This is the start of a new police procedural series set in Newcastle (England) featuring DCI Jack Lambert. There is, of course, a serial killer, as well as the obligatory team dysfunction, broken relationships and tortured hero. It was quite good, but there was nothing particularly original here.
Two bodies have been found entwined, their shallow grave having been recently dug up to make their discovery inevitable. The victims did not appear to know each other, and had nothing in common. Jack Lambert has recently returned to work after recovering from injuries sustained in a previous serial killing case that left both he and the force bruised by press criticism, his confidence lost. Then a member of a local drug dealing gang, which Jack was involved with in his previous life, is found dead, and a pop star reports being stalked. Overworked and understaffed, Jack and his underlings, ice cold Christensen and borderline sex-pest Watkins, are getting nowhere even when more bodies show up, and have to battle hostile journalists and solicitors, office power struggles and try to get help from Jack’s angry ex, the pathologist, and alcoholic friend the psychological profiler. Throw in gang turf wars and a horribly unhealthy lifestyle and it’s no wonder Jack is having headaches...
I don’t really know Newcastle, apart from a few weekend visits in the very early 90s when my sister was studying there - and neither have I read much fiction set there - most of my UK based series seem to be set in London or Yorkshire. I like it when the location becomes almost another character, but this certainly didn’t suggest anything appealing about the place - it never seems to stop raining, for a start.
The plot was okay, with quite a lot of threads introduced, things ended up being wrapped up very quickly, as it’s not a particularly long book.
I was disappointed that the author missed the opportunity to take the main point of difference here - an openly gay detective who has recently come out, and go somewhere with it - maybe this is being kept for future books, but the hero is neither in any kind of active relationship nor even attracted to anyone. He doesn’t even really get any kind of grief or bullying for it, his colleagues just tip-toe around the subject, showing a sensitivity that doesn’t ring true compared to the rest of their behaviour (rampant sexism and misogyny, for example.)
I also kept feeling that I had missed an earlier book, with all the references to the Newcastle Knifer case that are made, but this is definitely the first in the series. I’ve read so many detective series that I’m used to the lead being a misunderstood genius, so Lambert being a complete dimwit felt a bit odd. He rushes into danger alone, on the say-so of a bad guy, not once but twice, and doesn’t really solve the case apart from one moment of insight.
I’m possibly being a bit hard on this, especially as it’s a first novel. I did enjoy reading it for the most part, the writing was fine although as others have mentioned, the ARC has some errors with names etc that have hopefully been corrected for publication, and there was a serious lack of spacing between sub-chapters that made it hard to follow at times. I probably would read the next one to see where Peacock takes his amiable Geordie hero, but the genre is crowded, and for those who don’t read as much crime fiction as I do, this is not the best out there.
My thanks to Bloodhound Books and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for a voluntary honest review. Open Grave is published on 26.09.18.