What do you think?
Rate this book
The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery
Twelve-year-old Flossie is no ordinary ghost — she’s the caretaker of every soul in Highgate Cemetery. And during World War II, even the ghosts are unsafe.
Flossie Birdwhistle is the Turnkey at London’s Highgate Cemetery. As Turnkey, it’s Flossie’s job to ensure that all the souls buried in the cemetery stay at rest. Not an easy job for a young ghost, but a task made especially difficult by World War II: London is being attacked every night by enemy bombers, and even the dead are unsettled. When Flossie encounters the ghost of a German soldier carrying a mysterious object that seems to exist in both the living and spirit worlds, she becomes suspicious — what is the officer up to? Before long, Flossie uncovers a sinister plot that could destroy not only her cemetery, but also her beloved country. Can Flossie and her ghostly friends stop the soldier before it’s too late? History collides with the supernatural in this exciting, ethereal mystery from Allison Rushby.
256 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 1, 2017
15 people are currently reading
1583 people want to read
About the author
Allison Rushby
44 books291 followersAllison Rushby adores cities with long, winding histories; wild, overgrown cemeteries; redbrick Victorian museums; foxes; tea; and ivy. She lives in Queensland, Australia.
http://www.allisonrushby.com.
http://www.allisonrushby.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 93 reviews
December 21, 2018
Marketed as a middle grade book The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery (Turnkey) is ambitious to take on the difficult topic of WWII and how to explain the complexity to children. Allison Rushby does this by creating cemetery grave keepers, if you will. Ghosts or spirits that keep everyone in their cemetery safe and at rest. The concept overall was really interesting and it was a fast paced book. I certainly flipped pages quickly. However the plot was complex and it concerns me that it's took much for the average 9-11 year old.
Complex Plot
Delving into the plot of Turnkey the reader needs to understand a few things:
1) The Nazis were the 'bad guys' (easy enough)
2) They have levels or ranks of military (not too bad)
3) They are trying to win a war by overtaking London (tolerable) and,
4) They believe that mystical spirit magic can do this.(here's where it gets tough).
Turnkey has to establish two things quickly for the reader. The four points above AND the magical construct that Rushby has created to tell her story from. The construct itself isn't too complicated but how it can or might work is.
Additionally there are a lot of players in this book (seven turnkeys alone before we add in other ghosts and the Nazis) and while the language is very simple and well written for the 9-11 age range I still had a hard time keeping track of who was who.
Magic
The thing with magic in stories is you have to set-up rules and parameters. If you want a twist to shock a reader then it needs to make sense inside those parameters that you create. Which means in a short period of time you need to not only tell the story/plot of your book, develop the characters, set the scene AND describe the magic. This gets a little lost in the multitude of characters in Turnkey. I worry that a child would not find this book to be very engaging as they would loose track of who was who very quickly.
Dark
As with any WWII book the overall context is dark and foreboding. It was an awful time in human history and there is no easy way to tell any of the multitude of stories that are relevant to the time. There continues to be thousands of books published about WWII because there is so much for us (as a society) to learn and be reminded of from that war. Prejudice (of all kinds), value of life, lose of home or safe space, etc. are all touched upon in Turnkey. If you are not prepared to talk to your child about the horrors and evils that people can do to each other then I would definitely stray from this book. I would also encourage parents to read this book with their child or ensure they talk about it after the child finishes reading it; as there are bound to be concerns that arise.
In fact this is probably a book best suited for kids a little older who are struggling to read. With it's complexity and serious topics it may be written for 9-11 but 12+ are likely to find the story interesting and not too challenging to read.
Overall
This isn't the best children's WWII story I've read recently. But it's not the worst. Had I not felt like the magic was used to conveniently result in an outcome our heroine needed, I might have liked it more.
I think a better alternative for children's WWII fiction is The Dollmaker of Krakow by R.M. Romero. With far fewer characters and a less complex plot it was more meaningful to me. That said, if you want something a little more like The Book Thief but for a younger age (ie: Set in London, average person's fear during bombing, etc.) then Turnkey is a solid choice.
For those parents or guardians nervous about giving this book to younger children, it maybe worth a quick read before you hand it over so you know what you're getting the child into. It's a quick and easy read so not much time is needed to ensure you are comfortable with the topics and representation.
To read this and more of my reviews visit my blog at Epic Reading
Please note: I received an eARC of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. This is an honest and unbiased review.
Complex Plot
Delving into the plot of Turnkey the reader needs to understand a few things:
1) The Nazis were the 'bad guys' (easy enough)
2) They have levels or ranks of military (not too bad)
3) They are trying to win a war by overtaking London (tolerable) and,
4) They believe that mystical spirit magic can do this.(here's where it gets tough).
Turnkey has to establish two things quickly for the reader. The four points above AND the magical construct that Rushby has created to tell her story from. The construct itself isn't too complicated but how it can or might work is.
Additionally there are a lot of players in this book (seven turnkeys alone before we add in other ghosts and the Nazis) and while the language is very simple and well written for the 9-11 age range I still had a hard time keeping track of who was who.
Magic
The thing with magic in stories is you have to set-up rules and parameters. If you want a twist to shock a reader then it needs to make sense inside those parameters that you create. Which means in a short period of time you need to not only tell the story/plot of your book, develop the characters, set the scene AND describe the magic. This gets a little lost in the multitude of characters in Turnkey. I worry that a child would not find this book to be very engaging as they would loose track of who was who very quickly.
Dark
As with any WWII book the overall context is dark and foreboding. It was an awful time in human history and there is no easy way to tell any of the multitude of stories that are relevant to the time. There continues to be thousands of books published about WWII because there is so much for us (as a society) to learn and be reminded of from that war. Prejudice (of all kinds), value of life, lose of home or safe space, etc. are all touched upon in Turnkey. If you are not prepared to talk to your child about the horrors and evils that people can do to each other then I would definitely stray from this book. I would also encourage parents to read this book with their child or ensure they talk about it after the child finishes reading it; as there are bound to be concerns that arise.
In fact this is probably a book best suited for kids a little older who are struggling to read. With it's complexity and serious topics it may be written for 9-11 but 12+ are likely to find the story interesting and not too challenging to read.
Overall
This isn't the best children's WWII story I've read recently. But it's not the worst. Had I not felt like the magic was used to conveniently result in an outcome our heroine needed, I might have liked it more.
