What do you think?
Rate this book
Van Buren and DeLuca Mystery #2
Murder in the City of Liberty
Hamish DeLuca and Regina “Reggie” Van Buren have a new case—and this one could demand a price they’re not willing to pay.
Determined to make a life for herself, Reggie Van Buren bid goodbye to fine china and the man her parents expected her to marry and escaped to Boston. What she never expected to discover was that an unknown talent for sleuthing would develop into a business partnership with the handsome, yet shy, Hamish DeLuca.
Their latest case arrives when Errol Parker, the leading base stealer in the Boston farm leagues, hires Hamish and Reggie to investigate what the Boston police shove off as a series of harmless pranks. Errol believes these are hate crimes linked to the outbreak of war in Europe, and he’s afraid for his life. Hamish and Reggie quickly find themselves in the midst of an escalating series of crimes.
When Hamish has his careful constructed life disrupted by a figure from his past, he is driven to a decision that may sever him from Reggie forever . . . even more than her engagement to wealthy architect Vaughan Vanderlaan.
Determined to make a life for herself, Reggie Van Buren bid goodbye to fine china and the man her parents expected her to marry and escaped to Boston. What she never expected to discover was that an unknown talent for sleuthing would develop into a business partnership with the handsome, yet shy, Hamish DeLuca.
Their latest case arrives when Errol Parker, the leading base stealer in the Boston farm leagues, hires Hamish and Reggie to investigate what the Boston police shove off as a series of harmless pranks. Errol believes these are hate crimes linked to the outbreak of war in Europe, and he’s afraid for his life. Hamish and Reggie quickly find themselves in the midst of an escalating series of crimes.
When Hamish has his careful constructed life disrupted by a figure from his past, he is driven to a decision that may sever him from Reggie forever . . . even more than her engagement to wealthy architect Vaughan Vanderlaan.
Audio CD
First published May 28, 2019
17 people are currently reading
1816 people want to read
About the author
Rachel McMillan
26 books1,169 followersRachel McMillan is the author of over 20 novels including the bestselling The London Restoration and The Mozart Code and the upcoming Operation Scarlet. She has also co-written The Liberty Scarf and The Castle Keepers with Aimie K Runyan and J'nell Ciesielski. Her works of non-fiction include Dream, Plan and Go: A Travel Guide for Independent Adventure and the upcoming: An Aim at Eternity: The Life of Christopher Wren. Rachel lives in Toronto where she works as a literary agent and is always planning her next trip to Vienna.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 125 reviews
June 15, 2019
Rachel McMillan has written an authentic and atmospheric Mystery steeped in history. 1940s Boston Hamish and Reggie are a couple years into running their detective agency. Their newest client is a well known black baseball player who is being messed with. The racism and the criminal element on the cobblestone streets of Boston is really brought to life with McMillan‘s words. Throw in some major romantic tension and this book really had a bit of everything. The perfect balance of mystery, history, and romance.
This book really reminded me of the 1980s television show “Moonlighting”. Reggie was smart savvy and spunky and Hamish was shy and quirky. The sexual tension between them was palpable and I think that will be a fun storyline that will run throughout the series. The mystery was interesting but I think it was more of a social commentary on 1940s Boston especially when it came to racism and anti-Semitism. There was also that mobster/criminal element to the story that is expected I guess with a book with this setting and time. This was such an entertaining read and even though there were some dark spots it ultimately was full of hope. Perfect for anyone who loves a well told Mystery or romance that is fizzing with history! The book was a real gas!
This book really reminded me of the 1980s television show “Moonlighting”. Reggie was smart savvy and spunky and Hamish was shy and quirky. The sexual tension between them was palpable and I think that will be a fun storyline that will run throughout the series. The mystery was interesting but I think it was more of a social commentary on 1940s Boston especially when it came to racism and anti-Semitism. There was also that mobster/criminal element to the story that is expected I guess with a book with this setting and time. This was such an entertaining read and even though there were some dark spots it ultimately was full of hope. Perfect for anyone who loves a well told Mystery or romance that is fizzing with history! The book was a real gas!
August 4, 2018
Hamish and Reggie are doing SUCH a good job of being *"just friends"
We're back in Boston and it is all cobblestones and cannoli....
And there's Nate, of course, and Luca too!
....and baseball.
Spira, Spera!
*actually they're doing a terrible job of it.
We're back in Boston and it is all cobblestones and cannoli....
And there's Nate, of course, and Luca too!
....and baseball.
Spira, Spera!
*actually they're doing a terrible job of it.
May 21, 2019
Onetime socialite Regina “Reggie” Van Buren and shy lawyer Hamish DeLuca met in a previous book I haven’t read. But not having read the first in the series isn’t what kept me from enjoying this sequel in which the pair, now partners in a detective agency, look into some nasty pranks aimed at a baseball rising star.
Set in Boston in 1940, Murder in the City of Liberty features characters that made me think of the 1980s television show Moonlighting: DeLuca is the stolid Cybil Shepherd character, while Reggie’s the devil-may-care Bruce Willis stand-in. As on the show, there’s a sexual tension between the two characters, with the female reluctant to reciprocate the male’s love. How could such a set-up go wrong?
Ask author Rachel McMillan. Somehow I could never get into this cozy mystery. Reggie seemed so foolhardy and thoughtless (her quest for “adventure” always seems to create trouble for DeLuca), and Deluca seems like such a sad sack that I have to admit that I couldn’t force myself to finish this book. Say what you like about the original Moonlighting, the actors made you care about the characters they played, Maddie Hayes and David Addison, and neither made stupid mistakes. I simply couldn’t make myself feel the same way about DeLuca and Reggie.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Thomas Nelson through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Set in Boston in 1940, Murder in the City of Liberty features characters that made me think of the 1980s television show Moonlighting: DeLuca is the stolid Cybil Shepherd character, while Reggie’s the devil-may-care Bruce Willis stand-in. As on the show, there’s a sexual tension between the two characters, with the female reluctant to reciprocate the male’s love. How could such a set-up go wrong?
Ask author Rachel McMillan. Somehow I could never get into this cozy mystery. Reggie seemed so foolhardy and thoughtless (her quest for “adventure” always seems to create trouble for DeLuca), and Deluca seems like such a sad sack that I have to admit that I couldn’t force myself to finish this book. Say what you like about the original Moonlighting, the actors made you care about the characters they played, Maddie Hayes and David Addison, and neither made stupid mistakes. I simply couldn’t make myself feel the same way about DeLuca and Reggie.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Thomas Nelson through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
June 5, 2019
From my endorsement (which ended up on the front cover. Oh. My. Squee.): Rachel McMillan paints her portrait of 1940 Boston with brushes of poetry, humor, and care for historical detail. In this sequel she brings us home, not only to a city she clearly loves, but also to her winning cast of characters. Flavored with quipping nods to The Thin Man and imbued with insecurities and prejudices of the time and place, Murder in the City of Liberty is an irresistible read.
Other thoughts: LUCA. And Ray. And a revelation at the end that promises great conflict between the cousins in Book 3. Looking forward to the fallout and, I trust, redemption.
Other thoughts: LUCA. And Ray. And a revelation at the end that promises great conflict between the cousins in Book 3. Looking forward to the fallout and, I trust, redemption.
June 11, 2019
I first must say that for a book from a Christian publisher, the faith elements are either very thickly veiled OR missing. I'm not sure which.
Murder in the City of Liberty is a well-written, engaging book with fabulous characters. I seriously had so much fun with them. You have no idea. Quirky, interesting, consistent but not predictable all the time. And, of course, my favorite. Flawed. Thanks to a character arc that is going through the series, I suspect there’ll be even more.
And actually, thinking about that. The character arc could explain the lightweight faith elements. If they don’t have much yet, maybe it’s because something is coming… An interesting thought.
The mystery isn’t one you’ve never seen, but seriously, with the characters, the setting, etc—it made it seem new and fun.
Though I haven’t read the first book, I didn’t have any trouble getting up to speed. Rachel McMillan did a fabulous job giving us the past without dumping it on us or giving us too many spoilers. It all feels like stuff we’d likely figure out early on reading the other book—okay, a couple of minor things we wouldn’t have known but nothing that will ruin those stories.
I spent the entire book on tenterhooks about everything!
It wasn’t that Murder in the City of Liberty was that suspenseful. Instead, it was more like it was that delightful. You just knew something fun would happen every now and then—something bad—something unexpected.
With every element that a solid mystery needs—red herrings, fun detectives, means, motives, opportunities, and more than just the mystery driving it… this Van Buren and De Luca series promises to be a whole lot of fun.
Meanwhile, I'm really glad that I asked for a review copy of this one and now I’m off to buy the first book. 🙂
Murder in the City of Liberty is a well-written, engaging book with fabulous characters. I seriously had so much fun with them. You have no idea. Quirky, interesting, consistent but not predictable all the time. And, of course, my favorite. Flawed. Thanks to a character arc that is going through the series, I suspect there’ll be even more.
