Libro de ejercicios + CD-Audio (del Libro de ejercicios) correspondiente al A1.1 de Menschen, método actual de gran atractivo y con amplio apoyo audio-visual que motiva por los textos, las tareas y la interacción en clase
مکمل تمرینی خوبی برای کتاب اصلیه ولی در کل به نظرم نیاز بود تمرینات بیشتر و قویتری باشه برای من کافی نبود گاهی نیاز میدیم از گوگل کمک بگیرم تا منابع تمرینی بیشتری بهم بده.
A bit weak on explanations of grammar, heavily rely on students' ability in pattern recognition. Don't try to get perfect in some of the grammatical elements in this A1.1 level book as assumably we will see similar patterns in next levels as well.
2.5* The book itself has a lot of weaknesses. There aren't any dialogues to model the new grammar and words. There aren't any explanations for new grammar. The exercises aren't very varied, and the structure of them means that often times students don't need to really understand them in order to complete them successfully. Those exercises are typically just of the fill-in-the-blank or matching varieties. There are too few writing exercises, which means students may struggle in production. This book is one that can be supplemented by a good teacher, but it isn't one I would recommend a German teacher to use.