I want to start by saying I’m not the biggest fan of the Most Wanted series. If I had a choice to choose the weakest series out of I’ve read this far (can’t count Horrorland since I haven’t read it), this is BY FAR the weakest series. And books like Night Of The Puppet People remind of the cons that modern Goosebumps books tend to have. Issues like: dropped concepts that seem to stand out or sound interesting, and an overall tameness to the entire story. This book on the surface looked like a lot of things: a Night Of The Living Dummy reskin, told in the Most Wanted format. The tagline says something to the effect of: Monsters you WANT to see. No, Stine. Stop. We didn’t want to see this one. PUPPET PEOPLE? Ouch. As the story progresses it felt more a kin to stories from Series 2000, albeit the tamed modern versions we typically get with exceptions to ahandful of books out there. And it’s problems are synonymous with the typical bad books of the series. Why a 2⭐️ review? I guess I’ll explain.
The story starts off with an okay prologue taking place 7 years prior to the current events. This portion is told in third person, which was odd. But it fits. These two twins named Ben and Jenny are having a birthday party and this wizard act with marionette puppets decides to perform at their party but you’d expect it, the puppets are somehow botching the act. The birthday twins are traumatized by this memory, and as the present day arises later on, you learn that it was a suppressed memory the two shared. But what became of that mechanism?
Well modern day kicks in, they’re now 12 and they introduce us to their best-friend Bird, who’s Dad happens to be the costumed wizard from their suppressed memory. The main perspective is now told in Ben’s eyes, and there is a new talent show coming up with a $500 prize he desperately wants to win. Too bad, he, he sister, and Bird don’t have any real talents. We then meet two dislikable brats named Anna and Maria who snuff them off as some type of pretentious do-gooders who are seemingly only mean to them. They learn that the two girls have a puppet show in mind for the talent show and struggle to find something cooler.
They rummage through Bird’s attic and find the puppets and decide to go through with adding the puppets to their act for the talent show, potentially one upping Anna and Maria. They want to keep it a secret from Bird’s father, who seemingly hid them away on purpose not to be found.
The trip then use the puppets at the talent show tryouts, pissing off Anna and Maria and two separate events involving the trio’s and girls’ puppets ensues. Leaving the trio suspended from school and banned from the talent show.
After it’s revealed that it may or may not have been a prank elaborated by a certain party, this is where the story really loses its railing (in a negative way). We are made to believe the puppets aren’t really alive, but somehow maybe are and they have “electrical” powers to say the least. Ben is on the receiving end of said powers and let’s say, he gets infected with Puppet Cells..: I wish I was making that up, but that legit happens in the book.
The body horror gets a bit good but still tamer than what you would’ve saw in the mid to late 90’s. The kids notice that Ben is essentially becoming a puppet. By some stroke of miracle, they find a card in one of the puppets pockets and head to the headquarters of this puppet maker’s shop (actually offering origin to object centered goosebumps books Stine - A for effort - F for results here). They end up breaking into the location on the card, greeted by this puppet maker who offers to cure Ben from the.. Puppet Cells.. because the puppets they had were a “bad batch”. After seeing the “bad puppets” reaction to the puppet maker, they freak out. But after a few dozen mini fake outs, dun dun dun. The puppet maker wants to cure Ben, make him human, only to turn him back to a puppet again… What?
The context gets heavily convoluted as the kids managed to escape the puppet maker’s place without knowing what happens further. They decide to attend the talent show and boo people (because I guess they’re the mean kids after all) and discover a horrifying twist. With its own fair share of disappointment accompanied with it.
This story has lots that happens, but that’s all I can say about it. Stuff happens. The tangibility of the plot stems down this repressed memory that the twins share. The unsettling truth of the puppets… right? Well, that concept isn’t actually utilized in this story. Once they “remember” the birthday party, it doesn’t even phase them. All of that for nothing I suppose? Wasted potential with that concept. It also feels eerily familiar to the plot structure of a book earlier on in Most Wanted called Son Of Slappy, if you read that, the first 90 or so pages will feel extremely familiar. And remember back to the point earlier that on the surface this book is a blatant reskin of the NOTLD books? Well it is. This book suffers from anything original. And the originality, towards the end, rather sucks. Nothing makes sense involving context. Are these puppets evil or is it the puppet maker? Why would pranks be involved with certain people if the puppets…weren’t.. alive? And above all else, why would the puppet maker cure a human of puppet cells… to put puppet cells back into him? I think it was hinted at corrupted cells, but ay yi yi? PUPPET CELLS?
This book went from being a NOTLD rip off, to being a NOTLD rip off with a bad twist angle, interjecting weak science fiction points for shock value. Dismantling the cool concepts it had going for it, and leave the reader realizing the trio of kids by the end are just as awful as Anna and Maria. I guess the main message to take away (loosely) is the cost of greed. Don’t be greedy people!!! Shame shame! But this book even fails to highlight that basic of a moral concept in a meaningful way. The only good from this story is the interesting ideas of suppressed memories which got botched and the sliver of good body horror. Everything else was boring, dull, unoriginal, and bad.
I’ve read much worse in the series, this book at least tries to offer something to the table, just botches it at every turn. Better than most 1 ⭐️ books are able to do. It’s a bad book, not quite terrible but easily a bad book. I gave this book a 2.7/5 ⭐️ for me, which is a D-. I don’t recommend this book at all. Maybe some new readers would get a kick out of it, if they haven’t been exposed to other Goosebumps books in the past. Read Son Of Slappy in this series over this, that’s a better book.