And actually, thinking about that. The character arc could explain the lightweight faith elements. If they don’t have much yet, maybe it’s because something is coming… An interesting thought.
The mystery isn’t one you’ve never seen, but seriously, with the characters, the setting, etc—it made it seem new and fun.
Though I haven’t read the first book, I didn’t have any trouble getting up to speed. Rachel McMillan did a fabulous job giving us the past without dumping it on us or giving us too many spoilers. It all feels like stuff we’d likely figure out early on reading the other book—okay, a couple of minor things we wouldn’t have known but nothing that will ruin those stories.
I spent the entire book on tenterhooks about everything!
It wasn’t that Murder in the City of Liberty was that suspenseful. Instead, it was more like it was that delightful. You just knew something fun would happen every now and then—something bad—something unexpected.
With every element that a solid mystery needs—red herrings, fun detectives, means, motives, opportunities, and more than just the mystery driving it… this Van Buren and De Luca series promises to be a whole lot of fun.
Meanwhile, I'm really glad that I asked for a review copy of this one and now I’m off to buy the first book. 🙂
May 22, 2019
I was having a bit of a time to get into this story, but soon realized that this was the second book, and I did feel lost.
While this story takes place just prior to WWII we meet prejudice and antisemitism head on, and there is a mystery and sparks flying, I’ll admit I had to fight my way through this book.
I have a fondness for the Red Socks, and this baseball team led me there, but maybe I needed the first book to really get this book.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Thomas Nelson, and was not required to give a positive review.
While this story takes place just prior to WWII we meet prejudice and antisemitism head on, and there is a mystery and sparks flying, I’ll admit I had to fight my way through this book.
I have a fondness for the Red Socks, and this baseball team led me there, but maybe I needed the first book to really get this book.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Thomas Nelson, and was not required to give a positive review.
May 21, 2019
This novel was the epitome of historical romantic mysteries set in 30s Boston, with all the civil unrest, tension between the protagonists, and the underlying web binding crime and their pasts together.
Reggie is her usual charming self- even as the loved ones of her former life jeopardize her independence. Hamich stands tall as a strong man despite his disability, and shines an honesty seldom seen in fiction. And Lucas stays in the shadows, a safe distance from his beloved cousin as he moves further into the world of crime- but still manages to charm himself into his status as a favorite character. And, of course, there is Nate, good old Nate- who doesn't deserve any of the antisemitism threatening Boston.
The historical aspect itself is rife with tension revealing an evil that haunted that era, and tragically today as well. The author also does such a spectacular job at instilling the aura and lingo of the times, giving an atmospheric immersion of 1930s.
The romance really rises in tension in this installment, with our characters having been partners for a couple years now (and Hamich being the only honest one in the relationship), but a side romance also rises.
And the mystery takes a darker turn than I was expecting, knocking me off guard, but these deadly beliefs have deadly consequences.
Anyway, if you enjoy historical novels, romantic novels, and/or mysteries, you will enjoy this expertly crafted story.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher, and the views and opinions are my own.
Reggie is her usual charming self- even as the loved ones of her former life jeopardize her independence. Hamich stands tall as a strong man despite his disability, and shines an honesty seldom seen in fiction. And Lucas stays in the shadows, a safe distance from his beloved cousin as he moves further into the world of crime- but still manages to charm himself into his status as a favorite character. And, of course, there is Nate, good old Nate- who doesn't deserve any of the antisemitism threatening Boston.
The historical aspect itself is rife with tension revealing an evil that haunted that era, and tragically today as well. The author also does such a spectacular job at instilling the aura and lingo of the times, giving an atmospheric immersion of 1930s.
The romance really rises in tension in this installment, with our characters having been partners for a couple years now (and Hamich being the only honest one in the relationship), but a side romance also rises.
And the mystery takes a darker turn than I was expecting, knocking me off guard, but these deadly beliefs have deadly consequences.
Anyway, if you enjoy historical novels, romantic novels, and/or mysteries, you will enjoy this expertly crafted story.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher, and the views and opinions are my own.
July 6, 2019
For the last two years Hamish DeLuca and Reggie Van Buren have been solving small cases involving property and rental law and searching for missing pets. Now they are being consulted for a potentially huge case. A guy named Pete Kelly owns dockland by the waterfront he uses for a variety of purposes. A powerful architectural firm wants to buy the land and build affordable housing (but poorly constructed) on the site. Pete isn't interested in selling. When Reggie is nearly killed and Hamish spies an old nemesis of his cousin Luca's, he becomes suspicious that this scheme has his cousin's name all over it. Determined to stay out of his cousin's business, Hamish enjoys dancing with pretty Bernice Wong while pining for Reggie, who is still dating Vaughn Vanderlaan who works for the same firm interested in the waterfront. They pick up another case when Boston farm league player Errol Parker turns to Van Buren and DeLuca for help. He's been the target of some very nasty pranks and feels frightened because he believes the crimes are related to the color of his skin. He aims to be the first African-American baseball player for the Boston Red Sox but some people are not happy about it. Hamish has a nasty encounter with a group calling themselves the Christian Patriots are rallying and handing out hate-filled leaflets aimed at "protecting" America from a foreign war, Jews and other ethnic groups. Could they be trying to harm Errol or scare him away from baseball? Hamish and Reggie aim to find out. Meanwhile, Nate Reis is acting strangely and Hamish is concerned and Reggie can't make up her mind what to do about her feelings for Hamish vs. her feelings for Vaughn. Can she ever untangle any of this mess and get her happily ever after like in the pictures?
I didn't care for this mystery as much as the previous one. This one doesn't have as much local color. I was eager to read this because I live in the current hometown of the Boston minor league baseball team but the team in the story is fictional and they play in Charlestown. Charlestown plays more of a role than the North End in this story. The main North End location is the docks. Mrs. Leoni makes very brief cameos but not enough of her cannoli and cookies make it into the novel. The end of the novel features the important erection of the Paul Revere statue in the Prado by the Old North Church.
The mystery here seems a lot darker than the Flamingo mystery, especially given the fact the reader is privy to insider information Hamish doesn't know about his cousin. The Christian Patriots "alt-right" group was modeled after the Nazi Party and other Fascist groups of the time but uncomfortably and sadly sounded so much like certain groups today and even like a certain politician. That to me is more frightening that the mystery. The actual murder takes place WAY late in the book. I had a feeling it was going to be one of two characters, neither of which I wanted to die. The one that did was too awfully tragic to make the story enjoyable. There was also too much romantic drama for me. Like Reggie, I want my nice, neat happily ever after at the end of the story!
I really appreciated how human these characters are. They're all three-dimensional with complicated thoughts and feelings. They make mistakes and more mistakes; feel guilt and have conflicted feelings about people close to them. Should Hamish love his cousin Luca who has always been kind to him but is involved in some shady business? Should the reader care for Luca, who seems to be a gangster but not mafia as I thought previously. (WHY WHY WHY does the Italian guy HAVE to be a gangster/mafia/villain type?) Thank goodness Hamish is such a great guy or I'd be very mad at the author. Hamish is such a dear. He's a wonderful beta hero who deserves a happily ever after ending. His anxiety and panic attacks seem better in Boston but not entirely cured and never will be. He's learned to live with his problem and Reggie is good for him because she recognizes the signs and helps Hamish take a break to calm down. Yet Hamish makes what he thinks is a huge mistake in this novel. He cares for and trusts his cousin Luca even though he knows Luca may not be worthy of his trust. I don't like Luca very much but at the end of the novel some information comes to light that explains why Luca is the way he is and what may have happened. Hamish is determined to maintain family ties and figure it out.
Reggie still has a lot of growing up to do. She's very naive and looks at life as though it were a movie. She keeps waiting for some drama or some exciting moment when her life will change for the better. Reggie strings along two good men because she is waiting for a screenwriter to come and figure it out for her. I don't understand her worries about confessing her feelings to Hamish. Her feelings may be confused but I believe he would respect that, as much as he loves her, and give her the space she needs. I believe that is what he is doing and she doesn't know that. Even at the end, when I didn't agree with some of her decisions, I still felt compassion for her and liked her enough to want her to have that happy ending. Vaughn was rather a surprise. I kept waiting for him to do something nasty like Cal in the James Cameron movie Titanic but he's a decent man who loves Reggie but isn't the right fit for her. He doesn't deserve to be led on by Reggie. Reggie's mother reminded me too much of Mrs. DeWitt-Bukater and her father is kind of a helpless idiot. Yes I do want to see your fine things sold at auction. I'd like to see you get a job or stand in line at the soup kitchen because that's the reality for most people. I didn't like Reggie's decision but I probably would have done the same thing.
Vaughn's best friend Dirk is a really awful person. He seems lazy but hides a cunning mind. He's more of a mastermind like Luca but doesn't get his hands dirty. He leaves that to Walt Brinker, a workingman and member of the Christian Patriots whom Hamish actively dislikes. Walt is a nasty man who repulses me. He stands for everything I abhor and would hate me as much as I hate him. I do not blame Hamish for losing his temper. Walt may be involved in more serious crimes and tied in some way to the major mystery. Pete Kelly is another new and unlikable character. He's also a member of this Christian Patriots group despite the fact he's Irish and only 1o0 years ago his people were hated as much as he hates newer immigrants like the Italians. His business seems a little shady and he leaves Reggie is a perilous position-possibly on purpose.
