**As per all of my reviews, I like to preface by saying that I listened to this book in audiobook format. This does indeed slightly skew my rating. I have found that audiobooks, give me a better "relationship" with the characters if done well, but also kills the book for me if narrated poorly. Also due to the nature of listening to the text, names and places may be spelled incorrectly here as I often do not have the physical volume in front of me.
Also, I have written this review in a "rolling updates" style. In that I basically chronicle my reading as I progress. This may make for a jarring and spoilery review so be warned.**
Alright, it's been almost two years since we've gotten the previous book in the series. The book Hearts and Mind's was pretty much a set up and history of how Section 31 made contact and may have had a pivotal role in early human interference with an alien race.
This is brought to a head when Picard reaches a mysterious planet in the Oddyessian Pass, and triggers one of their crew members, Taurik to divulge that he may have had information about this event. From a previous novel Taurik learns this but is sworn to secrecy. This is all handled by Admiral Akaar, who keeps the chains on Taurik and when contacted by Picard, pretty much tells him to shut up and follow
So this planet that they "discover" is the home world of the Eizand. So the Majestic 12…(pre Section 31) used a captured Eizand fighter that crashed on earth, to launch a strike against the Eizand themselves. The astronaunts who were sent to launch this devastating strike against the Eizand homeworld couldn't/wouldn't complete the mission… Despite this the factions on the planet of Eizand us this 'near miss' opportunity to launch strikes against other Eizand factions and put the blame on humanity. Unfortunately the violence escalated to such a point that it decimated Eizand and forever it was blamed to be a strike by Earth.
This creates a sort of false narrative that Admiral Akaar is trying to hide. Even before this Admiral Akaar is not on good terms with Picard and Akaar's demands to keep this hidden doesn't help…
Anyway Picard and his team is somehow captured and imprisoned...The away team is rescued by an Eizand rogue. He breaks them out, and tells them he wishes to have the truth revealed, that his race, the Ezands have been lied to about human's attack on them…
We get some exposition and waxing poetic of philosophy of what an organization like Section 31 means. And does the end justify the means, and came some smaller crimes be overlooked for great good? Admiral Ross who we get to see in DS9, has retired and like many other ex-Sect 31 members been moved to a sort resort planet where he can live out his days….Yea…until he's rounded up in a sweeping raid of arrests. This again reminds me of post WWII and how many Nazi officers fled to Argentina to hide. Of course i don't really think the same level of maleficence is comparable.
Like Ross we also see the (attempted) arrest of Admiral Nechayev. She has a bit more luck and is able to beam to another location… they follow here there but she seems to be able to make more of struggle..They end up taking her in but we get some exposition in the way of inner monologue that Section 31, while being dismantled may not be so easily stopped. Automation within Section 31 has already been set in place.
the crew conveniently comes upon a massive massive ship that seems derelict. Just as an aside, and this is a smaller complaint, but I'm a bit weary of the story idea of Huge ship that is nearly quadrople the size of the enterprise…as well as derelict mystery alien ship… and this doesn't help that this story of Control is so hot off of the heels of me watching Star Trek Discovery Season 2….which deal literally with a giant alien sphere with data that is used for Control.
This actually is sort of a sticking point for me as not only does this show that there's no real relationship between the "novel-verse" aka the Beta canon and the TV show prime canon… but it also sort of lessens the impact of the novels…
We get a sort of expect 'alien attack' from within the derelict ship. But the ship's defensive mechanism kicks in and destroys the aliens attacking them…but leaves the away team alone.
The book, uses the many many times over used tropes of 'can't beam the team out of danger', interference in weapons and convenient plot devices used over and over in trek.
So the story has taken two paths. It's gone one route with a very interesting story of the idea of Section 31 having the curtain thrown open, and gutted. I like the idea that all of these higher ranking officials are being plucked out of their comfortable living spaces and brought to trial. Admiral Ross who we know from DS9 meets a surprising and gruesome end. Now despite the already tired "Control" story, I really like the story point of having all of these "badmirals" facing trial but still having a sort of justifable defense. The classic greater good question comes up.
