What do you think?
Rate this book
A cosa servono le ragazze
"A cosa servono le ragazze" è un romanzo che racconta la vera storia di Nellie Bly, la prima giornalista investigativa al mondo, la donna che ha contribuito a rivoluzionare la condizione sociale femminile.
La storia inizia nel 1885, quando Elisabeth Cochrane, una mattina, leggendo il Dispatch, rimane colpita da un articolo che tratta del ruolo delle donne, viste esclusivamente come perfette padrone di casa e madri di famiglia. Elizabeth s'infuria e decide di scrivere a sua volta al giornale. La sua voce è forte, totalmente nuova, polemica: e questo non può che piacere al direttore del giornale che, in maniera del tutto inaspettata, le propone un lavoro come giornalista. Nellie Bly sarà il nome con cui inizierà a firmare i suoi articoli diventando una vera icona del femminismo, che si batte contro l'industria dominata dagli uomini, riportando storie che nessun altro vuole raccontare. Non si accontenta di scrivere, ma con una passione e determinazione dirompenti, si cala nei ruoli più diversi per vivere sulla propria pelle e documentare le situazioni e le condizioni delle donne lavoratrici del suo tempo. Fingendosi pazza, arriverà addirittura a entrare nel manicomio di Blackwell's Island, rimanendoci per dieci lunghi giorni. Spogliata, drogata, picchiata, dovrà sopportare dieci notti di terrore e rivivere i giorni più bui della sua infanzia, per riuscire poi a fuggire e raccontare al mondo la sua storia.
La storia inizia nel 1885, quando Elisabeth Cochrane, una mattina, leggendo il Dispatch, rimane colpita da un articolo che tratta del ruolo delle donne, viste esclusivamente come perfette padrone di casa e madri di famiglia. Elizabeth s'infuria e decide di scrivere a sua volta al giornale. La sua voce è forte, totalmente nuova, polemica: e questo non può che piacere al direttore del giornale che, in maniera del tutto inaspettata, le propone un lavoro come giornalista. Nellie Bly sarà il nome con cui inizierà a firmare i suoi articoli diventando una vera icona del femminismo, che si batte contro l'industria dominata dagli uomini, riportando storie che nessun altro vuole raccontare. Non si accontenta di scrivere, ma con una passione e determinazione dirompenti, si cala nei ruoli più diversi per vivere sulla propria pelle e documentare le situazioni e le condizioni delle donne lavoratrici del suo tempo. Fingendosi pazza, arriverà addirittura a entrare nel manicomio di Blackwell's Island, rimanendoci per dieci lunghi giorni. Spogliata, drogata, picchiata, dovrà sopportare dieci notti di terrore e rivivere i giorni più bui della sua infanzia, per riuscire poi a fuggire e raccontare al mondo la sua storia.
558 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2018
282 people are currently reading
887 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 80 reviews
September 12, 2022
Why I chose to read this book:
1. Nellie Bly first intrigued me when I became aware of her celebrity from a reading comprehension essay that I had assigned to my Grade 3 students a few years ago. Later, as I was listening to the audiobook The Address by Fiona Davis, a reference was made to Nellie Bly while the protagonist was living at Blackwell's Island Lunatic Asylum. I just had to read more about this woman! and,
2. June is "Biographical Fiction Month" for me!
Praises:
1. Plot: author David Blixt neatly lays out how Elizabeth Cochrane got started in her career as the female pioneer of investigative reporting, how she received her pen name "Nellie Bly", her stint as a foreign correspondent in Mexico, and most exciting of all, her undercover expose of Blackwell's Island Lunatic Asylum, where she brought to light how female patients were mistreated through horrible neglect and violent assaults by various staff members;
2. Characterization: Blixt paints Nellie Bly as a no-nonsense, opinionated spitfire who knows what she wants. At times, I rooted for her tenacity, felt sympathy for her as a child living in an abusive home, but also found her unlikable whenever she was "hitting on" a married male colleague - definitely a well-rounded character; and,
3. I appreciated Blixt's inclusion of various newspaper columns, especially those written by Nellie Bly herself!
Niggles:
1. for the most part, the dialogue seemed authentic, but occasional "modern day" slip-ups occurred. I got quite distracted by the various spelling and grammatical errors found throughout the book. Also, the island country south of India wasn't named Sri Lanka until 1972, long past Nellie Bly's time!
I don't understand why independently-published books are "infamous" for such inconsistencies! Do they not hire copy editors or even proofreaders? Please, show respect to your readers and clean up mistakes before sending these books to market!
2. Plot: some plot lines were a bit extraneous. I wish more detail was given about Nellie Bly's reporting of government corruption in Mexico and why she felt that she was in danger.
Overall thoughts:
Even though some parts of this book seemed overkill and other parts felt lacking, and the conventional errors sure didn't appeal to me, I did enjoy the story as a whole since it did keep me turning the pages. Most importantly, I did learn more about Nellie Bly, especially her time spent as an undercover "insane patient", as I had hoped.
Recommendation?
If you can get past my "niggles", then I do recommend this well-researched book!
1. Nellie Bly first intrigued me when I became aware of her celebrity from a reading comprehension essay that I had assigned to my Grade 3 students a few years ago. Later, as I was listening to the audiobook The Address by Fiona Davis, a reference was made to Nellie Bly while the protagonist was living at Blackwell's Island Lunatic Asylum. I just had to read more about this woman! and,
2. June is "Biographical Fiction Month" for me!
Praises:
1. Plot: author David Blixt neatly lays out how Elizabeth Cochrane got started in her career as the female pioneer of investigative reporting, how she received her pen name "Nellie Bly", her stint as a foreign correspondent in Mexico, and most exciting of all, her undercover expose of Blackwell's Island Lunatic Asylum, where she brought to light how female patients were mistreated through horrible neglect and violent assaults by various staff members;
2. Characterization: Blixt paints Nellie Bly as a no-nonsense, opinionated spitfire who knows what she wants. At times, I rooted for her tenacity, felt sympathy for her as a child living in an abusive home, but also found her unlikable whenever she was "hitting on" a married male colleague - definitely a well-rounded character; and,
3. I appreciated Blixt's inclusion of various newspaper columns, especially those written by Nellie Bly herself!
Niggles:
1. for the most part, the dialogue seemed authentic, but occasional "modern day" slip-ups occurred. I got quite distracted by the various spelling and grammatical errors found throughout the book. Also, the island country south of India wasn't named Sri Lanka until 1972, long past Nellie Bly's time!