Errol Parker is a good guy trying to make life better for African-Americans and show his nephew Toby that if he works hard he can get ahead. Errol is being harassed because either he's the best player on the team and others are jealous and/or simply because he's a black player on a white team trying to "better" himself joining the Major Leagues. He seems intelligent and doesn't deserve any of the things that happen. Toby is a bright boy with big dreams. He's outgrowing his mother's narrow world and eager to make himself known. I really like him and admire his tenacity.
Nate is a little more likable and sympathetic now we know exactly what he does. He tries to keep his head down and stay out of drama but it's difficult. His story adds a little more complication to the mystery. I LOVE the ending to his story. I wasn't expecting that.
Despite the darkness of this book, I'd be up for reading another one just because of the characters, including Boston. I give the author lots of credit for understanding the passion New Englanders have for their sports teams but it was very odd (she probably did this on purpose) to have the characters talking about going to see a Patriots game in 1940 and have them mean baseball. She shouldn't have chosen a real team name. Also, Boston had two baseball teams, the Red Sox and the Bees (formerly the Braves). Bonus points for tossing in all the reasons why locals love to attend their farm league team games over the major team games all the way in Boston. We're devastated they are leaving us and likely will get more expensive.
I didn't care for this mystery as much as the previous one. This one doesn't have as much local color. I was eager to read this because I live in the current hometown of the Boston minor league baseball team but the team in the story is fictional and they play in Charlestown. Charlestown plays more of a role than the North End in this story. The main North End location is the docks. Mrs. Leoni makes very brief cameos but not enough of her cannoli and cookies make it into the novel. The end of the novel features the important erection of the Paul Revere statue in the Prado by the Old North Church.
The mystery here seems a lot darker than the Flamingo mystery, especially given the fact the reader is privy to insider information Hamish doesn't know about his cousin. The Christian Patriots "alt-right" group was modeled after the Nazi Party and other Fascist groups of the time but uncomfortably and sadly sounded so much like certain groups today and even like a certain politician. That to me is more frightening that the mystery. The actual murder takes place WAY late in the book. I had a feeling it was going to be one of two characters, neither of which I wanted to die. The one that did was too awfully tragic to make the story enjoyable. There was also too much romantic drama for me. Like Reggie, I want my nice, neat happily ever after at the end of the story!
I really appreciated how human these characters are. They're all three-dimensional with complicated thoughts and feelings. They make mistakes and more mistakes; feel guilt and have conflicted feelings about people close to them. Should Hamish love his cousin Luca who has always been kind to him but is involved in some shady business? Should the reader care for Luca, who seems to be a gangster but not mafia as I thought previously. (WHY WHY WHY does the Italian guy HAVE to be a gangster/mafia/villain type?) Thank goodness Hamish is such a great guy or I'd be very mad at the author. Hamish is such a dear. He's a wonderful beta hero who deserves a happily ever after ending. His anxiety and panic attacks seem better in Boston but not entirely cured and never will be. He's learned to live with his problem and Reggie is good for him because she recognizes the signs and helps Hamish take a break to calm down. Yet Hamish makes what he thinks is a huge mistake in this novel. He cares for and trusts his cousin Luca even though he knows Luca may not be worthy of his trust. I don't like Luca very much but at the end of the novel some information comes to light that explains why Luca is the way he is and what may have happened. Hamish is determined to maintain family ties and figure it out.
Reggie still has a lot of growing up to do. She's very naive and looks at life as though it were a movie. She keeps waiting for some drama or some exciting moment when her life will change for the better. Reggie strings along two good men because she is waiting for a screenwriter to come and figure it out for her. I don't understand her worries about confessing her feelings to Hamish. Her feelings may be confused but I believe he would respect that, as much as he loves her, and give her the space she needs. I believe that is what he is doing and she doesn't know that. Even at the end, when I didn't agree with some of her decisions, I still felt compassion for her and liked her enough to want her to have that happy ending. Vaughn was rather a surprise. I kept waiting for him to do something nasty like Cal in the James Cameron movie Titanic but he's a decent man who loves Reggie but isn't the right fit for her. He doesn't deserve to be led on by Reggie. Reggie's mother reminded me too much of Mrs. DeWitt-Bukater and her father is kind of a helpless idiot. Yes I do want to see your fine things sold at auction. I'd like to see you get a job or stand in line at the soup kitchen because that's the reality for most people. I didn't like Reggie's decision but I probably would have done the same thing.
Vaughn's best friend Dirk is a really awful person. He seems lazy but hides a cunning mind. He's more of a mastermind like Luca but doesn't get his hands dirty. He leaves that to Walt Brinker, a workingman and member of the Christian Patriots whom Hamish actively dislikes. Walt is a nasty man who repulses me. He stands for everything I abhor and would hate me as much as I hate him. I do not blame Hamish for losing his temper. Walt may be involved in more serious crimes and tied in some way to the major mystery. Pete Kelly is another new and unlikable character. He's also a member of this Christian Patriots group despite the fact he's Irish and only 1o0 years ago his people were hated as much as he hates newer immigrants like the Italians. His business seems a little shady and he leaves Reggie is a perilous position-possibly on purpose.
Errol Parker is a good guy trying to make life better for African-Americans and show his nephew Toby that if he works hard he can get ahead. Errol is being harassed because either he's the best player on the team and others are jealous and/or simply because he's a black player on a white team trying to "better" himself joining the Major Leagues. He seems intelligent and doesn't deserve any of the things that happen. Toby is a bright boy with big dreams. He's outgrowing his mother's narrow world and eager to make himself known. I really like him and admire his tenacity.
Nate is a little more likable and sympathetic now we know exactly what he does. He tries to keep his head down and stay out of drama but it's difficult. His story adds a little more complication to the mystery. I LOVE the ending to his story. I wasn't expecting that.
Despite the darkness of this book, I'd be up for reading another one just because of the characters, including Boston. I give the author lots of credit for understanding the passion New Englanders have for their sports teams but it was very odd (she probably did this on purpose) to have the characters talking about going to see a Patriots game in 1940 and have them mean baseball. She shouldn't have chosen a real team name. Also, Boston had two baseball teams, the Red Sox and the Bees (formerly the Braves). Bonus points for tossing in all the reasons why locals love to attend their farm league team games over the major team games all the way in Boston. We're devastated they are leaving us and likely will get more expensive.
March 10, 2019
Historical fiction with a touch of crime is always appealing to me--and, this book' set in Boston, 1940 held a lot of promise for me. The two protagonists are compelling characters but the mystery takes a very distant second place to the romance. And, for me that was both boring and tedious.
I wanted the modest, but dashing, hero to win the girl. And, I was prepared for him to have to earn his place before she came to her senses----but, all of the tension in the book seemed to be romantic, not plot inspired. The criminal aspects of the book were convoluted enough (although secondary) that I was frequently confused---and, this book did not merit the reader getting confused about "who's on first."
This is a series I wanted to enjoy. With characters crafted to earn our affection and interest. But, the author just didn't deliver enough story or depth of character to really engage me.
Netgalley provided me with a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I wanted the modest, but dashing, hero to win the girl. And, I was prepared for him to have to earn his place before she came to her senses----but, all of the tension in the book seemed to be romantic, not plot inspired. The criminal aspects of the book were convoluted enough (although secondary) that I was frequently confused---and, this book did not merit the reader getting confused about "who's on first."
This is a series I wanted to enjoy. With characters crafted to earn our affection and interest. But, the author just didn't deliver enough story or depth of character to really engage me.
Netgalley provided me with a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
June 15, 2019
On a scale of cotton candy and Brussels sprouts, Murder in the City of Liberty by Rachel McMillan is unlimited kettle corn. Lightly sweet with a touch of saltiness, kettle corn is an addictive crunch that you can't feel bad consuming. What's another handful?
[copy received. opinions my own.]
Regina, known as Reggie by her friends, and Hamish are decently good amateur sleuths. Hired to figure out what's going on in the life of a famous baseball player, they find more questions than answers. Then, in the midst of it all, Reggie faces family responsibility that clashes with her heart while a familiar but dangerous face from Hamish's past reappears.
Once again, I've managed to start a series right smack in the middle. I do this. All the time! But, I had heard about Rachel McMillan's author prowess for a long time, and I jumped at the chance to read this book of hers. Now, I don't read mystery often, but I did enjoy Reggie and Hamish so much along with the details of Boston. Without being a mystery connoisseur, I'd like to say that story offered a little something for everyone--strong female heroine, quirky male lead, murder, romance, history, and so much more.
If you enjoy history, mystery, and strong characters, Murder in the City of Liberty is for you.
[copy received. opinions my own.]
