What do you think?
Rate this book
Between the Water and the Woods
Emeline's quiet village has three important rules:
Don't look at the shadows.
Do'’t cross the river.
And don't enter the forest.
An illustrated fantasy filled with beauty and power, Between the Water and the Woods sweeps you into a world where forests are hungry; knights fight with whips; the king is dying; and a peasant girl’s magic will decide the future of the realm.
When Emeline's little brother breaks all three of their village's rules, she is forced to use her family's forbidden magic to rescue him from the dark things he awakens, the Ithin. Now that the Ithin are afoot in the land, she must, by law, travel to the royal court and warn the king. But the only way she and her family can make the journey to the capital is with the protection of a sour magister and a handsome, whip-wielding Lash Knight. Will Emeline survive in a city where conspiracies swirl like smoke and her magic is all but outlawed?
Seven full-page black-and-white illustrations included.
Don't look at the shadows.
Do'’t cross the river.
And don't enter the forest.
An illustrated fantasy filled with beauty and power, Between the Water and the Woods sweeps you into a world where forests are hungry; knights fight with whips; the king is dying; and a peasant girl’s magic will decide the future of the realm.
When Emeline's little brother breaks all three of their village's rules, she is forced to use her family's forbidden magic to rescue him from the dark things he awakens, the Ithin. Now that the Ithin are afoot in the land, she must, by law, travel to the royal court and warn the king. But the only way she and her family can make the journey to the capital is with the protection of a sour magister and a handsome, whip-wielding Lash Knight. Will Emeline survive in a city where conspiracies swirl like smoke and her magic is all but outlawed?
Seven full-page black-and-white illustrations included.
310 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 2019
31 people are currently reading
1868 people want to read
About the author
Simone Snaith
6 books43 followersTHE QUAVERING AIR (Fantasy) is out now on Amazon.
Simone Snaith is an author of Fantasy, Young Adult, and Urban Fantasy novels. She also sings in the Los Angeles band Turning Violet. Her YA Fantasy, BETWEEN THE WATER & THE WOODS, is available through Holiday House Publishing wherever books are sold. It is illustrated by Sara Kipin.
Simone Snaith is an author of Fantasy, Young Adult, and Urban Fantasy novels. She also sings in the Los Angeles band Turning Violet. Her YA Fantasy, BETWEEN THE WATER & THE WOODS, is available through Holiday House Publishing wherever books are sold. It is illustrated by Sara Kipin.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 110 reviews
June 22, 2019
'It struck her that, in the wrong hands, science could be even deadlier than magic. Perhaps the problem with all power was that the wrong hands reached out for it.'
This felt like an ode to all the books I'd grown up reading and what made me fall in love with fairytales. It is sweet and subtle, relying more upon the dialogue between characters to shape their personalities rather than their actions, and it's the kind of story all ages can enjoy. I loved the simplicity of this story . . . and even then it managed to throw a few unexpected twists at me!! Also, Reese is a dear and the budding relationship in this book was just so sweet I almost got a toothache.
Also, I loved how the family unit stayed together throughout the entirety of the story??? And it wasn't forced!! It wasn't weird! Even with a growing romance, it wasn't awkward (no more than the normal level haha) and the family was understanding and supportive. And this story was quite funny! I found myself chuckling aloud so many times, mostly when it came to the two irrepressible young boys, but also with Emeline's shy sass was quite entertaining. And of course there was the dry sarcasm of Reese which masked his true soft side.
So, while this wasn't super fast-paced or high literature . . . this still feels like a book necessary to the world. Why? Because it's sweet and innocent while still maintaining a level of responsibility. It does not pretend to be dark or gritty for the sake of hooking readers in; it simply is, and what it is felt quite powerful to me. This ain't ye olden, patriarchal-and-sexism-infused fairytail but neither does it slap you in the face with its ferocity. It's not a weak book, it is just a quiet one. And sometimes those are the ones I love the most.
This felt like an ode to all the books I'd grown up reading and what made me fall in love with fairytales. It is sweet and subtle, relying more upon the dialogue between characters to shape their personalities rather than their actions, and it's the kind of story all ages can enjoy. I loved the simplicity of this story . . . and even then it managed to throw a few unexpected twists at me!! Also, Reese is a dear and the budding relationship in this book was just so sweet I almost got a toothache.
Also, I loved how the family unit stayed together throughout the entirety of the story??? And it wasn't forced!! It wasn't weird! Even with a growing romance, it wasn't awkward (no more than the normal level haha) and the family was understanding and supportive. And this story was quite funny! I found myself chuckling aloud so many times, mostly when it came to the two irrepressible young boys, but also with Emeline's shy sass was quite entertaining. And of course there was the dry sarcasm of Reese which masked his true soft side.
So, while this wasn't super fast-paced or high literature . . . this still feels like a book necessary to the world. Why? Because it's sweet and innocent while still maintaining a level of responsibility. It does not pretend to be dark or gritty for the sake of hooking readers in; it simply is, and what it is felt quite powerful to me. This ain't ye olden, patriarchal-and-sexism-infused fairytail but neither does it slap you in the face with its ferocity. It's not a weak book, it is just a quiet one. And sometimes those are the ones I love the most.
August 6, 2019
This was an interesting tale. Told from single POV that of main character Emeline, it features magic, a little bit of steampunk, young love, a bit of mystery and political intrigue that kept me interested till the very end.
Emeline is a young maiden who lives in the village named Equane with her father and younger brother Dale. The village is mostly peaceful and surrounded by a small moat that protects it from the darkness in the woods. One day while playing Dale and Emeline encounter the long forgotten yet feared creature, Ithin, at the edge of the woods. When it's evident that they have to report the sighting to the King in person, they start their journey accompanied by a couple of friends.