I don't understand why independently-published books are "infamous" for such inconsistencies! Do they not hire copy editors or even proofreaders? Please, show respect to your readers and clean up mistakes before sending these books to market!
2. Plot: some plot lines were a bit extraneous. I wish more detail was given about Nellie Bly's reporting of government corruption in Mexico and why she felt that she was in danger.
Overall thoughts:
Even though some parts of this book seemed overkill and other parts felt lacking, and the conventional errors sure didn't appeal to me, I did enjoy the story as a whole since it did keep me turning the pages. Most importantly, I did learn more about Nellie Bly, especially her time spent as an undercover "insane patient", as I had hoped.
Recommendation?
If you can get past my "niggles", then I do recommend this well-researched book!
December 24, 2018
Have you heard of Nellie Bly? That spitfire of a reporter important for catapulting women’s rights? ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
Nellie Bly was born Elizabeth Cochrane in small-town Pennsylvania during the Victorian era. As an adult, she reads the article, “What Girls are Good For,” which compels her to to write a letter to the Pittsburgh Dispatch. Well, guess what? They paper hired her as a reporter, which was practically unheard of for women at the time.
Elizabeth changes her name to Nellie Bly and becomes a champion of the issues she finds most important, the plight of women.
Nellie Bly lives her life no-holds-barred. She does not hold back with what she thinks, and if there’s a story to tell, she’s going to uncover it.
Her biggest project comes when she pretends to be mentally ill so she can report on treatment inside an asylum. She’s successful getting inside, but once there, she is overwhelmed with what she encounters. She is imprisoned for a week when she is supposed to be rescued, but no one comes.
Blixt provides a fascinating and riveting account of Bly’s most adventurous and triumphant life. I think everyone will inspired by Nellie. She stops at nothing to uncover the wrongs in the world, and she uses her powerful voice for change. It’s hard to wrap my head around how much she was able to accomplish at a time when women were not working outside the home unless it was in service. She chooses her own path and lives life exactly as she chooses.
Overall, Blixt’s writing is a brilliant sorcery in this account of a brave and bold woman and her heroic actions.
Thank you to the author for the complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
My reviews can also be found on my blog: www.jennifertarheelreader.com
Nellie Bly was born Elizabeth Cochrane in small-town Pennsylvania during the Victorian era. As an adult, she reads the article, “What Girls are Good For,” which compels her to to write a letter to the Pittsburgh Dispatch. Well, guess what? They paper hired her as a reporter, which was practically unheard of for women at the time.
Elizabeth changes her name to Nellie Bly and becomes a champion of the issues she finds most important, the plight of women.
Nellie Bly lives her life no-holds-barred. She does not hold back with what she thinks, and if there’s a story to tell, she’s going to uncover it.
Her biggest project comes when she pretends to be mentally ill so she can report on treatment inside an asylum. She’s successful getting inside, but once there, she is overwhelmed with what she encounters. She is imprisoned for a week when she is supposed to be rescued, but no one comes.
Blixt provides a fascinating and riveting account of Bly’s most adventurous and triumphant life. I think everyone will inspired by Nellie. She stops at nothing to uncover the wrongs in the world, and she uses her powerful voice for change. It’s hard to wrap my head around how much she was able to accomplish at a time when women were not working outside the home unless it was in service. She chooses her own path and lives life exactly as she chooses.
Overall, Blixt’s writing is a brilliant sorcery in this account of a brave and bold woman and her heroic actions.
Thank you to the author for the complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
My reviews can also be found on my blog: www.jennifertarheelreader.com
December 10, 2018
Read for a cover quote, which I was very happy to do! David Blixt pens a heroine for the ages in "What Girls Are Good For," which follows the extraordinary career of pioneer newspaperwoman Nellie Bly. A pint-sized dynamo who refuses to stay in the kitchen, Nellie fights tooth and nail to make a name for herself as a journalist, battling complacent men, corrupt institutions, and her own demons along the way. This real-life Lois Lane had me cheering aloud as I turned the pages - simply a delight.
November 15, 2025
Recunosc faptul ca nu stiam nimic despre Nellie Bly inainte sa citesc acest volum, astfel am descoperit pas cu pas povestea ei - este cu adevarat un exemplu de curaj si ambitie. 😊
December 28, 2018
2018 has shaped up to be one of the best years of reading that I can remember! I don't even know how I'm going to narrow it down to my favorite reads of the year but I do know that What Girls are Good For will be on it!
As I was finishing up reading What Girls are Good For last night all I could think of was just how I was going to write a review worthy of this amazing book. Since that's impossible I'll just tell you about how much I loved it!
I was absolutely blown away by David Blixt's novel of Nellie Bly -- a woman before her time, a woman that defied expectations and challenged the status quo of women, a woman after my own heart! She had a big mouth, a big heart, and big amibitions, and I adored her instantly.
If you know David or follow him online you know he is a great advocate for women and that shines through in the book. In my opinion, I've not found many male authors that can write women well, particularly a woman like Nellie, but David is the exception.
Historical authors are tasked with bringing important figures from history to life and David did just that with Nellie Bly, and brilliantly I might add. I think he did her proud!
Do yourself a favor and pick this up soon! Be prepared to fall in love with Nellie!
As I was finishing up reading What Girls are Good For last night all I could think of was just how I was going to write a review worthy of this amazing book. Since that's impossible I'll just tell you about how much I loved it!
I was absolutely blown away by David Blixt's novel of Nellie Bly -- a woman before her time, a woman that defied expectations and challenged the status quo of women, a woman after my own heart! She had a big mouth, a big heart, and big amibitions, and I adored her instantly.
