What do you think?
Rate this book
My Heart Belongs
My Heart Belongs in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania: Clarissa's Conflict
When War Reaches Clarissa’s Back Door, the Trustworthy Become Even Fewer. Journey into Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, of 1863 where Clarissa Avery Ross lives a full life. By day she is the daughter of a respectable shoemaker being courted by seminary student Kyle Forrester. But by night she is a conductor on the Underground Railroad, working with a mysterious man called Liberty. She would like to share her work with Kyle, but he refuses to enlist when the war breaks out. How can she remain true to a man being labeled a coward? When the war comes to her back door in an epic battle, the greatest challenges to her faith and love are yet to come.
424 pages, Kindle Edition
Published November 1, 2018
10 people are currently reading
1667 people want to read
About the author
Murray Pura
149 books748 followersreader, writer, author, free thinker
books published in 2023
KINGFISHER CROSS
NEVENA IN LOVE
CLARA RAVEN
UNDER THE STONES
available on Amazon, B&N, Indigo, etc.
listed for Best Series of the Year Award 2023
Hemingway Award 2022 Seattle
Word Guild Award 2022, 2012 Toronto
books published in 2023
KINGFISHER CROSS
NEVENA IN LOVE
CLARA RAVEN
UNDER THE STONES
available on Amazon, B&N, Indigo, etc.
listed for Best Series of the Year Award 2023
Hemingway Award 2022 Seattle
Word Guild Award 2022, 2012 Toronto
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 104 reviews
November 6, 2018
I have thoroughly enjoyed reading the My Heart Belongs series and this one was no exception! I live 40 minutes from Gettysburg and have enjoyed going there many times. We get right into the thick of things with the battle ranging around us. The author's descriptions and research are much appreciated and made me feel as though I was right there with the scrap of a red-headed heroine. She's a brave one and won't back down from anyone. Mentions of Quakers,Amish,quilts,abolitionist,Underground Railroads and faith fill the book. I love how faith was immersed in the writing. The author really brings this time period to life!
Pub Date 01 Nov 2018
I was given a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing, Inc. through NetGalley. Thank you. All opinions expressed are my own.
Pub Date 01 Nov 2018
I was given a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing, Inc. through NetGalley. Thank you. All opinions expressed are my own.
July 29, 2022
This one was a chore to read. The heroine was abrasive and unlikable for most of the book, and it was never clear how the pampered society girl managed to live her second secret life without her parents having a clue she was sneaking out disguised as a man. The love interest is a love triangle trope, which is my least favorite, and most of the characters are ill-humored. Even Liberty, who's supposed to be the true love, is abrasive and rude.
The story left me with more questions than answers and the characters didn't win my heart.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free reading copy. A favorable review was not required.
The story left me with more questions than answers and the characters didn't win my heart.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free reading copy. A favorable review was not required.
August 13, 2018
An interesting historical romance full of actual events! Set around Gettysburg, starting in 1860, with characters heavily involved in the Underground Railroad, the story includes events and examines issues leading up to the epic Civil War battle.
The romance is a complex one, with some strong personalities, coming together in surprising ways. Clarissa is a fiery redhead, full of zeal for the antislavery movement, risking her life alongside many others in the Underground Railroad through Pennsylvania. The risks she takes become sacrificial as war looms and then explodes close to home. It took me awhile to get used to her, but eventually came to admire her fearless attitude and service. Prayers and Scripture, as well as hymns and spirituals add some faith and hope to the story.
"But he knoweth the way that I take: when he hath tried me, I shall come forth as gold.”
The author shows his thorough research in the many discussions and events included, plus the cameo appearances of historical figures. The horrors and violence of events are added and described just enough to get a glimpse of how awful it must have been. It is hard to imagine the scope and carnage of war. Some of the dialogue seemed overly dramatized at times, and a bit far fetched. I enjoyed the story more in the last half.
Recommend to readers who enjoy stories based on real history, especially the Civil War, with some faith and clean romance. 3.5 stars
(An e-book was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.)
The romance is a complex one, with some strong personalities, coming together in surprising ways. Clarissa is a fiery redhead, full of zeal for the antislavery movement, risking her life alongside many others in the Underground Railroad through Pennsylvania. The risks she takes become sacrificial as war looms and then explodes close to home. It took me awhile to get used to her, but eventually came to admire her fearless attitude and service. Prayers and Scripture, as well as hymns and spirituals add some faith and hope to the story.
"But he knoweth the way that I take: when he hath tried me, I shall come forth as gold.”
The author shows his thorough research in the many discussions and events included, plus the cameo appearances of historical figures. The horrors and violence of events are added and described just enough to get a glimpse of how awful it must have been. It is hard to imagine the scope and carnage of war. Some of the dialogue seemed overly dramatized at times, and a bit far fetched. I enjoyed the story more in the last half.
Recommend to readers who enjoy stories based on real history, especially the Civil War, with some faith and clean romance. 3.5 stars
(An e-book was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.)
January 9, 2020
I want to start by saying that I've been reading the My Heart Belongs in series and have been enjoying it immensely. I've only read 3 or 4 others aside from this one but they've all been 4-5 star reads. So please don't let this review put you off from the series, as it is not an overall reflection of the series as a whole.
Back to this book. I found the Underground Railroad to be an interesting topic to read about.
The major problem I have with this book is that it's labeled Christian fiction but a lot of the elements aren't Christian.
For example, the characters exchange some random vows near an alter while talking about marriage, and say because God was their witness, they are now married. However, there is no formal ceremony, she doesn't take his last name, and they do even state that they are pretend married. Then later in the book, the characters spend the night together in each others arms, snuggling and kissing.
I feel that goes against one of the main elements of Christian fiction, and I have never seen a book featuring this. The characters try to justify it, saying they are married before God, but at the same time they are not married.
I also feel that this was very unrealistic, as this is historical fiction, and back then something like that would have been considered very improper and it's just not something that would have happened. The romance in general was very physical, and didn't seem to fit with the time era.
I couldn't really connect to the characters in this book. I felt that we were supposed to see Clarissa as a strong, independent woman, after all she is working for the Underground Railroad. However, half the time she seemed like a silly girl, childlike almost. She says some of her temper and strange behaviors are due to her being a red head, which just seemed like an odd thing to say.
Some of her childlike thinking showed in that she's experiencing a bit of a love triangle. However she mentions she's not sure if she likes choice A, choice b, or maybe neither of them. It seemed very uncharacteristic for a proclaimed Christian to be leading people on like that. I understand that love triangles do happen, but this one came across as her not caring about the men involved, which was just another strange aspect of her character, and a contradiction of who she is supposed to be.
