of the intentions of seemingly mundane characters that are lurking, marching forth strategically from the recesses of the background. Do you think you know your family? Well, think again.
Narrated in two parts, the characters unravel like the twisty folktales of childhood. They dance at the altar of pragmatism and informed choices of adulthood, just as much as they blend and mingle with their need for freedom, their primal natures and the greedy clutches of insidious human forces. This book deals with darkness, both the physical manifestations of it and the monsters within. But what sets the characters apart are the reasons and sources of their varying depravity. One is at the mercy of her mind, while the others are working for their vices. There is absolutely nothing mundane about these characters - they reel you in and you are compelled to read their story. But most importantly, you want to know how it all ends.
Kiran Manral grips you with her writing -
each line is lyrical and haunting, building up to suspense that spurs you on. The action and dialogue are paced brilliantly, with just the right amount of give while maintaining an air of mystery.
Missing, Presumed Dead is one of those books that come along after an interlude of mind-numbing narratives. Aisha's history, psyche, actions and story are to be delved into. Because once you start reading, you won't stop turning the pages and opening the doors that the characters leave ajar - inviting you to tap into their dark and alluring world. Nothing is as it seems and Kiran Manral crafts a tale resplendent in both intrigue and terror. Missing, Presumed Dead is an absolute must read!
August 21, 2019
What I loved about the book – Missing, Presumed Dead published by Amaryllis….
Simple language with a few words that makes you look up into the dictionary. Which is good because you get to know the new words! 🙂
The cover of the book is usual but doesn’t strike you as anything extraordinary. When you complete the book, you get the gist of why the way it is like that.
Good insights into the human relationships and thought processes as to how things can simply go wrong.
The story gathers momentum and there’s never a dull moment.
Finished the whole book in one go. (I read fast… so don’t get disheartened if you take two days).
What I didn’t like? Why I had left this book in wishlist for so long? Just happy that I have finally read it now!
Simple language with a few words that makes you look up into the dictionary. Which is good because you get to know the new words! 🙂
The cover of the book is usual but doesn’t strike you as anything extraordinary. When you complete the book, you get the gist of why the way it is like that.
Good insights into the human relationships and thought processes as to how things can simply go wrong.
The story gathers momentum and there’s never a dull moment.
Finished the whole book in one go. (I read fast… so don’t get disheartened if you take two days).
What I didn’t like? Why I had left this book in wishlist for so long? Just happy that I have finally read it now!
January 7, 2020
Just finished 'Missing, Presumed Dead' by Kiran Manral ___very intriguing storyline, lyrical prose that creates vivid imagery, and so engrossing that it traveled with me to my kitchen.
If I have to pick something that bothered me a little, then it would be the usage of several unusual and tough words, for example ___'She came to him a tabula rasa.' or 'sepulchral' manner or 'pulchritude' of aromas etc. but it's my problem, I guess. I take it as a learning experience. The ending is a little unconventional for a novel but I liked it.
My first 2020 book. Very good start, I'd say.
If I have to pick something that bothered me a little, then it would be the usage of several unusual and tough words, for example ___'She came to him a tabula rasa.' or 'sepulchral' manner or 'pulchritude' of aromas etc. but it's my problem, I guess. I take it as a learning experience. The ending is a little unconventional for a novel but I liked it.
My first 2020 book. Very good start, I'd say.
August 31, 2018
Kiran Manral has put together a thrilling tale that is shocking and relatable at the same time. It’s interesting in an addictive sort of way!
What I personally liked the most about reading this one was how the author has made use of the atmosphere as another character. You are in the cold hills, and part of the thrill is the scenario surrounding the story. For someone like me, who loves the brooding English novel, this is the closest any Indian author has come to creating a similar aura.
It’s a must read!
What I personally liked the most about reading this one was how the author has made use of the atmosphere as another character. You are in the cold hills, and part of the thrill is the scenario surrounding the story. For someone like me, who loves the brooding English novel, this is the closest any Indian author has come to creating a similar aura.