If you know David or follow him online you know he is a great advocate for women and that shines through in the book. In my opinion, I've not found many male authors that can write women well, particularly a woman like Nellie, but David is the exception.
Historical authors are tasked with bringing important figures from history to life and David did just that with Nellie Bly, and brilliantly I might add. I think he did her proud!
Do yourself a favor and pick this up soon! Be prepared to fall in love with Nellie!
January 14, 2019
Pochi libri mi lasciano turbata, infastidita e con lo stomaco sottosopra come "A cosa servono le ragazze", ma abbiamo bisogno anche e soprattutto di libri del genere.
Quando ho saputo dell'uscita di questo libro sapevo che avrei dovuto leggerlo: la storia della prima (dopo mille difficoltà) giornalista investigativa del mondo, femminista, che addirittura si finse pazza per entrare in manicomio e raccontare di ciò che accadeva, non poteva essere ignorata.
E ho fatto bene!
La storia di Nellie è sconvolgente perchè è ambientata a fine '800 ma anche e soprattutto perchè i ragionamenti che vengono espressi dalla prosa metodica e completa di Blixt sono incredibilmente -e in alcuni casi disgustosamente- attuali. La ragazza, che non ha intenzione di sposarsi e aver figli, vuole soltanto vivere la propria vita secondo i suoi personali canoni, lavorando, mantenendo la propria indipendenza ed autonomia e, perchè no, anche innamorandosi.
Nel periodo in cui Nellie vive, però, le cose non sono così semplici, e i giudizi arrivano aspri. Giudizi provenienti da chiunque, dal mondo degli affetti a quello lavorativo; ma è quì che Nellie sboccia e, in un mondo creato a misura di uomini, si fa valere in quanto essere umano.
La sua determinazione nel far rispettare le proprie idee e la propria persona sono le cose che più mi hanno colpito della storia di Blixt. Nellie si crea un mestiere e lo svolge al massimo, e nel farlo indaga su strani casi, viaggia in Messico e ne scopre la corruzione, parla di cultura, e, infine, arriva in un manicomio.
Già di per sè non proprio un libro facile, quando il lettore entra con Nellie in manicomio ha bisogno di uno stomaco forte per leggere di ciò che accade.
Le descrizioni delle condizioni in cui le donne -non tutte malate, anzi!- dell'epoca vivevano nella struttura, la poca empatia delle figure di potere, la crudeltà, l'indifferenza e l'assenza di rispetto con cui quelle donne venivano trattate mi hanno dato il voltastomaco.
Il velo di normalità che la società ha cercato di mantenere, separando il "normale" dal sempre "diverso" in Nellie Bly crolla, e fa male, perchè si parla di qualcosa di terribilmente attuale, problematizzando i pensieri, le azioni e le intenzioni con cui le persone agiscono.
È un libro crudo che non si limita a raccontare della grandezza di una donna ma anche a mettere in luce tutto ciò che non va nella società di allora e di ora, raccontato in uno stile romanzato che si prende il suo tempo senza essere lento.
La caratterizzazione dei personaggi è sublime, a partire da Nellie fino ad arrivare ai personaggi secondari e alle comparse, e sebbene non sia un libro di piccola mole non sono riuscita a posarlo. Blixt ha avuto fra le mani una grande eredità e ne ha fatto una grande storia, una sorta di biografia raccontata chiaramente e senza indorare la pillola, che comunque mi ha conquistata fino all'ultima pagina.
Quando ho saputo dell'uscita di questo libro sapevo che avrei dovuto leggerlo: la storia della prima (dopo mille difficoltà) giornalista investigativa del mondo, femminista, che addirittura si finse pazza per entrare in manicomio e raccontare di ciò che accadeva, non poteva essere ignorata.
E ho fatto bene!
La storia di Nellie è sconvolgente perchè è ambientata a fine '800 ma anche e soprattutto perchè i ragionamenti che vengono espressi dalla prosa metodica e completa di Blixt sono incredibilmente -e in alcuni casi disgustosamente- attuali. La ragazza, che non ha intenzione di sposarsi e aver figli, vuole soltanto vivere la propria vita secondo i suoi personali canoni, lavorando, mantenendo la propria indipendenza ed autonomia e, perchè no, anche innamorandosi.
Nel periodo in cui Nellie vive, però, le cose non sono così semplici, e i giudizi arrivano aspri. Giudizi provenienti da chiunque, dal mondo degli affetti a quello lavorativo; ma è quì che Nellie sboccia e, in un mondo creato a misura di uomini, si fa valere in quanto essere umano.
La sua determinazione nel far rispettare le proprie idee e la propria persona sono le cose che più mi hanno colpito della storia di Blixt. Nellie si crea un mestiere e lo svolge al massimo, e nel farlo indaga su strani casi, viaggia in Messico e ne scopre la corruzione, parla di cultura, e, infine, arriva in un manicomio.
Già di per sè non proprio un libro facile, quando il lettore entra con Nellie in manicomio ha bisogno di uno stomaco forte per leggere di ciò che accade.
Le descrizioni delle condizioni in cui le donne -non tutte malate, anzi!- dell'epoca vivevano nella struttura, la poca empatia delle figure di potere, la crudeltà, l'indifferenza e l'assenza di rispetto con cui quelle donne venivano trattate mi hanno dato il voltastomaco.
Il velo di normalità che la società ha cercato di mantenere, separando il "normale" dal sempre "diverso" in Nellie Bly crolla, e fa male, perchè si parla di qualcosa di terribilmente attuale, problematizzando i pensieri, le azioni e le intenzioni con cui le persone agiscono.
È un libro crudo che non si limita a raccontare della grandezza di una donna ma anche a mettere in luce tutto ciò che non va nella società di allora e di ora, raccontato in uno stile romanzato che si prende il suo tempo senza essere lento.
La caratterizzazione dei personaggi è sublime, a partire da Nellie fino ad arrivare ai personaggi secondari e alle comparse, e sebbene non sia un libro di piccola mole non sono riuscita a posarlo. Blixt ha avuto fra le mani una grande eredità e ne ha fatto una grande storia, una sorta di biografia raccontata chiaramente e senza indorare la pillola, che comunque mi ha conquistata fino all'ultima pagina.