Regina, known as Reggie by her friends, and Hamish are decently good amateur sleuths. Hired to figure out what's going on in the life of a famous baseball player, they find more questions than answers. Then, in the midst of it all, Reggie faces family responsibility that clashes with her heart while a familiar but dangerous face from Hamish's past reappears.
Once again, I've managed to start a series right smack in the middle. I do this. All the time! But, I had heard about Rachel McMillan's author prowess for a long time, and I jumped at the chance to read this book of hers. Now, I don't read mystery often, but I did enjoy Reggie and Hamish so much along with the details of Boston. Without being a mystery connoisseur, I'd like to say that story offered a little something for everyone--strong female heroine, quirky male lead, murder, romance, history, and so much more.
If you enjoy history, mystery, and strong characters, Murder in the City of Liberty is for you.
June 8, 2019
Murder in the City of Liberty whisks you away on a mystery and adventure that's really about the characters and friendships. Loyalty, romance, relationships and their ties to the past, grace, and social justice are all themes displayed in an immersive setting of Boston with its cobblestones and steeples. I feel like I could map Boston from the descriptions Hamish and Nate give!
Rachel McMillan writes stories for the romantic at heart. I'm not referring to "love stories", though a hefty dose of starry eyes, dancing, and the delights of attraction are all found in the pages of this story. I'm referring to the slight idealist slant of her stories with characters to root for and eventual happy endings. A balance of realism is always present, too, portrayed through the realities of the era and their parallels to today's social and cultural challenges. HOPE is always present.
You probably know I'm here for the romance. Especially this slow-building, delicious connection and camaraderie between Hamish and Reggie. I thought I wanted Reggie to have an "Aha!" moment, but I was wrong. What Rachel gives readers is a gradual recognition where Reggie's concerned, the sparks finally making sense with just how intertwined Hamish is with her daily life and happiness. And with her "journal of independence". It is perfect.
Within the romantic aspect of the story, the truth of how Reggie is changing and realizing her path in life is magnificent. I really like how she reconciles her past with her identity, embracing how her choices were not in vain but a part of herself, part of what makes her tick and what determines the life she is meant to choose.
Let's talk about two of the secondary characters: Nate and Luca. They couldn't be more different, but both have a deep and meaningful connection with Hamish. Both are catalysts for Hamish's growth. I have liked Nate from the very beginning, but this story makes him one of my very favorite secondary characters who gets to steal the scene more than once! I appreciated the way he reminds Hamish that patience is required for change. And I liked how a particular thing surprised Nate near the end :)
And Luca. He brings the theme of loyalty to the forefront. It's funny how he shapes, defines, even dictates the progression of the story yet he's hardly "present" on the page. Only a strongly written character can have that kind of presence through a story, to be both likable and disruptive at the same time.
The brave thing Rachel McMillan is doing with these characters is shining a light on mental illness and bringing awareness through the HERO of the story. In this second book, we often see Hamish through the lens of his closest circle, showing both their familiarity with him and the grace they extend as they embrace each other's imperfections. The maturing in this is twofold: growing Hamish as a person and McMillan's story style and presentation developing alongside.
I could go on and on about this story, how it incorporates current events of its era, how it handles prejudice and war, how it shows the fallacy and strength of human nature. Wit, baseball, cannolis, nods to classic films, end-of-the-world-kisses, and blue eyes are just the icing on top of this one-of-a-kind adventure that I'm sure to love even more upon rereading!
Thank you to Netgalley for the review copy. This is my honest review.
Rachel McMillan writes stories for the romantic at heart. I'm not referring to "love stories", though a hefty dose of starry eyes, dancing, and the delights of attraction are all found in the pages of this story. I'm referring to the slight idealist slant of her stories with characters to root for and eventual happy endings. A balance of realism is always present, too, portrayed through the realities of the era and their parallels to today's social and cultural challenges. HOPE is always present.
You probably know I'm here for the romance. Especially this slow-building, delicious connection and camaraderie between Hamish and Reggie. I thought I wanted Reggie to have an "Aha!" moment, but I was wrong. What Rachel gives readers is a gradual recognition where Reggie's concerned, the sparks finally making sense with just how intertwined Hamish is with her daily life and happiness. And with her "journal of independence". It is perfect.
Within the romantic aspect of the story, the truth of how Reggie is changing and realizing her path in life is magnificent. I really like how she reconciles her past with her identity, embracing how her choices were not in vain but a part of herself, part of what makes her tick and what determines the life she is meant to choose.
Let's talk about two of the secondary characters: Nate and Luca. They couldn't be more different, but both have a deep and meaningful connection with Hamish. Both are catalysts for Hamish's growth. I have liked Nate from the very beginning, but this story makes him one of my very favorite secondary characters who gets to steal the scene more than once! I appreciated the way he reminds Hamish that patience is required for change. And I liked how a particular thing surprised Nate near the end :)
And Luca. He brings the theme of loyalty to the forefront. It's funny how he shapes, defines, even dictates the progression of the story yet he's hardly "present" on the page. Only a strongly written character can have that kind of presence through a story, to be both likable and disruptive at the same time.
The brave thing Rachel McMillan is doing with these characters is shining a light on mental illness and bringing awareness through the HERO of the story. In this second book, we often see Hamish through the lens of his closest circle, showing both their familiarity with him and the grace they extend as they embrace each other's imperfections. The maturing in this is twofold: growing Hamish as a person and McMillan's story style and presentation developing alongside.
I could go on and on about this story, how it incorporates current events of its era, how it handles prejudice and war, how it shows the fallacy and strength of human nature. Wit, baseball, cannolis, nods to classic films, end-of-the-world-kisses, and blue eyes are just the icing on top of this one-of-a-kind adventure that I'm sure to love even more upon rereading!
Thank you to Netgalley for the review copy. This is my honest review.
January 1, 2025
I was very confused about what was going on, partially but definitely not entirely bc this is a book 2 and I got it in a blind date w a book without reading 1. but I support the anti fascist rhetoric!
May 28, 2019
Murder in the City of Liberty by Rachel McMillan is a story filled with accurate details and a nod to classic literature. The story does have a dead body in it and does move the story along, but, I believe, the plot is more a cultural nod to the social and racial tensions of the 1940's. America is on the brink of World War II, even though majority of the citizens want to ignore the rising terror. McMillan jumps into the plot and brings 1940's Boston to life. I really enjoy her attention to historical detail with her settings and bringing the conflicts to light. The romantic heat between Hamish and Reggie spark even hotter in this addition of their story. McMillan does wonderfully at creating a story that grips my attention and kept me glued to the page. I finished the whole novel in under one day. Wonderful story. I can't wait to see what troubles and romance come to Hamish and Reggie next.
I received a complimentary copy of Murder in the City of Liberty by Rachel McMillan from Thomas Nelson publishing, but the opinions stated are all my own.
I received a complimentary copy of Murder in the City of Liberty by Rachel McMillan from Thomas Nelson publishing, but the opinions stated are all my own.
January 23, 2019
I love a mystery that uses the political and sociocultural influences of the times to enhance the story. Boston is the setting, in the 1940’s, where racism and corruption exist in the background. Reggie and Hamish are hired to find out who is harassing a Black baseball player, when they become enmeshed in a deeper mystery. I love these two characters, but did find the various Mob like characters and the subplot a bit difficult to follow. If you enjoyed Murder at the Flamingo, this 2nd in the series is a must.
November 16, 2019
Love Hamish & Reggie ❤
July 21, 2019
When this book popped up for review, I was thrilled! I haven’t read the first book in the series, but it has been on my radar. Then this one came up and I was eager to dive in.
I am absolutely in love with the cover and can’t get enough of the colors and the gorgeous art deco details in the background. I felt like the cover absolutely captures the time period and would make readers excited to pick this one up……I know I was excited!
With this being the second book, I was hopeful that I hadn’t missed too much of the character back stories and that I wouldn’t be too lost. I also liked that it was set in Boston and not the typical New York or London settings that are so popular in many historical mysteries.
So, I think I should have read the first book before this one. I did feel like I was missing some plot holes and little nuances of the story. I think the author attempted to help new readers orientate in the story, but for me, I felt like I would have appreciated more of the story if I had read the first book and then started this one.
I did like that this book had a lot of romance, but I was surprised that the romantic elements outweighed the mystery in some spots. It’s such a delicate balance when incorporating romance into mystery novels but even if this was a little heavy handed on the romance, I found that I enjoyed the romantic elements and continued to mostly stay invested in the mystery. I thought Reggie and Hamish has great chemistry but I would have liked to have had a little more focus on the mystery itself as this book series seems to be more of a detective series.
I did like how well Boston was described by the author. I felt like I was there and could see everything. But then I felt like that same descriptiveness didn’t carry over all the time. There were some times in the action sequences that needed more descriptions about how things happened.
