I'm not going to rate this book because I have some serious Catholic guilt that would come into play if I did, but I will tell you a little bit about what you might want to know about it if you are considering picking it up.
Lysa TerKeurst is a good writer. She's relatable. She has a sense of humor. She's grounded. She's bright. It's clear that a lot of serious thought, meditation, and prayer has gone into her writing. She's extremely self reflective and earnest.
Girl LOVES her some extended metaphors. At various points in the book, our lives are dust, paintings, bathing suits, cakes, you name it.
The catalyst for Lysa writing this book was finding out that her husband of twenty-something years was having an affair and separating from him just one year before their youngest kid was going to be leaving the house and she thought they would finally get to have their second act of life together. She also writes about two unexpected health issues that knocked her for a loop. She makes an effort to give advice that can apply to any disappointing scenario. Her target audience is very clearly women.
She can come off as a bit judgmental at times, particularly when discussing the sinfulness of a friend's extramarital affair. But I think, in that case, she was just trying to make a very strong point about how giving into temptation and quick fixes can ultimately end up disappointing us.
The big thing to keep in mind is that this book is very, very, VERY religious. I assume that most picking it up would realize that the author is writing from a Christian perspective, but it's important to know going in that this is one long sermon about God's plan. Bible verses, metaphors, parables, and personal stories combine to tell the message over and over: "Everything happens for a reason. God has a plan for you." At the beginning of the book, Lysa promises no bumper sticker sayings or cliche platitudes. But, in the end, that's what the whole book boils down to.
I appreciate the deep and thoughtful way that Lysa breaks down those concepts. She gives the reader permission to feel hurt and overwhelmed and angry and gives a lot of examples of times in her own life and in friends' lives when God "loved them too much to answer their prayers in the way that they wanted." She hammers this message in over and over and compares it to children who sometimes can't understand that discomfort or pain now will help them later. I don't think she gave this example in a book, but it made me think about when a baby is given a shot. There's a tiny pinprick of pain, and parents hate to see how scary that pain might be for the baby, but they don't take the baby home without the shot just because the baby cries and doesn't want the shot. The baby doesn't realize that the shot is necessary now to avoid pain, sickness, or even death later. I find that metaphor to be somewhat reassuring in some cases, but I can only really happily apply that to some situations. I am never going to be able to reconcile war, genocide, starvation, natural disasters, murder, suicide, and human evil with "God has a plan."
I found it notable that none of the examples in Lysa's book really have to do with a person dying. They are mostly examples of times when she could actually point to a bit of the "why" because pain and suffering eventually led to some good coming of the situation. For example, she was in so much abdominal pain in the hospital that it led her doctors to run more tests and find something that could have killed her, and they were able to fix it. She prayed for God to take the pain away, but if he had, she would have died. (A bit cheesy and simplistic to me, and hard to compare to pain when someone does actually die. What good is that pain for?) She does talk about how human suffering and pain brings us together and how we experience pain so that we can be compassionate toward others. But I don't know that I could take her message and make it fit with some of the worst case scenarios in this world, like child death.
Above all, Lysa is a really devout Christian. In some ways I wish I had her kind of faith to get me through difficult and unexpected situations. Maybe this book helped a little, but it wasn't life changing for me. It was a bit too repetitive and a lot too long and preachy. The religious messages are very Protestant/Evangelical, so that made me a bit uncomfortable as well. I definitely wouldn't recommend it to a friend going through a hard time for fear of pissing them off, because this is like a 300 page sympathy card to basically say "everything happens for a reason." But, others may feel differently.
Also to note: Lysa got back together with her husband. Doctors fixed both of her medical problems. So her devastating situations did all have happy endings, which may also be hard for some readers who know that their own particular situations can't be fixed.