January 7, 2019
It would be pretty much impossible to come up with enough superlatives to describe this David Blixt book regarding the infamous Nellie Bly, a woman who stood up for rights when women were expected to only stand up at a kitchen sink, a woman who put herself willingly in perilous situations in order to enlighten her readers about the injustices that were being committed - and routinely ignored - all around them, a woman whose courage cannot be understated.
Focusing on her early years, this book tells the story of how Nellie Bly came to be. Elizabeth Cochrane in real life, she was infuriated after reading an article in the Pittsburgh Dispatch entitled "What Girls Are Good For". Penning an angry reply, she has no clue what changes her reply will bring to her life.
No newspaper in those Victorian years hired female reporters. Women couldn't handle it. Women belonged in the home. The men would be uncomfortable around women reporters - they wouldn't be able to cuss and act normal, etc. Eventually Elizabeth Cochrane, writing as Nellie Bly, becomes the first female reporter. At first she is given exactly what you would expect - covering fashion, elite society, and the like - none of which interested her.
She fights hard to be taken seriously. She convinces her boss to let her go to Mexico (her mother will go with her, much to her dismay - but safety is first) to bring to light what really is happening there. The trip takes months, and she runs afoul of government officials and must return quickly, where she reports exactly what is going on. Women loved her - although a few found her unfeminine and manly, a woman who didn't know her place. Men didn't know what to think.
The biggest story is when she fakes being insane in order to be admitted to a horrific insane asylum with rumors of extreme abuse. What she goes through in 10 days is nothing short of torture. Because of her bravery, the abusers are held accountable by a court of law, and her articles bring her fame and fortune. The women who were abused are removed and taken care of. No more icy cold baths, no more windows open all winter with no appropriate clothing, no more rancid food, no more hard beds, no more bruises and worse.
This is one of those books that will stay with you. Thanks to people like the brave Nellie Bly, women began to make strides with regards to their rights as equal human beings to the powerful men.
Focusing on her early years, this book tells the story of how Nellie Bly came to be. Elizabeth Cochrane in real life, she was infuriated after reading an article in the Pittsburgh Dispatch entitled "What Girls Are Good For". Penning an angry reply, she has no clue what changes her reply will bring to her life.
No newspaper in those Victorian years hired female reporters. Women couldn't handle it. Women belonged in the home. The men would be uncomfortable around women reporters - they wouldn't be able to cuss and act normal, etc. Eventually Elizabeth Cochrane, writing as Nellie Bly, becomes the first female reporter. At first she is given exactly what you would expect - covering fashion, elite society, and the like - none of which interested her.
She fights hard to be taken seriously. She convinces her boss to let her go to Mexico (her mother will go with her, much to her dismay - but safety is first) to bring to light what really is happening there. The trip takes months, and she runs afoul of government officials and must return quickly, where she reports exactly what is going on. Women loved her - although a few found her unfeminine and manly, a woman who didn't know her place. Men didn't know what to think.
The biggest story is when she fakes being insane in order to be admitted to a horrific insane asylum with rumors of extreme abuse. What she goes through in 10 days is nothing short of torture. Because of her bravery, the abusers are held accountable by a court of law, and her articles bring her fame and fortune. The women who were abused are removed and taken care of. No more icy cold baths, no more windows open all winter with no appropriate clothing, no more rancid food, no more hard beds, no more bruises and worse.
This is one of those books that will stay with you. Thanks to people like the brave Nellie Bly, women began to make strides with regards to their rights as equal human beings to the powerful men.
January 11, 2019
Nellie Bly was possibly the world's first under-cover, investigative journalist - both male or female - and her story is well worth investigating through this intense biographical, historical fiction novel "What Girls are Good For: A Novel of Nelly Bly" by David Blixt.
https://tcl-bookreviews.com/2019/01/1...
https://tcl-bookreviews.com/2019/01/1...
February 18, 2020
I heard a lot of positive things about writer David Blixt's books before starting this.
Sadly most of his historical fiction is not set in periods that I am most interested in reading about but this book was and it was really cheap on Kindle so I took a chance and I am so glad I did!
Nellie Bly has fascinated me as I had already read her books Ten days in a madhouse and Around the world in seventy-two days and have really enjoyed both.
What David Blixt does for me in this book is something I had not expected to be possible, he made Nellie come alive more than I got from reading just her own words. I'm glad to learn from the afterword that he is already working on a next book about Nellie Bly. Because while I was reading I thought that it was a pity the book was going to end and that I would have loved it if this was a 10 book series.
There certainly is material enough left to fill some extra volumes and I will be first in line to read these :-) So al in al 5 star book!
Sadly most of his historical fiction is not set in periods that I am most interested in reading about but this book was and it was really cheap on Kindle so I took a chance and I am so glad I did!
Nellie Bly has fascinated me as I had already read her books Ten days in a madhouse and Around the world in seventy-two days and have really enjoyed both.
What David Blixt does for me in this book is something I had not expected to be possible, he made Nellie come alive more than I got from reading just her own words. I'm glad to learn from the afterword that he is already working on a next book about Nellie Bly. Because while I was reading I thought that it was a pity the book was going to end and that I would have loved it if this was a 10 book series.
There certainly is material enough left to fill some extra volumes and I will be first in line to read these :-) So al in al 5 star book!
December 17, 2018
Elizabeth Cochrane has always been seen as a troublemaker, questioning why things are the way they are and standing up for what she believed was right. As an adult, Lizzie takes a stand after a newspaper column by the Quiet Observer defames women. After writing a reply to the column, Elizabeth is hired by the Pittsburgh Dispatch for her unique point of view. Given the pseudonym Nellie Bly, she quickly used her new found skills to tell the stories of women's issues that were not often discussed including poverty, divorce and the stories of factory girls. Nellie eventually finds herself in Mexico then New York to write the story of a lifetime after committing herself to an asylum.