This one landed firmly in the middle for me. On one hand I didn’t love it like I was expecting to but on the other hand I wasn’t sure if that was because I hadn’t read the first book or if I truly just didn’t like the novel. In the end I decided to go for a 3 star review. I don’t know that I would read any more books in the series without first going back and reading the first book as it seems like things would make a lot more sense then,
See my full review here
I am absolutely in love with the cover and can’t get enough of the colors and the gorgeous art deco details in the background. I felt like the cover absolutely captures the time period and would make readers excited to pick this one up……I know I was excited!
With this being the second book, I was hopeful that I hadn’t missed too much of the character back stories and that I wouldn’t be too lost. I also liked that it was set in Boston and not the typical New York or London settings that are so popular in many historical mysteries.
So, I think I should have read the first book before this one. I did feel like I was missing some plot holes and little nuances of the story. I think the author attempted to help new readers orientate in the story, but for me, I felt like I would have appreciated more of the story if I had read the first book and then started this one.
I did like that this book had a lot of romance, but I was surprised that the romantic elements outweighed the mystery in some spots. It’s such a delicate balance when incorporating romance into mystery novels but even if this was a little heavy handed on the romance, I found that I enjoyed the romantic elements and continued to mostly stay invested in the mystery. I thought Reggie and Hamish has great chemistry but I would have liked to have had a little more focus on the mystery itself as this book series seems to be more of a detective series.
I did like how well Boston was described by the author. I felt like I was there and could see everything. But then I felt like that same descriptiveness didn’t carry over all the time. There were some times in the action sequences that needed more descriptions about how things happened.
This one landed firmly in the middle for me. On one hand I didn’t love it like I was expecting to but on the other hand I wasn’t sure if that was because I hadn’t read the first book or if I truly just didn’t like the novel. In the end I decided to go for a 3 star review. I don’t know that I would read any more books in the series without first going back and reading the first book as it seems like things would make a lot more sense then,
See my full review here
August 3, 2022
It’s no secret that I love when authors connect their works. This series follows Hamish DeLuca, son of Ray DeLuca and Jem Watts DeLuca from the Herringford and Watts Mysteries. Ah, this always makes me so happy!
I truly enjoyed this book. However, as it is the second book in the series, and I haven’t read the first, I was a little lost at times because clearly things in the first book carried over into this one.
The mystery itself was intriguing, but as mentioned because I didn’t read book 1 first, much of the impact and revelations were lost on me. And I was still a little confused in the end. Read series in order, kids. ;)
The characters were amazing! Hamish and Reggie have a great relationship. They’re friends with an slow burn romance. (Not my favourite trope.) I can’t say the romance journey was my favourite because I kept wanting to speed it up a bit, haha. Everything comes to fruition in the end a bit abruptly, and now I want to know if there’s a third book because I would like to read more about Hamish and Reggie!
Speaking of, Reggie is strong, independent, and kind, though I wasn’t crazy about her on-off relationship with her ex-fiancé whose name escapes me. Hamish is quiet, steady, and yet battles nerves and anxiety. (Male anxiety was a unique angle and well done.) Then there’s Nate…ah, this man is gold! Luca and Hamish’s relationship strongly intrigued me, and with that ending, I want more details!
WW2 Boston was fun and culturally informative! Set in mid-1940, this was before America joined the war, but the politics and antisemitism were present, creating an interesting atmosphere.
Now I need to go back and read the first book to clear up a few things!
I truly enjoyed this book. However, as it is the second book in the series, and I haven’t read the first, I was a little lost at times because clearly things in the first book carried over into this one.
The mystery itself was intriguing, but as mentioned because I didn’t read book 1 first, much of the impact and revelations were lost on me. And I was still a little confused in the end. Read series in order, kids. ;)
The characters were amazing! Hamish and Reggie have a great relationship. They’re friends with an slow burn romance. (Not my favourite trope.) I can’t say the romance journey was my favourite because I kept wanting to speed it up a bit, haha. Everything comes to fruition in the end a bit abruptly, and now I want to know if there’s a third book because I would like to read more about Hamish and Reggie!
Speaking of, Reggie is strong, independent, and kind, though I wasn’t crazy about her on-off relationship with her ex-fiancé whose name escapes me. Hamish is quiet, steady, and yet battles nerves and anxiety. (Male anxiety was a unique angle and well done.) Then there’s Nate…ah, this man is gold! Luca and Hamish’s relationship strongly intrigued me, and with that ending, I want more details!
WW2 Boston was fun and culturally informative! Set in mid-1940, this was before America joined the war, but the politics and antisemitism were present, creating an interesting atmosphere.
Now I need to go back and read the first book to clear up a few things!
April 5, 2021
This book is a sequel to the previous book Murder at the Flamingo. So here we meet again Reggie Van Buren and Hamish DeLuca who are living in the City of Liberty, Boston 1937. Their latest case comes from Errol Parker a leading base stealer in baseball who just happens to be black. Pranks are being played on him. The police think it's nothing, however Errol thinks they are actually hate crimes against him brought on by the coming war. As Reggie and Hamish start investigating they experience their own series of crimes like the killing of Errol's nephew Toby. Then the are interpersonal complications with Reggie having 2 men interested in her. She is starting to love Hamish yet she gets engaged to wealthy architect Vaughan Vanderlaan. More for practical reasons and her parent's design rather for love. How will this mystery turn out and what other characters wiil be involved to create possibly more complications and help bring a conclusion? Read this book to find out.
June 16, 2019
Y’all, I just adore Hamish DeLuca. This man is loyal to those closest to him and strives to protect them even when his own anxiety threatens. It’s obvious there’s been a growing friendship (and perhaps more?) between Hamish and Reggie in the couple years that have passed since the first book (Murder at the Flamingo).
The actual murder is secondary to the mystery of what’s happening with Nate as well as the will-they-or-won’t-they question of Hamish and Reggie’s relationship. But the murder mysteries are why I devour every book written by Rachel McMillan. No, that honor goes to the authentic relationship dynamics—both the good and the bad, insights into the history of the places she writes about, and the immersion into the era. Her passion for the city, people, and culture (in this case, 1930s and 40s Boston) are seeped so deep into these pages, I fell in love with the city too.
Disclosure statement:
I receive complimentary books from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, including NetGalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
The actual murder is secondary to the mystery of what’s happening with Nate as well as the will-they-or-won’t-they question of Hamish and Reggie’s relationship. But the murder mysteries are why I devour every book written by Rachel McMillan. No, that honor goes to the authentic relationship dynamics—both the good and the bad, insights into the history of the places she writes about, and the immersion into the era. Her passion for the city, people, and culture (in this case, 1930s and 40s Boston) are seeped so deep into these pages, I fell in love with the city too.
Disclosure statement:
I receive complimentary books from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, including NetGalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
June 14, 2019
Hamish + Reggie 4 ever! No, I’m not doodling romantic daydreams inside the cover of my school books, but I would happily read books about these two forever. Even their names go together perfectly! Perhaps more perfectly than they do themselves, but that explanation is better left to the story…
To be a little more serious—I adore this series. I adore the setting, the characters (Hamish gets all the heart-eyes), and the kinds of issues they’re tackling, both personally and professionally. And I adore how character-driven the stories are, even though I occasionally felt as though I lost the thread of the mystery in this one as a result. (More on that in a moment.) Not only is there the delicious romantic tension between Hamish and Reggie but also the tension created when friendship, familial loyalty, and suspicion collide. And if you really want to enjoy all of that to the full, I highly recommend you read Murder at the Flamingo before diving in to this one.
The mystery Hamish and Reggie tackle begins simply enough—if you don’t count the near drowning, that is: baseball player Errol Parker asks them to investigate a series of pranks he believes are racially motivated. But then it twists and turns as Hamish and Reggie follow a trail that keeps circling back to a radical political organisation, a proposed property development, and Hamish’s cousin. I loved the organic, slightly chaotic way it unfolded, and I especially loved that it was inseparable from the time and setting of the novel. After all, what’s the point of such a vividly rendered historical setting if your mystery could be set anywhere and anytime?
As I hinted earlier, my only difficulty was that I occasionally felt as though I had missed some connecting dots when it came to untangling the mystery. Then again, perhaps Hamish and Reggie are simply cleverer than I am—which is entirely possible! I could also have been slightly distracted (in a good way) by all the interpersonal stuff going on—which I’ve already mentioned is one of the things I LOVE about this series, but if you’re looking for a straight mystery without the character focus or the romance, this is a heads up you won’t find that here.
And I can’t finish this review without saying a little *squeee* for the meeting between Nate and a certain someone towards the end of the story. (Have I mentioned Nate? He gets heart-eyes too.) SUCH a great scene. *giggle* And here’s a *GASP* for a revelation made to Hamish!! I’m so looking forward to more from these characters!
I received a copy of this novel from the publisher. This has not influenced the content of my review, which is my honest and unbiased opinion.
To be a little more serious—I adore this series. I adore the setting, the characters (Hamish gets all the heart-eyes), and the kinds of issues they’re tackling, both personally and professionally. And I adore how character-driven the stories are, even though I occasionally felt as though I lost the thread of the mystery in this one as a result. (More on that in a moment.) Not only is there the delicious romantic tension between Hamish and Reggie but also the tension created when friendship, familial loyalty, and suspicion collide. And if you really want to enjoy all of that to the full, I highly recommend you read Murder at the Flamingo before diving in to this one.