I think a better alternative for children's WWII fiction is The Dollmaker of Krakow by R.M. Romero. With far fewer characters and a less complex plot it was more meaningful to me. That said, if you want something a little more like The Book Thief but for a younger age (ie: Set in London, average person's fear during bombing, etc.) then Turnkey is a solid choice.
For those parents or guardians nervous about giving this book to younger children, it maybe worth a quick read before you hand it over so you know what you're getting the child into. It's a quick and easy read so not much time is needed to ensure you are comfortable with the topics and representation.
To read this and more of my reviews visit my blog at Epic Reading
Please note: I received an eARC of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. This is an honest and unbiased review.
October 2, 2018
3.5 Stars.
June 9, 2018
A BIG Thank You to NetGalley and Candlewick Press for providing me a copy of “The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery” by Allison Rushby in exchange for my review. This was an interesting read. The story is unique and has a good blend of adventure, fantasy, mystery and drama into it.
I enjoyed Allison Rushby’s style of writing. I really liked that the backdrop was set against World War II and we get an insight of the war from a ghost’s perspective. The story is set against the backdrop of London and the author depicts the grim environment it was in during that time. She doesn’t shy away from the brutal realities that the people faced during the bombings. Furthermore, it was interesting that the author has portrayed life after death in a very peaceful way. There is no mention of heaven or hell. Even the ghosts are not vengeful and restless as we would imagine. It is just about keeping souls at rest in the afterlife, and shown in a very serene manner.
The characters are all displayed wonderfully. Flossie is a strong, brave and helpful girl who persists in doing what she feels is right. She is a wonderful role model for younger readers and is very inspiring in her actions to help others. Even the supporting characters are charming in their own manner, especially Violet and Hugo Howsham. On a side note, I would have liked to read a bit more about Viktor Brun and why he turned out to be such a psychopath.
There were a few small tidbits that I felt could have been better. Personally, I would have liked it if the author removed the character of Grace completely. I felt this side story was unnecessary and too melodramatic. I can understand why the author would want to include her in the plot, but I didn’t care for it. Also, some of the facts mentioned in the book are inaccurate and could be misleading to younger readers. The author does highlight it in the end, but could have been better if it was accurate. Also, I wasn’t really clear as to the time-lapse that happens when Flossie travels to different locations. I felt that a lot of time passes by while she travels and had trouble imagining the timelines in the story.
Overall, “The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery” was a nice read but could have been better. I rate it 3.5 out of 5 stars. I hope this becomes a possible series as I would enjoy reading Flossie’s adventures during different incidents and milestones.
I enjoyed Allison Rushby’s style of writing. I really liked that the backdrop was set against World War II and we get an insight of the war from a ghost’s perspective. The story is set against the backdrop of London and the author depicts the grim environment it was in during that time. She doesn’t shy away from the brutal realities that the people faced during the bombings. Furthermore, it was interesting that the author has portrayed life after death in a very peaceful way. There is no mention of heaven or hell. Even the ghosts are not vengeful and restless as we would imagine. It is just about keeping souls at rest in the afterlife, and shown in a very serene manner.
The characters are all displayed wonderfully. Flossie is a strong, brave and helpful girl who persists in doing what she feels is right. She is a wonderful role model for younger readers and is very inspiring in her actions to help others. Even the supporting characters are charming in their own manner, especially Violet and Hugo Howsham. On a side note, I would have liked to read a bit more about Viktor Brun and why he turned out to be such a psychopath.
There were a few small tidbits that I felt could have been better. Personally, I would have liked it if the author removed the character of Grace completely. I felt this side story was unnecessary and too melodramatic. I can understand why the author would want to include her in the plot, but I didn’t care for it. Also, some of the facts mentioned in the book are inaccurate and could be misleading to younger readers. The author does highlight it in the end, but could have been better if it was accurate. Also, I wasn’t really clear as to the time-lapse that happens when Flossie travels to different locations. I felt that a lot of time passes by while she travels and had trouble imagining the timelines in the story.
Overall, “The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery” was a nice read but could have been better. I rate it 3.5 out of 5 stars. I hope this becomes a possible series as I would enjoy reading Flossie’s adventures during different incidents and milestones.
August 20, 2018
Flossie is 12 years old. She's been the turnkey of Highgate Cemetery for quite a while now. As a turnkey she must take care of the souls that come to Highgate Cemetery. She's the only soul that is allowed to wander off the cemetery and on one of her excursions to St Paul's, during the bombings of London in 1940, she sees the ghost of a Nazi officer. This is when the story gets interesting.
Flossie now has to unravel the mystery of why the officer was at St Paul's, this leads her not only to the turnkeys of the other London cemeteries but also to a cemetery in Berlin.
The story is a mix of historical fiction, children's fiction, ghost story and mystery. I quite enjoyed it, although it took me some time to get into the story. I am sure children/middle graders, who have a basic knowledge of what happened during WW II, will like it a bit more than I did.
Flossie now has to unravel the mystery of why the officer was at St Paul's, this leads her not only to the turnkeys of the other London cemeteries but also to a cemetery in Berlin.
The story is a mix of historical fiction, children's fiction, ghost story and mystery. I quite enjoyed it, although it took me some time to get into the story. I am sure children/middle graders, who have a basic knowledge of what happened during WW II, will like it a bit more than I did.
March 5, 2019
Dnf 21%
March 4, 2017
Flossie is the ghost of a 12-year-old girl. She is also a Turnkey. This means she is in charge of London's Highgate cemetery and its residents. When Flossie sees the ghost of a German soldier at the top of St Paul's cathedral she is very suspicious. World War II is in progress and Flossie can't help thinking the German ghost might be a spy.
Although this is a story about ghosts it is not a ghost story. Instead, it is the story of a clever. brave and determined girl who just happens to be a ghost.
Allison Rushby expertly weaves fantasy elements with real life events to create a believable world and a very likeable heroine. The supporting characters are also well-drawn and a twist in the end shows that Flossie is not the only young ghost brave enough to fight for what is right.
Reviewed by Penny Guy (Bookrapt)
Although this is a story about ghosts it is not a ghost story. Instead, it is the story of a clever. brave and determined girl who just happens to be a ghost.