There also didn't seem to be a lot of character development. If anything some of the characters seemed to slide backward in development.
Overall I thought the plot was odd, as it seemed to change courses several times during the book. I was often not quite sure what I was reading about.
I considered putting the book down multiple times and wish I had.
If you enjoy learning about the Underground Railroad this book might be a book you'll enjoy. However, there is no authors note, so I'm not sure how much of what was written was fiction and stretched for the book, and what was fact. But if you know more about the Underground Railroad than I do, you'd know the difference and could enjoy that part more.
This book was definitely not for me and I'd give it 0 of 5 stars.
Back to this book. I found the Underground Railroad to be an interesting topic to read about.
The major problem I have with this book is that it's labeled Christian fiction but a lot of the elements aren't Christian.
For example, the characters exchange some random vows near an alter while talking about marriage, and say because God was their witness, they are now married. However, there is no formal ceremony, she doesn't take his last name, and they do even state that they are pretend married. Then later in the book, the characters spend the night together in each others arms, snuggling and kissing.
I feel that goes against one of the main elements of Christian fiction, and I have never seen a book featuring this. The characters try to justify it, saying they are married before God, but at the same time they are not married.
I also feel that this was very unrealistic, as this is historical fiction, and back then something like that would have been considered very improper and it's just not something that would have happened. The romance in general was very physical, and didn't seem to fit with the time era.
I couldn't really connect to the characters in this book. I felt that we were supposed to see Clarissa as a strong, independent woman, after all she is working for the Underground Railroad. However, half the time she seemed like a silly girl, childlike almost. She says some of her temper and strange behaviors are due to her being a red head, which just seemed like an odd thing to say.
Some of her childlike thinking showed in that she's experiencing a bit of a love triangle. However she mentions she's not sure if she likes choice A, choice b, or maybe neither of them. It seemed very uncharacteristic for a proclaimed Christian to be leading people on like that. I understand that love triangles do happen, but this one came across as her not caring about the men involved, which was just another strange aspect of her character, and a contradiction of who she is supposed to be.
There also didn't seem to be a lot of character development. If anything some of the characters seemed to slide backward in development.
Overall I thought the plot was odd, as it seemed to change courses several times during the book. I was often not quite sure what I was reading about.
I considered putting the book down multiple times and wish I had.
If you enjoy learning about the Underground Railroad this book might be a book you'll enjoy. However, there is no authors note, so I'm not sure how much of what was written was fiction and stretched for the book, and what was fact. But if you know more about the Underground Railroad than I do, you'd know the difference and could enjoy that part more.
This book was definitely not for me and I'd give it 0 of 5 stars.
September 19, 2018
This book is a romance set in 1860 to 1863 in Gettysburg. In the first half of the book, the scenes where Clarissa led escaped slaves along the Underground Railroad were exciting. But it seemed like most of the scenes were of her 'normal' life, like her romantic walks with Kyle. When war broke out, we got a lot of "I hate you" and "I love you" scenes and love letters while her fiance's at war. Excitement returned when the war came to Gettysburg (and they still managed to spend time kissing intensely).
My main problem was with the hussy...er, heroine. She was extremely forward about embracing and passionately kissing a man, even before he was officially courting her. They also had premarital sex (implied rather than described). She justified this to herself--that God would bless this--because they love each other. She even called herself by his last name and called him her husband before the actual wedding.
I was continually annoyed by her spoiled attitude. She was hateful to people who hurt her pride--for example, Liberty scared her when trying to save her life and even apologized for it, but she basically cursed him to hell for doing so. She was impulsive plus often jumped to wrong conclusions. She's a red head, so she feels that passion, a quick temper, and tantrums are alright. One minute she hates a man and the next she's attracted to him. Even with her beauty and kisses, I can't understand why any man was attracted to her. But they all were.
There were no graphic sex scenes or bad language. Overall, I enjoy actual diaries from this time more than this story, but people who enjoy impulsive, passionate heroines may enjoy it.
I received an ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through Netgalley.
My main problem was with the hussy...er, heroine. She was extremely forward about embracing and passionately kissing a man, even before he was officially courting her. They also had premarital sex (implied rather than described). She justified this to herself--that God would bless this--because they love each other. She even called herself by his last name and called him her husband before the actual wedding.
I was continually annoyed by her spoiled attitude. She was hateful to people who hurt her pride--for example, Liberty scared her when trying to save her life and even apologized for it, but she basically cursed him to hell for doing so. She was impulsive plus often jumped to wrong conclusions. She's a red head, so she feels that passion, a quick temper, and tantrums are alright. One minute she hates a man and the next she's attracted to him. Even with her beauty and kisses, I can't understand why any man was attracted to her. But they all were.
There were no graphic sex scenes or bad language. Overall, I enjoy actual diaries from this time more than this story, but people who enjoy impulsive, passionate heroines may enjoy it.
I received an ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through Netgalley.
November 19, 2018
My Heart Belongs in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania by Murray Pura is a book about the Underground Railroad during the Civil War and the battle of Gettysburg.
I was pleased to see a book about Gettysburg, since it is close to where my father was born and we visited several times while on vacation. I loved reading about the Lutherans in the town and the Seminary since my husband’s ancestor was a student there.
However, I was not pleased with Clarissa Avery Ross at all. She was petulant and too outspoken for the times, when young ladies were taught to be demure. She was like Scarlet O’Hara on steroids. I could not see her being trusted as a conducter on the Underground Railroad because of her immaturity and rashness.
By the time the war got to Gettysburg and Clarissa was thrown into the aftermath of the battle, nursing the wounded, I felt like she had finally grown up. She went about her tasks as it was her Christian Duty, not caring which solders were Rebels and which were Union. Then she actually saw battle and that’s where her stubbornness served her well.
Mr. Pura does an exceptional job of describing the battle at Gettysburg. And the scene with Abraham Lincoln dedicating the cemetery was very moving. I remember that memorizing the Gettysburg Address was a requirement in my Junior High days. I wish everyone would be able to recite it. It is important to remember.
Thankyou Mr. Pura for bringing this part of our National History to life.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing. I was not required to give a favorable review. All opinions are my own. *
I was pleased to see a book about Gettysburg, since it is close to where my father was born and we visited several times while on vacation. I loved reading about the Lutherans in the town and the Seminary since my husband’s ancestor was a student there.
However, I was not pleased with Clarissa Avery Ross at all. She was petulant and too outspoken for the times, when young ladies were taught to be demure. She was like Scarlet O’Hara on steroids. I could not see her being trusted as a conducter on the Underground Railroad because of her immaturity and rashness.