Now while I love this portion of the book, it seems like we can't have a Star Trek story without a checklist of things….Alien race in distress….Starfleet finds mystery situation….Alien race may appear hostile…Alien race gets Starfleet to help….a Problem happens….Resolved. I like how Ward continues the exploration of the Odessian pass…but we're just getting a congo line of the same stories..
I know that Trek does well to stick to a format or sort of 'safe script'… and because of the sheer amount of stories told over the years I completely realize that there is a definite lack of new stories….literally running out of possibilities, but I feel like the recipe really needs to be played with a bit.
So anyway the alien race on the ship for whatever reason has gone derelict and projected their consciousness into this sort of hyper realistic simulation. The entire crew has removed themselves from their bodies and I assume needs the help of Starfleet to help them get back on their feet… Big surprise…
Also I like how much DS9 involvement we're getting.. We're getting some good scenes with Worf and Martok…and even Worf's rumminations on his involvement with Dax. So I definitely love the 'deep cuts'.
Martok, who's been pretty much a "brother" to Worf, this is continued here.
The book has two stories here, and it's unfortnately focusing on the more generic alien encounter story line instead of the storyline that is, to me, far more interesting. The trial of the section 31 higher ups is pretty important in the grand scheme of things and it seems a bit underhanded to relagate it to a 'B' plot. I really love the idea that the President of the Federation is an Andorian woman. Kellessar zh'Tarash. She meets with Admiral Akaar, but unfortunately nothing is really resolved.. the dialogue and action in these scenes doesn't really lead or accomplish anything. They just discuss what happened and Akaar says that he would be willing to take the blame. And they basically just agree that it's a crap situation. I really would love to see more of a reaction to the news from different area's around the Federation. Different planets and races and their reaction to this.
We're back with the main story and it's just so routine.. The alien race is still floundering and this guild of scavengers and salvagers is coming to try to take the ship by force… but one ship has met with the Enterprise and are willing to help them. So they have to try to talk down her comrades or stand against them…so yea okay.. sort of interesting. But I can see this as the B plot here.
The story wraps up with a sort of mixed bag of feelings for me. On one hand I really liked that we're now going to see Picard sort of 'suit up' and go to face the music so to speak. He's returning to Earth and going to face up to the charges against him and the other members of S31. After only 3 books in the Oddesyian pass ( or 4?) I still feel as though there should be a return here. The stories we got from the exploration of the Pass itself have been standard Star Trek fair but nothing really pushing the boundaries of story beats. So on that note, it leaves me a bit disappointed overall. Playing into that same idea, the story in this specific book, was also a mix. I wanted more of the S31 story. We're never given 100% of the focus on this. The book starts out focusing on this story but quickly peels away to the standard Trek story of alien species in need. Which… is fine, but it's a bit hard to focus on something so mundane when you have something so 'big' going on that's only getting half or less than half the spotlight.
The chunk of the resolution of the main story is again pretty standard, lots of obstacles for the Enterprise crew to overcome. We get some nice team work with them. It sort of goes a bit…weird when we start getting into the whole consciousness aspect, in which it feels like I need to pop some mushrooms to fully experience what T'ressa Chen and later the rest of the crew experience. The aliens have a method of traveling long distances in that they separate their bodies from their conscious minds. Though…it's never stated what happens to their bodies…or where they are kept oddly enough. But the ship is also host to this holodeck like area but it's not really the same thing. Called "Haven" it's sort of an existential playground where the race can live out a normal (non starship traveling) existence while they are indeed traveling the galaxy. I suppose this race doesn't have as quick of warp drives as the Federation… Since this whole set up would probably be more trouble than it's worth, since traveling at max warp would cut down on the traveling time, that it would make creating a device that lets your consciousness roam and live in a separate realm….feel a bit of a waste.
Anyway all's well that ends well, the pirates that were going to salvage the ship, are beaten back, until they surrender seeing the error of their plundering ways. So it's not a bad story at all. I can't say it's anything mind blowing for one half…but also something extremely vital to the continuing story on the other, which again creates this weird dichotomy.
Overall, I enjoyed it, but wanted more of one aspect, and less of another. Not a bad problem to have I suppose