I liked how vivid a world the author created. The background was well developed, and it gave me opportunity to really get into the story. The Kingdom that was divided by two factions - magic believers, Theurgists, and the scientists, Sapients, is ruled by a sick King. The capital is full of machinations and plots to gain his favor. And in the middle of it all is Emeline who possesses the magic that can topple the order of the Council and turn the tide. A chance encounter with a Lash Knight Reese brings her into the sights of both factions and also gives her a chance to explore and fall in love.
The romantic angle here is so sweet and subtle. I loved those moments when gruff Reese was trying to be gentle with Emeline. I loved Emeline in the end where she showed true courage and stood strong by Reese's side battling the enemy. I didn't care for her much till the middle of the book though. She lacked zest and was a bit bland but all of that suddenly changed in the end. Reese was a bit condescending in the beginning but when Emeline got to know him, she saw that his attitude was really a defense mechanism against his fellow Knights resentment and snide remarks. He never fit and was caught in between - neither the noble nor the poor villager.
The mystery of Ithin creatures was well made and quite fascinating. I really liked the tale this author spun. The ending felt a bit unfinished and slightly abrupt for my liking. I wished for the epilogue that would have completed the story for me. Despite that I enjoyed the story of young love, magic and bravery. I recommend it.
Emeline is a young maiden who lives in the village named Equane with her father and younger brother Dale. The village is mostly peaceful and surrounded by a small moat that protects it from the darkness in the woods. One day while playing Dale and Emeline encounter the long forgotten yet feared creature, Ithin, at the edge of the woods. When it's evident that they have to report the sighting to the King in person, they start their journey accompanied by a couple of friends.
I liked how vivid a world the author created. The background was well developed, and it gave me opportunity to really get into the story. The Kingdom that was divided by two factions - magic believers, Theurgists, and the scientists, Sapients, is ruled by a sick King. The capital is full of machinations and plots to gain his favor. And in the middle of it all is Emeline who possesses the magic that can topple the order of the Council and turn the tide. A chance encounter with a Lash Knight Reese brings her into the sights of both factions and also gives her a chance to explore and fall in love.
The romantic angle here is so sweet and subtle. I loved those moments when gruff Reese was trying to be gentle with Emeline. I loved Emeline in the end where she showed true courage and stood strong by Reese's side battling the enemy. I didn't care for her much till the middle of the book though. She lacked zest and was a bit bland but all of that suddenly changed in the end. Reese was a bit condescending in the beginning but when Emeline got to know him, she saw that his attitude was really a defense mechanism against his fellow Knights resentment and snide remarks. He never fit and was caught in between - neither the noble nor the poor villager.
The mystery of Ithin creatures was well made and quite fascinating. I really liked the tale this author spun. The ending felt a bit unfinished and slightly abrupt for my liking. I wished for the epilogue that would have completed the story for me. Despite that I enjoyed the story of young love, magic and bravery. I recommend it.
March 4, 2019
Between the Water & the Woods presents us the story of Emeline, a girl with a hidden magical power connected to earth. We follow her journey with other characters. One of the characters is her father which was something I'd never read before in YA (Teenagers usually stay away from parental figures and I was glad because the author included a constant/present parental figure).
The world building was interesting, the illustrations AMAZING, the romance was cute and the story was somehow trying to pass meaningful messages which I appreciated.
However, I could not connect with the characters. Maybe I had expectations for more depth/emotion or maybe it was just because of the pacing that I could not connect with them.
The reason why I'm giving this rating is that even though I felt the story had a lot of potential, I kept losing focus because the pacing was very slow and the author used too many descriptions. I love prose with descriptions and the author sometimes wrote such lovely quotes when she described certain sceneries...However, in almost every paragraph, EVERY detail of what was happening from action to thoughts to physical reactions to feelings etc was included (I even found a paragraph in which a quote was unnecessarily repeated twice ("Her jaw dropped."), in my opinion, everything was excessively described. I believe that the plot would have benefited from fewer descriptions, especially because it is a story that can be read not just as a YA but also may appeal to MG fans but I felt like the writing style was closer to an adult novel even though the story is undeniably juvenile. Unfortunately, It prevented me from fully enjoying this novel.
Nevertheless, I give kudos to the author for including family and nature themes: these are themes that nowadays are overwhelmed by romance and I thought it was nice for a change.
Those who enjoy beautiful illustrations, fairytales, and medieval-like worlds might enjoy this;)
[This Review reflects my opinions]
ARC provided by the publisher via Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review (Thank you!)
The world building was interesting, the illustrations AMAZING, the romance was cute and the story was somehow trying to pass meaningful messages which I appreciated.
However, I could not connect with the characters. Maybe I had expectations for more depth/emotion or maybe it was just because of the pacing that I could not connect with them.
The reason why I'm giving this rating is that even though I felt the story had a lot of potential, I kept losing focus because the pacing was very slow and the author used too many descriptions. I love prose with descriptions and the author sometimes wrote such lovely quotes when she described certain sceneries...However, in almost every paragraph, EVERY detail of what was happening from action to thoughts to physical reactions to feelings etc was included (I even found a paragraph in which a quote was unnecessarily repeated twice ("Her jaw dropped."), in my opinion, everything was excessively described. I believe that the plot would have benefited from fewer descriptions, especially because it is a story that can be read not just as a YA but also may appeal to MG fans but I felt like the writing style was closer to an adult novel even though the story is undeniably juvenile. Unfortunately, It prevented me from fully enjoying this novel.