By the time the war got to Gettysburg and Clarissa was thrown into the aftermath of the battle, nursing the wounded, I felt like she had finally grown up. She went about her tasks as it was her Christian Duty, not caring which solders were Rebels and which were Union. Then she actually saw battle and that’s where her stubbornness served her well.
Mr. Pura does an exceptional job of describing the battle at Gettysburg. And the scene with Abraham Lincoln dedicating the cemetery was very moving. I remember that memorizing the Gettysburg Address was a requirement in my Junior High days. I wish everyone would be able to recite it. It is important to remember.
Thankyou Mr. Pura for bringing this part of our National History to life.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing. I was not required to give a favorable review. All opinions are my own. *
November 8, 2018
Filled with Civil War historical detail that brings the Battle of Gettysburg to life, this My Heart Belongs was another good read in this series. This book had it all: the Underground Railroad, battles leading up to Gettysburg, Gettysburg, and wonderfully realistic characters. Clarissa was an interesting young lady: daring, brave, adventuresome, opinionated, and courageous. Playing a double role as either a man or a cultured young lady came second nature to her. Liberty was a perfect foil to Clarissa and played many roles as well. Overall, a well done read.
I would have given it a 5 but felt that the romance eclipsed the historical at times.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Books through NetGalley. Opinions are mine alone. I was not compensated for this review.
I would have given it a 5 but felt that the romance eclipsed the historical at times.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Books through NetGalley. Opinions are mine alone. I was not compensated for this review.
March 29, 2022
I have been to the Gettysburg National Park and had a tour, doing it again in May with my son. I guess growing up in Iowa I heard more about the Northern battles, where they were. I know my great-great-grandfather was on his way to the Battle of Vicksburg but caught up in a skirmish in Tennessee and didn't make it. I now live in Jackson, Mississippi, and know a little more about Southern battles, especially Vicksburg. But it NEVER dawned on me until I was on the tour at Gettysburg, that it and Vicksburg happened on the SAME days!!! And I love history!!
This was a great little story combining the Underground Railroad, the battle, and women soldiers (for both sides). I loved the characters of Clarissa and Ian - I had a feeling of his true identity early on, but it made it all the better in the end.
Enjoyable story and I may have to check some more of his books out. Rounding up to 4.5 stars.
This was a great little story combining the Underground Railroad, the battle, and women soldiers (for both sides). I loved the characters of Clarissa and Ian - I had a feeling of his true identity early on, but it made it all the better in the end.
Enjoyable story and I may have to check some more of his books out. Rounding up to 4.5 stars.
October 19, 2018
This was my first book by Murray Pura.
The book takes place in Gettysburg during prior to the Civil War and during it. It follows the underground railroad and a girl who is dedicated to seeing the end of slavery. The hero had to be rescued several times, which was nice.
This book was not for me. I'm finding that I don't enjoy war novels. The author did well painting the pictures of war without being overly graphic.
Give it a try if you enjoy historical war novels!
The book takes place in Gettysburg during prior to the Civil War and during it. It follows the underground railroad and a girl who is dedicated to seeing the end of slavery. The hero had to be rescued several times, which was nice.
This book was not for me. I'm finding that I don't enjoy war novels. The author did well painting the pictures of war without being overly graphic.
Give it a try if you enjoy historical war novels!
October 21, 2018
Good Civil War Drama!
Secret identities, Underground Railroad, the Civil War, and love.
This book had a bit more drama and grit than I expected. It is very well written with great historical details.
Clarissa is a smart, brave, outspoken redhead. Though she is a bit forward and not at all shy, I liked how the author showed her vulnerabilities.
Her Gettysburg will never be the same after the battle but it is where her heart belongs.
Secret identities, Underground Railroad, the Civil War, and love.
This book had a bit more drama and grit than I expected. It is very well written with great historical details.
Clarissa is a smart, brave, outspoken redhead. Though she is a bit forward and not at all shy, I liked how the author showed her vulnerabilities.
Her Gettysburg will never be the same after the battle but it is where her heart belongs.
December 21, 2018
FTC DISCLAIMER: I RECEIVED AN E-ARC FROM THE PUBLISHER THROUGH NET GALLEY. I VOLUNTARILY OFFER MY HONEST REVIEW OF THE BOOK, THOUGH IT IS NOT EXPECTED OF ME! RECEIPT OF THIS BOOK IN THIS MANNER DOES NOT AFFECT MY OPINION OF THE BOOK OR THE CONTENT OF MY REVIEW!
I was really looking forward to this story, because reading about the Civil War is one of my favorite time periods to read in, but I wound up utterly disappointed by this story!
The timeline seemed to jump around a lot, within the first half of the 1860s time period, though I am grateful that it did so in a linear fashion. The jumping around wound up being more of a confusing factor to the story rather than an enhancement.
The characterization seemed exaggerated, and there were a few places where I found my head spinning with how Clarissa kept changing her mood and feelings! I really began to hate her for it, and I couldn't connect to Kyle or Liberty too much either. I also really hated the love triangle that seemed to be set up between the two men, especially with the later revelations in the book.
I was not impressed with this story or author, and while it is worth reading as part of the larger My Heart Belongs in.. series, I feel it is not worth owning or re-reading.
I was really looking forward to this story, because reading about the Civil War is one of my favorite time periods to read in, but I wound up utterly disappointed by this story!
The timeline seemed to jump around a lot, within the first half of the 1860s time period, though I am grateful that it did so in a linear fashion. The jumping around wound up being more of a confusing factor to the story rather than an enhancement.
The characterization seemed exaggerated, and there were a few places where I found my head spinning with how Clarissa kept changing her mood and feelings! I really began to hate her for it, and I couldn't connect to Kyle or Liberty too much either. I also really hated the love triangle that seemed to be set up between the two men, especially with the later revelations in the book.
I was not impressed with this story or author, and while it is worth reading as part of the larger My Heart Belongs in.. series, I feel it is not worth owning or re-reading.
August 31, 2019
I did it again...I've had this book waiting to be read for a little bit and I finally read it. My plan...read fast and skim some so I can read through it really fast and move on to other things in life and other books waiting for me to catch up on because life went crazy the last several months and my PERFECTLY planned schedule went kaboom.
And when I mention that I was planning to skim it over, it isn't because of the book, it's life. Well, I started with good intentions and again life happened and my day went anything but my perfect plan. Hahahahahaha! I think it's time I give up on that "perfect plan" thinking! What do you think? But I picked up the book and was pulled in right away. And I thought I'd skim here and there...nope. I read it with very little skimming happening at all. I've just really enjoyed this series and I think I'm going to skim them and I can't do it. I get hooked!
