En esta tercera entrega de la saga de The Ring, que cuenta con la historia de Koji Suzuki y el arte de Sakura Mizuki, nos encontramos con la secuela de la historia vista en la película original. Si bien la trama fue deshechada para el cine, en este manga se pueden leer las verdaderas intenciones del autor. En Spiral se buscan y encuentran los orígenes de la misteriosa cinta que da inicio a este círculo vicioso de muertes en cadena demostrando que la maldición no es tal sino que todo se trata de algún tipo de experimento. De qué se tratará?
I can't tell if this is a reworking of the original story or the original story that has since been reworked into the Ring most of us know today. Either way, the lack of consistency and continuity annoys me.
So the curse is now a virus... okay, then. I could maybe buy that if it was explained differently, or even if it wasn't explained at all, because the theories they came up with are absolutely ludicrous. Apparently you can catch the virus by watching the videotape because the imagery presented will have your heart beating in a certain way that will leave your immune system defenseless or... something. Pseudo-science at its most unbelievable.
On top of that it completely changes certain characters in the story. Ex-wife Ms. Asakawa is no longer an ex-wife, or even a 'Ms.'; she's now a male colleague of Ryuji, and their son no longer exists. Stuff like this drives me nuts. This is why I can't take the X-Men movies seriously.
Mizuki's artwork doesn't do it for me this time around either...
All in all this wasn't a very compelling read, which is a shame because if done differently this could have been a lot more interesting. But it wasn't, so it isn't.
Well it was a slight improvement on Ring 2 at least. Better art and a more coherent story - I like the dark ending of Spiral - it's a bit rushed but I thought did an OK job of condensing down a very complex story.
This is more of a technoscience story then horror, one of the reasons I love it! It starts offer with an autopsy of Ryūji, the doctor intrigued by the case decides to dig deeper. He comes across Mai (Ryūji student), who tells him that she thinks the death is linked to a curse.
For me this is the perfect sequel to the Ring, it’s creepy and engaging in all the right places. Unlike most sequels it isn’t a rehash of the first, the only thing it has in common is the investigating the curse as well as some returning characters.
¿Algo más turbio que la cinta de vídeo que liquida a quien la ve en 7 días?
Es tu historia si... Te gusta el terror japonés, «The Ring» o las historias que cuando crees que no pueden ser más turbias, se lían más.
Ideal para leer entre lecturas.
Aunque es autoconclusivo, también está tanto en formato novela como manga la versión adaptada de la película.
Lo que más me ha gustado ha sido que en esta historia se transmita un virus la mar de extraño a través de la película. Además, conoceremos un poquito más de la historia de Sadako, lo que nos llevará a un interesante final abierto para que saquemos nuestras propias conclusiones
I'll start off by saying that I've never watched the movie, nor read the book, so I went into this completely blind. And, I have to say, it was pretty average. What I liked the most about it was the art style, which settled well the tone that was planned for the novel, but it wasn't enough to make it memorable. It's not bad by any means, I just know that I won't remember much of it in 6 months or so. I wouldn't recommend it, unless you can read it for free somewhere.
I'm glad I finally got to this manga adaptation after having read the original novel. Personally, I enjoyed this adaptation far more, it felt easier to follow in most cases and the tension was more impactful, and the pacing flowed much better. I do think if you're looking to get into this series, you need to try the novel by Koji Suzuki before you try this one, and it'll help you appreciate this far more for what it is.
I enjoyed it, but not as much as I enjoyed the first book of the series. There was slightly too much science in there which swamped me a bit, but there were certainly some great scary moments in the book.
I'm looking forward to reading the third book in the trilogy, but I will save it for a little bit later I think.