Nevertheless, I give kudos to the author for including family and nature themes: these are themes that nowadays are overwhelmed by romance and I thought it was nice for a change.
Those who enjoy beautiful illustrations, fairytales, and medieval-like worlds might enjoy this;)
[This Review reflects my opinions]
ARC provided by the publisher via Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review (Thank you!)
December 9, 2018
Immersive, lush storytelling full of action and humor, with a lovely message about celebrating who you are and embracing change.
February 11, 2019
I received an e-ARC from Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review. Review can be found on *Milky Way of Books*
A beautiful story about love family and nature. The illustrations will be fantastic in print since I got this as an e-ARC and Emeline's power of love is a delight to read. While this borders, to me, the line between YA and MG, it is recommended for its lush descriptions and wonderful storytelling.
A beautiful story about love family and nature. The illustrations will be fantastic in print since I got this as an e-ARC and Emeline's power of love is a delight to read. While this borders, to me, the line between YA and MG, it is recommended for its lush descriptions and wonderful storytelling.
June 15, 2021
5 out of 10.
Standard fantasy adventure story with a dash of romance. Nice illustrations, though.
Standard fantasy adventure story with a dash of romance. Nice illustrations, though.
April 6, 2025
3.5 stars ⭐️
0 chili peppers 🌶️
This is another book I picked up from some great art on Pinterest (turned out to be Sara Kipin, who illustrated frames for the book inserts), with a very “Over the Garden Wall” x “Spice and Wolf” vibe. It’s “the Familiar”-lite.
“Between the Water and the Woods” is an elevated YA story, and the simple writing style is actually a nice aspect because the world-building is thorough and immediately immersive. I say “elevated” thanks to the (wonderful) surprise commentary on bipartisan leadership, classicism, capitalism, and separation of church and state. My favorite part of this book was how each character has responded to the social-political climate around them; it was more interesting than the magic, frankly, to both me and the narrative.
Two criticisms: (1) I never got over the use of the term “dada” and kept waiting for it be the apex of a maturity arc, and (2) the pace of the last ~10% is an unearned rush as if someone told Snaith to hurry up and finish the book and don’t hold on the romance, equivalent to turning the knob on the gas stove too quickly.
Overall, this was a cute story with a long title. It’s not without a few head tilts as it crams a ton of different patchwork aspects all together. But is definitely the better version of the fantasy I read as a young adult.
0 chili peppers 🌶️
This is another book I picked up from some great art on Pinterest (turned out to be Sara Kipin, who illustrated frames for the book inserts), with a very “Over the Garden Wall” x “Spice and Wolf” vibe. It’s “the Familiar”-lite.
“Between the Water and the Woods” is an elevated YA story, and the simple writing style is actually a nice aspect because the world-building is thorough and immediately immersive. I say “elevated” thanks to the (wonderful) surprise commentary on bipartisan leadership, classicism, capitalism, and separation of church and state. My favorite part of this book was how each character has responded to the social-political climate around them; it was more interesting than the magic, frankly, to both me and the narrative.
Two criticisms: (1) I never got over the use of the term “dada” and kept waiting for it be the apex of a maturity arc, and (2) the pace of the last ~10% is an unearned rush as if someone told Snaith to hurry up and finish the book and don’t hold on the romance, equivalent to turning the knob on the gas stove too quickly.
Overall, this was a cute story with a long title. It’s not without a few head tilts as it crams a ton of different patchwork aspects all together. But is definitely the better version of the fantasy I read as a young adult.
January 3, 2019
Reviewed for School Library Journal.
July 30, 2019
I cannot, cannot, stress this enough: I absolutely loved this book. Loved.
And you just might as well. Especially if you like any of Hayao Miyazaki's films (Especially Howl's Moving Castle).
It was whimsy and charming. The tale was as if I was in a Studio Ghibli film (And it is not just because of the lovely cover). It was full of innocence and sweetness. But also touched on harsh truths about humans and their affinities to power and politics as well as the dangers of self-imposed ignorance by people who believe themselves to be smarter than nature.
Simone Snaith's tale is original and lovely. Lighthearted and sweet. But its charm is entirely her own spell that she has spun. She captured the innocence and complications of people in such a short span of 310 pages! Completed the tale in a such a wondrous way; you feel warm and satisfied when the soft sound of the hardcover plops closed. You will find that the low hum of adoration for her story seeps in your veins and you smile softly at the tingle. It is a feeling akin to the innocence of a first love or perhaps the nostalgia of the old tales of honorable knights and magic. But, of course, it is a good feeling. One that you will want to revisit again like a sweet memory. Perhaps when life is a little too dark or on a rainy day when you need warmth and comfort.
I will be rereading this book again to revisit that feeling. I know I will. Just like how we all re-watch any of the Studio Ghibli films and the Princess Bride over and over again. When we need to.
If I still worked at Barnes and Noble it would be my number one recommendation in the Young Adult Section and even to those under 13.
Thank you, Simone Snaith. For returning such an old world charm with this tale. Reading this was an honor. I think this was book was just delightful. And perhaps one day, would be just as delightful in the form of an animated film (Perhaps Hayao Miyazaki can pop out of retirement?). As the story and world you created is quite deserving of it, I think.
READ IT.
And you just might as well. Especially if you like any of Hayao Miyazaki's films (Especially Howl's Moving Castle).
It was whimsy and charming. The tale was as if I was in a Studio Ghibli film (And it is not just because of the lovely cover). It was full of innocence and sweetness. But also touched on harsh truths about humans and their affinities to power and politics as well as the dangers of self-imposed ignorance by people who believe themselves to be smarter than nature.