This is my first book ever by this author. And I really enjoyed his writing style and characters. Plus, it's a historical fiction novel. I should know just from that, that I'll be hooked.
I really enjoyed reading about the underground railroad and this part of history and aspects leading up to the Civil War as well as the battles in Gettysburg. I loved the letter writing and the way the author was able to showcase the patriotism as well as conflict of families and the emotions of sending loved ones away to war. It was well done.
Clarissa was a spitfire character. And she's finding her heart is torn between two men. How can she choose between the two. There are both good men. When a moment comes she is forced to decide. Oh I loved the sweet love story written in this book. It was very tender and full of heart and emotion.
The author spanned a lot of time in this story. I liked how he conveyed several months passing. Sometimes the chapter would end in the middle of a scene and I wanted more of that scene. And the next chapter would start several weeks to months later and I would think, "No! I wanted to know what happened!" But then, the character would think about it and recap what we missed. I really enjoyed seeing their thoughts and we didn't miss out as readers on what happened in that scene.
Definitely one I will highly recommend reading. If you haven't read any of these books, they're stand alone. So you can pick and choose, especially depending on what historical moment you want to focus on reading and learning more about.
Content: Clean. Some kissing nothing further. This is a Christian fiction novel so the characters do speak of God and attend church and pray. But I feel like it is done very well in the sense that the characters acted and thought just as people in that time would have acted and thought. So it doesn't feel preachy or over the top. It all flows smoothly together and makes for a lovely read. There are several moments of peril due to the subject matter (slavery, underground railroad and the Civil War). So there are battles, guns, fighting, bloodshed, death and such but not overly graphic. I think older YA readers would enjoy this one, especially those who have studied the Civil War in school recently or will be soon.
I received a copy from the publisher, Barbour Publishing, via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions in the review are my own.
Happy Reading!!!
And when I mention that I was planning to skim it over, it isn't because of the book, it's life. Well, I started with good intentions and again life happened and my day went anything but my perfect plan. Hahahahahaha! I think it's time I give up on that "perfect plan" thinking! What do you think? But I picked up the book and was pulled in right away. And I thought I'd skim here and there...nope. I read it with very little skimming happening at all. I've just really enjoyed this series and I think I'm going to skim them and I can't do it. I get hooked!
This is my first book ever by this author. And I really enjoyed his writing style and characters. Plus, it's a historical fiction novel. I should know just from that, that I'll be hooked.
I really enjoyed reading about the underground railroad and this part of history and aspects leading up to the Civil War as well as the battles in Gettysburg. I loved the letter writing and the way the author was able to showcase the patriotism as well as conflict of families and the emotions of sending loved ones away to war. It was well done.
Clarissa was a spitfire character. And she's finding her heart is torn between two men. How can she choose between the two. There are both good men. When a moment comes she is forced to decide. Oh I loved the sweet love story written in this book. It was very tender and full of heart and emotion.
The author spanned a lot of time in this story. I liked how he conveyed several months passing. Sometimes the chapter would end in the middle of a scene and I wanted more of that scene. And the next chapter would start several weeks to months later and I would think, "No! I wanted to know what happened!" But then, the character would think about it and recap what we missed. I really enjoyed seeing their thoughts and we didn't miss out as readers on what happened in that scene.
Definitely one I will highly recommend reading. If you haven't read any of these books, they're stand alone. So you can pick and choose, especially depending on what historical moment you want to focus on reading and learning more about.
Content: Clean. Some kissing nothing further. This is a Christian fiction novel so the characters do speak of God and attend church and pray. But I feel like it is done very well in the sense that the characters acted and thought just as people in that time would have acted and thought. So it doesn't feel preachy or over the top. It all flows smoothly together and makes for a lovely read. There are several moments of peril due to the subject matter (slavery, underground railroad and the Civil War). So there are battles, guns, fighting, bloodshed, death and such but not overly graphic. I think older YA readers would enjoy this one, especially those who have studied the Civil War in school recently or will be soon.
I received a copy from the publisher, Barbour Publishing, via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions in the review are my own.
Happy Reading!!!
Read
July 13, 2021Slaves--Underground Railroad--Conductors--Secret identities. All of these are featured in the beginning pages of this story and the adventure and intrigue never stop. My Heart Belongs in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania begins in 1860 when Clarissa Ross is a nineteen year old woman secretly involved in helping to lead slaves to freedom via the Underground Railroad. As her story continus over the next three years, we watch as she struggles with romantic feelings for two very different men and also frets and worries that war may eventually come to her beloved Gettysburg and change it forever.
Clarissa was a complicated young lady and I sometimes found myself irritated by her actions. Her red hair was often the excuse that she used for both her impulsiveness and her quick temper but there was also a positive side to her fiery nature. She strongly believed that all men are equal and none should be considered inferior and she never stopped trying to convince others. There aren't many fair maidens who would choose to dress like a man, chew tobacco and go into battle but Clarissa had no reservations in fighting for her beliefs or for the safety of the man that she loved.
It is very apparent that author Murray Pura thoroughly researched this part of our United States history and he has been able to weave the facts into a fascinating story. I never realized that the Amish, Mennonites and Quakers often aided the slaves in their journeys to freedom and I had forgotten that those who helped the slaves escape were referred to as conductors and that Moses was the code name for Harriet Tubman, the chief conductor of the Underground Railroad. I love history and this book has offered me a whole new understanding of the many causes that contributed to the Civil War and I've also been given a new insight into the intense suffering of those involved. I have gained a better concept of the Gettysburg Address that President Abraham Lincoln delivered in November 1863 and a deeper appreciation for those stirring words that I memorized many, many years ago!
I thoroughly enjoyed My Heart Belongs in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania and I recommend this book to anyone who enjoys historical fiction and Christian romance.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
Clarissa was a complicated young lady and I sometimes found myself irritated by her actions. Her red hair was often the excuse that she used for both her impulsiveness and her quick temper but there was also a positive side to her fiery nature. She strongly believed that all men are equal and none should be considered inferior and she never stopped trying to convince others. There aren't many fair maidens who would choose to dress like a man, chew tobacco and go into battle but Clarissa had no reservations in fighting for her beliefs or for the safety of the man that she loved.
It is very apparent that author Murray Pura thoroughly researched this part of our United States history and he has been able to weave the facts into a fascinating story. I never realized that the Amish, Mennonites and Quakers often aided the slaves in their journeys to freedom and I had forgotten that those who helped the slaves escape were referred to as conductors and that Moses was the code name for Harriet Tubman, the chief conductor of the Underground Railroad. I love history and this book has offered me a whole new understanding of the many causes that contributed to the Civil War and I've also been given a new insight into the intense suffering of those involved. I have gained a better concept of the Gettysburg Address that President Abraham Lincoln delivered in November 1863 and a deeper appreciation for those stirring words that I memorized many, many years ago!