I have of course heard the name Nellie Bly and her legacy, but never knew her whole story. Written with historical accuracy and the ability to dive into Nellie's head, Nellie's story is heartfelt, intriguing and raw. Learning about how Nellie grew up, I was able to see what drove her to be impassioned to fight for women's rights and those who are underserved. Throughout the story Nellie's passion and spirited personality shown through. Going undercover with Nellie was a treat as I saw snippets of factory life, Mexico City and the asylum through her eyes. I enjoyed being able to read her articles as well as how they came to be. I also was impressed by how many times Nellie was met by failure and still persisted, a lesson that still endures for many women today. Nellie Bly not only persisted, she learned, grew and honed her talent in order to become a better reporter. Overall, an intense story of one of the groundbreaking women in journalism.
This book was received for free in return for an honest review.
I have of course heard the name Nellie Bly and her legacy, but never knew her whole story. Written with historical accuracy and the ability to dive into Nellie's head, Nellie's story is heartfelt, intriguing and raw. Learning about how Nellie grew up, I was able to see what drove her to be impassioned to fight for women's rights and those who are underserved. Throughout the story Nellie's passion and spirited personality shown through. Going undercover with Nellie was a treat as I saw snippets of factory life, Mexico City and the asylum through her eyes. I enjoyed being able to read her articles as well as how they came to be. I also was impressed by how many times Nellie was met by failure and still persisted, a lesson that still endures for many women today. Nellie Bly not only persisted, she learned, grew and honed her talent in order to become a better reporter. Overall, an intense story of one of the groundbreaking women in journalism.
This book was received for free in return for an honest review.
December 21, 2018
There were two factors that made me want to read this book. First, the author. I’ve seen his books around in the circle of historical fiction authors, in fact, I met him once back in Denver when he did a masterclass on sword fighting, with the real thing (how did he get those through airport security?). His novels in Ancient Rome are patiently waiting while I wind my way out of the 19th/20th-century interests of late. Which brings me to my 2nd reason, Nellie Bly is a woman I’ve heard of but know nothing about. This is my kind of reading - entertaining and educational at the same time. I love reading about women in history, I was going to say strong women but they don't always start that way, it's a process, it’s through their experiences that make them stronger - like Nellie Bly.
I knew right from the beginning I’d love this book. Elizabeth or rather Nellie is spunky, spontaneous and rather a hoot. You never knew what she’d do next, whether it be interviewing factory workers, heading off to Mexico or an Insane Asylum I was totally captivated. Through these experiences, Nellie has to change and that’s what makes reading about her so interesting.
I love books that go deep, where not just the characters are developed nicely but the plot as well. I’ve found with some books this size that they could do with fewer pages but in this case, I loved the length and detail. The characters are authentic, I was immersed in the era, the author's research definitely shined through here.
What Girls Are Good For is a story of perseverance, standing up for what you believe in and an example of never giving up.
I knew right from the beginning I’d love this book. Elizabeth or rather Nellie is spunky, spontaneous and rather a hoot. You never knew what she’d do next, whether it be interviewing factory workers, heading off to Mexico or an Insane Asylum I was totally captivated. Through these experiences, Nellie has to change and that’s what makes reading about her so interesting.
I love books that go deep, where not just the characters are developed nicely but the plot as well. I’ve found with some books this size that they could do with fewer pages but in this case, I loved the length and detail. The characters are authentic, I was immersed in the era, the author's research definitely shined through here.
What Girls Are Good For is a story of perseverance, standing up for what you believe in and an example of never giving up.
March 15, 2019
David Blixt’s What Girls Are Good For is an illuminating and thought-provoking examination of the early career of Nellie Bly – the American feminist and journalist who turned a spotlight on many inequities of late 19th and early 20th-century society. Blixt has deftly interspersed Bly’s writings into this novel that traces her anger over limitations and demands placed on women in 1880s Pittsburgh (and elsewhere) to her groundbreaking exposé on conditions in New York City’s facilities for the “insane.” I found the description of conditions on Blackwell’s Island particularly poignant, as my great grandfather spent his final 13 years in New York’s Willard State Hospital, in the early 20th century. David Blixt has brilliantly colorized the sepia-toned world of our ancestors and I cannot wait until the April 27th meeting of our book club to share observations on this enjoyable, readable, and important book.
July 30, 2020
I feel like completing this book is more of an accomplishment than it should be. I have been trying to read it for over a year and just could not get through it.
The book really suffers from a lack of good editing. There are numerous spelling mistakes and grammatical errors throughout, so much so that whoever read the copy I checked out from the library prior to me started editing the book. But the author tries to tell too much story in too much detail and that makes the book too long. When Nellie goes into the insane asylum, the book is amazing, fast-paced and horrifying, but, to get to that, you have to sort through 300 pages of dreck.
I am glad I didn't buy this book.
The book really suffers from a lack of good editing. There are numerous spelling mistakes and grammatical errors throughout, so much so that whoever read the copy I checked out from the library prior to me started editing the book. But the author tries to tell too much story in too much detail and that makes the book too long. When Nellie goes into the insane asylum, the book is amazing, fast-paced and horrifying, but, to get to that, you have to sort through 300 pages of dreck.
I am glad I didn't buy this book.
July 4, 2023
Traduzione italiana di un libro pubblicato negli USA tramite self-publishing (trovo che sia una premessa fondamentale per evitare giudizi troppo negativi).
Riguardo la storia, a prescindere dalla traduzione, ritengo che la quantità degli argomenti trattati potesse occupare al massimo la metà delle pagine stampate, evitando tutte le ripetizioni e le descrizioni fin troppo particolareggiate (per un libro che è dichiaratamente un romanzo, non una biografia).
Riguardo la traduzione, preferisco non esprimermi ma si percepisce moltissimo che è stata fatta da più persone e questo non dovrebbe accadere mai.
Non mi esprimo nemmeno riguardo alla quantità di refusi (non solo tipografici ma anche grammaticali e, talvolta, sintattici) e alla mancanza di un indice (in un libro di 47 capitoli divisi in 5 parti), penso sia sufficiente riportare questi fatti.
Riguardo la storia, a prescindere dalla traduzione, ritengo che la quantità degli argomenti trattati potesse occupare al massimo la metà delle pagine stampate, evitando tutte le ripetizioni e le descrizioni fin troppo particolareggiate (per un libro che è dichiaratamente un romanzo, non una biografia).