Allison Rushby expertly weaves fantasy elements with real life events to create a believable world and a very likeable heroine. The supporting characters are also well-drawn and a twist in the end shows that Flossie is not the only young ghost brave enough to fight for what is right.
Reviewed by Penny Guy (Bookrapt)
Read
March 20, 2017Review to come.
July 24, 2018
It's December 1940 and London is being bombed night after night by the German Luftwaffe. In Highgate Cemetery, however, the souls who are buried there are, for the most part, at peace, thanks to Flossie Birdwhistle, 12. Flossie had died of rheumatic fever, and now served as the turnkey or keeper of the key, of Highgate. It is her job to make sure everyone stays peacefully at rest there. As turnkey, Flossie must stay awake and can even leave the cemetery, sometimes visiting the Golden Galley atop St. Paul's Cathedral, a tranquil place overlooking London until the war began. But one December night, she runs into someone else up there - a man who was clearly dead and part of the spirit world, though not a turnkey, and dressed in the uniform of a Nazi officer and carrying a strange looking round glass object. When he sees Flossie, he quickly flees.
Confused, Flossie decides to visit her friend Ada, the Turnkey of Tower Hamlets cemetery. No sooner does she tell Ada what she saw, than the Turnkey of Brompton Cemetery shows up with at least 100 souls dressed in the uniform of the *Chelsea Pensioners. The men are there because of the Blitz, but are soon drawn into the mystery of the Nazi officer in the SS uniform carrying the mysterious round object.
On a quick trip to the Invalids' Cemetery in Berlin, Flossie learns from the Turnkey there that the officer is part of the Ahnenerbe. But what is that? Is the officer a German spy? How can that be if he's already dead? And why does he know who Flossie is?
The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery is indeed a mystery...and historical fiction...and a ghost story. And yet it just didn't grab me until Flossie sees the SS officer on the dome of St. Paul's. A ghostly Nazi looking out at the bombing of London by the Luftwaffe reminded me that the the Nazi's, particularly Heinrich Himmler, head of the SS, had been interested in finding the "spiritual" roots of Germanic or Aryan heritage. That made this a definite game changer.
Flossie may only be a 12 year old protagonist, but she's smart and unrelenting in her pursuit of solving the mystery of the Nazi, especially after it becomes personal. But she's also compassionate and cares very much about the souls at rest in Highgate, as evidenced in the sub-storyline about Grace, a young girl injured in the Blitz who straddles life and death while trying to find her family. I could have lived without Grace's story, but I think it would have made a great sequel to this novel.
Highgate Cemetery is such a perfect setting for this story. It's creepy enough to make me never want to be there at night, but the spirits from all the London cemeteries are not the least bit scary.
The story does take a few unexpected turns that I didn't see coming and I liked that a lot. In fact, a lot of people have compared this novel to Neil Gaiman's Coraline and The Graveyard Book, and I suppose they are similar in a way, but I think The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery does a good job of holding its own.
I also thought that Rushby did a spot on job of presenting the Blitz in all its horror, and I liked Flossie's visits to the war rooms of the British and the Nazis, but I think one of my favorite things was the presence of the helpful Chelsea Pensioners in their tricorn hats and bright red coats. Which reminds me: The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery was originally published in Britain, and there may be some bits that young American readers don't not know about. Some of them are covered in the Author's Note, but not the Pensioners (see note below).
All in all, however, The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery is a great novel for anyone interested in WWII fiction, fans of ghost stories, and those who like a really good mystery.
This book is recommended for readers age 9+
This book was sent to me by the publisher, Candlewick Press
*Chelsea Pensioners - according to Wikipedia, they are soldiers who are residents of the Royal Hospital Chelsea, a retirement home for former members of the British Army.
Confused, Flossie decides to visit her friend Ada, the Turnkey of Tower Hamlets cemetery. No sooner does she tell Ada what she saw, than the Turnkey of Brompton Cemetery shows up with at least 100 souls dressed in the uniform of the *Chelsea Pensioners. The men are there because of the Blitz, but are soon drawn into the mystery of the Nazi officer in the SS uniform carrying the mysterious round object.
On a quick trip to the Invalids' Cemetery in Berlin, Flossie learns from the Turnkey there that the officer is part of the Ahnenerbe. But what is that? Is the officer a German spy? How can that be if he's already dead? And why does he know who Flossie is?
The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery is indeed a mystery...and historical fiction...and a ghost story. And yet it just didn't grab me until Flossie sees the SS officer on the dome of St. Paul's. A ghostly Nazi looking out at the bombing of London by the Luftwaffe reminded me that the the Nazi's, particularly Heinrich Himmler, head of the SS, had been interested in finding the "spiritual" roots of Germanic or Aryan heritage. That made this a definite game changer.
Flossie may only be a 12 year old protagonist, but she's smart and unrelenting in her pursuit of solving the mystery of the Nazi, especially after it becomes personal. But she's also compassionate and cares very much about the souls at rest in Highgate, as evidenced in the sub-storyline about Grace, a young girl injured in the Blitz who straddles life and death while trying to find her family. I could have lived without Grace's story, but I think it would have made a great sequel to this novel.
Highgate Cemetery is such a perfect setting for this story. It's creepy enough to make me never want to be there at night, but the spirits from all the London cemeteries are not the least bit scary.
The story does take a few unexpected turns that I didn't see coming and I liked that a lot. In fact, a lot of people have compared this novel to Neil Gaiman's Coraline and The Graveyard Book, and I suppose they are similar in a way, but I think The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery does a good job of holding its own.
I also thought that Rushby did a spot on job of presenting the Blitz in all its horror, and I liked Flossie's visits to the war rooms of the British and the Nazis, but I think one of my favorite things was the presence of the helpful Chelsea Pensioners in their tricorn hats and bright red coats. Which reminds me: The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery was originally published in Britain, and there may be some bits that young American readers don't not know about. Some of them are covered in the Author's Note, but not the Pensioners (see note below).
All in all, however, The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery is a great novel for anyone interested in WWII fiction, fans of ghost stories, and those who like a really good mystery.
This book is recommended for readers age 9+
This book was sent to me by the publisher, Candlewick Press
*Chelsea Pensioners - according to Wikipedia, they are soldiers who are residents of the Royal Hospital Chelsea, a retirement home for former members of the British Army.