I thoroughly enjoyed My Heart Belongs in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania and I recommend this book to anyone who enjoys historical fiction and Christian romance.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
November 17, 2018
The Vagaries of War Many aspects of “My Heart Belongs in Gettysburg” reminded me of “Gone With the Wind,” one of my favorite classics. The Civil War setting drew me in, especially since it was set in such a renowned location. In fact, that was one of the striking parts of the reading experience because most of the action took place prior to the famous Battle of Gettysburg, when the town was just a quaint place that outsiders would never have heard of. The heroine, Clarissa Ross, points this out herself, commenting that she does not want her idyllic town and its environs to be remembered for death and destruction. Given all of the tragic events that have occurred even recently in the U.S., this was a reminder that disasters can happen anywhere, and this is where faith comes in as we trust God that He is ultimately working all things for the good of His children. Clarissa was a distinctive character, to be sure. In some ways she reminded me of Scarlett O’Hara, with her stubbornness and her temper. An inimitable redhead, Clarissa was very strongminded and outspoken, which I think was due in part to her being an only child and also to her living in the North. Had she been raised in the South, I think that the patriarchal society there would have had a deeper influence on her and she may have been somewhat more submissive. At first I found her character to be off-putting, but I soon grew to admire her and her antics. The romance, which is usually my least favorite part of a story, was very engaging because it was fraught with both danger and surprises. From a historical viewpoint, I was pleased that this novel pointed out that the Civil War was about much more than just the issue of slavery; states’ rights and the economy were at the forefront of the fighting, especially in the beginning. The many different levels of conflict in the book were well balanced by the Christian and romantic aspects, and I only wish that the story had been a bit longer in order to fill out some of the details more fully and allow for the plot to play out more slowly. I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
November 17, 2018
Having previously read Murray Pura's wonderful writing on several occasions, I was looking forward to how he would approach a "My Heart Belongs...." story and even more so how he would handle the Civil War battle in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania.
I found the leading lady in this story, Clarissa Avery Ross, a bit of a character and frankly did not like her flippant attitude about much of life and especially how she interacted with the young men in her life. Her role as a member of the Underground Railroad helping escaped slaves in their journey to freedom was admirable and yet it, too, was complicated by her personality or attitude. Blame it on her "flaming red hair" or not. I didn't care for it. That doesn't mean her behavior and personality was not suited it simply means I didn't care for it.
How valid it was to the time period? I will leave that to the experts and those who research and delve into whatever records exist that narrate how young ladies "comported" themselves in the 1860s in America.
As the Civil War (or whatever other name one wishes to give this American war) moves into Pennsylvania, Clarissa's character or behavior changes. This is definitely in keeping with reality as when confronted with the very real prospects of war in your own backyard, and then the actual experience of said battles, a frivolous young lady can take on a definite transformation and become quite serious in attitude and behavior. This happens to Clarissa.
Mr. Pura expertly handles the workings of the Underground Railroad and the approach of the Confederate army on Gettysburg and the battle fought at that locale. In great detail, he paints word pictures that place the reader in the middle of the battles. He shows the fierceness of war. He describes the compassionate cessation of conflict while they comb the battlefield for survivors - Northern and Southern.
An interesting read. A good amount of history. A clean romance.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher to facilitate a review. Opinions are mine alone and are freely given.
I found the leading lady in this story, Clarissa Avery Ross, a bit of a character and frankly did not like her flippant attitude about much of life and especially how she interacted with the young men in her life. Her role as a member of the Underground Railroad helping escaped slaves in their journey to freedom was admirable and yet it, too, was complicated by her personality or attitude. Blame it on her "flaming red hair" or not. I didn't care for it. That doesn't mean her behavior and personality was not suited it simply means I didn't care for it.
How valid it was to the time period? I will leave that to the experts and those who research and delve into whatever records exist that narrate how young ladies "comported" themselves in the 1860s in America.
As the Civil War (or whatever other name one wishes to give this American war) moves into Pennsylvania, Clarissa's character or behavior changes. This is definitely in keeping with reality as when confronted with the very real prospects of war in your own backyard, and then the actual experience of said battles, a frivolous young lady can take on a definite transformation and become quite serious in attitude and behavior. This happens to Clarissa.
Mr. Pura expertly handles the workings of the Underground Railroad and the approach of the Confederate army on Gettysburg and the battle fought at that locale. In great detail, he paints word pictures that place the reader in the middle of the battles. He shows the fierceness of war. He describes the compassionate cessation of conflict while they comb the battlefield for survivors - Northern and Southern.
An interesting read. A good amount of history. A clean romance.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher to facilitate a review. Opinions are mine alone and are freely given.
November 30, 2018
Death lies on all sides...
Gettysburg. Probably the most famous battle in the Civil War, and, a name that still strikes solemnity and sadness in the heart even now over 150 years later.
I've been looking forward to My Heart Belongs In Gettysburg, Pennsylvania: Clarissa's Conflict for awhile now, first because it is an era not yet covered by the My Heart Belongs In... series, and second because this is the first book in the series written by a guy. I've read one of author Murray Pura's previous historical romances published by Barbour, which I did enjoy, but I do think I might have liked this one a little better.
I have to admit that Clarissa's naivete and super-idealism did not endear her to me at first. I did, however, have a sneaking admiration for the elusive and enigmatic Liberty. But as the war came closer and became more real to Clarissa and her idealism became tempered by experience I did find myself starting to like her more and admire her fighting spirit. In many ways I imagine reality was a bit like this, the boys went to war expecting glory and for it to be over by Christmas but as time went on everyone became more weary and even jaded but what they went through.
Danger and romance run high in My Heart Belongs In Gettysburg, Pennsylvania: Clarissa's Conflict as Murray Pura delivers an enjoyable historical romance - with some real twists and turns - against the backdrop of America's greatest conflict.
(I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are entirely my own.)
Gettysburg. Probably the most famous battle in the Civil War, and, a name that still strikes solemnity and sadness in the heart even now over 150 years later.
I've been looking forward to My Heart Belongs In Gettysburg, Pennsylvania: Clarissa's Conflict for awhile now, first because it is an era not yet covered by the My Heart Belongs In... series, and second because this is the first book in the series written by a guy. I've read one of author Murray Pura's previous historical romances published by Barbour, which I did enjoy, but I do think I might have liked this one a little better.