Simone Snaith's tale is original and lovely. Lighthearted and sweet. But its charm is entirely her own spell that she has spun. She captured the innocence and complications of people in such a short span of 310 pages! Completed the tale in a such a wondrous way; you feel warm and satisfied when the soft sound of the hardcover plops closed. You will find that the low hum of adoration for her story seeps in your veins and you smile softly at the tingle. It is a feeling akin to the innocence of a first love or perhaps the nostalgia of the old tales of honorable knights and magic. But, of course, it is a good feeling. One that you will want to revisit again like a sweet memory. Perhaps when life is a little too dark or on a rainy day when you need warmth and comfort.
I will be rereading this book again to revisit that feeling. I know I will. Just like how we all re-watch any of the Studio Ghibli films and the Princess Bride over and over again. When we need to.
If I still worked at Barnes and Noble it would be my number one recommendation in the Young Adult Section and even to those under 13.
Thank you, Simone Snaith. For returning such an old world charm with this tale. Reading this was an honor. I think this was book was just delightful. And perhaps one day, would be just as delightful in the form of an animated film (Perhaps Hayao Miyazaki can pop out of retirement?). As the story and world you created is quite deserving of it, I think.
READ IT.
May 20, 2019
3.5 stars
The story line was very simple and easy to figure out once they introduced the idea of automatons and water. The book also came off as to be read by a much younger crowd with a simple storyline as well as a very cute love interest.
I do wish I had more information on the magic and science mixture, but maybe the author will explore it in later books? However, the author did a good job of skirting all lines and playing it safe. This is not a bad thing because it opens her book up to younger readers who are not yet able to process all topics so heavily in one book.
This book is cute, creative, and huggable.
Maybe I had huge expectations and we can throw this review under my usual “high expectations bull-crap” because I should have noticed that the author writes for young adults. I keep telling myself I need to read more adult fictions but I keep getting sucker punched into these books with amazing covers, and keep forgetting that the storylines for a lot of young adult books these days are starting to all sound the same.
Maybe I’m looking for something different and I’m not finding it.
I would love for the author to keep up the good work though. She’s creative and just because the book wasn’t a five star for me. It could be for someone else.
The story line was very simple and easy to figure out once they introduced the idea of automatons and water. The book also came off as to be read by a much younger crowd with a simple storyline as well as a very cute love interest.
I do wish I had more information on the magic and science mixture, but maybe the author will explore it in later books? However, the author did a good job of skirting all lines and playing it safe. This is not a bad thing because it opens her book up to younger readers who are not yet able to process all topics so heavily in one book.
This book is cute, creative, and huggable.
Maybe I had huge expectations and we can throw this review under my usual “high expectations bull-crap” because I should have noticed that the author writes for young adults. I keep telling myself I need to read more adult fictions but I keep getting sucker punched into these books with amazing covers, and keep forgetting that the storylines for a lot of young adult books these days are starting to all sound the same.
Maybe I’m looking for something different and I’m not finding it.
I would love for the author to keep up the good work though. She’s creative and just because the book wasn’t a five star for me. It could be for someone else.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 18, 2019
Emeline's water and plant magic protects her and her family even as it's the cause, along with her brother's disobedience, that sends her from the safety of her village--well, maybe it's not that safe--to the capital city. Along the way she runs into more danger--and a Lash Knight--and the party, including also an assassin, a Sapient, and Innish, the knight's companion, travel on together. But the evil isn't just behind them, it's waiting in the capital and in the palace. The family--and Fish, their reluctant companion--has come to the king to ask his aid in protecting the village; however, the king is very ill, the villagers are looked down on by the elite in the capital, and Emeline's magic is a danger to her from the Sapients and the Theurgists and their conspiracies. But the royal woods are safe, aren't they? And even though they have the protection of a Lash Knight, Sir Reese, he has his own problems. And more is hidden than any of them realize.
I enjoyed the suspense, the romance, the adventure, and the unraveling of the secret of the Ithin.
I enjoyed the suspense, the romance, the adventure, and the unraveling of the secret of the Ithin.
June 29, 2019
Foiled again by pretty covers.
I outright love the cover. I love the illustrations in the book itself. Emeline is POC!
But nope, we get your typical YA fare. Our protag is not like the other girls(there's also A LOT of mentions of her bodice), she has a power but like...this power is not relevant for like 75% of the book. There's a boy, he's a jerkass to her at first but he's dreamy so it's okay.
The pacing is also poor. Most of the book was in the city with the characters just...meandering around. And when the final section did take off...it really took off. To the point that everything just kind of tied together neatly that it felt fake?
I dunno. I think I'm just disappointed in the direction this book took that I can't get my thoughts straight. The beginning held such promise too with the Ithin and the creepy factor but the book really went nowhere with it.
March 24, 2019
This is the cutest and most relaxing fantasy I've read in a long time. It's not intense, or very fast-paced, but I loved the characters and the magic/science debate. The story is decent and it's got a slow burn romance that I completely fell for. And a great dad-daughter-brother relationship. Bonus, it has gorgeous illustrations! It was just so relaxing for me. One problem I had with the novel was the world building and extent of the sciences. There is also no map. :/
If you're in a reading slump and need a mental break, this book will help!
If you're in a reading slump and need a mental break, this book will help!
July 7, 2023
I really enjoyed this read. The Ithin were appropriately scary, the tension between Reese and Emmaline was palpable, and I loved the magic and the family. It did give me slight uprooted vibes, which I dug. My only criticism would be the ending compared to the middle was kind of rushed and an extra fifty to a hundred pages would have been nice.