October 21, 2018
Allison Rushby has turned me into a serious fan girl and I’m not slightly mad. Actually I love it and would probably faint if I saw her because her books ARE THAT GOOD. Rushby can do no wrong and after The Mulberry Tree I thought that nothing would compare to that beauty but upon finished The Turnkey I could see that I was mistake. The Turnkey literally left me hugging the book to my chest.
I’ll continue my raving later but…
The Turnkey is a gothic little tale based in the heart of London during the war. Highgate Cemetery and those that are buried there are safe and at peace with Flossie Birdwhistle a mere girl/ghost of 12 who cares for them. Flossie is the guardian of the cemetery known as the ‘turnkey.’ One night Flossie encounters a dead Nazi officer up to no good and Flossie gives chase, leading her on an adventure one could not forget.
‘Life continues after death’ is one of my favourite sayings and ties in with this book brilliantly. I loved that this middle grade historical fiction contains ghosts and that their pure and hopeful intent stays with them in spiritual form. Flossie was just adorable. As a ghost you see her full of determination, love and her compassion is heart wrenchingly amazing.
Besides Flossie the other characters of the book were creative, pure and I devoured them whole, I loved them all though Flossie is my little kitten and I eternally love her.
The setting of the bombing of London in the midst of war is heartbreaking, brutal and fascinating and the depth Rushby goes to ensure not only the details of this war in her story are on point but the harsh reality of it is daunting for any reader and yet compelling. Did I mention that this is a middle grade read and the details and descriptions knock all middle grade books out of the ball park. Compared to this book they do not pass go and they do not collect their hundred dollars. Rushy is the almighty queen of middle grade reads and I doubt that I would find anything that would compare.
I loved every word. Every line. Literally everything about this book and I cannot stress enough how important it is to read her work. Rushby – you are the middle grade Queen.
I’ll continue my raving later but…
The Turnkey is a gothic little tale based in the heart of London during the war. Highgate Cemetery and those that are buried there are safe and at peace with Flossie Birdwhistle a mere girl/ghost of 12 who cares for them. Flossie is the guardian of the cemetery known as the ‘turnkey.’ One night Flossie encounters a dead Nazi officer up to no good and Flossie gives chase, leading her on an adventure one could not forget.
‘Life continues after death’ is one of my favourite sayings and ties in with this book brilliantly. I loved that this middle grade historical fiction contains ghosts and that their pure and hopeful intent stays with them in spiritual form. Flossie was just adorable. As a ghost you see her full of determination, love and her compassion is heart wrenchingly amazing.
Besides Flossie the other characters of the book were creative, pure and I devoured them whole, I loved them all though Flossie is my little kitten and I eternally love her.
The setting of the bombing of London in the midst of war is heartbreaking, brutal and fascinating and the depth Rushby goes to ensure not only the details of this war in her story are on point but the harsh reality of it is daunting for any reader and yet compelling. Did I mention that this is a middle grade read and the details and descriptions knock all middle grade books out of the ball park. Compared to this book they do not pass go and they do not collect their hundred dollars. Rushy is the almighty queen of middle grade reads and I doubt that I would find anything that would compare.
I loved every word. Every line. Literally everything about this book and I cannot stress enough how important it is to read her work. Rushby – you are the middle grade Queen.
March 7, 2017
This is a delightful story about a little twelve year old ghost called Flossie who is the peacekeeper of the souls in a London cemetery. She has a busy and important role in settling the disputes between the cemetery inhabitants, listening to their grievances and keeping their souls at peace. She takes her job very seriously and along with her counterparts, the other Turnkeys of the London cemeteries, is vigilant in the fulfillment of her duties. When a suspicious German soldier is seen in the area her suspicions are rightly aroused and the action rises as the Turnkeys must work together to save their beloved cemeteries and stop a great evil. Through Flossie’s memories we learn about her own death and the impact it had on her family members and how elements from her past may affect her future. At first glance you might think the setting might make this a depressing or maudlin book; however, this is not the case. Readers who enjoy ghostly stories or narratives set in World War II will enjoy this novel.
June 19, 2018
A middle grade ghost story, good for grades 3-6. This book had ghosts and Nazis, English cemeteries and WWII. It had a lot of interesting components and the writing was good, but the pacing was a bit off for me. I found it difficult to get into. I wouldn’t hesitate to have it on my shelf for students though.
March 13, 2017
Fine for gr 4-6. Gave an interesting look at England during WW2, and how the people coped. Themes of life and death, mystery, friendship and the importance of getting up again when life knocks you over.
June 25, 2017
For fans of middle grade ghostly fiction.
November 5, 2018
*thank you to Netgalley and Candlewick Press for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review*
2.5 stars
This was OK. I found it really hard to get into to at the beginning and had to push through it. The idea of a story about a Turnkey was interesting and that's probably what I enjoyed most about it, the main character Flossie. I think this book will be a Hit or Miss for most people. It's not bad, it just simply wasnt for me, but it did have parts that were enjoyable to read. I will add though that I really like the cover.
2.5 stars
This was OK. I found it really hard to get into to at the beginning and had to push through it. The idea of a story about a Turnkey was interesting and that's probably what I enjoyed most about it, the main character Flossie. I think this book will be a Hit or Miss for most people. It's not bad, it just simply wasnt for me, but it did have parts that were enjoyable to read. I will add though that I really like the cover.
June 15, 2017
Beautifully done, with just enough creep factor. I really enjoyed this one and I think kids aged 9-12 who enjoy the likes of the Graveyard Book or Coraline, will love this.
December 31, 2018
I was excited to receive this book in an exchange for a review. The description was intriguing. I received this book in October, and quickly lost interest. I did not finish it until December. I forced myself to read it, so that I could give an honest review.
The overall problem with this book, is that the author does not 'show the reader' what is happening. The author does a lot of 'telling'. It was like reading a well-written essay, or a book report. There was nothing technically wrong with the writing, but it was not engaging enough to draw me into the story. Due to this, I did not care about any of the characters at all.
There were some paragraphs where the author did a fair job at 'showing' the reader. The light from the crystal skulls, and the moonlight at the altar, were descriptive enough that I felt like I was there.
The plot was okay. It was mostly predictable, except I expected Grace to take the job that Elke took on at the very end.