I have to admit that Clarissa's naivete and super-idealism did not endear her to me at first. I did, however, have a sneaking admiration for the elusive and enigmatic Liberty. But as the war came closer and became more real to Clarissa and her idealism became tempered by experience I did find myself starting to like her more and admire her fighting spirit. In many ways I imagine reality was a bit like this, the boys went to war expecting glory and for it to be over by Christmas but as time went on everyone became more weary and even jaded but what they went through.
Danger and romance run high in My Heart Belongs In Gettysburg, Pennsylvania: Clarissa's Conflict as Murray Pura delivers an enjoyable historical romance - with some real twists and turns - against the backdrop of America's greatest conflict.
(I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are entirely my own.)
December 19, 2018
What do I love about Murray Pura's books? He's thorough in his research, and he keeps things moving, moving, moving. I haven't read all of his books, but this one is definitely worth five stars. He's a guy who can write romance without getting repetitious.
The novel is set in the pre- and during-Civil War period. I like how his heroine goes from spoiled and feisty to being more mature but still courageous. The hero is pretty much "hero-ing" all the way through. Not quite perfect, but close. The way we like heroes to be. You know.
This is one the guys will like too, I'm thinking. Available from Amazon and Barnes and Noble.
I received this book free from NetGalley, but my opinions are still my own.
The novel is set in the pre- and during-Civil War period. I like how his heroine goes from spoiled and feisty to being more mature but still courageous. The hero is pretty much "hero-ing" all the way through. Not quite perfect, but close. The way we like heroes to be. You know.
This is one the guys will like too, I'm thinking. Available from Amazon and Barnes and Noble.
I received this book free from NetGalley, but my opinions are still my own.
September 14, 2018
The setting in My Heart Belongs in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania was descriptive in such a way that I, although having never been there myself, was easily transported to Gettysburg and back in time to the events that took place in this book. I avoided history in school yet I was so drawn into this book and interested in the Civil War that I found myself researching it on the internet. The characters are very well developed. You truly feel like you know them. I got drawn into this book and did not want to put it down. For me it was a nonstop page turner. I eagerly look forward to more books from this author.
November 8, 2018
I believe My Heart Belongs in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania: Clarissa’s Conflict is my favorite that I have read from the My Heart Belongs in series. It has everything that I love to read most – history, strong heroine, action, romance, adventure and faith. I had no problem what so ever to keep turning the pages to see what would happen next.
I give My Heart Belongs in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania: Clarissa’s Conflict a well deserved five plus stars. I highly recommend it!
I received this book from the publisher. This review is 100% my own honest opinion.
I give My Heart Belongs in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania: Clarissa’s Conflict a well deserved five plus stars. I highly recommend it!
I received this book from the publisher. This review is 100% my own honest opinion.
October 26, 2018
I enjoyed this read, but I figured it out early in the book, but wanted to know how everything unfolded.
The author has us riding into the full battle of the civil war, and seeing such horrors, with the solace that we know how things ended, but what a high cost.
This story does have a bit of everything, including the War, Underground Railroad, church and family, and a bit of sweet romance.
A glimpse into life in the 1860’s in Gettysburg PA, and we are there!
I received this book through Net Galley and Barbour Publishing, and was not required to give a positive review.
The author has us riding into the full battle of the civil war, and seeing such horrors, with the solace that we know how things ended, but what a high cost.
This story does have a bit of everything, including the War, Underground Railroad, church and family, and a bit of sweet romance.
A glimpse into life in the 1860’s in Gettysburg PA, and we are there!
I received this book through Net Galley and Barbour Publishing, and was not required to give a positive review.
August 7, 2018
I have thoroughly enjoyed the My Heart Belongs series. This book was no exception. It was rich in history and the descriptions were vivid. The romance was sweet and heart warming. I loved the characters, especially the red headed heroine. She was quite feisty with her temper and passion. The hero was heroic and tender. This all mixed together and made a page turning book. I highly recommend it
August 6, 2018
Review to come.
November 21, 2018
While some scenes, specifically those transporting slaves to freedom on the Underground Railroad and on the battlefield, are full of action and descriptive, I did not connect with (or even like) the main character in this book.
Clarissa Avery Ross is stubborn, brash, prideful, selfish, and annoyingly silly at times. And she’s characterized by her red-headed temper. Granted, some of those traits are what make her so successful as a conductor on the railroad.
There was no surprise in the identity of Liberty—I had that figured out from the book description, but would have enjoyed more hints dropped around Clarissa.
Fans of Civil War history will enjoy this story as the account leading up to and through the Battle of Gettysburg are detailed and evoke the terrors and horrors of both civilians and the soldiers on each side of the conflict.
Disclosure statement:
I receive complimentary books from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, including NetGalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
Clarissa Avery Ross is stubborn, brash, prideful, selfish, and annoyingly silly at times. And she’s characterized by her red-headed temper. Granted, some of those traits are what make her so successful as a conductor on the railroad.
There was no surprise in the identity of Liberty—I had that figured out from the book description, but would have enjoyed more hints dropped around Clarissa.
Fans of Civil War history will enjoy this story as the account leading up to and through the Battle of Gettysburg are detailed and evoke the terrors and horrors of both civilians and the soldiers on each side of the conflict.
Disclosure statement:
I receive complimentary books from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, including NetGalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
November 13, 2018
I enjoy reading the My Heart Belongs Series, but I loved this one. It is rich in detail and history and happens to take place in my favorite era to read about. Civil War History is so interesting and when combined with a wonderful story that has a mysterious hooded man that assists Clarissa with the Underground Railroad you have the makings of a great book. It is well written and holds your attention throughout. Clarissa is a strong and opinionated woman that you wish you could meet in person. I now want to visit Gettysburg even more so. Put this on your must read list.
I received a complimentary copy from Barbour Publishing. The honest review and opinions are my own and were not required.
I received a complimentary copy from Barbour Publishing. The honest review and opinions are my own and were not required.
December 11, 2019
Lots of preaching, situations that would never have happened, annoying heroine, and way too sappy. Some of my friends might like the romance, but like I said, sappy. There were a few pretty exciting parts, but not enough to make up for the flaws.
November 6, 2018
This book is one of a kind! I really enjoyed reading about the Civil War from a woman's perspective, and not your average woman, at that! Clarissa truly is a spitfire and in a league of her own. She's portrayed as a redheaded sass who won't be told by ANYONE what to do. She comes to her own conclusions and sticks to her guns, her beliefs, and her faith.
Mystery and intrigue run rampant in this story with one situation after another taking the characters through a myriad of experiences. I loved the writing style and the descriptions of the situation the characters were facing as well as the environment they found themselves moving through.