The mystery Hamish and Reggie tackle begins simply enough—if you don’t count the near drowning, that is: baseball player Errol Parker asks them to investigate a series of pranks he believes are racially motivated. But then it twists and turns as Hamish and Reggie follow a trail that keeps circling back to a radical political organisation, a proposed property development, and Hamish’s cousin. I loved the organic, slightly chaotic way it unfolded, and I especially loved that it was inseparable from the time and setting of the novel. After all, what’s the point of such a vividly rendered historical setting if your mystery could be set anywhere and anytime?
As I hinted earlier, my only difficulty was that I occasionally felt as though I had missed some connecting dots when it came to untangling the mystery. Then again, perhaps Hamish and Reggie are simply cleverer than I am—which is entirely possible! I could also have been slightly distracted (in a good way) by all the interpersonal stuff going on—which I’ve already mentioned is one of the things I LOVE about this series, but if you’re looking for a straight mystery without the character focus or the romance, this is a heads up you won’t find that here.
And I can’t finish this review without saying a little *squeee* for the meeting between Nate and a certain someone towards the end of the story. (Have I mentioned Nate? He gets heart-eyes too.) SUCH a great scene. *giggle* And here’s a *GASP* for a revelation made to Hamish!! I’m so looking forward to more from these characters!
I received a copy of this novel from the publisher. This has not influenced the content of my review, which is my honest and unbiased opinion.
January 7, 2019
This is the second book in the series involving Hamish and Reggie. I was hoping they would have improved since the first outing but sadly they may have gotten worse. I had such a hard time finishing this. It, much like the first one, was not too mysterious. Or thrilling. The way the characters behave is somewhat incoherent.....
As if they aren’t fully formed humans yet and they are both old enough to be exercising far better judgment then they do here. The problem with the first book continues to follow this author.....taking way too long to do anything with the plot to grab your reader. The whole first 1/3 of the book was almost boring. They say the third time is the charm so I will read the third book in this series if the author writes one but I really can’t recommend this one. Thank you NetGalley for providing me with an advanced copy for review.
As if they aren’t fully formed humans yet and they are both old enough to be exercising far better judgment then they do here. The problem with the first book continues to follow this author.....taking way too long to do anything with the plot to grab your reader. The whole first 1/3 of the book was almost boring. They say the third time is the charm so I will read the third book in this series if the author writes one but I really can’t recommend this one. Thank you NetGalley for providing me with an advanced copy for review.
June 16, 2019
Oh. My. Word. I thoroughly loved every second spent with Reggie and Hamish in this fantastic murder mystery. Murder in the City of Liberty is SO, SO good. The plot is insanely fast paced and highly engaging. Hamish and Reggie are outstanding protagonists. The chemistry between the two — it’s a delicious blend of hope, romance, and tension. It kept me furiously turning pages well into the night! And the history. I learned so much about 1940s Boston and the political climate in the early days of WWII. Murder in the City of Liberty has a depth and complexity that avid murder-mystery readers will not want to miss!
When I fell in love with my husband, I don’t believe I had one clue as to what true love really is. I felt in love. When I looked at him my heart would flutter and I would go a bit weak in the knees. And I definitely had glorious expectations that only he could fulfill — the happily-ever-after, white-picket-fence, married-for-50+-years kind. These were the kind of feelings I knew only he could inspire. So I must have been in love, right?
Wrong! I went into my marriage with my eyes so firmly shut to reality. Love isn’t a feeling. As one of my favorite pastors says, “Love isn’t glandular.” In the novel, it is clear that Reggie and Hamish have deep feelings for one another. But Reggie is hesitant to admit her that feelings are love. Her biggest issue is how she has built Hamish up in her head. To Reggie, Hamish is the perfect man — a knight in shining armor. He is strong, intelligent, dependable, stable, kind, and selfless. And, she knows he loves her with his whole heart. But there is a moment where Hamish makes a grave error in judgment. Reggie realizes that Hamish is human just like everyone else, and she gets mad at him. The proverbial rose-colored glasses have been slapped off her face, and she now sees Hamish for who he truly is, the good parts and the bad. This is essentially what happened to me too. Six months after we said, “I Do,” life took a turn for the worse and I realized I didn’t really know the man I had married. In retrospect, I don’t think he realized the women he had married either. In one very bad moment all of my notions about love and marriage were stripped from me and what I was left with was real life. I didn’t want real life. I wanted my expectations and dreams. Reggie becomes angry with Hamish because she didn’t want real life either. She wanted the dream of Hamish that she had concocted.
BUT Reggie realizes that “love [means] accepting the lowest of a person.” People have positives and negatives. When we “fall” in love, we fall for the absolute best parts of each other. The negative parts of personalities seem to be nonexistent. In these “lovey-dovey” moments people knee-jerk react and get married. Then reality hits and the notion of romantic love falls away and we’re left with someone who has flaws. What I have learned in the decade since my husband and I first began a relationship is that love means being there for one another to the best of our abilities. But, we are going to make mistakes. We are fallible human beings. If love means being there for one another to the best of our abilities, it also means realizing that “the best of our abilities” is limited. I’m grateful for Reggie’s moment of clarity not just because I really want something to happen between Reggie and Hamish (which I do so, so much), but because it is a great reminder for me. I need to be a little more gracious towards my husband. God, the creator of the known and unknown universes, loves my husband just as he is warts and all. I need to do the same if I truly love him (which I do)! Reggie realizes she needs to be a little more gracious to her Hamish as well.
Murder in the City of Liberty is a wonderful story, and I highly recommend it. I am going to miss my time with Reggie and Hamish. Book 3 cannot come fast enough for me!
I received a review copy of this novel in eBook form from the publisher via NetGalley and Celebrate Lit. In no way has this influenced my review. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.
When I fell in love with my husband, I don’t believe I had one clue as to what true love really is. I felt in love. When I looked at him my heart would flutter and I would go a bit weak in the knees. And I definitely had glorious expectations that only he could fulfill — the happily-ever-after, white-picket-fence, married-for-50+-years kind. These were the kind of feelings I knew only he could inspire. So I must have been in love, right?
Wrong! I went into my marriage with my eyes so firmly shut to reality. Love isn’t a feeling. As one of my favorite pastors says, “Love isn’t glandular.” In the novel, it is clear that Reggie and Hamish have deep feelings for one another. But Reggie is hesitant to admit her that feelings are love. Her biggest issue is how she has built Hamish up in her head. To Reggie, Hamish is the perfect man — a knight in shining armor. He is strong, intelligent, dependable, stable, kind, and selfless. And, she knows he loves her with his whole heart. But there is a moment where Hamish makes a grave error in judgment. Reggie realizes that Hamish is human just like everyone else, and she gets mad at him. The proverbial rose-colored glasses have been slapped off her face, and she now sees Hamish for who he truly is, the good parts and the bad. This is essentially what happened to me too. Six months after we said, “I Do,” life took a turn for the worse and I realized I didn’t really know the man I had married. In retrospect, I don’t think he realized the women he had married either. In one very bad moment all of my notions about love and marriage were stripped from me and what I was left with was real life. I didn’t want real life. I wanted my expectations and dreams. Reggie becomes angry with Hamish because she didn’t want real life either. She wanted the dream of Hamish that she had concocted.
BUT Reggie realizes that “love [means] accepting the lowest of a person.” People have positives and negatives. When we “fall” in love, we fall for the absolute best parts of each other. The negative parts of personalities seem to be nonexistent. In these “lovey-dovey” moments people knee-jerk react and get married. Then reality hits and the notion of romantic love falls away and we’re left with someone who has flaws. What I have learned in the decade since my husband and I first began a relationship is that love means being there for one another to the best of our abilities. But, we are going to make mistakes. We are fallible human beings. If love means being there for one another to the best of our abilities, it also means realizing that “the best of our abilities” is limited. I’m grateful for Reggie’s moment of clarity not just because I really want something to happen between Reggie and Hamish (which I do so, so much), but because it is a great reminder for me. I need to be a little more gracious towards my husband. God, the creator of the known and unknown universes, loves my husband just as he is warts and all. I need to do the same if I truly love him (which I do)! Reggie realizes she needs to be a little more gracious to her Hamish as well.
Murder in the City of Liberty is a wonderful story, and I highly recommend it. I am going to miss my time with Reggie and Hamish. Book 3 cannot come fast enough for me!
I received a review copy of this novel in eBook form from the publisher via NetGalley and Celebrate Lit. In no way has this influenced my review. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.
June 11, 2019
“You can make yourself believe a great many things about the choices you make.”
