What do you think?
Rate this book


194 pages, Hardcover
First published December 4, 2018
A book of lyrics is a strange beast. Readers who know the songs become 'bearers' as the brain belts out a speeded-up version of the familiar recording, while those readers unfamiliar with the lyrics are confronted by text presented in a poetry format, but which is avowedly not poetry. Poetry is a solo art form: most lyrics need to leave room for, and craft an affinity with, music - just as lines in a screenplay must be sparse enough to allow for an actor's interpretation. Even in instances where lyrics could pass for poetry to the unwary, lyrics on the page are still a boat in dry-dock, removed from the elements that buoy them and determine their velocity. (p.xi)So although I would not have bought this myself, I was of course mighty pleased to get it as a Christmas present, and the experience has been a whole lot more than I could have imagined it to be. The book itself is beautifully cloth bound, with a lovely little sparkle on the cover. Most of the songs included will be recognisable to fans, and it was tricky at first not to hear the melodies in your mind, but if you can make yourself focus just on the words on the page, I think even the die-hard follower will get something new from the songs by consuming in this different manner. After Mitchell's introduction, the collection began with a song that has always been one of my favourites lyric-wise, 'Top of the City':
One more step to the top of the cityOther favourites, that have always left me near tears when I've listened to them, included 'This Woman's Work' (I should be crying but I just can't let it show / I should be hoping but I can't stop thinking), 'Army Dreamers' (What could he do? / Should have been a father' / But he never even made it to his twenties / What a waste), 'Deeper Understanding' (about humans losing themselves to the digital age...can you believe this was from the late 80s?!), and 'Experiment IV'; the latter should be offered as proof that Kate is one of greatest and most emotive storytellers of our time:
Where just a couple of pigeons are living
Up on the angel's shoulders
I don't know if I'm closer to Heaven but
It looks like Hell down there
These streets have never been
Paved with gold
Welcome to the loneliest city in
The world (p.6)
We were working secretly for the militaryThen there were the surprises. Firstly, the songs that I've never really listened closely enough to notice how clever the lyrics are, such as with 'Sat in Your Lap', which I think has so much wacky stuff going on musically, it's hard to really listen to the words. Reading them both made me laugh out loud and marvel at how right Kate is (for it's true as a species we all have very little patience...):
Our experiment in sound was nearly ready to begin
We only know in theory what we are doing
Music made for pleasure, music made to thrill
It was music we were making here until
They told us all they wanted
Was a sound that could kill someone from a distance
So we go ahead and the meters are over in the red
It's a mistake in the making (p.64)
I've been doing it for years, my goal is moving nearSecondly, there were the songs that I didn't recognise, that have completely passed me by. So this book has also given me a few new (to me) Kate Bush songs to seek out, which I'm rather excited about!
It says 'Look, I'm over here', then it up and disappear
Some say that knowledge is something sat in your lap
Some say that knowledge is oh-oh-oh-oh
I want to be a lawyer, I want to be a scholar
But I really can't be bothered, ooh just
Gimme it quick, gimme it, gimme, gimme, gimme, gimme (p.34)