I enjoyed this book. I haven't lived in the world of traditional academia, with its emphasis on tenure and position, so Elegant Freefall provided a rare glimpse into this world that I found engaging and entertaining. The main character, Sylvia, is well-developed, and the revelation she experiences at the end was truly satisfying. I was cheering Sylvia throughout the book, even in the parts where she was annoying and self-centered. The antagonist, Lily, is also intriguing, and her sudden transition from "the one" to "a terrible mistake" makes for an exciting conflict. The story is entertaining and definitely keeps you reading.
I didn't completely connect with the characters myself, but that's because the book was not written for me. Concerns about who's sleeping with whom and the search for love aren't among my favorite plot points, but I found that Rodgers captures those feelings very effectively through dialog that sounds real. My favorite feature of this book is that the most lovable characters were Arkansans, all begging Sylvia to return to her home state and her roots. As a native Arkansan who left the state to seek her fortune, only to return after learning there's no place like home, I loved the descriptions of some of my favorite places in Arkansas. I definitely connected with Sylvia's reluctance to return to a state that isn't necessarily known for its open-mindedness, yet is so beautiful, so friendly that natives are drawn to it despite its shortcomings. The descriptions of Arkansas and of relationships with parents and friends kept me reading, and I'm glad that there was a happy ending, and perhaps a change of heart, for Sylvia at the end.