Riguardo la traduzione, preferisco non esprimermi ma si percepisce moltissimo che è stata fatta da più persone e questo non dovrebbe accadere mai.
Non mi esprimo nemmeno riguardo alla quantità di refusi (non solo tipografici ma anche grammaticali e, talvolta, sintattici) e alla mancanza di un indice (in un libro di 47 capitoli divisi in 5 parti), penso sia sufficiente riportare questi fatti.
January 3, 2019
I’ve wanted to know more about pioneering journalist Nellie Bly for a long time, so when I learned that David Blixt had written a novel about her, I snapped it up. It’s an engrossing tale, full of a young woman’s rage against injustice and detailing the adventures Nellie Bly gets into because of that fury. The story about how she investigated an insane asylum in New York makes the last section of the novel nearly impossible to put down. I recommend this book without reservation.
July 9, 2020
Blimey, this was a long read!
3.5. stars
Positives being it beautifully depicts a part of American history, and Nellie Bly , who I had never heard of, is a true inspiration.
Negatives, it’s just too drawn out for my liking. The whole Mexican part left me rather cold. I didn’t get drawn in until the last quarter of the book, but then it was unputdownable!
3.5. stars
Positives being it beautifully depicts a part of American history, and Nellie Bly , who I had never heard of, is a true inspiration.
Negatives, it’s just too drawn out for my liking. The whole Mexican part left me rather cold. I didn’t get drawn in until the last quarter of the book, but then it was unputdownable!
March 18, 2019
“A cosa servono le ragazze” è un romanzo asettico, ammorbante, sicuramente non aiutato da un pessimo lavoro di traduzione e editing.
La recensione completa qui: https://www.lalibridinosa.com/2019/03...
La recensione completa qui: https://www.lalibridinosa.com/2019/03...
December 19, 2018
When I was a little girl, I had a book called 'Herstory', which highlighted women in history who were badass, bluntly put, and who seemed to get the short end of the stick. It had all different women, from Cleopatra to Carry Nation to Frida Kahlo and many others. If I could ever find it again, I'd buy it in a hot minute because I adore reading about women in history. Included was Nellie Bly. Nellie was way ahead of her time and I was thoroughly intrigued as a little girl, about this woman who was sick of the patriarchy and their rules that had women repressed and stuck at home, waiting for a husband. She didn't believe that a woman's sole purpose in life should be to bear children. It wasn't something she wanted for herself and I was glad to read about it.
David Blixt has taken up the mantle and has written this novel from Nellie's POV. Now, I know some of you are thinking, 'why is a man writing a woman's story?' I assure you, it is well done and is extremely thoughtful. I would truly have believed Nellie was writing the book herself. It is very clear that Mr. Blixt studied her writing well because he writes in her voice perfectly.
Nellie Bly is a pseudonym for Elizabeth Cochrane, who is known as a 'troublemaker'. To those of us who have read about her, she is ahead of her time. She reads a piece in the local paper that sends her absolutely on edge and she writes a response. It leads her to get a job there and beginning her very illustrious career. What she is most especially known for is what is covered, her infiltrating an asylum and documenting the mistreatment of women, Mexico City as well as factory life. She took on Women's Rights before it was the 'cool' thing to do, essentially and what an impact. Yet, she remains largely unappreciated. This book--and the others that are coming out this coming year--are finally shining a light on the 'troublemaker' herself.
I highly recommend this book. It is big, but it is worth the time it'll take you to read it. I was in a bit of a slump, but this grabbed my attention. The attention to the time period, the locales, the story, and everything...it's exceptional. I really give Mr. Blixt his props for this. You all know how I adore a well-researched book.
You know how Senator Elizabeth Warren said earlier this year, "Nevertheless, she persisted?" Nellie Bly is the embodiment of that.
Now. Go. Go read this.
David Blixt has taken up the mantle and has written this novel from Nellie's POV. Now, I know some of you are thinking, 'why is a man writing a woman's story?' I assure you, it is well done and is extremely thoughtful. I would truly have believed Nellie was writing the book herself. It is very clear that Mr. Blixt studied her writing well because he writes in her voice perfectly.
Nellie Bly is a pseudonym for Elizabeth Cochrane, who is known as a 'troublemaker'. To those of us who have read about her, she is ahead of her time. She reads a piece in the local paper that sends her absolutely on edge and she writes a response. It leads her to get a job there and beginning her very illustrious career. What she is most especially known for is what is covered, her infiltrating an asylum and documenting the mistreatment of women, Mexico City as well as factory life. She took on Women's Rights before it was the 'cool' thing to do, essentially and what an impact. Yet, she remains largely unappreciated. This book--and the others that are coming out this coming year--are finally shining a light on the 'troublemaker' herself.
I highly recommend this book. It is big, but it is worth the time it'll take you to read it. I was in a bit of a slump, but this grabbed my attention. The attention to the time period, the locales, the story, and everything...it's exceptional. I really give Mr. Blixt his props for this. You all know how I adore a well-researched book.
You know how Senator Elizabeth Warren said earlier this year, "Nevertheless, she persisted?" Nellie Bly is the embodiment of that.
Now. Go. Go read this.
January 18, 2019
Bellissima lettura quella di "A cosa servono le ragazze" di David Blixt, una totale immersione nella vita di una donna che ha rivoluzionato il mondo del giornalismo investigativo.
Nellie Bly - che avevo già conosciuto in "Dieci giorni in manicomio", ha combattuto da sempre per i suoi diritti di donna e per essere ritenuta degna di lavorare, arrivando poi a intraprendere la carriera di giornalista.
Dalle prime battaglie con i fratelli e la famiglia, fino alla decisione di farsi internare in manicomio per indagare sulle condizioni dei pazienti, David Blixt ci racconta la vita di una persona che ha tanto da insegnare a tutti noi.
Quando il femminismo non aveva ancora un nome, moltissime donne lottavano per essere considerate.
Ho adorato questo libro non solo per la trama interessante, ma anche per lo stile in cui il tutto viene raccontato. Non mi sono annoiata mai!