These things brought my rating from a 3 to a 4, though the female protagonist was enough to drive me crazy. Her attitude and responses were unruly and ill mannered at best. Remember, she's not a 15 or 16 year old going through puberty but a 19 year old who should know better.
Some triggers for me were the excessive descriptions of kissing scenes and maybe even the allusion of premarital sex. Overall, though, the book had me hooked and it never slowed down. One thing after another continued to take the characters down different avenues, and because the female protagonist was willing to risk her life for the greater good, the reader is able to be a party to it. And for that, I'm thankful for her personality traits, good and bad.
Mystery and intrigue run rampant in this story with one situation after another taking the characters through a myriad of experiences. I loved the writing style and the descriptions of the situation the characters were facing as well as the environment they found themselves moving through.
These things brought my rating from a 3 to a 4, though the female protagonist was enough to drive me crazy. Her attitude and responses were unruly and ill mannered at best. Remember, she's not a 15 or 16 year old going through puberty but a 19 year old who should know better.
Some triggers for me were the excessive descriptions of kissing scenes and maybe even the allusion of premarital sex. Overall, though, the book had me hooked and it never slowed down. One thing after another continued to take the characters down different avenues, and because the female protagonist was willing to risk her life for the greater good, the reader is able to be a party to it. And for that, I'm thankful for her personality traits, good and bad.
April 30, 2020
My Heart Belongs in Gettysburg: Clarissa's Conflict is by Murray Pura.
it's a stand-alone book that starts in 1860 and runs through the end of 1863.
Clarissa has always had a hot temper to go with her red hair,
something that helps her face danger as she works on the Underground Railroad.
What she never expected was that the war would challenge her ideas of love ....
to make her realize that love often comes in more than one form.
And then the Confederates show up in her town for 3 very long, hot days in 1863,
challenging everything she believed in.
Meanwhile, the mysterious fella who keeps working with her on the Underground Railroad
drives her completely nuts.
He knows that his game is a deadly one - one that could cost his life at any time.
Love shouldn't have a place in his life, especially with his multiple names.
But Clarissa challenges him everywhere, and he finds himself fighting his feelings for her.
Will the love they find in each other be strong enough to survive anything thrown at them?
It was an "easy" kind of read with characters that are hard to forget.
Very hard to put down.
The unit that was featured in particular was the 69th PA Infantry Volunteers,
who saw action on both July 2 and July 3 at the stone wall.
Here's a couple of quotes that struck me in particular:
"... I emphasize that our great nation is at a crossroads.
One state has left us.
Others shall follow in the new year,
once the holidays have concluded
and governments are back in session.
What does the future hold?
I tell you, we must be true to God.
We must be true to scripture.
We must be a free nation before God.
We must be a Christian nation.
And to be such a nation, all men must be free in their souls and in their intellects and in their will to choose freely.
Their bodies must be free.
Without chains.
Without bars on their windows.
Without manacles on their wrists and ankles.
We cannot be a nation honoring God
as long as one man or one woman or one child is enslaved.
....We ought to be a nation of independence for all,
not just a privileged few.
Freedom Now, Freedom Tomorrow, Freedom Forever
Kyle
found in Chapter 3
"...we will fight back with fire and steel
to give this country the chance
to be a haven of freedom for all people for all time.
Every generation will have to fight
to gain or maintain their liberties....
We'll lose this war if we don't win today."
Ian
very early in the morning
July 3, 1863
Gettysburg
found in Chapter 18
it's a stand-alone book that starts in 1860 and runs through the end of 1863.
Clarissa has always had a hot temper to go with her red hair,
something that helps her face danger as she works on the Underground Railroad.
What she never expected was that the war would challenge her ideas of love ....
to make her realize that love often comes in more than one form.
And then the Confederates show up in her town for 3 very long, hot days in 1863,
challenging everything she believed in.
Meanwhile, the mysterious fella who keeps working with her on the Underground Railroad
drives her completely nuts.
He knows that his game is a deadly one - one that could cost his life at any time.
Love shouldn't have a place in his life, especially with his multiple names.
But Clarissa challenges him everywhere, and he finds himself fighting his feelings for her.
Will the love they find in each other be strong enough to survive anything thrown at them?
It was an "easy" kind of read with characters that are hard to forget.
Very hard to put down.
The unit that was featured in particular was the 69th PA Infantry Volunteers,
who saw action on both July 2 and July 3 at the stone wall.
Here's a couple of quotes that struck me in particular:
"... I emphasize that our great nation is at a crossroads.
One state has left us.
Others shall follow in the new year,
once the holidays have concluded
and governments are back in session.
What does the future hold?
I tell you, we must be true to God.
We must be true to scripture.
We must be a free nation before God.
We must be a Christian nation.
And to be such a nation, all men must be free in their souls and in their intellects and in their will to choose freely.
Their bodies must be free.
Without chains.
Without bars on their windows.
Without manacles on their wrists and ankles.
We cannot be a nation honoring God
as long as one man or one woman or one child is enslaved.
....We ought to be a nation of independence for all,
not just a privileged few.
Freedom Now, Freedom Tomorrow, Freedom Forever
Kyle
found in Chapter 3
"...we will fight back with fire and steel
to give this country the chance
to be a haven of freedom for all people for all time.
Every generation will have to fight
to gain or maintain their liberties....
We'll lose this war if we don't win today."
Ian
very early in the morning
July 3, 1863
Gettysburg
found in Chapter 18
December 10, 2018
Let me first say that I am in love with the My Heart Belongs series. I’ve read three so far and I recommend them all! I finished this book at midnight, because I didn’t want to stop until I reached the end.
One of the newest additions, MHB in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, tells us the story of Clarissa Avery Ross, an only child, who spends her days as a civilized lady and her nights conducting a train for the Underground Railroad. She’s a wild and carefree redhead who is stubborn and just a little bit confrontational. The actual battle of Gettysburg doesn’t take place until near the end of the book, most of the book centers around the Underground Railroad and Clarissa’s growing romance with Kyle… and Liberty. Suddenly, she finds herself with feelings for both men for different reasons. This book covers about a two-and-a-half-year period, from the beginning of the Civil War to the mid-point at Gettysburg. Having visited Gettysburg on several occasions, I loved “visiting” the city and the battlefield again through the story. I could easily picture the locations mentioned and felt an instant connection having seen these places for real.
I loved the Clark Kent-Superman thing going on. This book has adventure, danger, disguises, romance, history, and a rich element of faith and the freedom found in Jesus alone. The romantic elements were beautifully written, and the love story developed naturally.