May 24, 2019
This book was so good! The minute Emeline and the Lash Knight meet, the story really takes off. I loved the mystery and growing romance. Also a fan of Sara Kipin’s art, so it felt like such a wonderful surprise to come upon the illustrations in the book!
May 9, 2025
⭐️3.5
I loved the dark vibes of this book! The mystery of the forests were good and the origins of the Ithin! I also loved how Reese was spiky upon first meeting and softened over time.
The things I disliked about this book are how singular this earth-shattering event was, the weird pacing, and the unsatisfying ending. :/
You’d think an army of automatons was bad. Suddenly, we find out the Ithin is real, but there was only one live one and the implication of maybe one more? And yet, all this is only limited to Emeline’s village and the capital. Also I get that Emeline is a Keldare, but how is it possible she is literally the only one with magic? And it’s completely unrelated to these folkloric horrors gallivanting about? Why is it all so localized?? The world-building was just not there.
The pacing was also botched. 50% of the book was some weird half-baked feminist commentary with traveling and thorny interactions. I thought it was going to go somewhere, but not really. That time could have easily been spent world building but instead it was men leering, anxiously tittering about, and pointless interactions with bystanders. The last 20% could have easily been stretched out to include more info as well?? Like the reveals felt like someone shooting bullets into the air and then they all rain down at the same time.
The ending was supremely unsatisfying with Irwind being like oh I crafted these eldritch horrors that murdered people and then I was too scared to tell anyone. Also I’m the long lost brother of the king. Oh also, my automatons are showing up rn everyone panic. It was so re re. I also wanted to see more development of Emeline and Reese’s relationship. The side characters like Dada, Fish, Dale, and Aladane were NOT fleshed out at all, and I feel like they were just written in to whatever interactions so we didn’t forget about them.
Anyway, it was a fun, quick read with some romance. Nothing crazy, but a good palette cleanser.
I loved the dark vibes of this book! The mystery of the forests were good and the origins of the Ithin! I also loved how Reese was spiky upon first meeting and softened over time.
The things I disliked about this book are how singular this earth-shattering event was, the weird pacing, and the unsatisfying ending. :/
You’d think an army of automatons was bad. Suddenly, we find out the Ithin is real, but there was only one live one and the implication of maybe one more? And yet, all this is only limited to Emeline’s village and the capital. Also I get that Emeline is a Keldare, but how is it possible she is literally the only one with magic? And it’s completely unrelated to these folkloric horrors gallivanting about? Why is it all so localized?? The world-building was just not there.
The pacing was also botched. 50% of the book was some weird half-baked feminist commentary with traveling and thorny interactions. I thought it was going to go somewhere, but not really. That time could have easily been spent world building but instead it was men leering, anxiously tittering about, and pointless interactions with bystanders. The last 20% could have easily been stretched out to include more info as well?? Like the reveals felt like someone shooting bullets into the air and then they all rain down at the same time.
The ending was supremely unsatisfying with Irwind being like oh I crafted these eldritch horrors that murdered people and then I was too scared to tell anyone. Also I’m the long lost brother of the king. Oh also, my automatons are showing up rn everyone panic. It was so re re. I also wanted to see more development of Emeline and Reese’s relationship. The side characters like Dada, Fish, Dale, and Aladane were NOT fleshed out at all, and I feel like they were just written in to whatever interactions so we didn’t forget about them.
Anyway, it was a fun, quick read with some romance. Nothing crazy, but a good palette cleanser.
August 28, 2020
3.5 stars - A book I picked up for the illustrations, keeping an eye out for Kilpin.
I loved this little romance/adventure story. It was the sweet/feel good fantasy novel that was not all swords, violence, and the she-will-save-them-all motif. However, I do wish this wasn't so short, and in turn, more flushed out.
Emeline is from a small, disconnected village at the edge of the kingdom, surrounded by a protective moat from the dangerous woods. One day, Emeline's brother, Dale, crosses the moat on a dare, and encounters a Dark Creature, called the Ithin and when Emeline saves her brother via water lilies, her family must now travel to the Capital to tell the King of the new threat.
I loved the story telling in this book. Snaith's writing is easy to consume and she creates a strong family dynamic that we do not see much in the genre. Care not only extends to her father and brother, but to Mr. Fish, a farmer in the village, and her brother's pesky friend Aladane. The world is mystical and old, yet developing and constantly changing.
Yet, it is too simplistic. For example, the reader does not learn much about Emeline's magic, her mysterious late mother, dark creatures, or the "magic that was left to spoil." Within this world, there is a clear divide between science and magic, but the reader only gets a taste and neither side is truly explored; the danger in this world is present, but not truly felt; the social norms are not clearly defined in this world. The reader experiences the world through naive Emeline and her family as their village is so stuck in time, they do not use money, but barter instead, the rest of the world are using guns with silver bullets, carriages that run on steam, and eat meat from a cow, and not fish; they don't even have coffee. Devastating.
In turn, characters are not fully flushed out. The reader knows Emeline, but other than her bravery, protective tendencies, budding fear of her magical abilities, and feelings for Sir Reese, we don't know much else about her. Sir Reese, a character that is depicted as an Underdog, is not given details, but basic information. The budding romance between Reese and Emeline is sweet and innocent, yet was missing a small something.
The novel moved along well enough, but most of the book, the characters are travelling. By the time we are all in the city and learn some thematic political intrigue, the novel is on the way to wrapping up. The "twist" and final battle are interesting, definitely didn't see coming, but some of the magical wind was taken out of my sails.
I left the book satisfied for these characters, but incredibly curious. I wanted to see more of these characters and this world. I wanted to see more of Emeline's abilities. I wanted to know what the King decided! I wanted to see the romance fully develop between the two. Go Reese for being considerate of the entire family, by the way. You just don't see that type of consideration.
