Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Books for providing me with an advanced digital read copy of PROLOGUE TO MURDER by Lauren Elliott. This is the second book in the series featuring Addie Greyborne, former researcher for Boston Public Library and new resident for Greyborne Harbor. It isn’t necessary to have read the first book in the series to understand this one, and the mystery stands alone in each book. There are some relationship developments with a couple of other major characters that were started in the first book, but Ms. Elliott makes it easy to understand what those are if you start reading the series with this book.
In this novel, Addie is once again confronted with townspeople who are less than pleased that she has moved to the area. Just when she thought she had earned her place by solving the previous murder, she is plunged into a second one courtesy of a new gossip columnist who has just been hired by the local paper and who seems to have targeted Addie for some reason.
There are others around who also have it in for Addie and make her life uncomfortable. Starting off, there is Lacey Davenport, one time girlfriend of Addie’s possible love interest, Chief of Police Marc Chandler. She has come back to town after spending time on the west coast and seems focused on driving a wedge between Addie and the rest of the town, especially Marc. As the book unfolds, her reasons become more clear; although from the beginning the tension and dislike between the two women is evident. There is also Addie’s business neighbor who runs the local bakery. She made it clear in the first book she didn’t like Addie and that seems to have deepened with this novel. She marshals a number of other people in town who seem intent on making Addie miserable.
All of this combines to create a hole in Addie’s business and a rift between both her and Marc as well as her best friend Serena, Marc’s sister. Addie is confused about why she is on the receiving end of such hatred and has no way to combat the problem. The rift between Marc and Addie seems exceptionally mercurial and they go from warming to each other’s company to arguing and going in separate directions in such a short time it feels a bit unnatural.
The mystery is well done. June, the former librarian has been found dead and there are limited clues as to what has happened. The gossip columnist, “Miss Newsy” starts spreading the rumor that Addie commited the murder because she wanted the position of librarian, and although she explains to every one she isn’t a librarian but a researcher and has no interest, her protests fail to sway anyone’s opinion.
The murder takes place as the town is preparing for it’s annual pirate fest. June, the victim, had done extensive research on pirates who settled in Greyborne Harbor until Addie’s ancestor came along and drove them out. Could it be that some of June’s research has information about possible buried treasure? Adding to this theory is the information that Lacey’s ancestor had a feud with Addie’s ancestor over driving the pirates out and the thought that perhaps Lacey is continuing the bad feelings from that distant feud.
Into the midst of all this comes Simon, a new doctor in town who develops an immediate interest in Addie. She is conflicted because she has feelings for Marc, but acknowledges there is something about Simon that draws her to him. There is a setup for a perfect triangle in these relationships that continues throughout most of the book.
The clues and red herrings throughout the book are good, although it was easy early on to determine the identity of the murderer. The book is interesting, but the sudden shifts between attraction and anger between Addie and Marc create some unnecessary tension and serve to bog down some of the rest of the story. It’s as if the book is half mystery and half romance, not fully one or the other.
Overall, I liked most of this book, although I did not like it as much as the first book in the series. I will read then next book in the series before I make a final decision as to whether or not to continue reading the series.