It’s a must read!
August 8, 2019
Kiran Manral’s Missing,Presumed Dead is multi-layered thriller intelligently weaving emotional turmoil, mental trauma and ups and downs of a relationship in a relatable plot. Aisha and Prithvi’s marriage goes downhill when Aisha starts showing signs of mental illness. Her children try to cope up with the phases in which their mother is in and out of sanity. Aisha struggles to fight the monsters in her head and salvage whatever is left of her dysfunctional marriage.
The story is fast-paced and you will find yourself turning pages one after the other. The characters convey their stories convincingly. However, the ending was way too complicated and disappointing for me. It could have been better. There were some stark disparities in the plot but the narration of the story makes up for the loss. If you like thrillers, I don’t think you should miss this one.
August 23, 2018
Kiran Manral cements herself as legend in the genre of Mystery with Missing, Presumed Dead.
"There is a trembling eloquence to certain silences that words would only diminish, that can draw two people together the same way other silences tear two people apart."
Missing, Presumed Dead by Kiran Manral is the perfect mystery because it fools you - the reader. It presents all the possible facts from within the lives of its central characters. So much so that you are absolutely absorbed by them, undoubting of the intentions of seemingly mundane characters that are lurking, marching forth strategically from the recesses of the background. Do you think you know your family? Well, think again.
Narrated in two parts, the characters unravel like the twisty folktales of childhood. They dance at the altar of pragmatism and informed choices of adulthood, just as much as they blend and mingle with their need for freedom, their primal natures and the greedy clutches of insidious human forces. This book deals with darkness, both the physical manifestations of it and the monsters within. But what sets the characters apart are the reasons and sources of their varying depravity. One is at the mercy of her mind, while the others are working for their vices. There is absolutely nothing mundane about these characters - they reel you in and you are compelled to read their story. But most importantly, you want to know how it all ends.
Kiran Manral grips you with her writing -
each line is lyrical and haunting, building up to suspense that spurs you on. The action and dialogue are paced brilliantly, with just the right amount of give while maintaining an air of mystery.
Missing, Presumed Dead is one of those books that come along after an interlude of mind-numbing narratives. Aisha's history, psyche, actions and story are to be delved into. Because once you start reading, you won't stop turning the pages and opening the doors that the characters leave ajar - inviting you to tap into their dark and alluring world. Nothing is as it seems and Kiran Manral crafts a tale resplendent in both intrigue and terror. Missing, Presumed Dead is an absolute must read!
"There is a trembling eloquence to certain silences that words would only diminish, that can draw two people together the same way other silences tear two people apart."
Missing, Presumed Dead by Kiran Manral is the perfect mystery because it fools you - the reader. It presents all the possible facts from within the lives of its central characters. So much so that you are absolutely absorbed by them, undoubting of the intentions of seemingly mundane characters that are lurking, marching forth strategically from the recesses of the background. Do you think you know your family? Well, think again.
Narrated in two parts, the characters unravel like the twisty folktales of childhood. They dance at the altar of pragmatism and informed choices of adulthood, just as much as they blend and mingle with their need for freedom, their primal natures and the greedy clutches of insidious human forces. This book deals with darkness, both the physical manifestations of it and the monsters within. But what sets the characters apart are the reasons and sources of their varying depravity. One is at the mercy of her mind, while the others are working for their vices. There is absolutely nothing mundane about these characters - they reel you in and you are compelled to read their story. But most importantly, you want to know how it all ends.
Kiran Manral grips you with her writing -
each line is lyrical and haunting, building up to suspense that spurs you on. The action and dialogue are paced brilliantly, with just the right amount of give while maintaining an air of mystery.
Missing, Presumed Dead is one of those books that come along after an interlude of mind-numbing narratives. Aisha's history, psyche, actions and story are to be delved into. Because once you start reading, you won't stop turning the pages and opening the doors that the characters leave ajar - inviting you to tap into their dark and alluring world. Nothing is as it seems and Kiran Manral crafts a tale resplendent in both intrigue and terror. Missing, Presumed Dead is an absolute must read!