Some of the characters seemed unnecessary. The Guides, or the "magnificant seven", played a very small role in the story. Also, Amelia didn't do anything to help move the plot along. She had no purpose.
I did love the setting, and the idea of the story. Cemeteries, ghosts, evil Nazis, war, crystal skulls - that's all right up my alley. It's a shame I couldn't care about the characters.
The overall problem with this book, is that the author does not 'show the reader' what is happening. The author does a lot of 'telling'. It was like reading a well-written essay, or a book report. There was nothing technically wrong with the writing, but it was not engaging enough to draw me into the story. Due to this, I did not care about any of the characters at all.
There were some paragraphs where the author did a fair job at 'showing' the reader. The light from the crystal skulls, and the moonlight at the altar, were descriptive enough that I felt like I was there.
The plot was okay. It was mostly predictable, except I expected Grace to take the job that Elke took on at the very end.
Some of the characters seemed unnecessary. The Guides, or the "magnificant seven", played a very small role in the story. Also, Amelia didn't do anything to help move the plot along. She had no purpose.
I did love the setting, and the idea of the story. Cemeteries, ghosts, evil Nazis, war, crystal skulls - that's all right up my alley. It's a shame I couldn't care about the characters.
May 4, 2019
This book has everything I really love... ghosts, cemeteries, historical setting during WWII and creative twists of being a spirit. The story follows Flossie, a young ghost that was chosen to hold the key to Highgate Cemetery. Her job is to make sure that all the people buried there are comfortable and resting and that is pretty difficult during a war with bombs being dropped all around them. One day while retrieving a doll for a restless young girl, Flossie sees a ghost carrying a crystal skull that looks familiar to her. That is all I am going to say about the story because I do not want to spoil it but I highly recommend it to kids of all ages especially during the Fall/Halloween season.
August 15, 2018
3.75✪'s
Enjoyed.
It was whimsical & endearing.
Enjoyed.
It was whimsical & endearing.
November 29, 2017
I am recommending this one everywhere. :-)
July 18, 2018
Review originally published 18 July 2018 at Falling Letters. I received a copy from the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for my honest review.
I wanted to read The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery because I love a ghostly middle grade story. Unfortunately, that’s not what this book is. A few reviewers have invoked The Graveyard Book in comparison. I can see some similarities, but the dark aspects I loved about The Graveyard Book are not present here. The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery is first and foremost a historical tale about World War II. It’s not a spooky story at all. I found the plot simple and straightforward, not that engaging. Rules that supposedly govern what the ghosts and their interred can do are easily set aside in favour of moving the story ahead.
The characters fit conveniently into the plot, like they were written to serve it. Few words are devoted to character development. Flossie is a sweet girl, especially with her concern for her interred, but the reader doesn’t learn much about her. I would have liked to learn about who she was before she became a Turnkey – more of her personality and who she is beyond that role. She feels mostly like an actor in a plot and less a fully realized girl. Early in the book, the reader briefly learns how she came to be in her current outfit. The story could have been strengthened with more tidbits of that sort, that give insight to Flossie’s character. Another scene could have been emotionally powerful, but instead took place over two pages and again only served to move the plot forward.
The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery highlighted for me the occasional disparity between how I review a book personally and how I would review it ‘professionally’ (i.e., for a young reader). This time next year, I will have completed my MLIS and will hopefully be working as children’s librarian. I imagine I may shift how I review at that time. I think I might split my reviews into a ‘professional opinion’ and a ‘personal opinion’. Turnkey didn’t appeal to me personally, but it does have appeal factors that would lead me to recommend this book to certain types of readers.
The Bottom Line: The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery isn’t quite up to snuff with the rest of the middle grade novels I’ve been reading this year. Young readers who enjoy historical fiction about WWII may appreciate the unique perspective this book offers.
I wanted to read The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery because I love a ghostly middle grade story. Unfortunately, that’s not what this book is. A few reviewers have invoked The Graveyard Book in comparison. I can see some similarities, but the dark aspects I loved about The Graveyard Book are not present here. The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery is first and foremost a historical tale about World War II. It’s not a spooky story at all. I found the plot simple and straightforward, not that engaging. Rules that supposedly govern what the ghosts and their interred can do are easily set aside in favour of moving the story ahead.
The characters fit conveniently into the plot, like they were written to serve it. Few words are devoted to character development. Flossie is a sweet girl, especially with her concern for her interred, but the reader doesn’t learn much about her. I would have liked to learn about who she was before she became a Turnkey – more of her personality and who she is beyond that role. She feels mostly like an actor in a plot and less a fully realized girl. Early in the book, the reader briefly learns how she came to be in her current outfit. The story could have been strengthened with more tidbits of that sort, that give insight to Flossie’s character. Another scene could have been emotionally powerful, but instead took place over two pages and again only served to move the plot forward.
The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery highlighted for me the occasional disparity between how I review a book personally and how I would review it ‘professionally’ (i.e., for a young reader). This time next year, I will have completed my MLIS and will hopefully be working as children’s librarian. I imagine I may shift how I review at that time. I think I might split my reviews into a ‘professional opinion’ and a ‘personal opinion’. Turnkey didn’t appeal to me personally, but it does have appeal factors that would lead me to recommend this book to certain types of readers.
The Bottom Line: The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery isn’t quite up to snuff with the rest of the middle grade novels I’ve been reading this year. Young readers who enjoy historical fiction about WWII may appreciate the unique perspective this book offers.
June 23, 2020
What an interesting wee book. The idea of the dead spying for their nation was ingenious I thought. I'm old enough to remember Indiana Jones and was aware of the Nazis' attempts to find various arcane structures like the Ark of the Covenant, but kids, who are the target readership, may be a befuddled by that. Easy to read.
March 5, 2020
An inventive adventure set in London's graveyards - and other places - during WWII. Incorporating a brilliantly fantastical range of characters, from the eponymous Turnkeys, to deceased Chelsea Pensioners and malevolent Nazis (both dead and alive), this is a well-realized fantasy with an intriguing plot that keeps you wanting to know what happens next.