Truly, despite my above complaints, I would recommend this book. It's a sweet middle-grade story that I would love to read again. I will definitely keep an eye on this other to see how her writing develops over time.
I loved this little romance/adventure story. It was the sweet/feel good fantasy novel that was not all swords, violence, and the she-will-save-them-all motif. However, I do wish this wasn't so short, and in turn, more flushed out.
Emeline is from a small, disconnected village at the edge of the kingdom, surrounded by a protective moat from the dangerous woods. One day, Emeline's brother, Dale, crosses the moat on a dare, and encounters a Dark Creature, called the Ithin and when Emeline saves her brother via water lilies, her family must now travel to the Capital to tell the King of the new threat.
I loved the story telling in this book. Snaith's writing is easy to consume and she creates a strong family dynamic that we do not see much in the genre. Care not only extends to her father and brother, but to Mr. Fish, a farmer in the village, and her brother's pesky friend Aladane. The world is mystical and old, yet developing and constantly changing.
Yet, it is too simplistic. For example, the reader does not learn much about Emeline's magic, her mysterious late mother, dark creatures, or the "magic that was left to spoil." Within this world, there is a clear divide between science and magic, but the reader only gets a taste and neither side is truly explored; the danger in this world is present, but not truly felt; the social norms are not clearly defined in this world. The reader experiences the world through naive Emeline and her family as their village is so stuck in time, they do not use money, but barter instead, the rest of the world are using guns with silver bullets, carriages that run on steam, and eat meat from a cow, and not fish; they don't even have coffee. Devastating.
In turn, characters are not fully flushed out. The reader knows Emeline, but other than her bravery, protective tendencies, budding fear of her magical abilities, and feelings for Sir Reese, we don't know much else about her. Sir Reese, a character that is depicted as an Underdog, is not given details, but basic information. The budding romance between Reese and Emeline is sweet and innocent, yet was missing a small something.
The novel moved along well enough, but most of the book, the characters are travelling. By the time we are all in the city and learn some thematic political intrigue, the novel is on the way to wrapping up. The "twist" and final battle are interesting, definitely didn't see coming, but some of the magical wind was taken out of my sails.
I left the book satisfied for these characters, but incredibly curious. I wanted to see more of these characters and this world. I wanted to see more of Emeline's abilities. I wanted to know what the King decided! I wanted to see the romance fully develop between the two. Go Reese for being considerate of the entire family, by the way. You just don't see that type of consideration.
Truly, despite my above complaints, I would recommend this book. It's a sweet middle-grade story that I would love to read again. I will definitely keep an eye on this other to see how her writing develops over time.
March 19, 2019
(Disclaimer: I received this book from the publisher. This has not impacted my review which is unbiased and honest.)
Between the Water and the Woods is a quiet book. Emeline was my favorite element of the book. Incredibly protective of her family, Emeline is motivated by love and a sense of community. Not only that, but she grows into her own decisions as she leaves her small village and has all sorts of new experiences. Not to mention, her relationship with Reese was a lovely contrast not only between their personalities, but between their backgrounds.
At the same time Between the Water and the Woods really picks up by the end transcending everything I expected. Society is divided by those who believe in magic and those who deny it, transforming their village sighting into one of politics, with all sides who have a stake in what Emeline and Dale stumbled into.
full review: https://utopia-state-of-mind.com/revi...
Between the Water and the Woods is a quiet book. Emeline was my favorite element of the book. Incredibly protective of her family, Emeline is motivated by love and a sense of community. Not only that, but she grows into her own decisions as she leaves her small village and has all sorts of new experiences. Not to mention, her relationship with Reese was a lovely contrast not only between their personalities, but between their backgrounds.
At the same time Between the Water and the Woods really picks up by the end transcending everything I expected. Society is divided by those who believe in magic and those who deny it, transforming their village sighting into one of politics, with all sides who have a stake in what Emeline and Dale stumbled into.
full review: https://utopia-state-of-mind.com/revi...
June 11, 2022
To be honest, I got this book on interlibrary loan because I follow Sara Kipin’s art lol. But the story was fun! It’s definitely geared towards tweens, although I think older kids would enjoy it as well. It’s a fun travel story with monsters, romance, and intrigue. If you’re looking for an easy magical read, this was a solid book.
June 8, 2019
I liked the narrative (and the illustrations were fantastic), but I never really felt like Emeline was in legitimate danger, or that she really went through the hero's journey. Still, it was a fun Friday afternoon read.
dnf
May 21, 2024dnf @ 80%
was a cute book but ig just not my cup of tea?
the storyline's well crafted but i just got bored at one point, if i have the time i'd like to restart this to finish it one day!!!
was a cute book but ig just not my cup of tea?
the storyline's well crafted but i just got bored at one point, if i have the time i'd like to restart this to finish it one day!!!
September 9, 2025
3.5 ⭐️’s
August 21, 2024
Artwork kept showing up when I looked up fantasy knights on Pinterest. Picked up the book to see what the story was about. Long review short: not bad but I found it a bit shallow in plot and character.
January 1, 2022
Sweet and simple. I was surprised that there were a lot of steampunk elements, which were a bit underdeveloped (as well as the magic system). Actually, my only complaint is that the whole story was a bit underdeveloped; I would have happily read a longer book if it was more fleshed out.