February 19, 2019
It has been a while I read this but missed posting review on Goodreads. I picked it up assuming it to be thriller, but the book was much more in addition to being a thriller. The book gives you peek in Aisha's life who is in dysfunctional matrimony with Prithvi. Aisha suffers from illness and living consistently in the fear that one day demons in her head will take over her completely. Aisha and Prithvi live away from hustle bustle in remote area of hill town with their young kids. Despite their cracked marriage they continue to live under the same roof with for the sake of their kids or for the sake of love or life they once shared together. Their life takes different turn when one stormy night Aisha's half sister Heer arrives at her doorstep.Then as if by coincidence Aisha meets handsome and young man, Daljeet who interestingly, takes an immediate liking for her. The story moves much faster thereafter and you find it difficult to put the book down.
What I liked about the book? Kiran's writing, its poetic and laced with beautiful words. Beauty of the prose is such that you just want to stay with the narrative, delve in the world writer has created and soak in it for the time being. Writer has explored each and every corner of her characters mind and put out there brilliantly. She has cleverly portrayed Aisha's character, her insecurities and her mental illness. The book also has Prithvi's narrative which has equal space and its written from man's perspective.
What I felt wanting was closure. There is no definite closure to the story in the book and for a suspense cum thriller angle I want all answers. I wish the book was complete in that sense.
However, overall i thoroughly enjoyed reading this book and it was an overwhelming experience for me.
What I liked about the book? Kiran's writing, its poetic and laced with beautiful words. Beauty of the prose is such that you just want to stay with the narrative, delve in the world writer has created and soak in it for the time being. Writer has explored each and every corner of her characters mind and put out there brilliantly. She has cleverly portrayed Aisha's character, her insecurities and her mental illness. The book also has Prithvi's narrative which has equal space and its written from man's perspective.
What I felt wanting was closure. There is no definite closure to the story in the book and for a suspense cum thriller angle I want all answers. I wish the book was complete in that sense.
However, overall i thoroughly enjoyed reading this book and it was an overwhelming experience for me.
April 20, 2019
I read a good suspense book after really long. I did have my share of issues with the book but overall it was a good read.
It revolves around Aisha, a woman in a dysfunctional marriage . She has 2 kids. She is also suffering from mental illnesses such as anxiety and bipolar disorders. The story starts with Aisha having a visitor who is none other than her half sister Heer from her father. She had never seen Heer before this. Anyways, just when I thought that the book is going to be about the equation between the two sisters, the book changes direction and Aisha goes missing. For a brief while the audience knows here whereabouts but at a crucial moment, the narrative shifts focus on Prithvi, Aisha's husband. series of events makes it difficult to decide whether Aisha is dead or just missing.
The book is a page turner and its story is its strength.
I like how there are no unnecessary characters.
Things I didn't like in the book are that initially it seems too bollywood-like and over dramatic and unbelievable. The vocabulary is too good to be comfortably read. The initial half is fast paced.
Apart from all this I enjoyed the book.
It revolves around Aisha, a woman in a dysfunctional marriage . She has 2 kids. She is also suffering from mental illnesses such as anxiety and bipolar disorders. The story starts with Aisha having a visitor who is none other than her half sister Heer from her father. She had never seen Heer before this. Anyways, just when I thought that the book is going to be about the equation between the two sisters, the book changes direction and Aisha goes missing. For a brief while the audience knows here whereabouts but at a crucial moment, the narrative shifts focus on Prithvi, Aisha's husband. series of events makes it difficult to decide whether Aisha is dead or just missing.
The book is a page turner and its story is its strength.
I like how there are no unnecessary characters.
Things I didn't like in the book are that initially it seems too bollywood-like and over dramatic and unbelievable. The vocabulary is too good to be comfortably read. The initial half is fast paced.