December 14, 2017
My name is Flossie, and it's my responsibility to see that all of the dead in Highgate Cemetery rest in peace. Turnkeys like me are able to move throughout the world of the living just by thinking about places, but the other dead are confined to their cemeteries. Imagine my surprise when I found a twilight German SS officer atop St. Paul's Cathedral; how could he possibly be here and what was he doing? I've since discovered Viktor Brun is spying on the English army, and he's discovered a way to communicate with the living. The crystal skull he carries is the key to everything, and I've felt the evil within it. However, there's another soul inside the skull that argues with Viktor. More disturbing, I've learned Viktor knows my name, and he's the man responsible for sinking a navy ship, sending a thousand men to the bottom of the ocean, including my father.
I assumed this book would be a cute story about a girl living around a cemetery, but I wasn't expecting the seriousness of the plot. The setting was in World War II London, seen through the eyes of the deceased characters. Most of them were loyal English citizens, so they were doing all they could to help their country win WW II. That was the main conflict in the book, and Brun's connection to Flossie's father added a big complication to things. Violet was a supporting character from a different cemetery, and her brother kept secrets from Flossie, which left the door open for him to do something unexpected. His secret, and the help of a seemingly insignificant character, were keys to resolving the climax. Flossie had deep compassion for all of the deceased in Highgate Cemetery, although she had self-doubts about being an effective turnkey. The role of Turnkeys and their unique abilities was the creative charm in the book. Flossie was able to freely move anywhere she wanted among the living, but she still needed to hide from Viktor whenever he was around; it was strange to picture dead spirits trying to hide. She didn't see any way to stop this cruel Nazi, but that made her character even more determined. The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery tells a wonderfully exciting adventure, and I recommend you give it a shot!
I assumed this book would be a cute story about a girl living around a cemetery, but I wasn't expecting the seriousness of the plot. The setting was in World War II London, seen through the eyes of the deceased characters. Most of them were loyal English citizens, so they were doing all they could to help their country win WW II. That was the main conflict in the book, and Brun's connection to Flossie's father added a big complication to things. Violet was a supporting character from a different cemetery, and her brother kept secrets from Flossie, which left the door open for him to do something unexpected. His secret, and the help of a seemingly insignificant character, were keys to resolving the climax. Flossie had deep compassion for all of the deceased in Highgate Cemetery, although she had self-doubts about being an effective turnkey. The role of Turnkeys and their unique abilities was the creative charm in the book. Flossie was able to freely move anywhere she wanted among the living, but she still needed to hide from Viktor whenever he was around; it was strange to picture dead spirits trying to hide. She didn't see any way to stop this cruel Nazi, but that made her character even more determined. The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery tells a wonderfully exciting adventure, and I recommend you give it a shot!
July 19, 2018
A curious read about the keepers of our spirit's comfort at life's end set amidst WWII as the evil powers that be try to bridge the world of twilights and the living for nefarious purposes...
Can you just imagine? WHAT IF the Hitler regime had been able to accomplish what is being attempted in this book? I mean, the effects would have been devastating on such another level, I can't even begin to envision it...and yet, it is said he did have an obsession or sorts with the occult, and supernatural interests. *shivers* Sorry, but no one should have so much power, especially with that much hatred in their heart, but I digress...this book isn't JUST about the war and what COULD have been. It's about the enumerable souls left behind in the rubble, those that passed from natural causes and those "helped along" by the tragedies occurring all around them, and where they all fit in. A phrase repeated much was that it wasn't their war...it was for the living and they were beyond that world's reach for all intents and purposes. Thing is once the soldier appeared, all bets were off and choosing inaction would leave ghostly blood on their hands regardless of who would or would not see it. Flossie may have been an unusual pick for a turnkey, but she was without a doubt chosen, and with good reason. Despite her lack of years, she's knowledgeable, dependable, compassionate, and determined. She faces down ghosts from her own past, conquers unanswered questions that left fear in her formerly beating heart, and manages to keep the faith and stand strong when everything seems to be crumbling to the ground.
In the end, there was so much learned and so many miles of the heart covered, showing us that looks can be deceiving, not all lost can be saved, and sometimes the greatest thing we can give is ourselves. A great pick for Historical Fiction fans as well as the Middle Grade set. The use of a younger soul to guide the way makes it more approachable, while her lack of confidence makes her seem more human. After all, we aren't all born with a backbone of steel...but it doesn't mean we can't accomplish great things in this life...or even perhaps in the after.
**copy received for review
Can you just imagine? WHAT IF the Hitler regime had been able to accomplish what is being attempted in this book? I mean, the effects would have been devastating on such another level, I can't even begin to envision it...and yet, it is said he did have an obsession or sorts with the occult, and supernatural interests. *shivers* Sorry, but no one should have so much power, especially with that much hatred in their heart, but I digress...this book isn't JUST about the war and what COULD have been. It's about the enumerable souls left behind in the rubble, those that passed from natural causes and those "helped along" by the tragedies occurring all around them, and where they all fit in. A phrase repeated much was that it wasn't their war...it was for the living and they were beyond that world's reach for all intents and purposes. Thing is once the soldier appeared, all bets were off and choosing inaction would leave ghostly blood on their hands regardless of who would or would not see it. Flossie may have been an unusual pick for a turnkey, but she was without a doubt chosen, and with good reason. Despite her lack of years, she's knowledgeable, dependable, compassionate, and determined. She faces down ghosts from her own past, conquers unanswered questions that left fear in her formerly beating heart, and manages to keep the faith and stand strong when everything seems to be crumbling to the ground.
In the end, there was so much learned and so many miles of the heart covered, showing us that looks can be deceiving, not all lost can be saved, and sometimes the greatest thing we can give is ourselves. A great pick for Historical Fiction fans as well as the Middle Grade set. The use of a younger soul to guide the way makes it more approachable, while her lack of confidence makes her seem more human. After all, we aren't all born with a backbone of steel...but it doesn't mean we can't accomplish great things in this life...or even perhaps in the after.
**copy received for review
July 21, 2020
Ripping, High Concept, Adventure
Everyone went nuts over Neil Gaiman's "Graveyard Book", but for my money this underappreciated gem deserves pride of place on any cemetery-adventure shelf. The blurbs you see that summarize the plot are spot on, but they don't at all capture the satisfying style and tone of the tale, or the appeal of the characters.