May 5, 2019
Actual rating: 3.5
Between the Water and the Woods is a nice little read. That’s it. I wish I could say it was exciting or full of adventure but it really wasn’t. The summary makes it out to be as if it’s going to be dramatic and full of people wanting to endanger Emaline’s and her family’s life or that her magic will rescue a kingdom full of monsters. It’s not a bad read and I def rec this book more so b/c of Kipin’s illustrations. Funny thing is that I kept wondering why the style looked so familiar until I realized I’ve been following the artist for some time on tumblr. I haven’t used the site in months so it took me a moment.
The story begins with Emaline watching over her brother while he plays with some of his friends. They play near a moat that surrounds the village in order to protect it from Dark Creatures who live in the woods next to them. Dark Creatures are supposed to be afraid of water so they don’t cross over. Well, Emaline’s brother Dale, wanting to prove that he’s brave, crosses the moat in order to fulfill a dare. Emaline, scared for her brother, rushes after him. Once on the other side, an Ithin tries to kill them but they get away by splashing water on it. Emaline discovers she has magic and after a town meeting, it is decided that by law she and her family have to report this sighting to the king.
The book had me hooked from the start. The characters made me laugh, cringe and say 'awww’. I enjoyed Dale and his little stowaway friend. Fish was a great character! He was funny, loyal, and trustworthy. While I grew to adore Reese, I don’t understand why he behaved like such a jerk in the beginning. Especially considering his background. I also don’t understand why he stopped behaving that way and start to like Emaline. Was it just because he finds out about her magic and being Keldare?? Same with her, why does she start to like him? Is it due to finding out his past and learning about how he differs from others? If I were her, I wouldn’t excuse the way he behaved just because he was handsome. Besides those little blips, I enjoyed reading about the characters. [Reese is so cute with the way he acts once he finds out about his feelings although I don’t think I like them as a couple. I couldn’t find any substance in their romance. And the “you treat me differently than everyone else” thing isn’t cutting it.]
The ending of the book is why I am not able to give this a higher rating. A big reveal happens and all of a sudden it feels as if there’s a race to the finish line. The story quickly wraps up in a nice big bow so everyone gets a “happy” ending. It seems so rushed to me.
This isn’t criticism but I wanted to point out that while reading it, it seemed very MG. I enjoy MG so I’m not bashing on it but for those who want an uncomplicated and simple read then this is it. There is no explanation about magic or any of the other creatures lurking about except the Ithin. There’s a convenient explanation to this all: The MC’s mother who is strongly implied to have had magic is dead so it’s not like we can get a rundown about the magic in this world and since they live in an isolated village they are ignorant about other ongoings besides what’s written in her father’s books.
**Written for RR Les Liaisons Dangereuses IG book review week 2 challenge (May 5-11).
Between the Water and the Woods is a nice little read. That’s it. I wish I could say it was exciting or full of adventure but it really wasn’t. The summary makes it out to be as if it’s going to be dramatic and full of people wanting to endanger Emaline’s and her family’s life or that her magic will rescue a kingdom full of monsters. It’s not a bad read and I def rec this book more so b/c of Kipin’s illustrations. Funny thing is that I kept wondering why the style looked so familiar until I realized I’ve been following the artist for some time on tumblr. I haven’t used the site in months so it took me a moment.
The story begins with Emaline watching over her brother while he plays with some of his friends. They play near a moat that surrounds the village in order to protect it from Dark Creatures who live in the woods next to them. Dark Creatures are supposed to be afraid of water so they don’t cross over. Well, Emaline’s brother Dale, wanting to prove that he’s brave, crosses the moat in order to fulfill a dare. Emaline, scared for her brother, rushes after him. Once on the other side, an Ithin tries to kill them but they get away by splashing water on it. Emaline discovers she has magic and after a town meeting, it is decided that by law she and her family have to report this sighting to the king.
The book had me hooked from the start. The characters made me laugh, cringe and say 'awww’. I enjoyed Dale and his little stowaway friend. Fish was a great character! He was funny, loyal, and trustworthy. While I grew to adore Reese, I don’t understand why he behaved like such a jerk in the beginning. Especially considering his background. I also don’t understand why he stopped behaving that way and start to like Emaline. Was it just because he finds out about her magic and being Keldare?? Same with her, why does she start to like him? Is it due to finding out his past and learning about how he differs from others? If I were her, I wouldn’t excuse the way he behaved just because he was handsome. Besides those little blips, I enjoyed reading about the characters. [Reese is so cute with the way he acts once he finds out about his feelings although I don’t think I like them as a couple. I couldn’t find any substance in their romance. And the “you treat me differently than everyone else” thing isn’t cutting it.]
The ending of the book is why I am not able to give this a higher rating. A big reveal happens and all of a sudden it feels as if there’s a race to the finish line. The story quickly wraps up in a nice big bow so everyone gets a “happy” ending. It seems so rushed to me.
This isn’t criticism but I wanted to point out that while reading it, it seemed very MG. I enjoy MG so I’m not bashing on it but for those who want an uncomplicated and simple read then this is it. There is no explanation about magic or any of the other creatures lurking about except the Ithin. There’s a convenient explanation to this all: The MC’s mother who is strongly implied to have had magic is dead so it’s not like we can get a rundown about the magic in this world and since they live in an isolated village they are ignorant about other ongoings besides what’s written in her father’s books.
**Written for RR Les Liaisons Dangereuses IG book review week 2 challenge (May 5-11).
September 12, 2020
I quite enjoyed this. What's not to like? Captivating characters, writing, and the world and politics were so fascinating. I love the idea of the lash knights. Also the pictures were gorgeous.