Apart from all this I enjoyed the book.
May 30, 2019
Missing, Presumed Dead transcends the usual thriller-dramas, in that it depicts the finer nuances of an unstable marriage coupled with mental illness quite brilliantly against a plot full of twists. Kiran Manral explores the various facades of Aisha's state of mind and builds her complex character with such finesse. Every chapter has you questioning what would be the end to this thriller, as more characters are introduced who further add to the tale which initially only seems like one of a dysfunctional marriage. I personally liked the fact that Aisha's character, although one with a mental illness, speaks about various aspects of simply being a woman in all true sense of the female gender; since as women we tend to have many shades.
This fantastic work by Kiran will have you asking for more at the end of it, and you can't help having a million questions on your mind just as you finish it. Simply un-put-down-able!
This fantastic work by Kiran will have you asking for more at the end of it, and you can't help having a million questions on your mind just as you finish it. Simply un-put-down-able!
December 5, 2018
A gripping tale indeed. The author has successfully managed to create an atmosphere of suspense. I would not label it as a thriller but it sure does keeps the readers glued till the end.
A disturbed marriage, trust issues, infidelity on either sides, a mysterious suicide leaves the readers wondering who is in the wrong. The author has shown no bias when it comes to portraying her protagonists and ensured that the story is visualised from various angles and view points.
I however feel that the end could have been better leaving no scope for ambuiguity but guess that's the authors ways of leaving her readers longing for more.
I rarely pick up mysteries but glad I did. It reminded me a lot of Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn.
So if you are into mysteries, highly recommended.
A disturbed marriage, trust issues, infidelity on either sides, a mysterious suicide leaves the readers wondering who is in the wrong. The author has shown no bias when it comes to portraying her protagonists and ensured that the story is visualised from various angles and view points.
I however feel that the end could have been better leaving no scope for ambuiguity but guess that's the authors ways of leaving her readers longing for more.
I rarely pick up mysteries but glad I did. It reminded me a lot of Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn.
So if you are into mysteries, highly recommended.
May 26, 2019
I am a fan of Kiran’s writing style. This one is yet another intriguing book from her. Mental illness, post partum depression, a marriage gone wrong, a woman's need to just get away, all of these are the crux of the story Missing, Presumed Dead which goes into the mind of a woman trapped in an unhappy marriage and looking for a way out. The author has written the protagonist with empathy and care, making one root for her, even though we realise she is perhaps not behaving in her own best interests. This one is a must read.
May 24, 2019
Not many authors toy with psychological horrors in India. This book, thus makes for an exceptional read. Author Kiran Manral digs into dysfunctional marriages and mental illness with her bare hands and then sculpts a masterpiece which leaves you both haunted and asking for more.
The writing is beautiful and storytelling is gripping. But the end... It just leaves you so unsettled.
The writing is beautiful and storytelling is gripping. But the end... It just leaves you so unsettled.
March 12, 2019
Invokes empathy for every character but then you backtrack.
Leaves you with a feeling of profound sadness for the protagonist, her life and family.
Amazing thriller...lovely twists.
Leaves you with a feeling of profound sadness for the protagonist, her life and family.
Amazing thriller...lovely twists.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 9, 2019
The story is about Aisha, who is in a dysfunctional marriage and suffers from mental illness. Only her kids, Maya and Aryan, are the reason she is still trying to keep herself functional. Her husband, Prithvi, is quite wary of her and there is hardly any communication between them. One day Aisha's half-sister, Heer, comes to meet her for the first time and two days later Aisha goes missing!
The story was a bit slow in the beginning but the narration was so strong that it kept me hooked. The second half picked up and was intense. The characters were fleshed out fantastically, especially the children, Maya and Aryan. The dark and grim atmosphere added to the caliginous mood of the story. The author was on point the way she described BiPolar Disorder and Anxiety Disorder and the way they affect the person and their relationships.