Our heroine, Flossie Birdwhistle, is the kind and earnest Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery, which means she's responsible for the welfare and peace of all of the souls interred there. Flossie was twelve when she died, so she's "twelve" as a spirit. But of course she grows and "ages" in experience and wisdom as the years pass. As a consequence you end up with a character who has girlish aspects, (in terms of life experiences), and yet also the maturity and insight that has come from her experience as a Turnkey.The result is a remarkably engaging mix of innocence and depth that the author manages to keep in delicate balance throughout the book. Flossie Birdwhistle stands up quite nicely with such classic heroines as Pollyanna, Rebecca, Heidi, Pippi, and the like. And as with those classic heroines, a bit of edge and vinegar can slip into Flossie's tale to balance the sweetness. (As a bonus, Flossie has other Turnkeys from other cemeteries to whom she can turn for help, and has the entire cast of spirits from her cemetery and neighboring cemeteries, who also chip in. The result is a large, varied, and colorful group of supporting players, many of whom are very effective scene, or page, stealers.)
All of this would be enough, even if the book were solely just a comedy of manners, or the cemetery equivalent of a village dramedy cozy, with Flossie as the befuddled vicar character. But no. This is also a ripping tale of World War II, the Blitz, espionage, and hints of dark spirit magic. This is a suspense thriller with lurking and spying and escaping and conflict. It's atmospheric, reasonably genuine to the era, briskly paced, and very clever.
So, lots going on here, and it was all good. This was a very entertaining find.
(Please note that I received a free ecopy of this book without a review requirement, or any influence regarding review content should I choose to post a review. Apart from that I have no connection at all to either the author or the publisher of this book.)
Everyone went nuts over Neil Gaiman's "Graveyard Book", but for my money this underappreciated gem deserves pride of place on any cemetery-adventure shelf. The blurbs you see that summarize the plot are spot on, but they don't at all capture the satisfying style and tone of the tale, or the appeal of the characters.
Our heroine, Flossie Birdwhistle, is the kind and earnest Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery, which means she's responsible for the welfare and peace of all of the souls interred there. Flossie was twelve when she died, so she's "twelve" as a spirit. But of course she grows and "ages" in experience and wisdom as the years pass. As a consequence you end up with a character who has girlish aspects, (in terms of life experiences), and yet also the maturity and insight that has come from her experience as a Turnkey.The result is a remarkably engaging mix of innocence and depth that the author manages to keep in delicate balance throughout the book. Flossie Birdwhistle stands up quite nicely with such classic heroines as Pollyanna, Rebecca, Heidi, Pippi, and the like. And as with those classic heroines, a bit of edge and vinegar can slip into Flossie's tale to balance the sweetness. (As a bonus, Flossie has other Turnkeys from other cemeteries to whom she can turn for help, and has the entire cast of spirits from her cemetery and neighboring cemeteries, who also chip in. The result is a large, varied, and colorful group of supporting players, many of whom are very effective scene, or page, stealers.)
All of this would be enough, even if the book were solely just a comedy of manners, or the cemetery equivalent of a village dramedy cozy, with Flossie as the befuddled vicar character. But no. This is also a ripping tale of World War II, the Blitz, espionage, and hints of dark spirit magic. This is a suspense thriller with lurking and spying and escaping and conflict. It's atmospheric, reasonably genuine to the era, briskly paced, and very clever.
So, lots going on here, and it was all good. This was a very entertaining find.
(Please note that I received a free ecopy of this book without a review requirement, or any influence regarding review content should I choose to post a review. Apart from that I have no connection at all to either the author or the publisher of this book.)
June 25, 2018
At first glance, I thought The Turnkey of Highgate Cemetery would be similar to something like The Graveyard Book, with the main character living around a cemetery. While Flossie and her friends are ghosts there isn't anything really spooky about this book, so it's not a very fair comparison. Instead, we have an interesting mix of historical details from World War II, the paranormal and some of the potential horrible outcomes that wars can cause. Flossie clearly loves her cemetery, and even though she sometimes feels she wasn't the best pick for the job, she does take steps to defend it against the Nazi soldier trying to destroy it. She does take her job as Turnkey very seriously, especially when the interred become restless. Like little Amelia who visits Flossie because she has been searching for the doll in her "memento mori" or picture of herself after her death, without a second thought Flossie finds a replacement that helps Amelia to return to rest. Flossie's past is slowly revealed as the circumstances of her death and that of her father's become clear. Rushby created very specific rules for her world, how a Turnkey can warp from place to place, how they can copy an object from the real world into the spirit world and how the interred can only leave the cemetery if they're carried outside the gates. The story also examines some of the Nazi's practices during World War II, how they performed archaeological digs searching for the Ark of the Covenant, and how there was a group of individuals called the Ahnenerbe examining the racial heritage of Germans for Hitler. Overall, a very enjoyable ghost story set during World War II and enough twists and danger to keep things entertaining.
* In exchange for an honest review, an ARC was received from the publisher. *
July 23, 2018
Thanks to Candlewick Press for this ARC! I do know that the definition of ‘turnkey’ is ‘a keeper of the keys’ and this time, Allison Rushby has written an exciting story of those whose job is to ensure that all souls buried in the cemetery stay at rest. Flossie Birdwhistle is the Turnkey at London’s Highgate Cemetery. She, who died at twelve, is quite young to be one, but each Turnkey also has an advisor and Flossie’s is Hazel, the fox. Plus, she has a number of friends who are Turnkeys at other cemeteries, and are helpful and kind. This adventure means she needs all the help she can find!
Flossie’s work is made especially difficult by World War II. The time of the London Blitz is one filled with danger, and often Flossie is found at the top of St. Paul’s Cathedral watching and worrying. When Flossie encounters the ghost of a German soldier carrying a mysterious object that seems to exist in both the living and spirit worlds, she becomes suspicious — what is the officer up to? Before long, Flossie uncovers a sinister plot that could destroy not only her cemetery but also her beloved country. She asks for help from ghostly friends.
The story includes all the usual ups and downs, showing especially Flossie’s thoughtful ways as well as her sorrow to have first lost her father, whose ghost, too, is involved in the story. Flossie also finds the courage to act in spite of the limitations of those in the spirit world. Pairing a ghostly world with its possibilities and restrictions and this time in history when many fought hard to save their countries creates lots of interest for further learning. Each page made me want to discover more!
There are some details of the death and destruction by the bombing, so the story is possibly best for ten years and up.