January 19, 2020
Between the Water and the Woods is a whimsical story about a young girl, Emeline, and the journey she must undertake to tell the King that darkness dwells in the woods of her small village, and to ask him for protection. Along the way, Emeline realizes she, herself, has magic abilities that could pose a threat to her journey--and she meets the hardened Reese, who she inevitably is charmed by. But with the kingdom split between magic believers and non-believers, will Emeline and her family be able to convince the sickly king to help? Or is her beloved village doomed?
With simplistic language and relatively flat characters, this novel feels severely misplaced as a young adult fantasy novel; it reads more like a juvenile novel, which isn't altogether bad, but definitely disappointing. From the excerpt on the back, I was expecting something with more intrigue, action, and depth; unfortunately, Between the Water and the Woods does not deliver on that. The artwork is absolutely beautiful and was, in my opinion, the most interesting part; I found myself quickly reading through the passages just to get a glimpse of Sara Kipin's art. The worst part, in my opinion, was that Emeline's mysterious magic powers are basically useless--just like her self-conscious ramblings and her constant mentioning of her bodice.
The characters felt very one-dimensional and there was no notable character development that felt realistic. Not really, and I didn't even find myself caring that much. I enjoyed this novel enough--the light whimsy had its charms--I really wish it could've had more. More development, more backstory, more middle-of-the-night-conversations (you know the kind). The potential was absolutely there, but Snaith needed someone to let her know that this type of novel was meant to have a heaviness, something that made it raw. Not all fantasy novels need to be flowers and meadows.
With simplistic language and relatively flat characters, this novel feels severely misplaced as a young adult fantasy novel; it reads more like a juvenile novel, which isn't altogether bad, but definitely disappointing. From the excerpt on the back, I was expecting something with more intrigue, action, and depth; unfortunately, Between the Water and the Woods does not deliver on that. The artwork is absolutely beautiful and was, in my opinion, the most interesting part; I found myself quickly reading through the passages just to get a glimpse of Sara Kipin's art. The worst part, in my opinion, was that Emeline's mysterious magic powers are basically useless--just like her self-conscious ramblings and her constant mentioning of her bodice.
The characters felt very one-dimensional and there was no notable character development that felt realistic. Not really, and I didn't even find myself caring that much. I enjoyed this novel enough--the light whimsy had its charms--I really wish it could've had more. More development, more backstory, more middle-of-the-night-conversations (you know the kind). The potential was absolutely there, but Snaith needed someone to let her know that this type of novel was meant to have a heaviness, something that made it raw. Not all fantasy novels need to be flowers and meadows.
July 27, 2019
3.7 STARS.
I ENJOYED IT.
I loved loved loved the little twist at the end that dealt with the magical aspect of the story. The romance was also very much welcomed and sweet. It gave me Pride and Prejudice vibes. I also liked how Snaith portrayed culture shock in this novel by both TELLING AND SHOWING the reader what it felt like to be in that situation. I find that this is becoming a rare thing in the YA fantasy I pick up. It wasn’t a deep portrayal but it was BALANCED. That’s really the word I would use to describe the novel. It’s themes also dealt with the balance of power between fantasy and science which could have been better but works either way for this short a book. Overall it’s such a good short and sweet fantasy novel.
Now it could have been better. While the twist was done well enough, throughout most of the book I thought that the romance was a bit underdeveloped and seemed like it was just hanging on to the very last half. It wasn’t even a solid love-hate thing because the characters just seemed a bit indifferent to each other at first (with a few moments of bickering). Now I still like it because it was fluffy towards the end when all the shit was going down. So to me it felt appropriate because that’s when stakes are at their highest. Also another weird thing that bugged me was how Reese only started actively showing that he liked Emeline after he sees her power in action. And his character isn’t super developed enough in my opinion that it’s totally off the table that he’s 1) Just another guy enchanted by something new that he cannot understand and 2) Using Emeline to gain status? He was pretty roughed up on his way to becoming a Lash Knight so it’s not entirely impossible.
In conclusion:
Good light read.
Don’t expect high fantasy.
Expect cutesy fluff and plant magic.
I ENJOYED IT.
I loved loved loved the little twist at the end that dealt with the magical aspect of the story. The romance was also very much welcomed and sweet. It gave me Pride and Prejudice vibes. I also liked how Snaith portrayed culture shock in this novel by both TELLING AND SHOWING the reader what it felt like to be in that situation. I find that this is becoming a rare thing in the YA fantasy I pick up. It wasn’t a deep portrayal but it was BALANCED. That’s really the word I would use to describe the novel. It’s themes also dealt with the balance of power between fantasy and science which could have been better but works either way for this short a book. Overall it’s such a good short and sweet fantasy novel.
Now it could have been better. While the twist was done well enough, throughout most of the book I thought that the romance was a bit underdeveloped and seemed like it was just hanging on to the very last half. It wasn’t even a solid love-hate thing because the characters just seemed a bit indifferent to each other at first (with a few moments of bickering). Now I still like it because it was fluffy towards the end when all the shit was going down. So to me it felt appropriate because that’s when stakes are at their highest. Also another weird thing that bugged me was how Reese only started actively showing that he liked Emeline after he sees her power in action. And his character isn’t super developed enough in my opinion that it’s totally off the table that he’s 1) Just another guy enchanted by something new that he cannot understand and 2) Using Emeline to gain status? He was pretty roughed up on his way to becoming a Lash Knight so it’s not entirely impossible.
In conclusion:
Good light read.
Don’t expect high fantasy.
Expect cutesy fluff and plant magic.
January 1, 2022
I loved this one. Loved the story and characters.
April 20, 2023
simple and sweet! very fairytale-like if you’re into that kind of thing. reese and emeline are soooo cuteeeee wish i could see more of them together <3
Displaying 1 - 30 of 110 reviews