However, I found a few things lacking which ended up making the story less impactful. I wish Aisha's and Prithvi's POV were narrated alternatively rather than in the form of Book 1 and Book 2. Also I found some inconsistencies which would act as spoilers so I'm refraining from mentioning them. There are some books where ambiguous endings might work but this one wasn't one of them and the climax didn't give any closure to the story. Also, I wish there were less of the description in the last 50 or so pages. They acted as hindrance rather than adding something to the story.
There are some parts which are very well written and had me completely hooked but the ineffective execution made the book fall short of the hard hitting read it could have been!
The story was a bit slow in the beginning but the narration was so strong that it kept me hooked. The second half picked up and was intense. The characters were fleshed out fantastically, especially the children, Maya and Aryan. The dark and grim atmosphere added to the caliginous mood of the story. The author was on point the way she described BiPolar Disorder and Anxiety Disorder and the way they affect the person and their relationships.
However, I found a few things lacking which ended up making the story less impactful. I wish Aisha's and Prithvi's POV were narrated alternatively rather than in the form of Book 1 and Book 2. Also I found some inconsistencies which would act as spoilers so I'm refraining from mentioning them. There are some books where ambiguous endings might work but this one wasn't one of them and the climax didn't give any closure to the story. Also, I wish there were less of the description in the last 50 or so pages. They acted as hindrance rather than adding something to the story.
There are some parts which are very well written and had me completely hooked but the ineffective execution made the book fall short of the hard hitting read it could have been!
April 25, 2024
The book is about the breakdown of Aisha and Prithvi’s marriage. Aisha is portrayed as suffering from a mental illness. The story is about how Aisha’s illness, Prithvi’s temper, a misinterpretation of actions, intentions and lack of communication create a barrier in a decades-old marriage that leads to devastating consequences.
Kiran Manral takes us into Aisha’s inner world. She brings alive Aisha’s demons and fears, providing a rare and unique experience of what living with emotional and mental difficulties feels like. I was glad Kiran Manral didn’t give an exact diagnosis for Aisha’s illness and left it open.
The book is set somewhere in the foothills of the Himalayas. Once again, an exact location is left open to interpretation. The poetic and descriptive language made for a captivating start. Whether it was the sense of isolation or the bad weather, the descriptions were on point and drew me into the book and Aisha’s head. The arrival of Aisha’s estranged half-sister, Heer, the inclement weather and the sordid history of Aisha’s parents’ marriage all combined to create a sense of impending doom.
The plot couldn’t live up to the expectations set up by the brilliant beginning. I loved the portrayal of Aisha’s mental state and the slow crumbling of the marriage. But the constant, out-of-the-blue switches in the POV, from Aisha to her daughter, Maya or the character of Daljeet (whom Aisha meets on the road) were jarring. And these sudden changes in POV were peppered throughout the book. It just made it difficult to parse whether it was Aisha or Prithvi imagining what the other characters might be feeling/thinking or if I was actually in the head of the other characters. In some places, it was easy to tell, but in others, not so much, which made for very tedious reading.
It also made the vague, open-ended conclusion to the book unsatisfying. Usually, I am a fan of vague endings but in this case, I felt cheated. The story and the end would have felt more authentic if Kiran Manral had strictly stuck to the POVs of Aisha and Prithvi without going into Daljeet’s head or occasionally dipping into Heer’s thoughts.
In conclusion, the descriptions and characterizations were perfect. Kiran Manral brought the foothills, Aisha, Prithvi and the rest of the characters to life. But the plot, the twists in the plot and the conclusion made the story feel incomplete.
For more such reviews, visit- https://bookishexperiences.wordpress.com
Kiran Manral takes us into Aisha’s inner world. She brings alive Aisha’s demons and fears, providing a rare and unique experience of what living with emotional and mental difficulties feels like. I was glad Kiran Manral didn’t give an exact diagnosis for Aisha’s illness and left it open.