The author Rachel McMillan has a way with words that is unique and thoroughly insightful. The characters are quirky and their witty and fun dialogue really makes the story shine. The murder mystery component is a bit reminiscent of Columbo or Murder She Wrote (or Moonlighting as another reviewer mentioned) but it’s the character study of Regina and Hamish and their relationship that take center stage in the book. I’ve followed Hamish’s parents’ story in Rachel McMillan’s previous Herringford and Watts series so I was already fond of Hamish as a baby. My mistake was not reading the first book, Murder at the Flamingo, prior to reading this one. Though the author gives us enough clues and details to piece together what happened in the first book, I felt like I missed out on much of the character development of Hamish, Regina, Nate (Hamish’s best friend), and Luca (Hamish’s cousin). So definitely read Murder at the Flamingo prior to reading this book.
There is a lot of emotional tug-of-war between Hamish and Regina, especially as Hamish becomes desperate for Regina’s affection and Regina entertains engagement to a childhood friend. Hamish is such an unlikely hero....yet he really is a hero - brave, protective, tender, and self-sacrificing even in the midst of anxiety attacks and demoralization. But this story is more than just two unlikely people working together and falling in love. It addresses the atmosphere in 1940 Boston where racial prejudice ran hot in the face of the Second World War, the wide gap between the haves and have-nots widened each day, and gangsters and businessmen alike battled each other for power and money. It addresses the debilitating disorder of anxiety and loyalty found in friendship and blood-kin. From how this book ends, there is more to come where Hamish and Regina are concerned. Perhaps Hamish’s cousin Luca as well.
I received a copy of the book from Thomas Nelson via Celebrate Lit Tours and was under no obligation to post a positive review. All comments and opinions are solely my own.
The author Rachel McMillan has a way with words that is unique and thoroughly insightful. The characters are quirky and their witty and fun dialogue really makes the story shine. The murder mystery component is a bit reminiscent of Columbo or Murder She Wrote (or Moonlighting as another reviewer mentioned) but it’s the character study of Regina and Hamish and their relationship that take center stage in the book. I’ve followed Hamish’s parents’ story in Rachel McMillan’s previous Herringford and Watts series so I was already fond of Hamish as a baby. My mistake was not reading the first book, Murder at the Flamingo, prior to reading this one. Though the author gives us enough clues and details to piece together what happened in the first book, I felt like I missed out on much of the character development of Hamish, Regina, Nate (Hamish’s best friend), and Luca (Hamish’s cousin). So definitely read Murder at the Flamingo prior to reading this book.
There is a lot of emotional tug-of-war between Hamish and Regina, especially as Hamish becomes desperate for Regina’s affection and Regina entertains engagement to a childhood friend. Hamish is such an unlikely hero....yet he really is a hero - brave, protective, tender, and self-sacrificing even in the midst of anxiety attacks and demoralization. But this story is more than just two unlikely people working together and falling in love. It addresses the atmosphere in 1940 Boston where racial prejudice ran hot in the face of the Second World War, the wide gap between the haves and have-nots widened each day, and gangsters and businessmen alike battled each other for power and money. It addresses the debilitating disorder of anxiety and loyalty found in friendship and blood-kin. From how this book ends, there is more to come where Hamish and Regina are concerned. Perhaps Hamish’s cousin Luca as well.
I received a copy of the book from Thomas Nelson via Celebrate Lit Tours and was under no obligation to post a positive review. All comments and opinions are solely my own.
June 8, 2019
Maybe I should have read the first book in this series before asking for this via NetGalley. Unfortunately, I don't think I can finish reading this.
For example, I was terribly confused by the scene which has DeLuca saving Van Buren from almost drowning. The whole episode just wasn't described so that I could visualize what was going on, who was where, how she got into the water, and how he was able to find her to save her. I'm hoping that this is fixed in the final version.
By the way, I don't think that this author knows Chicago that well. She describes a warehouse there near the lake, but by her description, it sounds like it is only yards from the lakefront. However, as far as I know there were never any shipping warehouses on the lakefront, only on the river. That means the characters in that scene couldn't have been looking out on Lake Michigan, but only onto the Chicago River.
Another thing that confused me was why the author gave DeLuca - who is so Italian that he translates from that language into English - a very Scottish first name like Hamish. If that's explained in the first novel, I really wish the author had added a line about it in this one.
Finally, the "romance" bit here - or should I call it angst - was too overpowering for me. DeLuca goes on and on about every aspect of this woman and why he adores her and how he feels when he's around her. When she started in on her feelings towards him, well... that's when I gave up on this book. (I only read about 15%.)
This is really a shame because I've been trying to find a good cozy mystery series where I can fall in love with the protagonist/s and enjoy some harmless sleuthing on a historical backdrop. I'm afraid this one didn't deliver for me.
Now I have to figure out what I'm going to tell NetGalley when I tell them I'll not be reviewing this book.
For example, I was terribly confused by the scene which has DeLuca saving Van Buren from almost drowning. The whole episode just wasn't described so that I could visualize what was going on, who was where, how she got into the water, and how he was able to find her to save her. I'm hoping that this is fixed in the final version.
By the way, I don't think that this author knows Chicago that well. She describes a warehouse there near the lake, but by her description, it sounds like it is only yards from the lakefront. However, as far as I know there were never any shipping warehouses on the lakefront, only on the river. That means the characters in that scene couldn't have been looking out on Lake Michigan, but only onto the Chicago River.
Another thing that confused me was why the author gave DeLuca - who is so Italian that he translates from that language into English - a very Scottish first name like Hamish. If that's explained in the first novel, I really wish the author had added a line about it in this one.
Finally, the "romance" bit here - or should I call it angst - was too overpowering for me. DeLuca goes on and on about every aspect of this woman and why he adores her and how he feels when he's around her. When she started in on her feelings towards him, well... that's when I gave up on this book. (I only read about 15%.)
This is really a shame because I've been trying to find a good cozy mystery series where I can fall in love with the protagonist/s and enjoy some harmless sleuthing on a historical backdrop. I'm afraid this one didn't deliver for me.
Now I have to figure out what I'm going to tell NetGalley when I tell them I'll not be reviewing this book.
June 24, 2019
I don't read a lot of mysteries, but I have been curious about Rachel McMillan’s writing for a while now, and when the opportunity popped up to review her latest release, the vintage look to the cover reeled me in. I am so glad I took a chance outside my favorite genre and look forward to reading more of this author!
The characters are fun and unique. Reggie is a runaway debutante, rebelling against her parents expectations, who has opened an investigative firm with her friend, who incidentally happens to be in love with her. Hamish is an amazing hero and I loved that he was imperfect, or as Reggie called him, a “rusty knight.” Neither of the main characters are without flaws, even with regard to the other person, and I liked how they make each other better over the course of the novel.
I really enjoyed the references to classic movies and music—it made me feel as if I was there, in that time and place. Another component that made me feel like I was there was the uncomfortable prejudices; the author made me understand the social and racial climate, very different from my own, without resorting to foul language or offensive slurs to make it more “realistic." McMillan went to the extra effort to convey the ideas rather than simply shock the reader, and I really appreciated that.
Those who like classic mysteries should really enjoy this book, and I would highly recommend it to anyone who enjoys historical novels as well. While mystery may not be my go-to genre, McMillan has certainly found a new fan in me. I will be looking up her backlist and eagerly awaiting another Van Buren and DeLuca novel!
I received a review copy of this book through Celebrate Lit but was under no obligation to post a positive review. The opinions expressed are both honest and my own.
The characters are fun and unique. Reggie is a runaway debutante, rebelling against her parents expectations, who has opened an investigative firm with her friend, who incidentally happens to be in love with her. Hamish is an amazing hero and I loved that he was imperfect, or as Reggie called him, a “rusty knight.” Neither of the main characters are without flaws, even with regard to the other person, and I liked how they make each other better over the course of the novel.
I really enjoyed the references to classic movies and music—it made me feel as if I was there, in that time and place. Another component that made me feel like I was there was the uncomfortable prejudices; the author made me understand the social and racial climate, very different from my own, without resorting to foul language or offensive slurs to make it more “realistic." McMillan went to the extra effort to convey the ideas rather than simply shock the reader, and I really appreciated that.
Those who like classic mysteries should really enjoy this book, and I would highly recommend it to anyone who enjoys historical novels as well. While mystery may not be my go-to genre, McMillan has certainly found a new fan in me. I will be looking up her backlist and eagerly awaiting another Van Buren and DeLuca novel!
I received a review copy of this book through Celebrate Lit but was under no obligation to post a positive review. The opinions expressed are both honest and my own.
Read
October 25, 2020DNF at page 78 although I will admit to skim-reading to the end.
Once I found out that this begins about two years after the ending of the last book, I should've tapped out immediately. Because, you know, the MCs still haven't gotten together and I'm all for slow burn, but a hero who is so beta that he's willing to wait that long to convince the heroine that the guy she's with isn't for her? Or for a heroine being confused about her feelings for both the hero and the other guy? For two years?