Nellie Bly - che avevo già conosciuto in "Dieci giorni in manicomio", ha combattuto da sempre per i suoi diritti di donna e per essere ritenuta degna di lavorare, arrivando poi a intraprendere la carriera di giornalista.
Dalle prime battaglie con i fratelli e la famiglia, fino alla decisione di farsi internare in manicomio per indagare sulle condizioni dei pazienti, David Blixt ci racconta la vita di una persona che ha tanto da insegnare a tutti noi.
Quando il femminismo non aveva ancora un nome, moltissime donne lottavano per essere considerate.
Ho adorato questo libro non solo per la trama interessante, ma anche per lo stile in cui il tutto viene raccontato. Non mi sono annoiata mai!
December 27, 2018
4.5 stars. There are historical fiction books that introduce you to people that you can't believe you didn't know about before. There are other historical fiction books where you can't believe the subject isn't one that has been visited before. This book is the latter. This book is a thoughtful, vibrant send up of an amazing woman. Blixt makes Nellie jump off the page and had me wondering how on earth it took someone so long to give her such a great historical fiction treatment!
Nellie Bly has always been fascinating to me. Here was a woman truly before her time. She became an investigative journalist at a time where the whole investigative journalism genre was still quite nascent. She became a journalist at a time where women were generally expected to stay home. She went against the grain and wrote amazing pieces that showed the dark underbelly of things that the general public had little awareness of. This book dives into all of her greatest feats and how she went about doing her work.
I was particularly interested in the level of detail that the author infused in this book. Nellie's world changes a lot throughout this book. I loved how the author included some of the newspaper articles surrounding the events of the book. It was so interesting seeing how the things Nellie went through were covered (like the whole mental hospital episode - fascinating!!!).
Nellie is such a great character! I loved getting to meet her all over again in this book! I definitely recommend this book!
Nellie Bly has always been fascinating to me. Here was a woman truly before her time. She became an investigative journalist at a time where the whole investigative journalism genre was still quite nascent. She became a journalist at a time where women were generally expected to stay home. She went against the grain and wrote amazing pieces that showed the dark underbelly of things that the general public had little awareness of. This book dives into all of her greatest feats and how she went about doing her work.
I was particularly interested in the level of detail that the author infused in this book. Nellie's world changes a lot throughout this book. I loved how the author included some of the newspaper articles surrounding the events of the book. It was so interesting seeing how the things Nellie went through were covered (like the whole mental hospital episode - fascinating!!!).
Nellie is such a great character! I loved getting to meet her all over again in this book! I definitely recommend this book!
December 15, 2018
A fascinating account
I received this book free from one of the book sites. I do not remember which one! This is my honest and voluntary review.
I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book. Being a fictional account with many true articles, this is Nellie Bly as never read. One of the best books I've read this year!
I received this book free from one of the book sites. I do not remember which one! This is my honest and voluntary review.
I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book. Being a fictional account with many true articles, this is Nellie Bly as never read. One of the best books I've read this year!
December 28, 2018
I hope the author is going to continue writing about Nellie Bly and the world she lived in. A fantastic story told by a phenomenal historical fiction author. I had a hard time putting this book down!
Deeply offended by a column written in her local newspaper, one that claims girls are only good for marriage and raising children, Nellie fights back with her pen. She’s observed her own mother suffering beneath the boot of her husband, beneath the boot of society that keeps her ever on the edge of poverty. Nellie’s reply is passionate and appeals to the editor of the newspaper and eventually she is given a job as a reporter. But she has only begun fighting. Her spirited approach to every battle keeps the narrative rolling without becoming sentimental, from the lives of factory girls, “mashing” male reporters, the Mexican police, and the evil nurses at the Blackwell asylum. The story is realistically told, the research meticulous, with deeper insights into the crusading nature of Nellie Bly.
Deeply offended by a column written in her local newspaper, one that claims girls are only good for marriage and raising children, Nellie fights back with her pen. She’s observed her own mother suffering beneath the boot of her husband, beneath the boot of society that keeps her ever on the edge of poverty. Nellie’s reply is passionate and appeals to the editor of the newspaper and eventually she is given a job as a reporter. But she has only begun fighting. Her spirited approach to every battle keeps the narrative rolling without becoming sentimental, from the lives of factory girls, “mashing” male reporters, the Mexican police, and the evil nurses at the Blackwell asylum. The story is realistically told, the research meticulous, with deeper insights into the crusading nature of Nellie Bly.
August 10, 2024
Excellent book. Got it in a book club exchange and loved it stayed up until 2 am finishing it. Gives you a lot to think about.
December 19, 2018
Nellie Bly is one of America’s most famous journalists. Many strong female characters such as Lois Lane, Lana Winters, and Maggie Dubois were all based on her. The novel What Girls Are Good For chronicles the early years of her life. After reading a newspaper article where it patronizes women’s daily lives, Nellie Bly writes a scathing letter to the newspaper about the hardships of womanhood. This impresses their editor, and he hires Nellie to write an article on the average woman. Happy with her assignment, Nellie wants to investigate the life of an average working woman. This is the first of many of Nellie’s strange adventures.
Nellie is a delightful and charming character. She is spirited and idealistic. She is bold, witty, and confident. She has a taste for adventure. She loves to go undercover and write about her experiences. However, I really like the part in the novel where Nellie feigns madness to get into the asylum. This is where we see Nellie at her most vulnerable and her insecure. However, it is through these experiences that Nellie becomes a stronger fighter and a wiser person.
Overall, this novel is about passion, beliefs, and inner strength. I thought all the characters were very realistic, and I loved how the author portrayed a male-dominated world that is baffled by an unconventional woman. The story is fast-paced and will draw you in with the first few pages. The only thing I did not like about this book was that there were some unnecessary and drawn-out scenes. However, I am excited for the sequel! What Girls Are Good For is a novel that you will want to read again! I recommend this for fans of Madame Presidentess, Falling Angels, and Emmy Nation: Undercover Suffragette.
(Note: This book was given to me as part of a blog tour in exchange for an honest review.)
