Thanks to NetGalley and the author for sending me an e-ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
This was a bit of a mixed bag for me. I expected to love "The Exchange," given its intriguing premise; though I did enjoy it, it didn't quite live up to its potential as a story.
The idea of time-traveling exchange students was fascinating and opened up a lot of possibilities that were largely cashed in on. The mystery aspect was fun, and I really loved how the truly far-fetched parts of the book - time-traveling exchange students - were integrated into the story so seamlessly. It wasn't difficult to suspend disbelief. However, it took well over half of the book for the plot to truly get going, and even when it did, there were quite a few loose ends that never got resolved. The mystery-ish aspect was really fun, and it COULD have helped the book overcome its weaker first half, but it left a little too much unresolved. For example *SPOILER*: why do we never find out if the Exchanges are actually being sent to their deaths? The kids talk about it as if it's fact, but we never actually learn whether they're right or not. And what's up with the mom subplot? It's thrown in for a few pages at the end of the book and helps to give credence to the kids' theory, but is sort of never touched on again despite the deep ramifications it should have had for the characters. There are also oft-repeated references to a character named Americus, someone who apparently had a huge impact on protagonist Ari's life, but whose identity is never fully explained. We're told that she was an Exchange from 1940s Hawaii, but nothing else. WHO WAS SHE??? And what the heck happened to her that turned Ari against the Institute? Whatever happened to Americus (and why is her name Americus? That doesn't seem period-accurate) is supposed to have shaped Ari's outlook and views in the future, so I don't understand why she was so glossed-over. *END SPOILER* Those loose ends, and the vague ending, kind of killed the momentum of what would otherwise have been a gripping finale. Now, if this book has a planned sequel, that's another thing entirely - that would make a lot of sense given the vague ending and plot holes. But since there isn't any mention of one anywhere online, I'm going to assume it's a standalone.
I wasn't hugely fond of the writing style either; it lacked polish and seemed, in places, unedited. Granted, this could very well be a consequence of the fact that it's an ARC, but the style of this didn't work for me. I'm probably just overly picky about this, but the punctuation was often off, and the sentence structure was...clunky at best. That, more than the plot holes, was what bothered me most about "The Exchange."
I know what I've said thus far sounds very harsh, and believe me, I wanted to edit it down to make it less so, but found that largely impossible. I enjoyed this book quite a bit - I really did! - but it had a lot of writing flaws that I found it hard to overlook. The good news? A lot of what I mentioned could be revised by the time the book is released, since nothing I mentioned would be impossible to correct. I hope it is, because "The Exchange" is a fun distraction with a fascinating premise and all the potential in the world were some minor issues to be addressed.I wasn't hugely fond of the writing style either; it lacked polish and seemed, in places, unedited. Granted, this could very well be a consequence of the fact that it's an ARC, but the style of this didn't work for me. I'm probably just overly picky about this, but the punctuation was often off, and the sentence structure was...clunky at best. That, more than the plot holes, was what bothered me most about "The Exchange."