I can't speak to the mystery itself, but the relationship between the MCs was just so frustrating. And not only did Hamish string another girl along for a while, unintentionally of course, the heroine becomes engaged to the other guy, who was a genuinely wonderful guy too, by the way, and actually started planning the wedding. And she didn't break it off with him until almost the last chapter of the book. I'm sorry, but I just can't with the indecisiveness, especially when it hurt two wonderful men.
Usually the other guy is not so nice and then you don't feel bad when the heroine chooses the hero over him. Horrible, I know. However, in this case, he totally deserved better than her. Unfortunately, I can't rate this since I didn't really read the whole thing. But if I were to give it any stars, they would all be for Hamish and Vaughn (the other guy).
I loved that this series was clean, and that there were some wonderful relationships in it. The historical context was also interesting and well developed. If the author ever wrote another entry in this series, with the MCs being a couple the whole time, I would be totally interested in it. I'm sorry that this one didn't work for me.
Once I found out that this begins about two years after the ending of the last book, I should've tapped out immediately. Because, you know, the MCs still haven't gotten together and I'm all for slow burn, but a hero who is so beta that he's willing to wait that long to convince the heroine that the guy she's with isn't for her? Or for a heroine being confused about her feelings for both the hero and the other guy? For two years?
I can't speak to the mystery itself, but the relationship between the MCs was just so frustrating. And not only did Hamish string another girl along for a while, unintentionally of course, the heroine becomes engaged to the other guy, who was a genuinely wonderful guy too, by the way, and actually started planning the wedding. And she didn't break it off with him until almost the last chapter of the book. I'm sorry, but I just can't with the indecisiveness, especially when it hurt two wonderful men.
Usually the other guy is not so nice and then you don't feel bad when the heroine chooses the hero over him. Horrible, I know. However, in this case, he totally deserved better than her. Unfortunately, I can't rate this since I didn't really read the whole thing. But if I were to give it any stars, they would all be for Hamish and Vaughn (the other guy).
I loved that this series was clean, and that there were some wonderful relationships in it. The historical context was also interesting and well developed. If the author ever wrote another entry in this series, with the MCs being a couple the whole time, I would be totally interested in it. I'm sorry that this one didn't work for me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 23, 2019
I'm happy to be back with the duo of Hamish and Reggie. They are a great team and for some reason remind me of the duo from the show Moonlighting. They have this quirky relationship that seems to compliment each other. I'm not quite sure if there are sparks between them at times, but they sure liven up the story.
There is an abundance of intrigue and not so nice people in the story. At times I didn't know who was good and who was bad. I remember reading the first book and thinking how much I enjoyed it. This book had me confused. There seemed to be too many characters and I didn't know if I was reading a mystery or a romance book.
The story covers a little about baseball and prejudice during this time period. I enjoyed reading about the great baseball players during this time period. My blood boiled as Errol Parker explained how he has been treated in the baseball world due to his color. He is the best at stealing bases, but someone is not happy with him playing. When he describes how his nephew was beat up at a game, you could feel Hamish and Reggie become angry and ashamed of how cruel people are.
Lies are being spread about different nationalities and the tension has built up to where it is infiltrated the baseball world. Why is this group spreading hate? Baseball is America's favorite pass time, but Errol thinks his life may be in danger. I wish the author would have not spent so much time on if Hamish and Reggie liked each other. This book is listed as a Christian fiction book, but I found no reference to faith at all in the book.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
There is an abundance of intrigue and not so nice people in the story. At times I didn't know who was good and who was bad. I remember reading the first book and thinking how much I enjoyed it. This book had me confused. There seemed to be too many characters and I didn't know if I was reading a mystery or a romance book.
The story covers a little about baseball and prejudice during this time period. I enjoyed reading about the great baseball players during this time period. My blood boiled as Errol Parker explained how he has been treated in the baseball world due to his color. He is the best at stealing bases, but someone is not happy with him playing. When he describes how his nephew was beat up at a game, you could feel Hamish and Reggie become angry and ashamed of how cruel people are.
Lies are being spread about different nationalities and the tension has built up to where it is infiltrated the baseball world. Why is this group spreading hate? Baseball is America's favorite pass time, but Errol thinks his life may be in danger. I wish the author would have not spent so much time on if Hamish and Reggie liked each other. This book is listed as a Christian fiction book, but I found no reference to faith at all in the book.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
September 5, 2019
Reggie Van Burden and Hamish DeLuca have continued their amateur sleuthing adventures ever since the events of Murder At The Flamingo two years prior. When pranks on an African American minor league baseball player turn foul, Reggie and Hamish plunge into the darker corners of Boston politics to uncover the source.
I really like these two main characters. They are strong and unique, and Reggie's waffling between her privileged socialite upbringing and her desire for independence rings true. Hamish is lovable, and I appreciate the author's desire to bring awareness to the anxiety that hounds thousands of people every day, and in an accurate historical setting for these novels.
This story lacked quite a bit in terms of plot. The mystery was hard to follow, and I agree with other reviewers who have said the scenes were not written in such a way that the reader could visualize what was happening. There were also some interesting choices like giving characters very similar names (Reid and Reis), or names similar to places when there was no connection between the two (Parker and the Parker House Hotel). It was also confusing as to what exactly was going on with Cousin Luca. He was not there but very much there at the same time.
The long and short of it: I loved every scene which focused on Hamish and Reggie, and I made it through the rest. The last few scenes with Nathaniel were adorable as well. This author's strengths are definitely in characterization and setting!
I received my copy of the book from the publisher. All opinions in this review are my own.
This review originated at http://reviewsbyerin.dreamwidth.org
I really like these two main characters. They are strong and unique, and Reggie's waffling between her privileged socialite upbringing and her desire for independence rings true. Hamish is lovable, and I appreciate the author's desire to bring awareness to the anxiety that hounds thousands of people every day, and in an accurate historical setting for these novels.
This story lacked quite a bit in terms of plot. The mystery was hard to follow, and I agree with other reviewers who have said the scenes were not written in such a way that the reader could visualize what was happening. There were also some interesting choices like giving characters very similar names (Reid and Reis), or names similar to places when there was no connection between the two (Parker and the Parker House Hotel). It was also confusing as to what exactly was going on with Cousin Luca. He was not there but very much there at the same time.
The long and short of it: I loved every scene which focused on Hamish and Reggie, and I made it through the rest. The last few scenes with Nathaniel were adorable as well. This author's strengths are definitely in characterization and setting!
I received my copy of the book from the publisher. All opinions in this review are my own.
This review originated at http://reviewsbyerin.dreamwidth.org
May 9, 2019
Reggie and Hamish sleuthing team is at work to solve the seemingly petty crimes in the baseball world.
After two years, Reggie and Hamish are still friends. Oh wells, good luck with that. Luckily, there are gangsters of all sorts to provide the opening for the changes in their relationship status - or to make them suffer. Or both.
Unfortunately, this second installments does not hold my excitement of the first volume. Maybe because I am not interested in baseball. Or maybe I am too much interested in the bad boy Luca. Or maybe because Reggie and Hamish's "friendship" can be dragged only for so long. What they have been doing during the two years from our last meeting?
So while this series have awaken my need to visit Boston and to watch couple of movies from the Hollywood Golden Era, I would prefer more active sleuthing. And more Luca! Luca, truly, is soul of this series for me - a bit darkened, but the more interesting for it!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Thomas Nelson through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
After two years, Reggie and Hamish are still friends. Oh wells, good luck with that. Luckily, there are gangsters of all sorts to provide the opening for the changes in their relationship status - or to make them suffer. Or both.
Unfortunately, this second installments does not hold my excitement of the first volume. Maybe because I am not interested in baseball. Or maybe I am too much interested in the bad boy Luca. Or maybe because Reggie and Hamish's "friendship" can be dragged only for so long. What they have been doing during the two years from our last meeting?
So while this series have awaken my need to visit Boston and to watch couple of movies from the Hollywood Golden Era, I would prefer more active sleuthing. And more Luca! Luca, truly, is soul of this series for me - a bit darkened, but the more interesting for it!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Thomas Nelson through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
June 23, 2019
Murder in the city of liberty
Reggie and Hamish are private investigators. There is a murder. They had met the person that got murder and knows his uncle. Will they find out who did it? They are also attracted to each other but don’t want to admit it.
The book is set in the 1940’s. Even though it is fiction there is some based on true events. It was enjoyable reading about the baseball players.
The book was a little slow starting out but did get interesting after a few chapters. This is my first book by the author. I will have to read some of her other books.
I received an advanced copy of the book from the publisher through Celebrate Lit. I was not required to write an positive review. This is my own opinion.
Reggie and Hamish are private investigators. There is a murder. They had met the person that got murder and knows his uncle. Will they find out who did it? They are also attracted to each other but don’t want to admit it.
The book is set in the 1940’s. Even though it is fiction there is some based on true events. It was enjoyable reading about the baseball players.
The book was a little slow starting out but did get interesting after a few chapters. This is my first book by the author. I will have to read some of her other books.
I received an advanced copy of the book from the publisher through Celebrate Lit. I was not required to write an positive review. This is my own opinion.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 125 reviews