I learned many new things about the Underground Railroad and the Civil War. It was interesting to see the war through the eyes of a Canadian author. I felt that this gave the author a more neutral look at the truth, reasons, and politics behind the war that many may have never known or even considered.
It’s a war book. There’s a bit of blood and death. This is just a note of warning before you start, in case you didn’t think of that. 😊
I give this book a hearty 5 stars. I can’t wait to read more in this series, and more books by this author.
One of the newest additions, MHB in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, tells us the story of Clarissa Avery Ross, an only child, who spends her days as a civilized lady and her nights conducting a train for the Underground Railroad. She’s a wild and carefree redhead who is stubborn and just a little bit confrontational. The actual battle of Gettysburg doesn’t take place until near the end of the book, most of the book centers around the Underground Railroad and Clarissa’s growing romance with Kyle… and Liberty. Suddenly, she finds herself with feelings for both men for different reasons. This book covers about a two-and-a-half-year period, from the beginning of the Civil War to the mid-point at Gettysburg. Having visited Gettysburg on several occasions, I loved “visiting” the city and the battlefield again through the story. I could easily picture the locations mentioned and felt an instant connection having seen these places for real.
I loved the Clark Kent-Superman thing going on. This book has adventure, danger, disguises, romance, history, and a rich element of faith and the freedom found in Jesus alone. The romantic elements were beautifully written, and the love story developed naturally.
I learned many new things about the Underground Railroad and the Civil War. It was interesting to see the war through the eyes of a Canadian author. I felt that this gave the author a more neutral look at the truth, reasons, and politics behind the war that many may have never known or even considered.
It’s a war book. There’s a bit of blood and death. This is just a note of warning before you start, in case you didn’t think of that. 😊
I give this book a hearty 5 stars. I can’t wait to read more in this series, and more books by this author.
January 16, 2019
Clarissa lives the life of a respectable daughter in historical Gettysburg. But at night she helps lead people through a section of the underground railroad. During her travels she meets a man named Liberty who wears a hood to conceal his identity. During the day she courts the attention of a scholar named Kyle that her parents approve of for their only child.
I was so excited to get this book to review. I love reading historical fiction, especially stories about the underground railroad. I've really enjoyed the other books in this series. The story was well written, flowed well, and really highlighted some of the intense moments during that time period. The heroine though was enough to make me want to quit reading. She was spoiled, way too forward for the time period, and hateful. The seemingly two sides of her personality didn't mesh well at all. She professed to be a Christian, but repeatedly flew off into a temper, was extremely judgmental and was always jumping to erroneous conclusions, she was loose with her affections, repeatedly disobeyed her parents, and wasn't very kind. I read a lot of historical fiction and just didn't feel like she was a true representation of a female for that time period. I have no idea why a guy would even be interested. Because of this, I found the main male character to be weak and spineless, even when you find out his "secret" that wasn't so secret. I would have been ok if she had ever come to realize her flaws and actively worked to correct them. But she blamed it all on her red hair and constantly made excuses for her behavior. Even when she did apologize, she didn't seem sincere. As a parent, I found her in serious need of discipline.
In conclusion, good story base, but not no endearing or redeeming main characters.
I received a copy of this book from Barbour Publishing. All thoughts expressed are my own.
I was so excited to get this book to review. I love reading historical fiction, especially stories about the underground railroad. I've really enjoyed the other books in this series. The story was well written, flowed well, and really highlighted some of the intense moments during that time period. The heroine though was enough to make me want to quit reading. She was spoiled, way too forward for the time period, and hateful. The seemingly two sides of her personality didn't mesh well at all. She professed to be a Christian, but repeatedly flew off into a temper, was extremely judgmental and was always jumping to erroneous conclusions, she was loose with her affections, repeatedly disobeyed her parents, and wasn't very kind. I read a lot of historical fiction and just didn't feel like she was a true representation of a female for that time period. I have no idea why a guy would even be interested. Because of this, I found the main male character to be weak and spineless, even when you find out his "secret" that wasn't so secret. I would have been ok if she had ever come to realize her flaws and actively worked to correct them. But she blamed it all on her red hair and constantly made excuses for her behavior. Even when she did apologize, she didn't seem sincere. As a parent, I found her in serious need of discipline.
In conclusion, good story base, but not no endearing or redeeming main characters.
I received a copy of this book from Barbour Publishing. All thoughts expressed are my own.
November 23, 2018
In Clarissa’s Conflict, we are taken to Gettysburg, Pennsylvania during the years of December 1860-December 1863. Clarissa was quite a feisty character, impulsive, independent, and the only child of her parents who allowed her escapades. At the beginning of the story we find Clarissa working in the Underground Railroad and dealing with all the dangers that involved. Clarissa does do some maturing as the story progresses, as she deals with the dangers of the Railroad and then the war is on her doorstep and in her town of Gettysburg.
Clarissa is a woman ahead of her time. She fights for the freedom of slaves in all that she can do and expects her love, Kyle Forrester to do the same. But though Kyle is against slavery, he goes about things much different than Clarissa. And then we are given a mysterious character by the name of Liberty, who is not only masked and resolute, almost terrifyingly so in his work on the Railroad, but has many secrets hidden that Clarissa is dying to uncover.
This story takes the reader from the start of the war, all the way through the battle of Gettysburg and gives us an eyewitness account of what it may have been like to be a young woman watching her town being turned into a battlefield. I have been to Gettysburg and could just imagine that horrible conflict there. Even though Clarissa could be over the top in her character at times, the romance was sweet and fierce, and the battle was a great reminder of thankfulness to those who fought for freedom and the preservation of the United States.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review. All views and opinions are my own.
https://pausefortales.blogspot.com/20...
Clarissa is a woman ahead of her time. She fights for the freedom of slaves in all that she can do and expects her love, Kyle Forrester to do the same. But though Kyle is against slavery, he goes about things much different than Clarissa. And then we are given a mysterious character by the name of Liberty, who is not only masked and resolute, almost terrifyingly so in his work on the Railroad, but has many secrets hidden that Clarissa is dying to uncover.
This story takes the reader from the start of the war, all the way through the battle of Gettysburg and gives us an eyewitness account of what it may have been like to be a young woman watching her town being turned into a battlefield. I have been to Gettysburg and could just imagine that horrible conflict there. Even though Clarissa could be over the top in her character at times, the romance was sweet and fierce, and the battle was a great reminder of thankfulness to those who fought for freedom and the preservation of the United States.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review. All views and opinions are my own.
https://pausefortales.blogspot.com/20...
Displaying 1 - 30 of 104 reviews