I was looking forward to this book as the previous one floored me with how lovely it was.
And, while
When a Duchess Says I Do
is beautifully written - with smooth prose, interesting fleshed out characters, and witty banter - it lacks… something.
If I had any doubt that Grace Burrowes’s uses English with almost magical elegance - creating lush beautifully written passages that almost mesmerise the reader - this book reassured me it wasn’t just my luck that I‘ve previously read titles that were that well written. From the very first pages this one just pulls the reader in; the language is so beautiful, so rich, and so smooth, it’s really a pleasure just to soak it in, even if the story it wants to tell is not that… thrilling.
I’d say
When a Duchess Says I Do
is a very gentle romance. Both when it comes to its characters and the romance itself.
Duncan – the Wentworth cousin introduced in the previous book – and Matilda are very reserved, stoic even; they both have this quiet mature demeanor that doesn’t necessary promise a whirling and passionate romance. Even though their relationship started with almost literal bang, later on the romance progresses slowly and almost in matter of fact manner. Not that it’s anything wrong with that. The previous book’s main couple’s romance started in a very matter of fact fashion, with both parties agreeing to marriage of convenience not expecting any passion between them. Reserved and practical protagonists not necessary mean lack of thrilling romance. There were heaps of it in My One and Only Duke. But here I feel like the delicate, almost too gentle way Duncan and Matilda’s romance unfolded was too much. Don’t get me wrong, there is a simmering heat between them; I have never considered playing chess a foreplay, but this book proved me wrong. The way they communicated while masterfully strategizing their next moves was the best part of this book.
But maybe, just maybe their quiet passion was buried just… to deep.
It’s shame as they are both interesting characters. I really enjoyed their back stories, especially Duncan’s as it was quite shocking. Here I must praise Grace Burrowes as she didn’t give out any hints of his tragic past before, and it was pleasantly surprising to slowly learn of it during lengthy conversations he had with Matilda. I really liked his dry humour and caring nature. He might seem a harmless boring academic, but there was solid strength within him.
Matilda also had quite intriguing past, and it felt like there could be more depth to her backstory. Still, she was really interesting heroine: incredible strong and determined with rich and adventurous life. She and Duncan were quite similar in many ways, while having a completely different life’s experiences. Maybe that’s why they complemented each other so well.
As for the rest of the characters, I was very happy Duncan’s protégé, Stephen, made a lengthy appearance in this book, as well as a Quinn and Jane (the main couple form the previous book). The family dynamic between Wentworths was, again, amazing; the banter lively and smooth, and you could really feel how loyal and loving they were to each other.
Last but not least, the story. The premise intrigued me, but I’d be lying if I said the gentle way the romance progressed didn’t hinder the story itself. Everything unfolded very slowly as the characters spend most of the time secluded in Duncan’s estate. There was some tension building, but the final act ended quite abruptly, with almost out of the character behaviors from some of the main protagonists. In a way I felt more satisfaction in the way Quinn dealt with Jane’s infuriating father than Duncan and Matilda did with hers.
I had a difficult time rating
When a Duchess Says I Do
. I love Grace Burrowes’s elegant prose, her likable characters and special kind of charm she adds to her love stories, but I guess I’m still not completely sold on very slow burn romances with both characters being very reserved. Matilda and Duncan’s passion was quiet and gentle, maybe just too gentle for me.
I look forward to the next book, and I still hope Stephen will get his happy ever after.
3/5 stars