Nellie is a delightful and charming character. She is spirited and idealistic. She is bold, witty, and confident. She has a taste for adventure. She loves to go undercover and write about her experiences. However, I really like the part in the novel where Nellie feigns madness to get into the asylum. This is where we see Nellie at her most vulnerable and her insecure. However, it is through these experiences that Nellie becomes a stronger fighter and a wiser person.
Overall, this novel is about passion, beliefs, and inner strength. I thought all the characters were very realistic, and I loved how the author portrayed a male-dominated world that is baffled by an unconventional woman. The story is fast-paced and will draw you in with the first few pages. The only thing I did not like about this book was that there were some unnecessary and drawn-out scenes. However, I am excited for the sequel! What Girls Are Good For is a novel that you will want to read again! I recommend this for fans of Madame Presidentess, Falling Angels, and Emmy Nation: Undercover Suffragette.
(Note: This book was given to me as part of a blog tour in exchange for an honest review.)
March 25, 2022
I enjoyed this story. This is my first book by this author which I enjoyed their writing style as well as their attention to details to make the story realistic. This is a story of inspriration, rage, determination and a young woman who may have just changed the world. A story about Nellie and her journey and life in journalism. I enjoyed being pulled into the story by the characters, Nellie is my favorite. I admired her determination and how she will inspire other women in this world. This is a fast paced, engaging story that took me on an emotional roller coaster in parts which made the story entertaining to read. The characters are not only connectable but they are also supportive and made the story come to life. This story had great growth throughout which made it easy to read. This is a great story that I really enjoyed and highly recommend.
January 8, 2019
What an excellent read!! What Girls Are Good For is based on the real-life events of Nellie Bly's life and her struggle to prove herself a woman newspaper reporter in a man's world.
She was a little spitfire who with her own sheer determination and strength became a newspaper reporter.
She just wanted to be a newspaper reporter...the only problem was that she was a woman and NOT a man. Because of this position she had to take on the larger problems that existed....going under cover disguised as women under going hardship situations.
It is even said that Nellie Bly was who the woman reporter Lois Lane in Superman was based on.
Great book!!
She was a little spitfire who with her own sheer determination and strength became a newspaper reporter.
She just wanted to be a newspaper reporter...the only problem was that she was a woman and NOT a man. Because of this position she had to take on the larger problems that existed....going under cover disguised as women under going hardship situations.
It is even said that Nellie Bly was who the woman reporter Lois Lane in Superman was based on.
Great book!!
December 2, 2018
La storia di Nellie Bly mi ha sempre affascinata. Ho sempre ritenuto il suo lavoro da giornalista investigativa nel manicomio importante. Quello che non sapevo, o che ahimè ho sempre ignorato, era che Nellie era più di tutte una femminista.
Leggere biografie di solito stanca, ma quando ho saputo della storia romanzata di Nellie non ho resistito.
Sono contentissima di averlo letto.
Posso solo dirvi: leggetelo.
Leggere biografie di solito stanca, ma quando ho saputo della storia romanzata di Nellie non ho resistito.
Sono contentissima di averlo letto.
Posso solo dirvi: leggetelo.
August 16, 2021
I've been fascinated by Nellie Bly for decades. Maybe it's because my own (eventually realized) ambition was to be a newspaper reporter. Maybe it's because she was such an iconoclast. In any event, the interest was there.
I heard author David Blixt speak during the Historical Novel Society conference and decided to grab his book. I'm glad I did; his narrative style in giving voice to Nellie is delightful. We get a good look at Nellie's life as she remembers things that happened in her childhood, and as she gets her feet wet reporting on various social issues.
Blixt relied heavily on two books I've read (10 Days in a Madhouse and Eighty Days: Nellie Bly and Elizabeth Bisland's History-Making Race Around the World) for his sourcing, but was also able to obtain newspaper clippings and other primary source documents to fill in around the edge and present a set of characters who are well-rounded and believable.
The culminating event of the book is Bly's stay on Blackwell Island and thus the work does not address her around-the-world journey. Honestly, it doesn't need too. It's full and complete, engaging, well-written, and jam-packed with historical detail.
Highly recommended.
I heard author David Blixt speak during the Historical Novel Society conference and decided to grab his book. I'm glad I did; his narrative style in giving voice to Nellie is delightful. We get a good look at Nellie's life as she remembers things that happened in her childhood, and as she gets her feet wet reporting on various social issues.
Blixt relied heavily on two books I've read (10 Days in a Madhouse and Eighty Days: Nellie Bly and Elizabeth Bisland's History-Making Race Around the World) for his sourcing, but was also able to obtain newspaper clippings and other primary source documents to fill in around the edge and present a set of characters who are well-rounded and believable.
The culminating event of the book is Bly's stay on Blackwell Island and thus the work does not address her around-the-world journey. Honestly, it doesn't need too. It's full and complete, engaging, well-written, and jam-packed with historical detail.
Highly recommended.
March 15, 2020
Un libro estremamente difficile da etichettare. Da un lato molto interessante, accurato e approfondito. Non conoscevo la storia di Nellie Bly e con "A cosa servono le ragazze" David Blixt mi ha dato tutti gli strumenti per decifrare questo personaggio. Nellie Bly è stata una donna eccezionale, appassionata, forte, determinata, intraprendente, coraggiosa. Una storia che grida forte alla difesa del femminismo e alla denuncia contro le ingiustizie sociali. Dall'altra parte, però, non mi sono sentita completamente coinvolta dal libro. L'ho trovato a tratti pesante, a tratti noioso e più volte sono stata tentata di abbandonarlo. Insomma, una storia che mi ha dato maggiore consapevolezza e di cui sono grata, ma che con uno stile di scrittura più accattivante mi avrebbe sicuramente conquistata di più!
January 20, 2019
I wasn’t sure I would like it...
But I loved it! The telling of Nellie Bly’s story was artfully done. I didn’t want to put it down. Looking forward to reading the sequel.
But I loved it! The telling of Nellie Bly’s story was artfully done. I didn’t want to put it down. Looking forward to reading the sequel.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 80 reviews