Flossie’s work is made especially difficult by World War II. The time of the London Blitz is one filled with danger, and often Flossie is found at the top of St. Paul’s Cathedral watching and worrying. When Flossie encounters the ghost of a German soldier carrying a mysterious object that seems to exist in both the living and spirit worlds, she becomes suspicious — what is the officer up to? Before long, Flossie uncovers a sinister plot that could destroy not only her cemetery but also her beloved country. She asks for help from ghostly friends.
The story includes all the usual ups and downs, showing especially Flossie’s thoughtful ways as well as her sorrow to have first lost her father, whose ghost, too, is involved in the story. Flossie also finds the courage to act in spite of the limitations of those in the spirit world. Pairing a ghostly world with its possibilities and restrictions and this time in history when many fought hard to save their countries creates lots of interest for further learning. Each page made me want to discover more!
There are some details of the death and destruction by the bombing, so the story is possibly best for ten years and up.
July 16, 2018
Flossie is very young to be a Turnkey, especially of such an important cemetery. She died when she was only twelve of rheumatic fever, but Flossie is very devoted to her interred spirits and is committed to helping them find rest; in spite of the war raging outside her gates. World War II makes it difficult for anyone, living or dead, to feel at peace. While on a mission for one of her interred, Flossie discovers an SS German spy who has found a way to do the impossible, a way to allow the living and the world of spirits to communicate! The patriotism of Flossie, other Turnkeys, and the ghosts of military men from the past rouse themselves to rescue King, country and the dead from Hitler's paranormal pursuits. With help from a German ghost they prevent the living and dead worlds from communicating and save the day, or rather, the night.
This book is delightful and charming with genuine British spirit. Flossie's youth accentuates the peril that she is in, but her confidence and determination garner trust from the reader and from the other characters in the book. Flossie is very level headed and deeply kind as well. She is determined to do her duties, whatever they may be and whether or not she must face them alone. Her character is the most intriguing element of the tale, but it does not overwhelm a mysterious plot or the other characters of her acquaintance. All is well balanced and enjoyable. Each character contributes to the story and to the feeling of patriotism and desire to do one's best regardless of the circumstances. just what one would expect from a tale of British heroism. This is a great book if you are looking for something with a bit of grave mystery and uplifting history.
This book is delightful and charming with genuine British spirit. Flossie's youth accentuates the peril that she is in, but her confidence and determination garner trust from the reader and from the other characters in the book. Flossie is very level headed and deeply kind as well. She is determined to do her duties, whatever they may be and whether or not she must face them alone. Her character is the most intriguing element of the tale, but it does not overwhelm a mysterious plot or the other characters of her acquaintance. All is well balanced and enjoyable. Each character contributes to the story and to the feeling of patriotism and desire to do one's best regardless of the circumstances. just what one would expect from a tale of British heroism. This is a great book if you are looking for something with a bit of grave mystery and uplifting history.
April 19, 2017
Some of the girls in my grade 4/5 book club (Gobstoppers) had been asking me for a book with a female protagonist. “The Turnkey” dropped into my lap and seemed the perfect fit for the group. I was also interested in what the three boys of the group would think of it (more because of the cover, which is rather “pretty”, than because of the leading female role).
I enjoyed it and I’m happy to report that the Gobstoppers did too. The plot is strong, the writing is good and the characters were adequately developed.
One thing I particularly liked was that we used the novel as a starting point for discussions at book club around World War II. “The Turnkey” is set during this period and is mostly historically accurate. In fact, Allison Rushby apologises at the end of the novel for her intended inaccuracies: they were needed for the novel to progress and frankly weren’t egregious. It’s a beautiful thing when a book provides not only entertainment but also natural education and an organic discussion.
I’d be happy to recommend “The Turnkey” to any 10+ child interested in action/adventure. Although set in the afterlife, the ghosts aren’t scary in the least. Beautifully done Allison Rushby.
L-J
Three Four Knock on the Door
Independent Children's Bookshop
I enjoyed it and I’m happy to report that the Gobstoppers did too. The plot is strong, the writing is good and the characters were adequately developed.
One thing I particularly liked was that we used the novel as a starting point for discussions at book club around World War II. “The Turnkey” is set during this period and is mostly historically accurate. In fact, Allison Rushby apologises at the end of the novel for her intended inaccuracies: they were needed for the novel to progress and frankly weren’t egregious. It’s a beautiful thing when a book provides not only entertainment but also natural education and an organic discussion.
I’d be happy to recommend “The Turnkey” to any 10+ child interested in action/adventure. Although set in the afterlife, the ghosts aren’t scary in the least. Beautifully done Allison Rushby.
L-J
Three Four Knock on the Door
Independent Children's Bookshop
August 28, 2018
Flossie Birdwhistle is an unusually young turnkey (think ghostly den mother) at the Highgate Cemetery in World War II-era London as she was only twelve when she passed away from rheumatic fever. Now, non-stop bombing of the city keeps her busy settling the newly dead into a peaceful rest. So, when she spots an out of place ghost wearing a Nazi uniform and clutching a mysterious artifact, she is tempted to just ignore it. However, her sense of duty forces her to discover his intentions.
As she learns more, she calls for help upon the other turnkeys of London, and eventually, upon the graveyard denizens to help stop the evildoer. A secondary plot line follows a young girl that has been injured during recent bombing and hovers between life and death. Almost invariably, characters do the right thing, and a sense of duty towards fellowmen and country pervades. It is enjoyable to witness how Flossie manages her duties, “mothers” her patrons, and courageously overcomes seemingly insurmountable challenges. Personally, I had a little trouble with the fact that characters continued to grow and evolve after death. However, I think young readers will have no trouble accepting that is possible. Recommended for readers in grades 4 – 6 that are looking for war stories, spy stories or ghost stories.
As she learns more, she calls for help upon the other turnkeys of London, and eventually, upon the graveyard denizens to help stop the evildoer. A secondary plot line follows a young girl that has been injured during recent bombing and hovers between life and death. Almost invariably, characters do the right thing, and a sense of duty towards fellowmen and country pervades. It is enjoyable to witness how Flossie manages her duties, “mothers” her patrons, and courageously overcomes seemingly insurmountable challenges. Personally, I had a little trouble with the fact that characters continued to grow and evolve after death. However, I think young readers will have no trouble accepting that is possible. Recommended for readers in grades 4 – 6 that are looking for war stories, spy stories or ghost stories.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 93 reviews