The book is set somewhere in the foothills of the Himalayas. Once again, an exact location is left open to interpretation. The poetic and descriptive language made for a captivating start. Whether it was the sense of isolation or the bad weather, the descriptions were on point and drew me into the book and Aisha’s head. The arrival of Aisha’s estranged half-sister, Heer, the inclement weather and the sordid history of Aisha’s parents’ marriage all combined to create a sense of impending doom.
The plot couldn’t live up to the expectations set up by the brilliant beginning. I loved the portrayal of Aisha’s mental state and the slow crumbling of the marriage. But the constant, out-of-the-blue switches in the POV, from Aisha to her daughter, Maya or the character of Daljeet (whom Aisha meets on the road) were jarring. And these sudden changes in POV were peppered throughout the book. It just made it difficult to parse whether it was Aisha or Prithvi imagining what the other characters might be feeling/thinking or if I was actually in the head of the other characters. In some places, it was easy to tell, but in others, not so much, which made for very tedious reading.
It also made the vague, open-ended conclusion to the book unsatisfying. Usually, I am a fan of vague endings but in this case, I felt cheated. The story and the end would have felt more authentic if Kiran Manral had strictly stuck to the POVs of Aisha and Prithvi without going into Daljeet’s head or occasionally dipping into Heer’s thoughts.
In conclusion, the descriptions and characterizations were perfect. Kiran Manral brought the foothills, Aisha, Prithvi and the rest of the characters to life. But the plot, the twists in the plot and the conclusion made the story feel incomplete.
For more such reviews, visit- https://bookishexperiences.wordpress.com
February 24, 2023
Missing, Presumed Dead by Kiran Manral is another first of mine this year; this year I have decided to read a few books, but of authors whose work I have never read before. So, I picked this up and though I had a bit of starting trouble, the end caught me by surprise.
Mental health has been in the spotlight for a couple of years now, but mostly, it is swept under the carpet as no one wants to acknowledge it or accept it.
Aisha and Prithvi are one of those couples who fell in love but as time passes, love flew out of the window, and what remained behind was neither acknowledgeable nor acceptable by both. The situation is aggravated more due to Aisha's mental health issues which both choose to, won't say ignore but pay importance or sort out. Both have their secrets and skeletons in their closets.
Even though it was a slow start for me but as the story progressed the storyline got me hooked. And the end left me thinking with lots many questions of my own.
If you like to read suspense and mystery, I would suggest picking this one up and settling down with a large cuppa of your favorite beverage and some snacks, and I bet you will love reading this one.
Mental health has been in the spotlight for a couple of years now, but mostly, it is swept under the carpet as no one wants to acknowledge it or accept it.
Aisha and Prithvi are one of those couples who fell in love but as time passes, love flew out of the window, and what remained behind was neither acknowledgeable nor acceptable by both. The situation is aggravated more due to Aisha's mental health issues which both choose to, won't say ignore but pay importance or sort out. Both have their secrets and skeletons in their closets.
Even though it was a slow start for me but as the story progressed the storyline got me hooked. And the end left me thinking with lots many questions of my own.
If you like to read suspense and mystery, I would suggest picking this one up and settling down with a large cuppa of your favorite beverage and some snacks, and I bet you will love reading this one.
January 8, 2020
Uff... Let me take a breather..
~
🛑Trigger warning- For the first half this book has few description of suicidal thoughts. Reader's discretion is advised.
~
I just finished this glorious copy of 'MISSING, PRESUMED DEAD' by
~
Genre- Mystery, thriller
~
"In a dysfunctional marriage, it may appear convenient when the wife commits suicide, but things aren't always what they seem... "
~
This book deliberately challenged my imagination power and my curious detective-like mind where I try to guess the ending of the story.
This book is from the point of two person, each having 9 chapters of their own.
One belonged to out female protagonist Mrs. Aisha Thakur and other belonged to Mr. Prithvi Thakur. The main protagonist made me feel sympathetic towards them throughout the story.
Each and every character were equally suspicions before my eyes.
In short, I really enjoyed the ups and downs of the predictions that I went through.
~
🛑Trigger warning- For the first half this book has few description of suicidal thoughts. Reader's discretion is advised.
~
I just finished this glorious copy of 'MISSING, PRESUMED DEAD' by
~
Genre- Mystery, thriller
~
"In a dysfunctional marriage, it may appear convenient when the wife commits suicide, but things aren't always what they seem... "
~
This book deliberately challenged my imagination power and my curious detective-like mind where I try to guess the ending of the story.
This book is from the point of two person, each having 9 chapters of their own.
One belonged to out female protagonist Mrs. Aisha Thakur and other belonged to Mr. Prithvi Thakur. The main protagonist made me feel sympathetic towards them throughout the story.
Each and every character were equally suspicions before my eyes.
In short, I really enjoyed the ups and downs of the predictions that I went through.
April 15, 2021
3.5 stars - One star for Kiran for trying a psychological thriller, not many people write that in India. One star for the superb portrayal of patients with anxiety and bipolar disorder and how difficult it is for their family and caretakers. One star for the heavy and gloomy language, I really admired the play of words. Half for the plot which looked promising till Book 1.
And that's it.
Kiran could have done a lot with the premise but unfortunately Book 1 was a very slow burner and Book 2 was devoid of any good thrills. I personally liked the chemistry shared by the kids.
P.S. The vocabulary can be heavy at times so make sure to read on Kindle. It is available free on Kindle Unlimited.
And that's it.
Kiran could have done a lot with the premise but unfortunately Book 1 was a very slow burner and Book 2 was devoid of any good thrills. I personally liked the chemistry shared by the kids.
P.S. The vocabulary can be heavy at times so make sure to read on Kindle. It is available free on Kindle Unlimited.
April 12, 2021
I wanted to read a book by Indian Author for a long time and then I came across ‘Missing presumed dead’ by Kiran Manral on Kindle Unlimited. The book is slow to start and gathers momentum around 40%. Its tough to put down after that. Book deals with a number of issues mental issues in families, domestic abuse and eating disorders. Kiran succeeds in creating a environment where you want to know what happens next and keeps the reader glued. The book comes to an end and leaves too many open ends for my liking. The other thing which kept nagging is why authors use complicated words – somnambulant, sepulchral, certitude, seuge to name a few.
January 10, 2020
A psychological thriller with a literary feel. Kiran Manral writes beautifully, her prose almost poetic in parts but never indulgent or pretentious, and always conjuring the apt word or imagery to capture the tumult of the protagonist's bipolar mind and the eeriness of a desolate mountain setting. The writing is unhurried and evokes perfectly the highs and lows and unpredictable acts and thoughts of a bipolar personality, the foggy lethargy induced by medication, the dysfunction it can cause in a family - and yet the pacing is excellent, the plot is taut with suspense. Excellent read.
June 3, 2021
Perfect suspense thriller story which does justice to all the characters.
Includes various aspects of Indian families such as property feuds, broken marriages, parenting in a broken marriage, disorders among teenagers, mental health issues and domestic violence.
The author sequenced and narrated the events in a way that you wouldn't stop until you finish it.
It has very deep characters and is a feast for anyone who is interested in psychology or human nature.
I started reading with certain expectations and the book was beyond them.
Includes various aspects of Indian families such as property feuds, broken marriages, parenting in a broken marriage, disorders among teenagers, mental health issues and domestic violence.
The author sequenced and narrated the events in a way that you wouldn't stop until you finish it.
It has very deep characters and is a feast for anyone who is interested in psychology or human nature.
I started reading with certain expectations and the book was beyond them.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 5, 2025
The premise was interesting, but the execution was poor. Most of the prose was overly descriptive, and the language was unnecessarily convoluted, ornamental, and dense. I didn’t enjoy the reading experience one bit. It was far too tedious. The ending left so many loose ends, it was frustrating. On the plus side, I think the characters were fleshed out quite well.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 36 reviews